Is this a thing now? (always on indicators)

Is this a thing now? (always on indicators)

Author
Discussion

ukaskew

Original Poster:

10,642 posts

221 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
Twice this week I've had cars behind me that have their indicator bulbs on permanently, and no other lights. When reaching a turning/roundabout they then use them as conventional indicators (i.e. they flash).

I know this has been fairly common in the US for a long time, but these were right hand drive European cars (a BMW and an Audi), so presumably modified intentionally to do it. Neither car was completely standard, so is it a 'scene' thing?

For clarity, definitely not side lights or DRLS, these are proper yellow/orange repeater bulbs/LEDs.

Incidently, yellow headlights seem to be 'in' again as well.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

126 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
ukaskew said:
...so is it a 'scene' thing?
Yes.

Sad, isn't it?

bony_13

166 posts

97 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
I'm sure on my Z4 and the same vintage E46 3series, that the indicator lights come on solidly if there is a bulb fault. Always seemed like a wierd thing to me, why you would actively want to do that I don't understand at all.

Jonno02

2,246 posts

109 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
Is there any legal issues with that? I hate the big transporter vans you see with the big stick out yellow bulbs on the side above the front wheel arch. Just strikes me as incredibly stupid design when at a glance, many people will mistake it for an indicator.

I've heard of cars indicators flashing much quicker than usual to let you know a bulb is dead, but not stay on permanently.

anonymous-user

54 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
bony_13 said:
I'm sure on my Z4 and the same vintage E46 3series, that the indicator lights come on solidly if there is a bulb fault. Always seemed like a wierd thing to me, why you would actively want to do that I don't understand at all.
On the e46 if the sidelight bulbs fail it puts the side repeaters on permanently, many 'scene' people unfortunately put blown sidelight bulbs in the headlights to make the car do this...

JakeT

5,428 posts

120 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
Learn2MergeInTurn said:
bony_13 said:
I'm sure on my Z4 and the same vintage E46 3series, that the indicator lights come on solidly if there is a bulb fault. Always seemed like a wierd thing to me, why you would actively want to do that I don't understand at all.
On the e46 if the sidelight bulbs fail it puts the side repeaters on permanently, many 'scene' people unfortunately put blown sidelight bulbs in the headlights to make the car do this...
LED Angel eyes will also trigger this, along with LED sidelight bulbs. I quite like the orange look for some reason. Not enough to remove my sidelight bulbs but I do like the look.

ka90

159 posts

123 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
My Honda MSX125 has the indicators on permanently, and like the OPs example, only turn into conventional indicators when actuated. It's scary the number of times I've had drivers almost pull out on me because they thought I was indicating to turn into the junction. I also blew one of my indicator bulbs once, so only one stalk was illuminated on the left side, again, very dangerous. Sketchy ride to pickup a bulb. I don't like it at all.

G600

1,479 posts

187 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
You can code it on BMWs with the right software as well.

Jimmy Recard

17,540 posts

179 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
I hadn't noticed this. I bet I will notice it very soon now it has been mentioned

KarlMac

4,480 posts

141 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
On modern European cars it's something that can be enabled through the engine management for the US market.

Yes it's a scene thing. Yes it's utterly pointless. No it doesn't particularly bother me.

anonymous-user

54 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
JakeT said:
Learn2MergeInTurn said:
bony_13 said:
I'm sure on my Z4 and the same vintage E46 3series, that the indicator lights come on solidly if there is a bulb fault. Always seemed like a wierd thing to me, why you would actively want to do that I don't understand at all.
On the e46 if the sidelight bulbs fail it puts the side repeaters on permanently, many 'scene' people unfortunately put blown sidelight bulbs in the headlights to make the car do this...
LED Angel eyes will also trigger this, along with LED sidelight bulbs. I quite like the orange look for some reason. Not enough to remove my sidelight bulbs but I do like the look.
Yep! The system that checks to see if the lights are working has problems with leds that why you peoples sidelights and number plate led bulbs flickering when they turn the ignition on something about incorrect resistance because they weren't designed with leds I believe smile

Gary29

4,159 posts

99 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
Argh really? This is a thing now? How long before someone pulls out of a T-junction in front of one of these thinking they were indicating to turn in?

Drummond Baize

200 posts

95 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
Learn2MergeInTurn said:
JakeT said:
Learn2MergeInTurn said:
bony_13 said:
I'm sure on my Z4 and the same vintage E46 3series, that the indicator lights come on solidly if there is a bulb fault. Always seemed like a wierd thing to me, why you would actively want to do that I don't understand at all.
On the e46 if the sidelight bulbs fail it puts the side repeaters on permanently, many 'scene' people unfortunately put blown sidelight bulbs in the headlights to make the car do this...
LED Angel eyes will also trigger this, along with LED sidelight bulbs. I quite like the orange look for some reason. Not enough to remove my sidelight bulbs but I do like the look.
Yep! The system that checks to see if the lights are working has problems with leds that why you peoples sidelights and number plate led bulbs flickering when they turn the ignition on something about incorrect resistance because they weren't designed with leds I believe smile
Haven't the bulbs got to be "CANBUS" types to avoid this?

rampageturke

2,622 posts

162 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
Gary29 said:
Argh really? This is a thing now? How long before someone pulls out of a T-junction in front of one of these thinking they were indicating to turn in?
Just to let you know if you havent seen this yet, the indicators when always on are usually pretty dim, it's really not as bad as you think, and I doubt people won't use them because they think they're already indicating like how some people use DRLs instead of actual headlights. If they didn't indicate whilst using this, I doubt they would have indicated anyway

ukaskew

Original Poster:

10,642 posts

221 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
Gary29 said:
Argh really? This is a thing now? How long before someone pulls out of a T-junction in front of one of these thinking they were indicating to turn in?
Cars in the US had this for years prior to DRLs, so I doubt it's a safety issue. Well, aside from the fact that the BMW had clearly disabled/removed the DRLs and only had the indicators on...and it was pretty dark.

Edited by ukaskew on Thursday 20th October 12:43

tigger1

8,402 posts

221 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
rampageturke said:
Just to let you know if you havent seen this yet, the indicators when always on are usually pretty dim, it's really not as bad as you think, and I doubt people won't use them because they think they're already indicating like how some people use DRLs instead of actual headlights. If they didn't indicate whilst using this, I doubt they would have indicated anyway
But definitely still illegal, and unsafe.

Things like this I'd like to see police given powers to just seize the car in question, only returning it a few weeks and a large fine later. It's all well and good saying I'm grumpy and "just don't like it" (I am and I don't)- but it's deliberately modifying a car in a way which makes it non-roadworthy (and potentially dangerous).

PorkInsider

5,888 posts

141 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
tigger1 said:
But definitely still illegal, and unsafe.

Things like this I'd like to see police given powers to just seize the car in question, only returning it completely crushed flat a few weeks and a large fine later...
yes

E36Ross

502 posts

112 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
My E36 has these....

Very very dim and flash as normal when indicator is on.

Although I'v them wired in so I can disable them in a few seconds. smile

sonnenschein3000

710 posts

90 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
But the new shape Range Rovers and Range Rover Sports have a big amber line on the front lights that come on with the headlamps. OK, fine, the indicator bulb is just below it and so is s separate bulb, but it looks the same.

Jaguar steve

9,232 posts

210 months

Thursday 20th October 2016
quotequote all
It's the all about me thing again isn't it. rolleyes

It's the hard of thinking placing a higher priority on creating a persona for themselves by adopting whatever is the current craze among the vain and dull witted rather than using vehicle lighting for its proper purpose which is to assist other road users to make better decisions and progress by informing them of your presence and intentions.

Retards.