PCP - 4 months old, want rid.

PCP - 4 months old, want rid.

Author
Discussion

ashleyman

Original Poster:

6,987 posts

100 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
nickfrog said:
279 said:
The small blemishes in the bodywork of a mass produced car (that the dealer are making an effort to rectify, perhaps just not to your standards*)
An effort to rectify ? They've buffer trailed 4 panels !!!!!!!!!!
The dealer put the buffer trails there not the factory!

nickfrog

21,183 posts

218 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
ashleyman said:
nickfrog said:
279 said:
The small blemishes in the bodywork of a mass produced car (that the dealer are making an effort to rectify, perhaps just not to your standards*)
An effort to rectify ? They've buffer trailed 4 panels !!!!!!!!!!
The dealer put the buffer trails there not the factory!
Yes indeed, I understand that, hence pointing out that the dealers' effort to rectify the factory defect resulted in more defect.

anonymous-user

55 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
nickfrog said:
279 said:
The small blemishes in the bodywork of a mass produced car (that the dealer are making an effort to rectify, perhaps just not to your standards*)
An effort to rectify ? They've buffer trailed 4 panels !!!!!!!!!!
Main Dealer in poor polish job shocker.

That's at best a 'Sorry Sir, we'll rectify the issue (all it needs is a few hours with a good detailer) and provide you with a free 1st year Service' at best.

jamieduff1981

8,025 posts

141 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
tenfour said:
The faults you mention sound to me like the car is an accident repair. It might be worth your piece of mind and your leverage to have the car independently inspected for crash damage by a recognised body like RAC etc. I'd think it extremely rare for a car to come off the production line with obvious paint defects/misaligned/loose trim etc, especially a premium product.
I'm not sure Germany's answer to Ford is a premium product - that and superior quality are just something people like to believe to justify paying more for their mass produced hatchback.

OP, just get shot of the thing however you can.

Jonno02

2,247 posts

110 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
jamieduff1981 said:
I'm not sure Germany's answer to Ford is a premium product - that and superior quality are just something people like to believe to justify paying more for their mass produced hatchback.

OP, just get shot of the thing however you can.
If you're not going to give any helpful comments to the OP, ps off and enjoy your obscure marque car that nobody else owns and leave us to our mass produced cars. wavey

nickfrog

21,183 posts

218 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
jamieduff1981 said:
I'm not sure Germany's answer to Ford is a premium product
Not sure what this has got to do with Germany or Ford. Could have happened with any mass produced car.

ashleyman

Original Poster:

6,987 posts

100 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
ok, anyway. Does anyone think I have a case for handing back the car, getting an exchange? Is it something I should pursue or just not worth thinking about?

Has anyone actually handed a car back? Whats the process? How did it go for you? What was your resolution?

I'm not a compensation we, but I really do feel like something is justified here. I've already paid for 2 years of servicing up front so not servicing. I'm on 10k miles per year that suited me but all the extra 105 mile round trips to the dealer has totally knocked my milage calculations out the window. I reckon this has added up to at least 500 miles so far not including trips to body shops or the local dealer. That's 5% of my yearly miles I can't use for myself plus the fuel costs involved in that - £120 for 2 tanks of fuel. Not a lot but still out of pocket.

I've been trying to have a think about what compensation if any I would feel appropriate and I can't think of any. Servicing, nice but already paid for. They could up my yearly milage but then that devalues the GFV at the end if I was to keep it to the end of the term. Could they give me the 19" alloys that I couldn't justify to the wife when I ordered the car? Thats a bit much £££ though. What is there that they can offer as a sorry?

I've been looking at replacement cars this morning if I was to end up handing it back and really can't find anything that would be ideal. This is why we picked the Golf R in the first place. So its not that I don't like the car its just been so much hassle since we got it.

peklim

52 posts

102 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
You could ask for a payment holiday for an appropriate period. I obtained this from BMW on a car which didn't have as may problems as yours.

Tuvra

7,921 posts

226 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
ashleyman said:
I've been trying to have a think about what compensation if any I would feel appropriate and I can't think of any. Servicing, nice but already paid for. They could up my yearly milage but then that devalues the GFV at the end if I was to keep it to the end of the term. Could they give me the 19" alloys that I couldn't justify to the wife when I ordered the car? Thats a bit much £££ though. What is there that they can offer as a sorry?

I've been looking at replacement cars this morning if I was to end up handing it back and really can't find anything that would be ideal. This is why we picked the Golf R in the first place. So its not that I don't like the car its just been so much hassle since we got it.
It sounds like you've had a very rare lemon. Personally, I would push VW to rectify the problem or possibly even take another car as a replacement, they may have a delivery mileage/demo car somewhere that you may be able to have while they take in your lemon and put it right once and for all.

In terms of what else, I'd stick with it, I have done 19k trouble free miles in mine and I am genuinely worried that the Focus RS I have coming in March will not live up to the Golf R. Pound for pound I think the Golf R is towards the top of the tree in terms of bang per buck, throw £1k at a DSG car and you have a serious bit of kit, despite what the naysayers here will have you believe smile

otolith

56,169 posts

205 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
VW aren't immune from this kind of thing.


ashleyman

Original Poster:

6,987 posts

100 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
Tuvra said:
It sounds like you've had a very rare lemon. Personally, I would push VW to rectify the problem or possibly even take another car as a replacement, they may have a delivery mileage/demo car somewhere that you may be able to have while they take in your lemon and put it right once and for all.

In terms of what else, I'd stick with it, I have done 19k trouble free miles in mine and I am genuinely worried that the Focus RS I have coming in March will not live up to the Golf R. Pound for pound I think the Golf R is towards the top of the tree in terms of bang per buck, throw £1k at a DSG car and you have a serious bit of kit, despite what the naysayers here will have you believe smile
It just seems to be one thing after another. I really don't have the time to be dealing with car issues. I bought a new car to try and make sure that it had maximum up-time but I seem to be spending more time trying to fix this new car than I did with the old one it replaced.

I've looked at other cars, the M140i and S3 are the next best thing but both of them would cost a lot more once you factor in Auto, Cruise and parking sensors. All things the Golf R has as standard. I would be tempted to get a replacement Golf R as it would mean I could change the colour and still keep such a great car but loose the issues. The Golf R is a fantastic machine but the issues I am having are just not cool.

Wish

1,273 posts

250 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
The DTD is in Kent.

I know them well. If you think of diggers you won't go wrong ;-)

lord trumpton

7,406 posts

127 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
I had a similar experience with a Golf R but not on PCP.

First one had a bonnet like a plumbers radio - full of inclusions and fisheyes in the paint - obviously been painted

The replacement had poorly aligned doors on pax side. st quality - kept it 2 months.

Recently bought an Octavia vrs230 - absolutely perfect throughout. I think the Wolfsburg boys need to up their game.

Jonno02

2,247 posts

110 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
Wish said:
The DTD is in Kent.

I know them well. If you think of diggers you won't go wrong ;-)
Aha the OP sent me an email telling me where. Bit far for me to order from being up in Glasgow! 500 mile trip!

ashleyman

Original Poster:

6,987 posts

100 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
lord trumpton said:
I had a similar experience with a Golf R but not on PCP.

First one had a bonnet like a plumbers radio - full of inclusions and fisheyes in the paint - obviously been painted

The replacement had poorly aligned doors on pax side. st quality - kept it 2 months.

Recently bought an Octavia vrs230 - absolutely perfect throughout. I think the Wolfsburg boys need to up their game.
How did you go about changing the first one?

Narcisus

8,081 posts

281 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
xRIEx said:
I know I'm probably a censored for asking this so apologies first off (but I'm going to ask anyway): if you were in standstill traffic why didn't you have a brake already applied (especially when messing with something that governs speed)? Also, isn't adaptive cruise a good thing for traffic jams?

Last thought: are you sure you didn't hit the RES button instead? (I don't know the button layout on these things.)
If it's dsg and like my Superb the handbrake is automatic. I've owned my car 10 months the and never touched it.

ashleyman

Original Poster:

6,987 posts

100 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
Narcisus said:
If it's dsg and like my Superb the handbrake is automatic. I've owned my car 10 months the and never touched it.
Yep, my Golf R is a DSG and I haven't touched the handbrake at all.

Narcisus

8,081 posts

281 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
Narcisus said:
If it's dsg and like my Superb the handbrake is automatic. I've owned my car 10 months the and never touched it.
Weird ! Talk about delayed double post !

nickfrog

21,183 posts

218 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
ashleyman said:
I've looked at other cars, the M140i and S3 are the next best thing but both of them would cost a lot more once you factor in Auto, Cruise and parking sensors.
The cost of Auto on a M140i is no different to DSG. Cruise and sensors is £500. There used to be std kit on the BMW that wasn't std on the Golf like leather, cruise, Brembos, Supersports, etc... But the main thing is that you can vet 20% to 22% off on the BMW, which should make it cheaper than the Golf.

timberman

1,284 posts

216 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
Wish said:
The DTD is in Kent.

I know them well. If you think of diggers you won't go wrong ;-)
Haha, that's where our tiguan came from 2 years ago,
Medway, kent to be exact.

We also had a slight issue with the drivers outside door trim not being affixed properly,

It took about 4 months before we finally got them to agree to pay for it to be rectified by our local dealer.