Same again, sir?

Author
Discussion

Jimbo.

Original Poster:

3,947 posts

189 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
Generally, I like to try different things and mix it up a little: different foods, beers, phones, computers, bikes etc. Variety is the spice of life, and all that...

But how far would you take It with a car given the faff and financial outlay? F'instance, if you had a car that fitted your needs _perfectly_, come the time for replacement, would you buy the same again, or you would you go for something different, purely because it's, well...different?

Just curious smile

R8Steve

4,150 posts

175 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
Jimbo. said:
Generally, I like to try different things and mix it up a little: different foods, beers, phones, computers, bikes etc. Variety is the spice of life, and all that...

But how far would you take It with a car given the faff and financial outlay? F'instance, if you had a car that fitted your needs _perfectly_, come the time for replacement, would you buy the same again, or you would you go for something different, purely because it's, well...different?

Just curious smile
I've thought about this lately as well. I've got a leased SLK 250 CDI AMG in black/black as my daily driver and have been thinking what to replace it with at the end of the lease. So far the most likely replacement is an SLK 250 CDI AMG in black/black. laugh

TiminYorkshire

513 posts

219 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
How do you find the SLK 250cdi? I presume you like it if going for the same again?

anothernameitist

1,500 posts

135 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
Why replace if it fits the bill?

I did change a car once like 4 like but did change colour for a bit of a change

R8Steve

4,150 posts

175 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
TiminYorkshire said:
How do you find the SLK 250cdi? I presume you like it if going for the same again?
I find it an excellent car hence why i'm struggling to think of a better replacement. Very cheap to lease, great MPG, fairly quick for what it is, looks great and the interior is a nice place to be. I recently did a 700 mile road trip up to the highlands and took it instead of the R8! (it was 21 degrees right enough so the retractable roof made the decision for me though to be fair)

Truckosaurus

11,275 posts

284 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
anothernameitist said:
Why replace if it fits the bill?
End of lease, car stolen, destroyed in crash, discarded due to Bangernomics, etc.

sidekickdmr

5,075 posts

206 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
I had a white insignia VX line estate specked upto the tee purchased as an ex demo. Loved it, great car and was easily as refined as the Merc/BMW equivalent, did about 50,000 miles in it in about 2 years.

Ended up selling it as it was a bit too big for just the two of us and one dog.

Then we ended up with a 2nd dog, so needed a bigger car again.

Purchased another insignia, again an ex demo VX line in white with all the toys, but this time a new (and improved) shape?

WORST CAR EVER

Cost us £24,000 and broke down 4 times in 4 months and all the new tech was just useless and slow.

It went ASAP and id never have another now.

So no, not always does the same mean good/safe

mk4gtiturbo

194 posts

147 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
I'm thinking the same. My vRS is due to end the lease in just over a years time. I still enjoy driving the car but my dilemma is do I just to buy it out and have the car I know the whole history of but no warranty (I know I can buy one) or just get another PCP deal. We'll see in a year I'll probably have changed my mind again.

Johnny 89

824 posts

152 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
This thought crossed my mind too..

I currently own a TVR Chimaera 400 in Macau yellow. I love the Chim.

However, my ideal spec. Chimaera is a Midas yellow 500. Is it ever worth me getting my ideal spec. As I have such a similar car already?

Oh, of course "similar" is relative.

Smitters

4,003 posts

157 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
I'm on my second Audi estate and my second Caterham, so I guess the answer's yes.

The changes have normally been prompted by a newer model having an advantage that cannot be cheaply or simply added to the existing one, so sale and replacement was the best route.

Jimbo.

Original Poster:

3,947 posts

189 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
Truckosaurus said:
anothernameitist said:
Why replace if it fits the bill?
End of lease, car stolen, destroyed in crash, discarded due to Bangernomics, etc.
Very much the latter with me! Although I'll be moving on from bangernomics to something a little nicer/newer, but otherwise nigh-on the same.

cerb4.5lee

30,534 posts

180 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
I had a sierra xr4x4 which I loved but foolishly sold it to buy a house then I realised I could still afford one so got another one in exactly the same colour and kept it for 5 and a half years until a clown crashed into me and wrote it off.

I keep thinking of buying another s14 200sx because that has been the most favourite car I have owned but I do keep wondering if I would be disappointed going back to one after nearly 10 years.

LittleEnus

3,225 posts

174 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
R8Steve said:
I've thought about this lately as well. I've got a leased SLK 250 CDI AMG in black/black as my daily driver and have been thinking what to replace it with at the end of the lease. So far the most likely replacement is an SLK 250 CDI AMG in black/black. laugh
Is that the AMG? Not just a SLK?

Major Fallout

5,278 posts

231 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
This is why I have had my bmw 650 for 7 maybe 8 years now.

Its nice to be in its nice to drive, the radio is good, I only need two seats.

T1berious

2,259 posts

155 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
We're looking at replacing a 330i with a 430d. I love the E92 as it's fun to drive, comfy and quite understated for the performance on offer. 132k later it still feels brilliant. Test drove the 430d and it felt lifeless in comparison, arcade game steering and it seemed to disconnect the driver rather than involve them.

Funny as progress doesn't always equal more fun.

LittleEnus

3,225 posts

174 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
Life is too short not to try news cars. I find it odd people will stay with Volvo's or Bm's. Mix it up brothers.

The Wookie

13,946 posts

228 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
I'm going to have the same issue when the time comes to replace the Cayenne. It's such a great package for what I use it for and despite the fact I virtually live in it I love driving it.

The replacement would have to be quick, do 30mpg with my driving, sound good, tow large trailers, have plenty of space, be comfortable on long runs, handle well enough, be able to wade, have a nice interior...

The Range Sport V8 Diesel might fit the bill but it doesn't sound as good and isn't as quick.

Upsettingly I think they're discontinuing the V8 diesel so I may not be able to get another once I've finished with this one. It's a great everyday car for me. I may well end up just running it into the ground.

sparkythecat

7,902 posts

255 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
In 1981, a friend of mine was bought a VW Golf 1500GLS for his 21st Birthday.
3 years later he replaced it with a Golf Gti
He's bought a new Golf Gti every 3 years since then and is now on his 10th.

WaferThinHam

1,680 posts

130 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
LittleEnus said:
Life is too short not to try news cars. I find it odd people will stay with Volvo's or Bm's. Mix it up brothers.
This. Would you drink the same beer all of the time?

R8Steve

4,150 posts

175 months

Friday 27th November 2015
quotequote all
LittleEnus said:
R8Steve said:
I've thought about this lately as well. I've got a leased SLK 250 CDI AMG in black/black as my daily driver and have been thinking what to replace it with at the end of the lease. So far the most likely replacement is an SLK 250 CDI AMG in black/black. laugh
Is that the AMG? Not just a SLK?
Not sure what you mean? AMG is just the spec level, like S series on Audi's. It's a 2.1 twin turbo diesel.