2 young guys killed in Austrian Alps racing. Came off a clif

2 young guys killed in Austrian Alps racing. Came off a clif

Author
Discussion

likesachange

2,631 posts

194 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
Riley Blue said:
Perhaps it's time this thread was locked.
agreed.

Whats done is done.

RIP

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

126 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
trails said:
My point still stands though; only whoever was there at the time really knows what happened and they are dead.
Which is why there's an inquest to look at the facts that are available, and make an official decision on what happened.
It was a single-vehicle incident. There was enough speed to take their car through a barrier. And that official decision was that Robinson lost control of the car in circumstances reports as "while racing" the Porsche. I've not read the transcript of the verdict. You've not read the transcript of the verdict. All we know is some bare facts plus a whole pile of hearsay around the edges, which nobody really seems to have any counter to.

Everything, added together, looks fairly conclusive from where I'm sat.

Sure, there's minor details - were they wearing belts or not, was there a mechanical problem or not - which we'll never know. But they don't actually change much. They were ttting it up there, and they ttted it waaaay too hard, and the direct and utterly predictable result was one last, very, very long "ohst" moment.

zebra

4,555 posts

214 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
trails said:
zebra said:
We know exactly why they are dead, we just do not know the minute detail.

They drove off a cliff. I doubt they were driving any more sensibly that day than their videos from the previous days demonstrated.

If you're upset by that, get over it.
No, no we don't and that's just the point; much supposition and guesswork but no facts. All we know is they are dead...who knows maybe they swerved to avoid a cyclist in the wrong place and the cyclist hasn't come forward.

I'm not upset I just think there is no harm in showing a little empathy, particularly when all the facts are not available.
Get a grip you melt. Their videos suggest otherwise, or are you trying to suggest that on this one day they were driving like miss daisy. Yeah right.

Wake up.

AyBee

10,535 posts

202 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
yonex said:
Of course, nobody on PH has ever made a mistake on the road. Nobody has ever broken the speed limit or has been at the mercy of the courts for various infringements of the Highway Code? Never, none of us rolleyes

Because we're all so talented lucky.
Whilst I agree with your sentiment, the middle ground is that we're all still here because we drive enthusiastically where a mistake has a much greater chance of not be fatal. These guys did not and paid the ultimate price, it was their choice though. RIP.

anonymous-user

54 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
AyBee said:
Whilst I agree with your sentiment, the middle ground is that we're all still here because we drive enthusiastically where a mistake has a much greater chance of not be fatal. These guys did not and paid the ultimate price, it was their choice though. RIP.
Yes. Luck.



bitchstewie

51,232 posts

210 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
Tasteful. Well done all.

Gav147

977 posts

161 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
zebra said:
We know exactly why they are dead, we just do not know the minute detail.

They drove off a cliff. I doubt they were driving any more sensibly that day than their videos from the previous days demonstrated.

If you're upset by that, get over it.
It's not about being upset though is it, it is just some of the comments in this thread are out of order... They made the choice to drive that day and what ever happened they paid the ultimate price, that is it, end of story. There is no need for all the snipping and armchair detectives trying to state what happened, if some of the posters stopped to think for a minute, this is an open public forum and any one of their friends and/or family could well be reading all the st that is getting posted in here.. There is no need for it.

RIP

S10GTA

12,679 posts

167 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
result was one last, very, very long "ohst" moment.
Is there an estimate for how long it would have been from leaving the road to hitting the deck?

hora

37,133 posts

211 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
https://youtu.be/y1LhUzL3qdU

This Summer I drove on these two roads. The first in a car with fading brakes with 5,000ft of drops on some bends and wooden barriers in places.

Looking at the car made me shudder.

What if I'd gone over the edge? Witnesses at the resort may have said I drove that Panda abit too quick yet I shat myself on some sections of that road.

Phil Dicky

7,162 posts

263 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
S10GTA said:
TooMany2cvs said:
result was one last, very, very long "ohst" moment.
Is there an estimate for how long it would have been from leaving the road to hitting the deck?
A sobering thought, I guess they had a few seconds of realisation they were going to die.

gweaver

906 posts

158 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
S10GTA said:
TooMany2cvs said:
result was one last, very, very long "ohst" moment.
Is there an estimate for how long it would have been from leaving the road to hitting the deck?
60 metres in freefall is about 3.5 seconds. Not a pleasant thought.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

126 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
gweaver said:
S10GTA said:
TooMany2cvs said:
result was one last, very, very long "ohst" moment.
Is there an estimate for how long it would have been from leaving the road to hitting the deck?
60 metres in freefall is about 3.5 seconds. Not a pleasant thought.
It'd be longer than that - 60m freefall in 3.5 seconds presumes terminal velocity already reached, doesn't it? So you've got vertical acceleration time... Wasn't there an estimate (guesstimate?) of 10sec earlier? I'd guess somewhere in the middle. Call it six seconds?

<crunch> through barrier
One elephant
Two elephants
Three elephants
Four elephants
Five elephants
Six elephants
<crunch> first landing...

11110111

612 posts

200 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
gweaver said:
S10GTA said:
TooMany2cvs said:
result was one last, very, very long "ohst" moment.
Is there an estimate for how long it would have been from leaving the road to hitting the deck?
60 metres in freefall is about 3.5 seconds. Not a pleasant thought.
It'd be longer than that - 60m freefall in 3.5 seconds presumes terminal velocity already reached, doesn't it? So you've got vertical acceleration time... Wasn't there an estimate (guesstimate?) of 10sec earlier? I'd guess somewhere in the middle. Call it six seconds?

<crunch> through barrier
One elephant
Two elephants
Three elephants
Four elephants
Five elephants
Six elephants
<crunch> first landing...
Seriously that's a grim thought but pls bear in mind that friends and family of the chap may be on here. I wouldn't want to read that about any of mine. Even the DMail has more class than that

gweaver

906 posts

158 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
It'd be longer than that - 60m freefall in 3.5 seconds presumes terminal velocity already reached, doesn't it?
No.

Try this online calculator http://keisan.casio.com/exec/system/1231475371

vonhosen

40,233 posts

217 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
I'd imagine the families were at the inquest so heard all the details.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

126 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
gweaver said:
TooMany2cvs said:
It'd be longer than that - 60m freefall in 3.5 seconds presumes terminal velocity already reached, doesn't it?
No.

Try this online calculator http://keisan.casio.com/exec/system/1231475371
Furry muff. No idea what the air resistance is, though...

Gary C

12,441 posts

179 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
11110111 said:
TooMany2cvs said:
gweaver said:
S10GTA said:
TooMany2cvs said:
result was one last, very, very long "ohst" moment.
Is there an estimate for how long it would have been from leaving the road to hitting the deck?
60 metres in freefall is about 3.5 seconds. Not a pleasant thought.
It'd be longer than that - 60m freefall in 3.5 seconds presumes terminal velocity already reached, doesn't it? So you've got vertical acceleration time... Wasn't there an estimate (guesstimate?) of 10sec earlier? I'd guess somewhere in the middle. Call it six seconds?

<crunch> through barrier
One elephant
Two elephants
Three elephants
Four elephants
Five elephants
Six elephants
<crunch> first landing...
Seriously that's a grim thought but pls bear in mind that friends and family of the chap may be on here. I wouldn't want to read that about any of mine. Even the DMail has more class than that
You are, of course right and if anyone knows them then deepest sympathy.

However, that thought described above does make a very deep impression and may make someone think twice.

Toltec

7,159 posts

223 months

Wednesday 16th November 2016
quotequote all
yonex said:
AyBee said:
Whilst I agree with your sentiment, the middle ground is that we're all still here because we drive enthusiastically where a mistake has a much greater chance of not be fatal. These guys did not and paid the ultimate price, it was their choice though. RIP.
Yes. Luck.
I'd change that to-

much greater chance of being correctable.

So I'd go judgement and experience, but I'm probably a wuss (or control freak) so if you want to rely on luck go for it, just no where near me please.

That road is a great drive, but the consequences of getting it wrong are scary, if nothing else I hope their memory serves to save a few lives in coming years.

trails

3,715 posts

149 months

Wednesday 16th November 2016
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
Which is why there's an inquest to look at the facts that are available, and make an official decision on what happened.
It was a single-vehicle incident. There was enough speed to take their car through a barrier. And that official decision was that Robinson lost control of the car in circumstances reports as "while racing" the Porsche. I've not read the transcript of the verdict. You've not read the transcript of the verdict. All we know is some bare facts plus a whole pile of hearsay around the edges, which nobody really seems to have any counter to.

Everything, added together, looks fairly conclusive from where I'm sat.

Sure, there's minor details - were they wearing belts or not, was there a mechanical problem or not - which we'll never know. But they don't actually change much. They were ttting it up there, and they ttted it waaaay too hard, and the direct and utterly predictable result was one last, very, very long "ohst" moment.
Agreed, probably is correct but its the tone of some on here that blows; everyone with the smallest drop of petrol in their veins has driven like an utter tool on the road at one time or another but most people get away with it; these poor feckers didn't and paid the ultimate price. That makes me sad so I must be soft smile

trails

3,715 posts

149 months

Wednesday 16th November 2016
quotequote all
zebra said:
Get a grip you melt. Their videos suggest otherwise, or are you trying to suggest that on this one day they were driving like miss daisy. Yeah right.

Wake up.
'Get a grip' rolleyes No grip issues here stripy.

I'm not suggesting anything; merely pointing out that neither of us know what really happened. So maybe step out of the powerfully built PH Director persona and have a little empathy for two poor kids and their families.