RE: £10K Garage: Ian Marsh

RE: £10K Garage: Ian Marsh

Wednesday 3rd December 2014

£10K Garage: Ian Marsh

PHer Ian Marsh takes an even more worthy approach to £100K Garage by choosing a fleet for just £10K



Name: Ian (B'stardchild)
Previously owned: "Lots of Opel/Vauxhalls, six banger barges and a few other makes though I've never owned a diesel!"
Currently owned: "Lotus Carlton (summer classic), BMW E38 740 (tow car), Mercedes SLK230 (daily beater) and two Opel Monzas (one track car, one long term resto)"
On the shortlist: "Much as I have enjoyed the choices people have been making with their £100K garages I thought I'd throw something a little cheaper into the mix. After all I think in these tough economic times you can get a lot of metal for your money and have some considerable variety in your motoring - maybe! I also wondered if I could replace my current fleet for £10K with cars that fit similar roles. I'm not a one car for all reasons man! My real future plans involve something plastic from Blackpool, with six cylinders preferably.

"So the goal I set myself with £10K was to find one of each: V8 barge, convertible, classic and track car, preferably RWD.

"And with whatever change left a very economical daily. One that can cope with commuting, tip runs, shopping and be utterly reliable because, lets face it, I only have £10,000 to spend to start with and I'm at the basement end of the motoring scale."



Audi A8 4.2 V8
Cost:
£1,075
Balance: £8,925
Why I chose it: "First, it must be the barge - it needs considerable towing capability (for the track car). It needs to be a nice place to be for European vacations as well as other general duties when passengers are a requirement and the ability to get to the destination is essential.

"At £1,075 with a reasonable MOT, AWD and a V8 this A8 fits the bill nicely. It took very little finding actually, has loads of equipment and reasonable miles. It's free to hand back the plate to DVLA but I quite like car related plates so it can stay.

"The only downside of this choice is an irrational hatred of portrait pictures of cars taken with mobile phone - but I'll not let that stand in the way of the choice."

From Shed money to £60K plus, see here for all PH's used A8s.

Mazda MX-5
Cost: £1,800
Balance: £7,125
Why I chose it: "The obvious PH choice but I need a fun convertible. At £1,800 with both hard and soft tops included it ticks all the boxes for year-round usability - sure there are cheaper about but I quite like the dirty nappy colour too (it's a Marmite shade for sure!). It should provide some top-down entertainment and perhaps provide a drop in replacement if the track car fails."

It's the obvious choice for a reason! MX-5s on PH here.


Porsche 944 2.7
Cost:
£3,295
Balance: £3,830
Why I chose it: "Now I need a classic car. Something that isn't going to be used everyday but puts a smile on my face and makes journeys an adventure, maybe for all the wrong reasons. And for all that it's probably got to be either Norfolk or Blackpool based, but I was swayed by the lure of a Porsche. At £3,295 It's mid-priced but I'm a sucker for a coupe body and pop up headlights that work. At 140K miles it seems to wear its miles well."

See here for all the 944s on PH.

VW Golf GTI Mk1
Cost:
£3,200
Balance: £630
Why I chose it: "I'm still short of a track car! Whilst I'd prefer RWD it's more important that the track prep is sorted already. This Golf is £3,200 with most of the essential stuff done (cage being the important one) and it's always easier if someone else has done most of the hard work for you. Rear-wheel drive would have been nice but if I've got to have front-wheel drive then why not one of the original hot hatch icons?"

Early Golf GTIs for sale here.


Nissan Micra
Cost:
£650
Balance: £-20...
Why I chose it: "I need something small, economical and utterly reliable to save fuel money on essential journeys so more can be spent at the weekends - the track day and tow car as well as the Porsche.

"Sorry for this choice but I introduce to you the automotive equivalent of the cockroach (it will still be here after the end of the world). It's only £650 with 73,000 miles, black bumpers and fold down seats. Bargain. I won't have to worry about anything other than routine maintenance, and it appears Nissans don't even mind less than routine maintenance.

"OK - I blew the budget by £20 (nobody pays sticker price, do they?) but due to cars selling before this could go to press various changes have been made to the line up.

"In the first draft I had enough change to fill up the Micra (different one) and go out for a curry..."

All Micras on PH (yes, really) this way.



Author
Discussion

fastgerman

Original Poster:

1,914 posts

195 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Great idea and loving the MK1 GTI, 944 and big Audi :-)

I do hate Nissan Micra's however...

d3llams

121 posts

126 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Now that is some garage for only £10k. I would probably change the Audi for a Jaaag though.

foxhounduk

493 posts

180 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Like the selection! Particularly the A8! Luxo-barge for peanuts.

Also, nice colour choice! Each one is burgundy lol

sandman77

2,417 posts

138 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Brilliant!!! This is much better than the (now tired format of) £100k garage.

Love the 944.

d3llams

121 posts

126 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Im a sucker for old Jags, the A8 will be a better winter hack/ tow car no doubt.

W124

1,532 posts

138 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Strong work!

900T-R

20,404 posts

257 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Actually, this is more fun than the £100K garage... thumbup

RobM77

35,349 posts

234 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Great choices, but how much to get them driving like they did when they were new?... wink

amstrange1

600 posts

176 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Great shout on the £10k garage - more please!

I reckon I'd spend the Micra purchase price (and tax, MOT, insurance and maintenance costs) on sticking more fuel in the A8 or MX-5.

Djtemeka

1,811 posts

192 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
I'm off to a good start on my 10k garage.
I own a 1.0 corsa with 50k miles. Bought for £300. Spent £40 on new brakes and pads and no advisories on mot. Had 8 months now and reliable. Only cost is the water ingress around the window area into the glove box. Common issue for those corsas apparently. £300 from a shop to strip down all the bits and reseal everything.
Total spend this year is still under £700. Best part is £50 gets us 450-500 miles.
Cheapo shopping car smile

daytona365

1,773 posts

164 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Must say that being piss poor, this selection is more akin to what I would personally choose. Don't understand how some folk can spend 40, 50, 60 grand on a totally mediocre, depreciating liability ?!

hwajones

775 posts

181 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all

Well done that Man!

J4CKO

41,565 posts

200 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Hope you have a MIG welder for that lot !

scubadude

2,618 posts

197 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Excellent revision to the format and actually obtainable if you where slightly mad :-)

I currently have about £10K on the drive in shape of small estate, van and dive boat, it's got me wondering what I could have if starting from scratch, the old Porsche is definitely an itch worth scratching in future.

WillBrumBrum

607 posts

198 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
I like how you bend the rules, by reducing it from £100k to £10k and then brake your own rules by going over the £10k by £20!

You remind me of the crooks Richard Branson, Nick Leeson and Derek Trotter!

ash reynolds

469 posts

191 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Like this!
Particularly the Golf whistle

DeltonaS

3,707 posts

138 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
ash reynolds said:
Like this!
Particularly the Golf whistle
Would make more sence to use the 944 as a track car.....


"nobody pays sticker price, do they?"

tank

It all depends cheeky boy, it's all relative, if the sticker is already on it's lowest low, some even pay over it....etc.etc.

Bispal

1,619 posts

151 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Great choice! I have 3 of them for all the reasons you mention. My £900 Micra for going to the train / tube station, running short errands and driving (and parking) in central London where it is in its element (being an auto). This means I don't need to ruin my 911 (996 targa) for short journeys and it becomes a great holiday car where it manages 34 mpg on trips though Europe. Not quite in the budget but same principle. I also have the MX5, in white but a mk1, you cant beat the pop up lights!) Mine is in A1 condition with only 50,000 miles from new and cost the same as your mk2. This will also become my track car as the Porsche tyres are £200+ each and toyos for the MX5 £29 each. Good choice of barge but i would prefer an estate, Mercedes 300 te-24? As for classic i think the MX5 and 996 are almost there :-) £10,000 much more fun, well done!

smilo996

2,793 posts

170 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
Best comment so far:

"I introduce to you the automotive equivalent of the cockroach"

He must be Scottish, Presbyterian or both.

Some good choices for the money with potential to be loved and made better.

Now waiting for the 1000K garage.

zerovira

63 posts

131 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
B'stard Child said:
Thanks - I wasn't bored with the 100K garage (it's nice to see how people would spend that money) it was just that I'll never have that kind of budget so submitted this for the real world PH'rs
Indeed.

As much as I like the 100k thing, I think putting the limit at 10k is far more sensible. Most of us will never have 100k to spend, so it is useful as a dream garage, but not very much as an attainable one... maybe we can create a new section? It will be useful to have new ideas on our everyday advertisement lurking...


By the way, I have to say I hate you brits a little. Here in spain second hand price tags for almost every car are much, much higher.