Sticking with a fun petrol, despite mega miles. Who's with me?

Sticking with a fun petrol, despite mega miles. Who's with me?

Author
Discussion

bodhi

10,485 posts

229 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
I'm with you OP, currently doing about 20k a year with a lovely petrol Bmw Straight 6 for company, and must admit I wouldn't even consider going back to a diesel. The noise and the driveability are easily worth the £5 extra a week it costs over the old 330d.

I also figured it wouldn't be long until we're all driving glorified milk floats cos of all this climate change nonsense, so felt I had to take the opportunity to run a multi cylinder petrol every day while I could. And its bloody lovely, if slightly saddening that these incredible engines are on the way out, being replaced with tedious 4 cylinder turbos.

The Big G

990 posts

168 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
Another one me here for smile on the face motoring.

I cover 25k+ each year. Two thirds in my BMW 840 at 26mpg. The remainder during the winter months in in the galant VR4 estate. That gets around 22mpg from super. 95% of my driving is on the motorway too.

Life's too short, but am thinking of a reliable small diesel estate/saloon instead, could save £200-250 a month or so which would make quite a big difference. Especially as I can't stop looking at Cerbera's, might make it easier to get the other half to agree to it smile

TheAngryDog

12,406 posts

209 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
My M5 is currently my daily, doing around 1600 miles a month.

Steve93

1,104 posts

190 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
I'm happy to stick with my 9-3 at 22mpg average.

Even my winter ST170 only does about 26mpg average.

bigkeeko

1,370 posts

143 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
I`ve tried a few diesels.

My last 3.0td wasn`t too bad but I spent my time convincing myself I liked it but I ended up selling it on and now drive a petrol 6.1L V8 as a daily. I even took it to Switzerland and back. £500 on fuel, so what? It was cheaper than 2 plane tickets and I loved it.
It would have been half the cost in a scabby smokey oil burner with no soundtrack or enjoyment with half the performance.




jamieduff1981

8,025 posts

140 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
My wife and I do around 35k/year between us. We're a petrol-only household. We both loathe diesels.

thelawnet

1,539 posts

155 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
jep said:
Yup, ran 3.0i X5 for 3 years with a 100mile round trip commute over the Peak District. Average mpg over 60k was 21.4, so I guess that makes me certifiable...
About £4k difference compared with the diesel. Still £16.5k worth of petrol though.

juice

8,533 posts

282 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
Got an S3 that does about 15mpg around town. Would never swap it for a dag-dag, life's too short

parabolica

6,715 posts

184 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
20k miles in 16 months with my 645Ci. I've never felt more alive.

VeegasS4

367 posts

157 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
I'm fully with you OP.

I used to run a twin turbo V8 - swapped to a 535d as well, but got rid within a few months as I hated it. Its neither fish nor foul. Its neither truely economical or fast.

I went straight back to a V8, i can live with the 26-28mpg for the noise and fun!

4lf4-155

700 posts

243 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
I chose a petrol Giulietta rather than diesel despite doing 20k a year.

It's on a lease deal which, after calculating mpg etc, costs me about £70 a month more than the diesel would.

It's a price I am very willing to pay.

SaintsPaul

679 posts

167 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
I am in this predicament at the moment.
I am about to sell my x type 2.0d. Do I replace it with a 2.0d Focus or a Focus ST ?
I have owned both before and I know which one I preferred to drive but boy did the ST hit your pocket laugh

DaveCWK

1,989 posts

174 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
I'm with you.
at a constant speed most petrol cars do reasonable'sih mpg.

DaveCWK

1,989 posts

174 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
swerni said:
My last petrol daily would do 19 on a run, the next one will do similar, the diesel Merc will do 50ish on a run.
I hate filling up but feel the need to go back to petrol.
What was it, a 6.0 V12 XJS? hehe

All petrol cars I have experienced with engines between 2-3L, turbo or otherwise, have done between 30 & 40mpg at 70mph.

andy-xr

13,204 posts

204 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
Not a chance, right tool for the job in my experience. I took on a role at a company 55 miles away from me, 110 mile a day round trip. Car I had at the time was a 3.0 X Type. On the second day I drove to my local car garage and asked him for anything diesel under a grand, then knocked about in those for a bit.

If I had to do that sort of commute again I'd be looking at my S Type and waving a cheery goodbye, there's no way I can afford to run that with it's mpg for commuting. I dont mind using it for company stuff as that's expensed. But no way out of my own pocket, it's £150/week just to get to work?

m8rky

2,090 posts

159 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
Did 75,000 in 3 years in a Citroen C2 VTS, mainly motorway miles commuting between Chichester and Southampton.
If you have ever driven one, they are ridicuosly low geared (70 is nearly 4000rpm) but it was fun.I went looking for C4 diesel and came back with the C2.
The real killer was that it was actually nearly the same MPG as my Xsara VTS which I was not using to save money on petrol nuts

So I sold it with mega miles on bought a low miles Xsara 1.4 as a work hack, nearly 44 mpg but 75bhp was killing me so I have now got another C2, a Code which is a VTS with leather seats.

55palfers

5,908 posts

164 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
I used to do 25K a year in a 7 year old W215 CL500 on car allowance and HMRC 26p (at the time) per mile.

Lovely!

MrBarry123

6,027 posts

121 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
Yep, I'm with you.

Went from 50mpg to 28mpg - doing 20-25k a year.

anonymous-user

54 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
Mega miles in a petrol = hours wasted queing up to fill up. As I don't want to be in first name terms with my local Esso I'll stick to diesel thanks ( 60 mpg & no mythical diesel breakdowns in 6+ years)

MrBarry123

6,027 posts

121 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
Jimboka said:
Mega miles in a petrol = hours wasted queing up to fill up. As I don't want to be in first name terms with my local Esso I'll stick to diesel thanks ( 60 mpg & no mythical diesel breakdowns in 6+ years)
Diesels are great for the weekday but rubbish on the weekends.

When I can squeeze 400 miles from a petrol engine that I enjoy driving on the weekends, a petrol works better for me.