RE: Renault Clio Williams: PH Carpool

RE: Renault Clio Williams: PH Carpool

Author
Discussion

highway

1,962 posts

261 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
In 95 I had a mint 1.9 gti with 24k on it. One of the later cars with pas and abs. It was quick and fun. I sold it to buy a Williams 3 new. I got some discount on it, no mean feet at the time. Paid £14k ish in 1996.
It was nice, brand new, quick and fun.

However it wasn't twice the car the 205 was and I resented it for that. I'd paid more than double than the 205 owed me hence it should have been twice the experience. The car mags at the time hailed it as being a sublime drivers car, better on a B road than a 512 TR I recall one headline proclaiming.

I sold it 6 months later, got back what I'd paid for it and bought an Mx 5.

Nice car but I never thought it as good as it was hyped up to be. The gear change on the Pug was tangibly better and despite giving 20bhp away the 205 felt as quick.

Mark Smith

164 posts

220 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
I've always liked the Williams Clio's but never been in one. I've got a Ph1 172 which replaced the Williams. It's 14 years old now but its still as sharp as ever. You certainly don't see very many of the Williams cars now.

s m

23,243 posts

204 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
highway said:
In 95 I had a mint 1.9 gti with 24k on it. One of the later cars with pas and abs. It was quick and fun. I sold it to buy a Williams 3 new. I got some discount on it, no mean feet at the time. Paid £14k ish in 1996.
It was nice, brand new, quick and fun.

However it wasn't twice the car the 205 was and I resented it for that. I'd paid more than double than the 205 owed me hence it should have been twice the experience. The car mags at the time hailed it as being a sublime drivers car, better on a B road than a 512 TR I recall one headline proclaiming.

I sold it 6 months later, got back what I'd paid for it and bought an Mx 5.

Nice car but I never thought it as good as it was hyped up to be. The gear change on the Pug was tangibly better and despite giving 20bhp away the 205 felt as quick.
Interesting post - I know what you mean. A friend traded his 1.9 205 for a Williams and I was quite excited to see it and have a go in it. They were a much talked about hot hatch at the time. I had a 309 Gti and I think I ( and my friend who bought the Williams ) had 'built it up' mentally to be so much better than the Peugeots that we were bound to be disappointed.
Still, a great hot hatch, and I hope the guy with this one enjoys his time with it when it's restored.

Swervin_Mervin

4,465 posts

239 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
s m said:
highway said:
In 95 I had a mint 1.9 gti with 24k on it. One of the later cars with pas and abs. It was quick and fun. I sold it to buy a Williams 3 new. I got some discount on it, no mean feet at the time. Paid £14k ish in 1996.
It was nice, brand new, quick and fun.

However it wasn't twice the car the 205 was and I resented it for that. I'd paid more than double than the 205 owed me hence it should have been twice the experience. The car mags at the time hailed it as being a sublime drivers car, better on a B road than a 512 TR I recall one headline proclaiming.

I sold it 6 months later, got back what I'd paid for it and bought an Mx 5.

Nice car but I never thought it as good as it was hyped up to be. The gear change on the Pug was tangibly better and despite giving 20bhp away the 205 felt as quick.
Interesting post - I know what you mean. A friend traded his 1.9 205 for a Williams and I was quite excited to see it and have a go in it. They were a much talked about hot hatch at the time. I had a 309 Gti and I think I ( and my friend who bought the Williams ) had 'built it up' mentally to be so much better than the Peugeots that we were bound to be disappointed.
Still, a great hot hatch, and I hope the guy with this one enjoys his time with it when it's restored.
I've never driven a 205, but have sampled 106s, 306s, Xsara VTS and multiple Renauilts and for me the PSA cars always had a different approach to the Renaults and the rears have always been more free.

I actually preferred my 1.8 16v to the Williams as I felt it a little more exciting and a little less composed than the wider front tracked Williams. Same for the engine - more fizz with the 1.8. I could still see myself with another actually, especially when people keep posting pics like the one above! cool

Hoygo 2

46 posts

125 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Love it,especially when they are in the conditions as good as this one,undoubtedly great car i must own one soon.

jcl

227 posts

244 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Looked after Mum's one that she owned for 5 or so years. Lovely thing and I was tempted to buy it when she sold it but the S1/S2 106 Rallyes I owned at the time were simply more fun.

What the hell happened Peugeot???

predding

455 posts

217 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Great car and nice write-up. Know the feeling re the 11th hour 180 - did the same with my Quattro last year after 20 years of ownership and my wife says "what are you doing?!" Was the wake-up call I needed - chap on the Quattro forum was v understanding...We will be at LM Classic this year :-)

s1rallyemark

151 posts

181 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Here's mine, had it nearly 2 years now and have pretty much just finished a full restoration




dukebox9reg

1,571 posts

149 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
I'm amazed that this hasn't had more love than just 2 pages. If this had been a 205 GTI you could guarantee there would be at least 3 times as many responses.


mazdaman1980

140 posts

205 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
I love how every time I read one of these features they are so in love with the car and then it's either for sale or hardly being driven. Granted he drove it daily but rally, why stop?

PHMatt

608 posts

149 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
I had a 1.4rt followed by a 1.8 16v as a youth.

Great fun to drive and compared to their contemporaries, I always thought they looked and drove better as well as having much higher spec.

Considering they were both under 10 years old though the reliability was horrific.
The RT snapped 2 clutch cables and a clutch pedal. The coil amplifier went. The exhaust rusted and snapped off and to top the lot, the engine blew up. Luckily I got a used one fitted for £500 so it lived on.
The valver, unbeknown to me, was running on 3 cylinders for it's first couple of months. Turns out the clip for the electrical connector to an injector had broken off. I played a game in 18 months called "chase the bulb" where every exterior bulb at some point had gone pear shaped and at no point did they all ever work at the same time. Even the bulbs in the dash went, leading to speeding ticket!
The fuel pump packed up and as new, they cost a bomb and require the fuel tank to be dropped to change. Luckily I found a used one and a decent mechanic who did it all for £200

I would certainly look at them fondly from a far but never ever buy another one.


Baz Tench

5,648 posts

191 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
dukebox9reg said:
I'm amazed that this hasn't had more love than just 2 pages. If this had been a 205 GTI you could guarantee there would be at least 3 times as many responses.

Rarity factor?

LuS1fer

41,139 posts

246 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
I had an R5 GT Turbo.
While I vaguely wanted a Clio williams, the design was always very bland and generic, compared to the, even then, "retro" 5 (Surely Renault are missing a new trick here to compete with Mini 500).

I liked them more in the metallic burgundy they came in later but it was never a car I lusted after. Then again, I am one of the few who never liked the 205GTi though I can see it's a classic design.

Swervin_Mervin

4,465 posts

239 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
I had an R5 GT Turbo.
While I vaguely wanted a Clio williams, the design was always very bland and generic, compared to the, even then, "retro" 5 (Surely Renault are missing a new trick here to compete with Mini 500).

I liked them more in the metallic burgundy they came in later but it was never a car I lusted after. Then again, I am one of the few who never liked the 205GTi though I can see it's a classic design.
They never came in anything other than Blue and Gold. The Blue changed from Sports Blue to Moncao and that was the only colour change.

You're probably thinking of Naples Red that the 1.8 16v came in wink

As for looks - I always thought they had it all. Flared front and rear arches, bonnet bulge, naca duct.

Sealine South

533 posts

140 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Had mine since October 11. Use it everyday, love it!!!

Put it on the market for £2,995 and phone rang its nuts off, I'll be keeping it now!

The_Ox

102 posts

228 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
These were fantastic cars! I had a Mk1 (number 86) for over a year. I was gutted when I sold it but I was pleased it went to somebody who was going to take care of it. I keep thinking about trying to buy another one... :-)

matt-man

2,665 posts

220 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
These are fantastic little cars!

Years back I had a 1.8 16V and i absolutely loved it to pieces. It was such a great engine, absolutely no low down power but one it came onto cam it just sang to the redline...

I sold it after about 3 years and 40000 miles due to getting a company car. i always promised myself i would buy a willams and about 2 years back i did exactly that. Williams 3:



Sadly the ther half was not so keen so after doing quite a lot of work to it (original spec products replaced)it had to go...apparently the jump from the rolls royce to the renault was too much for her hehe

Sold it to a guy in the forces who promised to love it and i hope he is as it was genuine little belter that car smile

p4cks

6,917 posts

200 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
andymc said:
I had completely missed this thread (the PH Carpool one) until Dom9 pointed me in this direction.

They are absolutely superb little cars. The more that are saved the better, they are certainly not going down in value and anyone wanting one as a little project (which inevitably, like mine, turns quickly into a major wallet-busting labour of love!) or a run about I can't speak highly enough of them.

They are twice the car the 205 GTI is/was.

dom9

8,090 posts

210 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
p4cks said:
They are twice the car the 205 GTI is/was.
We've talked about this before [angry smilie] wink

The proof will be in the pudding biggrin

Can't wait!