'Another thing to go wrong'

'Another thing to go wrong'

Author
Discussion

bearman68

4,662 posts

133 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
OK, enough of the electric hand brake bashing - just stop right there and take a breath. ...... Good.

Now all the people on PH are powerfully built types, with rippling muscles, and a huge amount of manual dexterity. So you don't struggle with a handbrake. But a little old lady with a big car might, or anyone with short legs that is not in a good position to pull the handbrake up. And with an electronic one, it always goes on consistently. And it can be made to come on a little bit more depending on the slope,and the temperature of the brakes, or if the car moves. And it does better hill starts than most. And it won't allow the car to roll backwards. So you see there are a few significant advantages to EPB's Add to that the packing space, and the easier assembly costs, and the fact manufacturers don't need to build that silly little drum brake inside the disc, and they become cheaper and better then the mechanical version. (You think mechanical versions are good - anyone had trouble with an E39 handbrake? - what a pile of rubbish)

Of course they do break. And I have to declare an interest, as my little company specialises in repairing them. So, in my personal opinion, the electric hand brake is a wonderful thing, and everyone should have at least 10 of them. smile

ian316

4,150 posts

106 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
bearman68 said:
OK, enough of the electric hand brake bashing - just stop right there and take a breath. ...... Good.

Now all the people on PH are powerfully built types, with rippling muscles, and a huge amount of manual dexterity. So you don't struggle with a handbrake. But a little old lady with a big car might, or anyone with short legs that is not in a good position to pull the handbrake up. And with an electronic one, it always goes on consistently. And it can be made to come on a little bit more depending on the slope,and the temperature of the brakes, or if the car moves. And it does better hill starts than most. And it won't allow the car to roll backwards. So you see there are a few significant advantages to EPB's Add to that the packing space, and the easier assembly costs, and the fact manufacturers don't need to build that silly little drum brake inside the disc, and they become cheaper and better then the mechanical version. (You think mechanical versions are good - anyone had trouble with an E39 handbrake? - what a pile of rubbish)

Of course they do break. And I have to declare an interest, as my little company specialises in repairing them. So, in my personal opinion, the electric hand brake is a wonderful thing, and everyone should have at least 10 of them. smile
haha pmsl best answer to that question

fttm

3,692 posts

136 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
Tire pressure sensors that light up on the dash when the external temperatures drop below minus 3 or 4 degrees , really fking handy when you live in Canada .

lj04

371 posts

192 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
I have spent longer changing electric window regulators than the time they have saved me and the wife. VW and Porsche reliability, bloody joke

J4CKO

41,628 posts

201 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
All the old cars pretty much have IC engines, complicated and wear our, what you want for total reliability is an Electric motor.

If anyone tells me says an old Mini or Morris Minor was better because it was more simple I wouldnt agree, points were st, you had to grease everything every month, the leaked oil, they didnt start easily the minute it rained.


Boosted LS1

21,188 posts

261 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
Fox- said:
ian316 said:
is the motor faulty, the switch or the loom somewhere it doesn't sound that simple
It really isn't that hard to test those things is it?
Why do you need it?

Boosted LS1

21,188 posts

261 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
ian316 said:
bearman68 said:
OK, enough of the electric hand brake bashing - just stop right there and take a breath. ...... Good.

Now all the people on PH are powerfully built types, with rippling muscles, and a huge amount of manual dexterity. So you don't struggle with a handbrake. But a little old lady with a big car might, or anyone with short legs that is not in a good position to pull the handbrake up. And with an electronic one, it always goes on consistently. And it can be made to come on a little bit more depending on the slope,and the temperature of the brakes, or if the car moves. And it does better hill starts than most. And it won't allow the car to roll backwards. So you see there are a few significant advantages to EPB's Add to that the packing space, and the easier assembly costs, and the fact manufacturers don't need to build that silly little drum brake inside the disc, and they become cheaper and better then the mechanical version. (You think mechanical versions are good - anyone had trouble with an E39 handbrake? - what a pile of rubbish)

Of course they do break. And I have to declare an interest, as my little company specialises in repairing them. So, in my personal opinion, the electric hand brake is a wonderful thing, and everyone should have at least 10 of them. smile
haha pmsl best answer to that question
Me to, what a load of dross. The handbrake handle is about leverage. Even if bearman68 couldn't pull up the handle I'm sure my granny could and she's been dead for years. Does he want a leg simulator to press the brake pedal coz he's to weak? Guess what, I bet electronic handbrakes are linked to those retina blazing brake lights that seem to be about making a huge statement to.

55palfers

5,913 posts

165 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
Boosted LS1 said:
ian316 said:
bearman68 said:
OK, enough of the electric hand brake bashing - just stop right there and take a breath. ...... Good.

Now all the people on PH are powerfully built types, with rippling muscles, and a huge amount of manual dexterity. So you don't struggle with a handbrake. But a little old lady with a big car might, or anyone with short legs that is not in a good position to pull the handbrake up. And with an electronic one, it always goes on consistently. And it can be made to come on a little bit more depending on the slope,and the temperature of the brakes, or if the car moves. And it does better hill starts than most. And it won't allow the car to roll backwards. So you see there are a few significant advantages to EPB's Add to that the packing space, and the easier assembly costs, and the fact manufacturers don't need to build that silly little drum brake inside the disc, and they become cheaper and better then the mechanical version. (You think mechanical versions are good - anyone had trouble with an E39 handbrake? - what a pile of rubbish)

Of course they do break. And I have to declare an interest, as my little company specialises in repairing them. So, in my personal opinion, the electric hand brake is a wonderful thing, and everyone should have at least 10 of them. smile
haha pmsl best answer to that question
Me to, what a load of dross. The handbrake handle is about leverage. Even if bearman68 couldn't pull up the handle I'm sure my granny could and she's been dead for years. Does he want a leg simulator to press the brake pedal coz he's to weak? Guess what, I bet electronic handbrakes are linked to those retina blazing brake lights that seem to be about making a huge statement to.
What about the Barge aficionados Barge of choice - the 1990's Mercedes-Benz?

Complete with a foot operated parking brake?

EazyDuz

Original Poster:

2,013 posts

109 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
Never even tried an e hand brake but cant say ive ever had a problem with the traditional ratchet and cable. Even if it is billion year old tech

ian316

4,150 posts

106 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
55palfers said:
Boosted LS1 said:
ian316 said:
bearman68 said:
OK, enough of the electric hand brake bashing - just stop right there and take a breath. ...... Good.

Now all the people on PH are powerfully built types, with rippling muscles, and a huge amount of manual dexterity. So you don't struggle with a handbrake. But a little old lady with a big car might, or anyone with short legs that is not in a good position to pull the handbrake up. And with an electronic one, it always goes on consistently. And it can be made to come on a little bit more depending on the slope,and the temperature of the brakes, or if the car moves. And it does better hill starts than most. And it won't allow the car to roll backwards. So you see there are a few significant advantages to EPB's Add to that the packing space, and the easier assembly costs, and the fact manufacturers don't need to build that silly little drum brake inside the disc, and they become cheaper and better then the mechanical version. (You think mechanical versions are good - anyone had trouble with an E39 handbrake? - what a pile of rubbish)

Of course they do break. And I have to declare an interest, as my little company specialises in repairing them. So, in my personal opinion, the electric hand brake is a wonderful thing, and everyone should have at least 10 of them. smile
haha pmsl best answer to that question
Me to, what a load of dross. The handbrake handle is about leverage. Even if bearman68 couldn't pull up the handle I'm sure my granny could and she's been dead for years. Does he want a leg simulator to press the brake pedal coz he's to weak? Guess what, I bet electronic handbrakes are linked to those retina blazing brake lights that seem to be about making a huge statement to.
What about the Barge aficionados Barge of choice - the 1990's Mercedes-Benz?

Complete with a foot operated parking brake?
I've always said this, the only odd thing on the car foot pedal to apply hand release when the w123 just had one lever doing its job perfectly

Fox-

13,241 posts

247 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
Boosted LS1 said:
Why do you need it?
Because it's convenient and works really well? It's automatically applied for me at traffic lights, it automatically disengages when I pull away and it automatically applies itself when I park the car. It holds the car perfectly and works every time. It's great.

By contrast the manual handbrake on my E39 530i was **** when i got the car at 4 years old and is still **** 11 years later.

northwestrecovery

159 posts

185 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
I don't post much on here but here is my take on it , more and more people don't want to change gear /dsg joke of a gearbox ha ha /cant or don't want to pull a hand brake /can't or don't want to switch on wipers or headlights /can't park ect . You people need a driver / taxi or the bus , driving is just that driving not being driven by the car .

TVR1

5,463 posts

226 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
DELETED: Comment made by a member who's account has been deleted.
Conversely, have you ever heard of an electronic parking brake failing, leaving the car careering down a hill? Manual parking brakes, on the other hand....

A pilots phrase,

'Better to be on the ground and stuck, wishing you were in the air, than being in the air and wishing you were down there...'

Boosted LS1

21,188 posts

261 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
Fox- said:
Boosted LS1 said:
Why do you need it?
Because it's convenient and works really well? It's automatically applied for me at traffic lights, it automatically disengages when I pull away and it automatically applies itself when I park the car. It holds the car perfectly and works every time. It's great.

By contrast the manual handbrake on my E39 530i was **** when i got the car at 4 years old and is still **** 11 years later.
I don't get you, how much automation do you want? How hard is it to use a conventional handbrake? Will you sleep walk into driverless drones because they do it all for you?

Fox-

13,241 posts

247 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
Boosted LS1 said:
I don't get you, how much automation do you want? How hard is it to use a conventional handbrake? Will you sleep walk into driverless drones because they do it all for you?
Manually operating a handbrake adds nothing to the experience of driving for me and takes up space in the interior. Why would you want one?

Sump

5,484 posts

168 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
Boosted LS1 said:
Fox- said:
Boosted LS1 said:
Why do you need it?
Because it's convenient and works really well? It's automatically applied for me at traffic lights, it automatically disengages when I pull away and it automatically applies itself when I park the car. It holds the car perfectly and works every time. It's great.

By contrast the manual handbrake on my E39 530i was **** when i got the car at 4 years old and is still **** 11 years later.
I don't get you, how much automation do you want? How hard is it to use a conventional handbrake? Will you sleep walk into driverless drones because they do it all for you?
Are you just getting angry because your skill set is now limited with the likes of Tesla coming to the forefront?

ian316

4,150 posts

106 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
Fox- said:
Boosted LS1 said:
I don't get you, how much automation do you want? How hard is it to use a conventional handbrake? Will you sleep walk into driverless drones because they do it all for you?
Manually operating a handbrake adds nothing to the experience of driving for me and takes up space in the interior. Why would you want one?
how much space does a steering wheel and pedals take up, just get a ps4 pad rhd lhd just pass the pad done

ian316

4,150 posts

106 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
oh no I forgot i'm 52 with fat thumbs and a ps4 pad is terrible lol

wc98

10,416 posts

141 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
Fox- said:
Boosted LS1 said:
I don't get you, how much automation do you want? How hard is it to use a conventional handbrake? Will you sleep walk into driverless drones because they do it all for you?
Manually operating a handbrake adds nothing to the experience of driving for me and takes up space in the interior. Why would you want one?
bloody awkward doing handbrake turns with an electronic handbrake.

bearman68

4,662 posts

133 months

Thursday 19th January 2017
quotequote all
Boosted LS1 said:
Me to, what a load of dross. The handbrake handle is about leverage. Even if bearman68 couldn't pull up the handle I'm sure my granny could and she's been dead for years. Does he want a leg simulator to press the brake pedal coz he's to weak? Guess what, I bet electronic handbrakes are linked to those retina blazing brake lights that seem to be about making a huge statement to.
Too, and because. Clearly your post is completely invalid due to poor punctuation. As for my physique - have you seen a bag of snakes? Fit as a butchers dog I am!
And no, hand brakes are not linked to brake lights - they are linked to the brake pedal. <Sigh>
Anyway, everyone should have an EPB, as I have kids to feed smile