RE: Revo's Mustang 'Ecobeast': PH Videoblog

RE: Revo's Mustang 'Ecobeast': PH Videoblog

Author
Discussion

aeropilot

34,630 posts

227 months

Friday 16th September 2016
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
I played my wife clips of the V8 and Ecoboost sounds and strangely she said she preferred the first one, which was the Ecoboost, the second, the V8 sounded fake !

Admittedly it was on a poxy laptop speak and she said the sound of a Mustang should make you go weak at the knees and neither did, guess you need to hear them in person.
The sound of stock V8 isn't going to make you go weak at the knees as the noise regs won't allow it......plenty of options to address that issue though smile


J4CKO

41,588 posts

200 months

Friday 16th September 2016
quotequote all
aeropilot said:
J4CKO said:
I played my wife clips of the V8 and Ecoboost sounds and strangely she said she preferred the first one, which was the Ecoboost, the second, the V8 sounded fake !

Admittedly it was on a poxy laptop speak and she said the sound of a Mustang should make you go weak at the knees and neither did, guess you need to hear them in person.
The sound of stock V8 isn't going to make you go weak at the knees as the noise regs won't allow it......plenty of options to address that issue though smile
Yeah, very true !

philmots

4,631 posts

260 months

Friday 16th September 2016
quotequote all
Good video again, I'm enjoying the regularity of them, keep it up.

To the car, when he was pulling through the gears it just sounded completely wrong, out of character.

macky17

2,212 posts

189 months

Friday 16th September 2016
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
macky17 said:
AndySheff said:
Devil2575 said:
Ah yes, the potential 6 series buyer who decides to buy a Ford instead...
Hah hah - well here's one ! I bought a 2012 Mustang GT instead of (one of) my other choice - a 6 series. Ended up with a much newer car. Lots of V8 lovliness. A manual 6spd. But of course it's too wide, too plasticky, and can't go round corners.
Exactly. Why wouldn't a petrolhead consider a BMW and a Ford together? Anyone who says otherwise is thinking of those strange non-petrolhead types who buy a badge with a car attached.
Perhaps you should have read my whole post rather than just responding to a sound bite. Of course a petrol head would consider a Ford and a BMW, I did back before I bought an E36 328 years back. However most people aren't petrolheads and petrolheads don't tend to have a massive influence on overall sales figures. Also buyers of used cars don't have an impact on new cars sales and hence new car production.
My bad. You're right, I only read that extract from someone else's quote.

I submit, however, that the Mustang is more likely to be bought by a petrolhead than a non-petrolhead - therefore 'we' are likely to have more influence on Mustang sales than, for example, sales of a 6-series.

FWDRacer

3,564 posts

224 months

Friday 16th September 2016
quotequote all
Had a V6 Mustang as hire this year in the US. Still thinking about the what if? What if Hertz hadn't fugged up my booking hehe B'stard's rage

V8 baby. Anything else is a pale imitation. Sure the I-4 is legacy only of 'stang iterations that had come before.

Centurion07

10,381 posts

247 months

Friday 16th September 2016
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
Just like the Vauxhall Monaro?

I like the Mustang, a mate who lived in Florida for years ran a Supercharged V8 of the last incarnation, but it isn't going to be a big seller.
Are they still available?

Even if they are, mention that name to a non-petrolhead and watch the look of complete disinterest spread across their face. EVERYONE has heard of a Mustang.

To date, there have been a smidge over 2000 new Mustangs (70% V8's) registered in the first year. I genuinely have no idea on Ford's targets but I would say for a 5 litre V8, that's pretty good going.

Personally I hope they don't sell too many more. I like the relative rarity.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

188 months

Friday 16th September 2016
quotequote all
Centurion07 said:
Devil2575 said:
Just like the Vauxhall Monaro?

I like the Mustang, a mate who lived in Florida for years ran a Supercharged V8 of the last incarnation, but it isn't going to be a big seller.
Are they still available?

Even if they are, mention that name to a non-petrolhead and watch the look of complete disinterest spread across their face. EVERYONE has heard of a Mustang.

To date, there have been a smidge over 2000 new Mustangs (70% V8's) registered in the first year. I genuinely have no idea on Ford's targets but I would say for a 5 litre V8, that's pretty good going.

Personally I hope they don't sell too many more. I like the relative rarity.
No they're not. It was a comment about the fact that Vauxhall offered something similar a few years back and it didn't do that well. I agree the Mustang is a lot better known but I still don't think it has enough appeal to get many sales from non-petrolheads. Non-petrolheads usually opt for the 2.0 diesel version of any car so a car that is only available as a petrol and two not especially economical ones at that isn't really going to be a top seller, I suspect at least anyway.
Rarity is great but ultimately it means that it won't last. Ford need to shift enough to justify selling them in the UK. If they don't it will be dropped.

vsonix

3,858 posts

163 months

Friday 16th September 2016
quotequote all
The Ecoboost engine is really impressive, but putting it in a full-size Mustang doesn't really seem to me to be the best place for it. As mentioned in the video it's a BIG car. Also, it's the kind of car that is mostly known for its V8, bought for its V8... not so much for the way it looks, although that is a part of it of course. What I think would be more interesting is if Ford were to keep in line with Mustang heritage of the 5.0 V8, optimising the power and economy, evolving the concept. Then, resurrect another smaller RWD 2-door coupe model like the Capri or Pinto, make that the showcase for the four and 5 pot motors.

peter450

1,650 posts

233 months

Saturday 17th September 2016
quotequote all
kapiteinlangzaam said:
swerni said:
kapiteinlangzaam said:
Devil2575 said:
kapiteinlangzaam said:
It absolutely competes with the 6 series. Not on new price, granted. But a 2-3yr old 640/650i Vs a new Mustang V8 is a very valid comparison. Same brief, same layout, same sort of experience.

Out of interest, which smaller cars do you think its competing with?
Ah yes, the potential 6 series buyer who decides to buy a Ford instead...

I think the vast majority of BMW buyer, Audi buyers and any other premium nrand buyers for that matter do so in no small part because of brand.

If it competes with anything it does so with cars in a similar price bracket. If anything it's an alternative to the new wave of expensive Hot hatches. It isn't a premium car and it isn't hoing to worry the Germans one bit.

I'm not saying that no potential BMW, Merc or Audi owners will choose a Mustang but I'd put money on the vast majority not.

Just my opinion but if the UK Mustang lasts I'd be amazed.
Well, it was on my shopping list - along with a few other posters in this thread hehe But, hey what we do we know... we only bought one!
I'd rather have the BMW than the new Mustang.

I've never even owned a BMW before.
New for new, me too. The BMW is the 'better' car under most metrics, I think. However thats not actually what im trying to argue.... id simply like to point out that used 6 Vs new Mustang is not such an unusual thought in a prospective buyers mind, and that no-one ever berates the 6 Series for being too big.
Mustang all day long, it's a legend and even if you can get a 6 series for the same price it's a totally different car quiet and refined it just won't have any of the character of the stang, add in much higher running cost and the fact that 35k of 6 series is still gonna loose 10k + in 3 years and I don't think you'd even be saving much money if any

RaineyDays

240 posts

100 months

Saturday 17th September 2016
quotequote all
Nice vid in Hebden Bridge and Pecket Well

Interesting car, see a few on my commute to Leeds and always makes my head turn.

Would have to be the V8 with an aftermarket exhaust for me though

Edited by RaineyDays on Saturday 17th September 14:56

anonymous-user

54 months

Saturday 17th September 2016
quotequote all
underphil said:
if you think a 4 cylinder turbo > V8, I think it is you that has been brainwashed !!
Our 4 cylinder turbo Jetta (200bhp) was faster than our V8 S8 (360bhp).

The Audi had a higher top end but the Jetta was quicker everywhere else.

J4CKO

41,588 posts

200 months

Saturday 17th September 2016
quotequote all
DrSteveBrule said:
underphil said:
if you think a 4 cylinder turbo > V8, I think it is you that has been brainwashed !!
Our 4 cylinder turbo Jetta (200bhp) was faster than our V8 S8 (360bhp).

The Audi had a higher top end but the Jetta was quicker everywhere else.
Cars with half the power are almost always quicker biggrin

Are you confusing felt quicker, made more noise or actually quicker, of course an S8 is heavier but a 200 bhp FWD isnt actually going to be quicker really is it.

mikey P 500

1,239 posts

187 months

Saturday 17th September 2016
quotequote all
What we need now is a new capri, needs to look like the mustang but be about the size and weight of a gt86 and then it can use this ecoboost engine. (Personally I think a 4 cylinder turbo mustang is ok. The original was v8 as it was the cheapest way of going fast with the technology of the day, but now it's cheaper to make a fast car with a down sized turbo engine so you could argue its still in the spirit of making a cheap fast coupe.

LuS1fer

41,135 posts

245 months

Saturday 17th September 2016
quotequote all
mikey P 500 said:
What we need now is a new capri, needs to look like the mustang but be about the size and weight of a gt86 and then it can use this ecoboost engine. (Personally I think a 4 cylinder turbo mustang is ok. The original was v8 as it was the cheapest way of going fast with the technology of the day, but now it's cheaper to make a fast car with a down sized turbo engine so you could argue its still in the spirit of making a cheap fast coupe.
I didn't really understand why they ever marketed the Mustang, a solid-gold American icon, in the UK. it would have been far better if they had simply changed all the exterior panels to look like a Capri and called it a Capri.
That way, they could have had both petrol engines (Capri 2.3S and Capri 5.0RS) and Ford could also have easily fitted some diesels without any great outcry from the purists.
The increased diesel sales would have paid for the restyle into a Capri.

Centurion07

10,381 posts

247 months

Saturday 17th September 2016
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
Centurion07 said:
Devil2575 said:
Just like the Vauxhall Monaro?

I like the Mustang, a mate who lived in Florida for years ran a Supercharged V8 of the last incarnation, but it isn't going to be a big seller.
Are they still available?

Even if they are, mention that name to a non-petrolhead and watch the look of complete disinterest spread across their face. EVERYONE has heard of a Mustang.

To date, there have been a smidge over 2000 new Mustangs (70% V8's) registered in the first year. I genuinely have no idea on Ford's targets but I would say for a 5 litre V8, that's pretty good going.

Personally I hope they don't sell too many more. I like the relative rarity.
No they're not. It was a comment about the fact that Vauxhall offered something similar a few years back and it didn't do that well. I agree the Mustang is a lot better known but I still don't think it has enough appeal to get many sales from non-petrolheads.
This is the point I was making though; the Monaro didn't do that well because the market for a large-capacity V8 is pretty niche so it was bought exclusively by petrolheads, whereas the Mustang doesn't suffer from that problem as everyone knows what it is (the name, at least) and therefore is attracting buyers that otherwise would've bought something else.

With over 2000 registered in the first year and the number I've seen on the road (Mustang meets excluded of course!) I would say that's probably already in excess of the Monaro.

ISWYS and I do agree that the number of non-petrolhead buyers is unlikely to be enough to make or break the Mustang as a viable RHD proposition for Ford. Especially given their current shocking customer "service" as regards the Mustang.

That said, it's doing pretty well down under but then they have a bit more of penchant for V8's than we do, but since they're RHD as well, it all helps.

peter450

1,650 posts

233 months

Saturday 17th September 2016
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
mikey P 500 said:
What we need now is a new capri, needs to look like the mustang but be about the size and weight of a gt86 and then it can use this ecoboost engine. (Personally I think a 4 cylinder turbo mustang is ok. The original was v8 as it was the cheapest way of going fast with the technology of the day, but now it's cheaper to make a fast car with a down sized turbo engine so you could argue its still in the spirit of making a cheap fast coupe.
I didn't really understand why they ever marketed the Mustang, a solid-gold American icon, in the UK. it would have been far better if they had simply changed all the exterior panels to look like a Capri and called it a Capri.
That way, they could have had both petrol engines (Capri 2.3S and Capri 5.0RS) and Ford could also have easily fitted some diesels without any great outcry from the purists.
The increased diesel sales would have paid for the restyle into a Capri.
The mustang is a legend not just in the USA but it's is a car known around the world, the Capri does not even come close theirs no way a mustang chassis reworked into a Capri would out sell the real deal.

Theirs a reason people are picking the Ford Mustang over BMW's and TT's and it's not just the V8 engine it's the fact it's a legendary car available for the first time in the UK. It's got a gold plated image over here you only need to say the name "mustang" and people even non car people know what it is and that was before they even sold them here

That kind of heritage and brand is priceless , there's no way it would sell better with a different body, name and bunch of 150hp diesels chucked in more like the complete opposite.

fred bloggs

1,308 posts

200 months

Saturday 17th September 2016
quotequote all
Its GOT to be V8. Id just be too embarresed to drive it if I got a fourpot.
I wouldnt even care if the four made twice the power,Imagine someone asking what engine it has and having to answer 'an ecoboost 2.3 turbo' May as well say 'an addblue sky greenline tec hybrid' or something.

fred bloggs

1,308 posts

200 months

Saturday 17th September 2016
quotequote all
Centurion07 said:
the Monaro didn't do that well because the market for a large-capacity V8 is pretty niche so it was bought exclusively by petrolheads,
The monaro didnt do well because of all the jap turbo cars cheaply availible at the time IMO.

Regiment

2,799 posts

159 months

Saturday 17th September 2016
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
I didn't really understand why they ever marketed the Mustang, a solid-gold American icon, in the UK. it would have been far better if they had simply changed all the exterior panels to look like a Capri and called it a Capri.
That way, they could have had both petrol engines (Capri 2.3S and Capri 5.0RS) and Ford could also have easily fitted some diesels without any great outcry from the purists.
The increased diesel sales would have paid for the restyle into a Capri.
Who cares about a Ford Capri when you've got the option of a Mustang, but yes, a diesel in a Mustang would have brought about the apocalypse I think.

mattwhite709

328 posts

99 months

Saturday 17th September 2016
quotequote all
I would just say what a lot of people have said already, the V8 in the Mustang is it's USP for this reason alone I wouldn't choose the 4 pot.