running two cars, is it worth it?

running two cars, is it worth it?

Author
Discussion

vikingaero

10,355 posts

170 months

Thursday 29th September 2016
quotequote all
I used to run 3 cars with my car allowance until I changed jobs and there was no alternative to a Eurobox.

AshBurrows

2,552 posts

163 months

Friday 30th September 2016
quotequote all
lostkiwi said:
You'd be in profit in just over 3 years assuming no costly maintenance on the Renault and assuming 30mpg from the Renault.

10k miles @15mpg= 666 gallons = 3023 litres. At 1.08/litre thats £3265 per year you spend on fuel.
10k miles @30mpg will be half that so you save ~1600 per year in fuel. Purchase price recouped in 3 years or so and just tax/insurance to complete.

If price of petrol goes up the time shortens.

Edited by lostkiwi on Thursday 29th September 15:07
Cheers pal!

TameRacingDriver

18,093 posts

273 months

Friday 30th September 2016
quotequote all
I see a slight issue here:-

"You'd be in profit in just over 3 years assuming no costly maintenance on the Renault"

tongue out

bony_13

166 posts

98 months

Friday 30th September 2016
quotequote all
If you do some home maintenance or modifications, the other benefit of running two cars is not having to have everything finished by Monday morning to get to work! It gives you a lot more freedom to either take or bigger projects, or to not be forced to finish things in the rain!

Alex_225

6,263 posts

202 months

Friday 30th September 2016
quotequote all
Scootersp said:
What running two cars does, is it makes you consider a frugal and relative shed (some just can't put up with this) to preserve condition mileage etc of another car. It usually comes when the nicer car is a keeper or passion, essentially a car that often without you realising stops you looking at/or at least purchasing anything else for a few years or even a decade or so.
Couldn't agree more with this comment!!

I've been driving a daily runabout since 2006 when I bought my Megane 225 and I loved the stress free ability to park anywhere and just generally not be fussy about it. Admittedly slowly but surely I've ended up with three 'weekend' cars and one daily but I'm more than happy to roll about in an '03 E Class day to day and preserve the condition/mileage/enjoyment of my other cars.

I can't see the drive of my CLS wearing off for some time yet.

KM666

Original Poster:

1,757 posts

184 months

Sunday 2nd October 2016
quotequote all
Sorry for the late reply, I've been busy at work all week. Thanks for the replies and some good points to mull over.

Somebody asked what car it is, it's only a Skoda Octavia 1.8 turbo, it's a weird luxury version but interesting enough to make me want to save it. I've ended up holding onto it for longer than any other car ive owned and it had major issues, which got sorted.
It now needs a bit of home restoration to make it as good as it can be.
I dont want it to defeat me before I'm done with it so it's a keeper for another couple of years at least. I want to see it through.

I do 60 miles down the M4 and M49 every day, it'd suit a diesel perfectly with the miles I do it'd pay for itself after a year. I have thought about the bike licence especially as bikes go toll free over the severn, but going into winter is really the wrong time to do it IMO.

I'm looking to spend £500 so depreciation is of no consequence to me. The car it'd be supplementing is at the bottom of its depreciation curve anyway.

I can get half decent mpg out of it but that's really concentrating on timings so everything's gentle, when I was flusher it's natural return was low 30s, but it's more the milage it's doing.
The extra routine maintainence on top of the mild restoration maintainence is getting the point that I've got nothing left to add to my savings.







Edited by KM666 on Sunday 2nd October 22:48

RobM77

35,349 posts

235 months

Sunday 2nd October 2016
quotequote all
Alex_225 said:
Scootersp said:
What running two cars does, is it makes you consider a frugal and relative shed (some just can't put up with this) to preserve condition mileage etc of another car. It usually comes when the nicer car is a keeper or passion, essentially a car that often without you realising stops you looking at/or at least purchasing anything else for a few years or even a decade or so.
Couldn't agree more with this comment!!

I've been driving a daily runabout since 2006 when I bought my Megane 225 and I loved the stress free ability to park anywhere and just generally not be fussy about it. Admittedly slowly but surely I've ended up with three 'weekend' cars and one daily but I'm more than happy to roll about in an '03 E Class day to day and preserve the condition/mileage/enjoyment of my other cars.

I can't see the drive of my CLS wearing off for some time yet.
Fair play if you can put up with something you don't really enjoy, but of course it doesn't have to be like that, unless you have expensive tastes! There are loads of cheap to run cars worth very little money that I enjoy driving, and if you can find one of those for your daily, then you're sorted smile I personally enjoy anything with a manual box, tidy handling and rear drive, so whilst I'm not as happy in my daily driver 3 series as I would be in a Porsche or a Lotus, I'm still pretty content.

s m

23,235 posts

204 months

Sunday 2nd October 2016
quotequote all
KM666 said:
Sorry for the late reply, I've been busy at work all week. Thanks for the replies and some good points to mull over.

Somebody asked what car it is, it's only a Skoda Octavia 1.8 turbo, it's a weird luxury version. I've ended up holding onto for longer than any other car and it had major issues, which got sorted.
It now needs a bit of home restoration to make it as good as it can be. I dont want it to defeat me before I'm done with it so it's a keeper for another year at least. I want to see it through.

I do 60 miles down the M4 and M49 every day, it'd suit a diesel perfectly with the miles I do it'd pay for itself after a year. I have thought about the bike licence especially as bikes go toll free over the severn, but going into winter is really the wrong time to do it IMO.





Edited by KM666 on Sunday 2nd October 22:33
150bhp Laurent and Klein version?

KM666

Original Poster:

1,757 posts

184 months

Sunday 2nd October 2016
quotequote all
Yep, but remapped with standard stage 1 hardware, so should be about 200bhp. I've spent a bit on suspension stuff, dampers, polybushing etc and have it on vrs brakes. I took to Italy for almost a year so I've bonded with it.

It's known as the turbo turd to friends.

Alex_225

6,263 posts

202 months

Monday 3rd October 2016
quotequote all
RobM77 said:
Fair play if you can put up with something you don't really enjoy, but of course it doesn't have to be like that, unless you have expensive tastes! There are loads of cheap to run cars worth very little money that I enjoy driving, and if you can find one of those for your daily, then you're sorted smile I personally enjoy anything with a manual box, tidy handling and rear drive, so whilst I'm not as happy in my daily driver 3 series as I would be in a Porsche or a Lotus, I'm still pretty content.
All depends on the enjoyment you're getting too. I mean I couldn't rattle around in something I disliked day to day, would be soul destroying as a petrol head. I do love getting into my E-Class though, the enjoyment isn't from it being a tearaway but it's effortless driving, creature comforts and sheer grunt from the engine (3.2 diesel).

I still love a manual car but for boring day to day stuff and motorway wafting, I'm a fan of auto boxes as well.