Nice House vs nice Car? Which takes priority?

Nice House vs nice Car? Which takes priority?

Author
Discussion

J4CKO

41,562 posts

200 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
Our house is payed for and fairly decent, it's the kids that use most of the money, just not sure at what age they will become independent, having to have three cars limits the budget, even maintaining them myself it's expensive, plus the house always needs something. Still, don't owe anyone a penny so can't complain.

I would always say house first and enjoy the shed level cars, put some effort in and don't get tangled up in leases if you can avoid it, spend the extra on the house, you will be glad twenty years down the line.

Urban Sports

11,321 posts

203 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
House everytime, we bought a big old run down detached a few years ago when we were in our mid 20's it was a huge jump in to it, we probably skipped about 3 house moves in one, it was a massive commitment at the time, as was and still is the renovation.

I've still had a few nice cars but my passion for them has been sacrificed somewhat, I don't regret it at all!

Dave Hedgehog

14,555 posts

204 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
housing wise all you need is somewhere to sling your stuff where it wont get nicked every 4 days

spending any more than that is just adding to "parasitic family / relative fund" which they will fight over when you are gone

best to waste it on cars and enjoy it imo


Urban Sports

11,321 posts

203 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
Dave Hedgehog said:
housing wise all you need is somewhere to sling your stuff where it wont get nicked every 4 days

spending any more than that is just adding to "parasitic family / relative fund" which they will fight over when you are gone

best to waste it on cars and enjoy it imo
I like walking round my big house naked, you can't beat it!

Urban Sports

11,321 posts

203 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
blade7 said:
House, living at home with mummy and daddy when you're over 25 is sad.
I know people in their 30's with a decent car but still living with Mum & Dad, it's tragic hehe

EricE

1,945 posts

129 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
House, always, except for very rare cases where the car appreciates faster than housing. (hindsight...)

CYMR0

3,940 posts

200 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
Single, no kids, never likely to get any, financially stable...

There's an argument for 'enough' house but no more than that. I can't see me stretching to live somewhere small but in a spectacular location and frankly I rattle around a 2-bed flat.

If I had kids, I'd probably be thinking of their inheritance and I can't imagine myself as a landlord or going self-employed so reasonable cars it is.

daemon

35,822 posts

197 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
ILoveMondeo said:
Has anyone here ever actually made this decision? You can have one or the other? (Yes there is always a middle ground but let's pretend that doesn't exist)

Buy the dream home, (well get a massive mortgage)... Be unable to so much expensive car stuff?

Or

Much smaller mortgage on a far from crap house, but nothing spectacular, get a Ferrari/Lamborghini/etc
Used to live in a smallish detached in a development and drove a new X5 and wifie had a new 3.0Si z4, so probably about £85,000 worth of cars at the door.

Opted to build our own home in the country - 5 bed, 4 en suite, 4 reception, twin garages, decent site. Wifie still drives a z4 (but a 2 litre turbo, changes every three years to another new one) but i've a Golf diesel predominantly due to commuting.

I limit myself to the odd cheapie weekend "toy" now.

New cars depreciate heavily. Houses (usually) go up in value.




Coolbanana

4,416 posts

200 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
I would never, ever, choose a car over a house as my priority. Always the house first and a serviceable car very much second with a nicer car only when extra disposable income allows.




ILoveMondeo

Original Poster:

9,614 posts

226 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
So what you're all saying is I should definitely get a 458 and live in a caravan? smile

Message received and understood ! House it is!


uuf361

3,154 posts

222 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
House for me too - sold my 997 TT cab to help have a bigger deposit for my house together with increasing the mortgage 4 fold........

Gradually working my way back with cars and now have 2 (still together under £30k) that should suit all my needs.....

goneape

2,839 posts

162 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
Nice car demands a nice place to keep it and preferably to service it. So, house first here too. Trevor fund going back to zero in the next 12 months

Funk

26,277 posts

209 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
KingNothing said:
Only have a Focus ST, but spent a fking fortune on it, plus debt, plus mods, plus interest, and finally realised I shouldn't have wasted my time and money, and as such I'm currently saving for a mortgage deposit, put the car back to standard, and it'll be sold eventually, and I'll run around in a shed for a while or the smallest lease I can find.
I saw this a lot on the focusstoc. The number of youngsters buying STs and spending thousands on modifying them was insane - and almost none of them had their own properties, they were just chucking money at their cars (which are now worth very little, especially modified).

If there's one piece of advice I could go back and give myself it would be to have gotten on the property ladder quicker and not blown my earnings one st back then that I can't even recall now.

daveky

148 posts

142 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
zoom star said:
I walk past a council estate on the way to work, probably the biggest house on the estate, on the end, in a largr corner plot, sat on the drive, massive modern motor home, and an Aston Martin.
Benefit fraud? Inheritence?

daveky

148 posts

142 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
Funk said:
I saw this a lot on the focusstoc. The number of youngsters buying STs and spending thousands on modifying them was insane - and almost none of them had their own properties, they were just chucking money at their cars (which are now worth very little, especially modified).

If there's one piece of advice I could go back and give myself it would be to have gotten on the property ladder quicker and not blown my earnings one st back then that I can't even recall now.
These days for a lot of kids in the SE owning property is a distant dream. The only people under 30 I know owning property are the spoilt pr1cks who've been given money or land and as a result think they're better than those who haven't.

paul383

68 posts

117 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
daveky said:
The only people under 30 I know owning property are the spoilt pr1cks who've been given money or land and as a result think they're better than those who haven't.
That didn't include you then? hehe

BrownBottle

1,370 posts

136 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
zoom star said:
I walk past a council estate on the way to work, probably the biggest house on the estate, on the end, in a largr corner plot, sat on the drive, massive modern motor home, and an Aston Martin.
Driver101 said:
It looks a bit wrong when you see a flash car in a rough area. I feel nervous leaving my car parked there, so they must feel uncomfortable living there.
It's worth noting the guy on the council estate with the nice car grew up there.

He knows everyone and everyone knows him, his car is generally safer than some soft lad staying in a nice area as that's where the TWOKers from said estate will head to rather than stting on their own doorstep.

Colonial

13,553 posts

205 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
Whatever works for the individual.

Who the fk cares whether bob down the street rents or own or what car he owns.

Work out what works for you. Do that.

anonymous-user

54 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
I agree with Colonial.

It depends on so many things, not least of which is the stage in life and your overall worth.

If you live in a £1m house, you could quite easily downsize to a £600k house which would still be nice and have some cash for toys and other investments.

Do that at a stage in life when you have no mortgage or dependants and you can have the best of both worlds.

Do that in your 30s with kids and a big mortgage and it may not be so clever!

ILoveMondeo

Original Poster:

9,614 posts

226 months

Saturday 9th August 2014
quotequote all
Just been to see the "nice house"

fk me, it's nice...

But needs so much work, new everything required.. no nice cars for years and years!

Barn for 3 cars, and a double garage... It's like a red rag to a bull "buy cars to put in me"

Current owner had two absolutely mint old landies in there, and 80 and a 90 I think... No expert though.

Wonder if I can get him to chuck them in?