Sticking with a fun petrol, despite mega miles. Who's with me?

Sticking with a fun petrol, despite mega miles. Who's with me?

Author
Discussion

TroubledSoul

Original Poster:

4,599 posts

194 months

Sunday 12th October 2014
quotequote all
Well.... Drove home from Edinburgh today and had a great blast along the A68 and A697 before reaching the monotony of the A1.

Would I go back to the 535d for that journey, being that the boring motorway leg was the longer part of the journey?

Not a chance.

bigkeeko

1,370 posts

143 months

Monday 13th October 2014
quotequote all
Diderot said:
if anyone doubts what a diesel can do, then they should drive a x3d or x40d and have an open mind.
I don`t doubt that diesel cars are now credible performers my friend. I had an A6 3.0 and with 230hp on tap it felt lively enough, it just didn`t float my boat. I have a work colleague with a 535d M sport saloon but he knows and I know that my petrol Jeep would jump all over it in a drag race but he needs the economy and I don`t.
Diesel has come on leaps and bounds but let`s compare his twin turbo 535d with a 3.0 twin turbo from the early 90s. Say, a Supra. Nearly 20 years on and the petrol equivalent is still MUCH quicker for the same size engine and amount of turbos. A few mods and the Supra is silly.

Big petrol engines are dying and this make me a bit sad. The same amount of technology isn`t being applied to them as diesels and like the Concorde they`re going to be a dinosaur of the past, a threat to the ozone and killing the planet etc. To some, my SRT8 Jeep is a source of amusement, almost like I have blundered and bought the wrong thing continually answering mpg questions. Six point what litre? How much road tax Ha ha etc.

I`ve maybe grown up in the wrong era. Mad Max, Dukes of Hazard etc.boxedin

Diesels are gaining ground and I will, in time, acquiesce.


Edited by bigkeeko on Monday 13th October 00:18


Edited by bigkeeko on Monday 13th October 00:32

DukeDickson

4,721 posts

213 months

Monday 13th October 2014
quotequote all
Near as damn it 20k pa in a Focus ST for what will probably be 8 years in a couple of months.
Overall, 20 years+ at that annual mileage & apart from hire cars, diesel mileage = 0 and likely to stay that way.

Not worth the misery unless doing moon miles every year.

anonymous-user

54 months

Monday 13th October 2014
quotequote all
Huge respect for this thread - we're a dying minority (until private diesel owners get hammered on tax after the next election biggrin )


kingofdbrits

622 posts

193 months

Monday 13th October 2014
quotequote all
I've done 96k miles in the lightly modified MPS in the last 3.5 years, last year was just over 30k miles and my P11d had an annual fuel spend of £7341, which is hurting a bit as my tax code is a bit low. It worked out that each mile cost 24p just in fuel.

It's new car time for me and i'll likely be moving to the dark side for the daily grind, will keep the fun petrol so if i do feel like i want to kill myself driving the derv i can hop back in the petrol.

corvus

431 posts

152 months

Monday 13th October 2014
quotequote all
TroubledSoul said:
Well.... Drove home from Edinburgh today and had a great blast along the A68 and A697 before reaching the monotony of the A1.

Would I go back to the 535d for that journey, being that the boring motorway leg was the longer part of the journey?

Not a chance.
A68 in an Impreza? Last time I was up there I was in a poxy Audi 80tdi that was overheating.

I envy you wink

donz29

364 posts

205 months

Tuesday 14th October 2014
quotequote all
New C63 arrived in May - now on 10k miles. Life's short.

cd0gg

3 posts

114 months

Tuesday 14th October 2014
quotequote all
I'm desperate to swap the Insignia diesel for a fast Petrol but just can't justify the fuel costs.
The best option so far is the Golf R with ~40mpg extra urban. Anything else anyone can suggest?

HairyMaclary

3,667 posts

195 months

Tuesday 14th October 2014
quotequote all
I've done 110k in a Clio 172.

Had it since nearly new. Biggest mileage between mots was just shy of 26k one year.

djglover

424 posts

217 months

Tuesday 14th October 2014
quotequote all
Got a 12 month old M135i with 21,000 miles on.

I have a pretty awesome commute through the Yorkshire dales.

Life's too short to drive a crap car

Man maths works in favour too, I do a fair amount of business miles (14k per year) and get 25p per mile and the petrol costs on average 17p per mile. So with the tax rebate and margin in the milage rate I make around £2k a year driving it. So if I keep it 15 years it will be free

Edited by djglover on Tuesday 14th October 13:15

inf

173 posts

192 months

Tuesday 14th October 2014
quotequote all
Currently doing 110 Miles a day in my 370z and my partner does 70 in a TTS. Loving the super fuel! No chance of moving to diesels we are just enjoying driving too much!

Edited by inf on Tuesday 14th October 14:52

TroubledSoul

Original Poster:

4,599 posts

194 months

Tuesday 14th October 2014
quotequote all
corvus said:
A68 in an Impreza? Last time I was up there I was in a poxy Audi 80tdi that was overheating.

I envy you wink
Yeah it was great. I had no idea of the delights ahead smile

Actually, it was one of those super rare drives where you encounter a few like minded people and so queues of traffic are gradually dispatched rather than becoming an obstruction. Made it all the more enjoyable.

donz29 said:
New C63 arrived in May - now on 10k miles. Life's short.
Top Man thumbup

digitalsafari

27 posts

152 months

Wednesday 26th November 2014
quotequote all
The family car for the past 3 years was a Volvo S40 2.0D, which I would call a Ford Focus with a nice interior but minus the Focus' fun to drive.

We needed a bigger car for our teenage kids and we don't do the miles to justify a diesel anymore (7-10K pa).

So all set on going back to petrol, but trying to find a three year old petrol family estate car that's not uber performance or dog slow proved to be a challenge.

Finally found a 61 plate 2011 Skoda Superb Estate 1.8 TSI SE 4x4 manual with just under 20K on the clock for 12K approved used from the main dealer.

For a big 1.8 powered 4WD barge it goes rather well, mpg is an indicated average of 23mpg for the nasty stop/start school run up a hill in heavy traffic, the 2WD diesel Volvo did an indicated 28-30mpg on the same run.





TheAllSeeingPie

865 posts

135 months

Wednesday 26th November 2014
quotequote all
Well done that man! thumbup

DrFutura

6 posts

113 months

Wednesday 26th November 2014
quotequote all
I drive a 3.0 litre V6 Jaguar x-type auto and get about 30mpg, a colleague who does virtually the same commute has a BMW 525d auto and only gets about 32mpg. He pays more per litre of fuel. He says that when he replaces it he will go back to petrol.

It is a no brainer: diesel stinks, I hate getting it on my shoes in a petrol station, even worse on hands. Diesel is more polluting. And petrol engines, particularly with six or eight cylinders sound wonderful.

Diesel is for tractors. Vile stuff. The fuel of the devil.

And if I ever have to down-size, small modern petrols with turbos are way better than small diesels and similar on fuel.

I have tried to convince myself in the past to buy a diesel, but never even got as far as a test drive.

Targarama

14,635 posts

283 months

Wednesday 26th November 2014
quotequote all
16k a year here in an E39 530i Auto. Does 29-30 mpg on a run and is perfect for me. Toying with changing it and the TVR for a 997 turbo next summer, 22-25mpg, meh who cares (work covers all my commuting miles and I only pay the tax on the rest).

talksthetorque

10,815 posts

135 months

Wednesday 26th November 2014
quotequote all
djglover said:
Got a 12 month old M135i with 21,000 miles on.

I have a pretty awesome commute through the Yorkshire dales.

Life's too short to drive a crap car

Man maths works in favour too, I do a fair amount of business miles (14k per year) and get 25p per mile and the petrol costs on average 17p per mile. So with the tax rebate and margin in the milage rate I make around £2k a year driving it. So if I keep it 15 years it will be free

Edited by djglover on Tuesday 14th October 13:15
These are the droids Man Math Figures I am looking for.

If I can squeeze this past the "fleet manager" (Hr lady) its Bye Bye Black Pump.