Rental fines

Author
Discussion

Michalgonci

Original Poster:

5 posts

4 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
So I've rented a van and the next day the slide door broke. Rental company kept my 250 pounds deposit and they said they will send me invoice for the repairs and even charge me for rental while the van is the garage without me having the van because the rental agreement ended.

They said they charging me rental (when not having the van for 3 months now) because I signed the agreement...

How is this my fault when the slide door broke the first day of having the used van??

QuickQuack

2,244 posts

102 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
Michalgonci said:
So I've rented a van and the next day the slide door broke. Rental company kept my 250 pounds deposit and they said they will send me invoice for the repairs and even charge me for rental while the van is the garage without me having the van because the rental agreement ended.

They said they charging me rental (when not having the van for 3 months now) because I signed the agreement...

How is this my fault when the slide door broke the first day of having the used van??
How did you break the door?

Michalgonci

Original Poster:

5 posts

4 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
I've open them, loaded the van and when tried ti closed they broke, even manager was there.

Sebring440

2,042 posts

97 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
You will have to read the terms & conditions of the agreement (you signed) to see if your are liable for all repairs and lost revenue.

No one here knows what these terms & conditions are.

Mont Blanc

650 posts

44 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
Sebring440 said:
You will have to read the terms & conditions of the agreement (you signed) to see if your are liable for all repairs and lost revenue.

No one here knows what these terms & conditions are.
This.

Also, I guess it depends how the door became broken:

If you overfilled the van and tried to slam/push the door shut on the load, then it would be entirely your fault.

If the load inside the van was nowhere near the door, and you shut the door 'normally' and it just simply fell apart, then clearly that wouldn't be your fault.

ArmaghMan

2,425 posts

181 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
Can't name and shame!

Would the renter have a name that might be used for a starship captained by James T Kirk?

ingenieur

4,097 posts

182 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
It doesn't sound very fair but probably easiest is to let them keep the £250 and give them nothing else?

1. how long is your contract for
2. are they able to charge your card or are they asking you to pay them?

Ham_and_Jam

2,253 posts

98 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
Isn’t it funny how people would be fuming if this happened to them, but to someone else its all thier fault for being so stupid.

Michalgonci

Original Poster:

5 posts

4 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
They will just keep charging me in my invoice (wages) as they are doing the invoice for me (Amazon worker)

normalbloke

7,467 posts

220 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
Michalgonci said:
They will just keep charging me in my invoice (wages) as they are doing the invoice for me (Amazon worker)
Oh lordy….

ingenieur

4,097 posts

182 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
There must be some dispute resolution service within the Amazon contracting regime which you can use to sort this out? Have you got a boss or a manager you can talk to about this?

Michalgonci

Original Poster:

5 posts

4 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
I dont even know who I'm speaking to, my manager saying talk to finance group...so I did and they just keep saying it's in your contract bla bla bla...i know i signed for it but .. comon....first day and door broke? Must of been done by previous driver

Mad Maximus

370 posts

4 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
Get your union involved.

cootuk

918 posts

124 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
Wouldn't "they" have expected you to inspect the van and accept it as fit for use when you first picked it up?

Michalgonci

Original Poster:

5 posts

4 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
What is union?

I did fleet checks and pictures and everything, the van was ok no damages. It's just my how lucky I am ..and even in the contract it's said that they are allowed to touch my wages etc....I'm screwed big time ..... Feel like don't want to live it's proper piss take

Ham_and_Jam

2,253 posts

98 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
Michalgonci said:
What is union?

I did fleet checks and pictures and everything, the van was ok no damages. It's just my how lucky I am ..and even in the contract it's said that they are allowed to touch my wages etc....I'm screwed big time ..... Feel like don't want to live it's proper piss take
Hey Michal

Don’t feel like this all your fault. They are taking the piss. Take a breath, and sort this logically. Go to the vendor and your Amazon contact and expain the situation. Write emails confirming the situation.

My advice would be to contact citizens advice (assuming you’re UK) if you can’t sort easily and quickly by amicable arrangements.

Keep us updated how you get on. Ignore the righteous on here, you will get lots of support and advice from many helpful people.

Good luck

Busa mav

2,563 posts

155 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
Ham_and_Jam said:
Hey Michal

Don’t feel like this all your fault. They are taking the piss. Take a breath, and sort this logically. Go to the vendor and your Amazon contact and expain the situation. Write emails confirming the situation.

My advice would be to contact citizens advice (assuming you’re UK) if you can’t sort easily and quickly by amicable arrangements.

Keep us updated how you get on. Ignore the righteous on here, you will get lots of support and advice from many helpful people.

Good luck
Great post, well done.

Plymo

1,152 posts

90 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
Once he mentioned Amazon it makes sense - by the sound of it hes working for one of the many companies that subcontract for them.
Lots of these companies are terrible, and I'm not convinced they are operating legally, they seem to exist to screw rental fees from the drivers more than anything else.

A guy I know was "Self employed" with one, and similar things to what's described here have happened to him - an example being his van breaking down (nothing to do with him either) so he couldn't work but they still deducted the rental money from him while it was being repaired.
The rates they were charging were well above the rates I could see available commercially from the various lease companies as well, but they had to use this company for it. They also set working shifts and wouldn't allow them to use the vans for anything else - That doesn't sound like self employment to me.
A self employed person is effectively running their own business so they are free to hire (or buy) their vehicle from wherever they like.
It's dodgy enough with uber/deliveroo/hermes etc as they can't set prices, but at least they have the freedom to get there vehicles from wherever suits them best.

They are absolute bds, not even sure if a union would be any use in this case as he's not an employee

ingenieur

4,097 posts

182 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
You can contact ACAS and begin the Employment Tribunals process. It is a free service and has a lot of clout.

This would no doubt be a case of "unlawful deduction from wages". There can't be any contract written which would effect employees like this, it sounds wrong... so probably is wrong.

When you contact ACAS and start the Employment Tribunals process the first thing that'll happen is the ACAS councillor will contact your employer and try to straighten things out at an early stage before a tribunal begins.

The employer has to cooperate so you won't be messed around.

At the end you will get back all the money which was unlawfully deducted from your wages.

1690cc

84 posts

17 months

Friday 26th January
quotequote all
Go to Citizen Advice they will help you sort this mess out.