Best Smoker Barges 1-5 large [Vol 7]

Best Smoker Barges 1-5 large [Vol 7]

TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED
Author
Discussion

derin100

5,214 posts

244 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
0a said:
sly fox said:
jonclancy said:
I've seen that car driving around Reading- looked in good nick.

It's a 1.8 though, slower than asphalt itself.
So tidy looking and basic though - that feeling that it will outlast any new car and anything produced for the next decade must be satisfying!

My CEO just texted saying he's about to buy an old e28 520 as a daily driver as he likes the approach of running old German cars. Replied with disclaimers about the e28 - rust electronics etc for self protection.
Unless he's a bit handy on the spanners himself I forsee trouble ahead. If not, then he's better off with a Merc of that vintage.

Pickled

2,051 posts

144 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
Rocksteadyeddie said:
The borkutation of the L322 is largely inherited. The P38 is a vehicle which only the most foolhardy bargist would contemplate, and even those brave enough would be reduced to a quivering tearful shadow of their former selves in mere months. The L322 by contrast is largely a Teutonic construct with many of the same traits as their German cousins. They're not perfect of course, and some parts can be expensive, but there are a good network of specialist who can address the main issues at reasonable cost. We've run two now - albeit at some multiple of thread budget - largely without issue.
Very true re: P38, I very nearly, in a moment of madness, bought a 4.6 a few years back, luckily the buy wouldn't shift on his price.

I know a fair few of the engine parts on the earlier L322s are shared with the E38/39 and X5, I think all lot of the reputation comes from new buyers having to return the cars for silly electrical niggles, which is would annoy me, but when they get to a certain age/value you kind of accept that things may (or may not) fail and budget accordingly. As we all know any car in this category has the potential to throw up massive bills, but I often think when a car gets to a certain age and mileage that if it was going to have a massive failure i.e. gearbox then it probably would have done so already it's a mantra that has served me well (so far) and to me the gamble is part of the fun, and I am fortunate to have 3 other cars to use so don't have to rely on having one perfectly reliable car.

Pickled

2,051 posts

144 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
derin100 said:
0a said:
sly fox said:
jonclancy said:
I've seen that car driving around Reading- looked in good nick.

It's a 1.8 though, slower than asphalt itself.
So tidy looking and basic though - that feeling that it will outlast any new car and anything produced for the next decade must be satisfying!

My CEO just texted saying he's about to buy an old e28 520 as a daily driver as he likes the approach of running old German cars. Replied with disclaimers about the e28 - rust electronics etc for self protection.
Unless he's a bit handy on the spanners himself I forsee trouble ahead. If not, then he's better off with a Merc of that vintage.
Agree, and certainly not a 520i, its a fantastically smooth engine (MB20) but is neither powerful or economic, in fact i'd rather have a tidy 525e.

0a

23,901 posts

195 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
derin100 said:
Unless he's a bit handy on the spanners himself I forsee trouble ahead. If not, then he's better off with a Merc of that vintage.
Yes I've pointed this out - get a merc, or a later BMW like an e34. Perhaps this 540 from 4 star! http://www.4starclassics.com/BMW-E34-540i-For-Sale...

The 520 engine isn't even that desirable - I'd want a 525 or a 528 (the latter in dark blue please!)

derin100

5,214 posts

244 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
The 520i very smooth and was "nippy" in its day but as said, it's not very frugal and by today's standards maybe a little slow. But those aren't my real warnings.

Even the youngest will be 27 years old now. Unless he's extremely lucky (or buying an expensive restored one) then there could be some big resto costs. Some important parts are now either NLA or difficult to find on Ebay etc e.g chrome bumpers, front struts themselves (not the inserts) and many cars have rotten spring seats on their front struts.

As a daily driver he'd be far better off with an E34.


nickod

397 posts

161 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
texasjohn said:
Nice E280, nearly 600,000 miles! wink

http://www.carandclassic.co.uk/car/C513306#
I think that's more likely to be 59000 miles going by what else the ad says. Red is growing on me for the saloon.

nickod

397 posts

161 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
harry kular said:
NastyNick74 said:
Could esteemed members point me in the direction of S124s please? I'm in the market for one in the next few weeks and feel I've explored all of the Bay, AT and Car and Classic.
Doesn't seem to be too many around. MTSV had a 300d, and I think W124.co.uk had a similar one too, but top money. What's the budget- top or bottom of thread?
Mine will be for sale soon. It is a 200 though albeit totally rust free and only 77k miles.

Julesx

73 posts

210 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
derin100 said:
A little (much less with the roof on) and it is a bit irritating...but nothing on the scale of the Pagoda or R107.
That's disappointing to hear - maybe I'm being fussy as I get older but I fancy a more relaxed drive TBH so on reflection maybe a W124 CE would suit me better.

As someone has already mentioned, the coupe does look good with all four windows dropped. I also think that whilst sunroofs on older cars can prove to cause issues, the big ones fitted to W124 means you do get lots of fresh air! Mmmm - decisions!

Julesx

73 posts

210 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Above post relates to R129's having 'scuttle shake' frown

jonclancy

139 posts

139 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
For the 1.8 190E I posted:

BARON CARS Reading

12 July

100% original, 70000 miles, long MOT and tax, fsh, hpi clear, no rust, drives like new £2800

From their Facebook page - just to give a feel for where the Reserve price might lie.

https://www.facebook.com/pages/BARON-CARS-Reading/...

derin100

5,214 posts

244 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
Julesx said:
That's disappointing to hear - maybe I'm being fussy as I get older but I fancy a more relaxed drive TBH so on reflection maybe a W124 CE would suit me better.

As someone has already mentioned, the coupe does look good with all four windows dropped. I also think that whilst sunroofs on older cars can prove to cause issues, the big ones fitted to W124 means you do get lots of fresh air! Mmmm - decisions!
That's kind of the conclusion I've come to as well....and for the same reasons.

I always look at SLs (all of them) with longing eyes as they are so good looking. However, sadly the reality, in my experience, isn't really the totally unflustered, relaxing cruise that photos tend to give the impression of. And so, I'm probably better off with my CE too as there is zero scuttle shaking in that.

Julesx

73 posts

210 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
derin100 said:
Julesx said:
That's disappointing to hear - maybe I'm being fussy as I get older but I fancy a more relaxed drive TBH so on reflection maybe a W124 CE would suit me better.

As someone has already mentioned, the coupe does look good with all four windows dropped. I also think that whilst sunroofs on older cars can prove to cause issues, the big ones fitted to W124 means you do get lots of fresh air! Mmmm - decisions!
That's kind of the conclusion I've come to as well....and for the same reasons.

I always look at SLs (all of them) with longing eyes as they are so good looking. However, sadly the reality, in my experience, isn't really the totally unflustered, relaxing cruise that photos tend to give the impression of. And so, I'm probably better off with my CE too as there is zero scuttle shaking in that.
Thanks - I think it will be a CE for me!

Funnily enough - I have just dropped my '72 W115 saloon (might have been considered a barge in its day even though it is the smaller engine version!) into SS Motors in Weybridge (highly recommended especially for older Mercs) for some repairs. They have 3 perfect Pagodas in at the moment and they are soooo nice, it hurts!! Sadly out of my price range and are without a doubt 'of their time' when it comes to the actual drive - still bloody lovely tho!

Caruso

7,437 posts

257 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
r129sl said:
Nice 560 SEL here. I tell you what I like about the ad: "Aircon present and requires replacement compressor, cooler and re-gas". They all need that, yet most sellers only mention the gas.

http://www.carandclassic.co.uk/car/C521011

I read the ad, and scrolling down expected to see a price at least double the £4150 asked. It looks like a bargain and honestly described.

Super Slo Mo

5,368 posts

199 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
derin100 said:
The 520i very smooth and was "nippy" in its day but as said, it's not very frugal and by today's standards maybe a little slow. But those aren't my real warnings.

Even the youngest will be 27 years old now. Unless he's extremely lucky (or buying an expensive restored one) then there could be some big resto costs. Some important parts are now either NLA or difficult to find on Ebay etc e.g chrome bumpers, front struts themselves (not the inserts) and many cars have rotten spring seats on their front struts.

As a daily driver he'd be far better off with an E34.
Yes, indeed. I bought a 1985 525e 4 years ago with the intention of restoring it. Lack of motivation mean I haven't got very far with it, although there's fairly comprehensive rot in one of the forward chassis rails that's difficult to get to without removing the engine/box (not easy in my single garage).

Front bumper is pretty decent though smile, although could use re-chroming.

You can still get many of the body panels, although they're not cheap. I believe bumpers are still available new (well, old stock) but are eye waveringly expensive.

There are lots of places the body can rot, many of them well hidden from view without removing covers/panels/trim etc.

I'm slightly tempted to move it on, to someone who'll restore it, it'd be a shame to break it really, but getting it back on the road requires quite a bit of work.

lowdrag

12,897 posts

214 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
Just helped a youngster out here in France.405 2litre petrol Pug belonging to one old man from new. He no longer can drive so with 40K miles from new £300. The youngster is delighted.

r129sl

9,518 posts

204 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
Julesx said:
derin100 said:
Julesx said:
That's disappointing to hear - maybe I'm being fussy as I get older but I fancy a more relaxed drive TBH so on reflection maybe a W124 CE would suit me better.

As someone has already mentioned, the coupe does look good with all four windows dropped. I also think that whilst sunroofs on older cars can prove to cause issues, the big ones fitted to W124 means you do get lots of fresh air! Mmmm - decisions!
That's kind of the conclusion I've come to as well....and for the same reasons.

I always look at SLs (all of them) with longing eyes as they are so good looking. However, sadly the reality, in my experience, isn't really the totally unflustered, relaxing cruise that photos tend to give the impression of. And so, I'm probably better off with my CE too as there is zero scuttle shaking in that.
Thanks - I think it will be a CE for me!

Funnily enough - I have just dropped my '72 W115 saloon (might have been considered a barge in its day even though it is the smaller engine version!) into SS Motors in Weybridge (highly recommended especially for older Mercs) for some repairs. They have 3 perfect Pagodas in at the moment and they are soooo nice, it hurts!! Sadly out of my price range and are without a doubt 'of their time' when it comes to the actual drive - still bloody lovely tho!
I don't think the 107 or the 129 are that bad and neither suffers any scuttle shake on a relaxed cruise. It's only when pressing too hard on broken roads that it manifests itself. An early 129 on 16" wheels I'd have thought is a very relaxing thing to drive. The only way to find out is to drive one.

Mustard

6,992 posts

246 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
Super Slo Mo said:
derin100 said:
The 520i very smooth and was "nippy" in its day but as said, it's not very frugal and by today's standards maybe a little slow. But those aren't my real warnings.

Even the youngest will be 27 years old now. Unless he's extremely lucky (or buying an expensive restored one) then there could be some big resto costs. Some important parts are now either NLA or difficult to find on Ebay etc e.g chrome bumpers, front struts themselves (not the inserts) and many cars have rotten spring seats on their front struts.

As a daily driver he'd be far better off with an E34.
Yes, indeed. I bought a 1985 525e 4 years ago with the intention of restoring it. Lack of motivation mean I haven't got very far with it, although there's fairly comprehensive rot in one of the forward chassis rails that's difficult to get to without removing the engine/box (not easy in my single garage).

Front bumper is pretty decent though smile, although could use re-chroming.

You can still get many of the body panels, although they're not cheap. I believe bumpers are still available new (well, old stock) but are eye waveringly expensive.

There are lots of places the body can rot, many of them well hidden from view without removing covers/panels/trim etc.

I'm slightly tempted to move it on, to someone who'll restore it, it'd be a shame to break it really, but getting it back on the road requires quite a bit of work.
I too have one sat in my garage, totally rust free, all trim perfect, only bodywork of note is a bloody scratch on the boot lid (from the garage door, trying to squeeze it in a packed garage) and a dented, but paint not broken rear door from when it was sat outside briefly post moving, when it was attacked by some drunk with a 'for sale' board....grrrrr

I've promised I'd sell it, but never get round to it, but not had the time to devote to using it either so hence it's sat for the last 4 yrs in my garage

Guess I ought to get it dragged into work, bang a new cam belt on it, lob in the new radiator I have for it (plastic elbow is bust on current) stick an Mot on it, and then sell it.... Mrs doesn't understand it!

Or do I sell as is? (All the hard work is done / not required)

Values seem to fluctuate wildly, needs to go to a really good home (its only had 2 previous owners, 1st one for the 20yrs with main dealer history (120k of it) every thing feels/looks/performs like new inside

...guess it's not going down in value! Lol

Motorrad

6,811 posts

188 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
lowdrag said:
Just helped a youngster out here in France.405 2litre petrol Pug belonging to one old man from new. He no longer can drive so with 40K miles from new £300. The youngster is delighted.
The 405 really was a sweet driving and looking saloon. Sounds great for 300 quid.

Julesx

73 posts

210 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
r129sl said:
I don't think the 107 or the 129 are that bad and neither suffers any scuttle shake on a relaxed cruise. It's only when pressing too hard on broken roads that it manifests itself. An early 129 on 16" wheels I'd have thought is a very relaxing thing to drive. The only way to find out is to drive one.
Yes, you quiet right, I need to drive a 129 to be sure.

If our roads were better it may not be an issue. Recently, in France, I found myself on one of there really smooth 'A roads' (actually a RN) near the Belgian border and I had one of those perfect driving moments where everything was so smooth but back here it seems you spend most of the time avoiding the holes!

As an aside - Anyone going to Uxbridge Classic Show on Sunday in their barge?

NastyNick74

138 posts

146 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
nickod said:
Mine will be for sale soon. It is a 200 though albeit totally rust free and only 77k miles.
Got any further details or photos?
TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED