Mini Cooper S v Renaultsport Clio 197
James Mills compares the fastest new Mini against a hot hatch stalwart
Mini Cooper S
Welcome to the second instalment of the ever-popular Mini adventure. The first right hand drive car has arrived in the UK and we've managed to get our hands on it before anyone else.
            Mini Cooper S above, Renault Clio Renaultsport 197 below          |
But it’s not just the all-new Mini which we’re interested in. We also wanted to bring along one of PistonHeads' all-time favourite hot hatches to date, the RenaultSport Clio 197.
Admittedly, the latest in a long line of go-fast Clios has come in for more than its fair share of flak, mostly because someone’s been feeding it all the pies. But expanding waistband issues aside, the 197 sets the benchmark by which other hot hatches fall short.
Small change
For now, UK car enthusiasts, hot hatch lovers and Mini-addicts alike can get their fix from the Cooper and Cooper S models. The pair features a new BMW-designed, PSA-built advanced 1.6-litre four-cylinder engine that makes the old 1.6-litre look uncomfortably like something knocked out for a GCSE project.
The more wallet-friendly £11,595 One and diesel-powered versions will follow next spring. The only marginally less wallet-friendly, best selling Cooper is yours for a fair £12,995. But the one everyone’s talking about, and the one you know you want to test drive, is the new turbo-charged Cooper S, a £15,995 investment. But is it a wise one?
Well, at first glance, it’s hard to tell. The Cooper S is matched penny for penny by RenaultSport’s Clio 197, with nothing to separate them on price. Delve a little deeper into the specification, however, and the Mini adventure starts to seem like a Mini money-making activity. Much as we applaud the fact that Mini has taken personalisation to new levels, so much so that no two Minis are the same, the Cooper S’s equipment levels are meagre. Notable absences over the 197 include air conditioning, cruise control, anti-submarining airbags and remote stereo control. Not great, especially considering the wrap-around glass area on Minis which means A/C is an absolute must.
In the hot seat
Mind you, the irony is that when you first open the doors to these two and settle into the cabins for a poke around, it’s actually the Clio 197 that feels like the skin-flint. Its sea of grey and black plastics and fabrics may well inject the French hatchback’s mood with a feel more akin to a German product, but after the Cooper S it’s positively shy and retiring. Of course, you could view that as a good thing. After all, not everyone wants to own a car that looks as if it was created by a trinket bracelet designer.
Then again, without wanting to come across all square, the Mini’s feel is fun and funky, and utterly unique. Nothing else on sale today comes close to the sense of occasion this hot hatch bestows on its occupants. Especially the driver.
Parked up, the Cooper S pulls off that neat trick of feeling fast at a standstill. You sit super low, right down on the floor. Get your legs stretched out to the classic floor-hinged throttle, pull the steering wheel back towards you and take in your surroundings. The comedy-sized speedo in the centre of the dash now houses the audio, communications and satnav equipment (when ordered) but it’s well away from your sight-line. Mini acknowledges as much, once again equipping the digital trip computer with a speed readout, which sits beneath the rev counter. With the glass area wrapping around you through 360 degrees, and that low-set stance, it really does feel ready to rock.
After the Cooper S, the Clio 197 feels just a little, well, mundane. Don’t get me wrong. RenaultSport has ticked all the usual boxes for a hot hatch environment, with a fair helping of its logos and plenty of silver brightwork dotted about the place, and our car even featured the optional and most excellent, lightweight Recaro bucket seats, but the simple fact is that nothing in this class can compare with the Mini’s feelgood factor.
Smooth to the touch
Fire it up and despite what you may have read about the one-time cheeky rascal’s newfound manners, the familiar exhaust burble is still present. Sure enough, the engine idles with a smoothness and civility which may lull some into worrying about its credentials as a grin-inducing, riotous hot hatch.
The moment you get underway, all the familiar Mini traits are there: immediacy, intimacy and invigoration. The throttle responds crisply, the gear change slices smoothly across the gate and the controls are tuned for one simple purpose, to spread a bloody great grin right across your face.
There’s a tactility to the Cooper S which means even when you’re just pottering, you can appreciate the depth of engineering that’s gone on behind the scenes. The revised multi-link rear suspension uses more aluminium in its construction, while the spring and damper tuning finally accounts for the effects of hideous run-flat tyres. And the end result is pliancy and level of mid-bend absorption which will come as a revelation to any Cooper S drivers.
It doesn’t come at the expense of thrills though. It simply makes the Cooper S faster and more able, and capable of showing some very serious machinery indeed a clean pair of heals across country.
Turbo technology
Lean on the throttle, and the twin-scroll turbocharger leaps to life in a flash, pulling earnestly from just 1,500rpm and flying along by 2,000rpm. With an overboost facility, it can summon up 192lb-ft of torque at 1,700rpm – compared with 157lb-ft at 5,550rpm for the hyperactive Renault. The all-alloy, direct-injection 1.6-litre Valvetronic unit even features a composite camshaft to reduce inertia, and boy do all the little tricks work. It loves to rev. Much more so than the old supercharged unit, and has a sweet, crisp rasp right through the rev range.
But it’s the performance that really bowls you over. You’d swear this little 1.6 was packing around 200bhp, not the quoted 175bhp. It really is that feisty.
With the Sport mode engaged, the steering and throttle firm up nicely and the Cooper S dispatches even the most demanding roads with a casual shrug. It slices its way cleanly through each apex. Loads up all four wheels evenly. Breaks grip with a delightfully natural progression. Dishes up a whiff of oversteer when you play with the throttle. And serves up a tiny helping of torque steer just to add an extra fizz of excitement to the process.
Uncompromising
You’ll have no worries about wheelspin or torque steer in the Clio 197. It feels like a little racing car – flat, tight and scalpel sharp. And, in the usual race car fashion, disappointing until you wring its neck.
It’s clearly been built with little, if any, compromise. The 2.0-litre 16-valve FR4 RS lump hits the magic 100hp per litre marker, but extracting the full, true 194bhp takes some doing. As was always so in the 172 and 182 models, this engine is sensitive to the way it’s run in, and to mileage and build tolerances. Some feel great, others less so. This is the second 197 I’ve tested and, like the first, it felt a little strangled and reluctant to rev.
But rev it you must. Right around the clock. Not much happens until 5,000rpm. So you have to work away at the six-speed gearbox. Which isn’t that pleasant an experience. First, third and fifth are always reluctant to disengage, so you have to yank the nicely positioned lever back in an unnatural fashion that saps your concentration.
There is great reward to be had when you work at it though. The engine screams away and sounds superb on heel-and-toe downshifts, and performance at this end of the spectrum is decent enough. But heaven forbid you drop out of the power band.
Our test figures bear it out. At the track, the 1,205kg Cooper S hit 60mph in 6.6 seconds and sprinted on to 100mph in 16.2 seconds. The Clio 197 managed 6.9 and 18.7 respectively. But that’s not all. In-gear flexibility is more significant than traffic light titillation. And here, the Cooper S turbo’s torque comes into its own. It muscles its way from 30-50mph in third in 2.9 secs and 50-70mph in fifth in 5.1 secs, against 4.3 and 7.3 respectively for the 1,240kg French charger. Oh dear.
This is hardcore
In the dry, the wide-track chassis set-up is simply astonishing. The 197’s levels of grip defy belief, and allow you to maintain momentum so you’re not constantly cursing the engine as you drop back out of the power band.
There’s no body roll to speak of, turn-in is immediate and the nose bites hard, refusing to relinquish its hold on the tarmac. Unsticking RenaultSport’s creation takes some doing.
Except when the heavens open. The stiffly set up torsion beam rear suspension is anything but forgiving. Even with the ESP switched on, and half a throttle opening to steady the chassis’ balance, the back can step out of line. Under hard braking it’s worse still, and lifting-off the throttle mid-bend is something you won’t repeat after your first trouser-troubling moment.
Again, it’s like a race car, and feels as if it needs the anti-roll bar to be disconnected -- I can’t imagine many Clio 197 buyers will have a personal race team in tow to set the car up for every journey.
Verdict
On many levels, the Clio 197 comes closest to capturing the spirit of something like Honda’s last Integra Type-R. On the right road, on the right day, in the right weather, in the right mood, you can have the drive of your life. But how often does everything click into place like that?
The fact of the matter is any decent turbo diesel would leave the 197 driver flailing at the gears. It feels like it’s got ADHD and should be on Ritalin. For every great drive you have in it, there will be another five trips where you can’t shake off that nagging doubt that you should have bought something else.
Not so the Cooper S. Every journey, no matter what the speed or how long the distance, will have you thinking you’ve made the right decision. The punchy Mini is fun on every level. Its spirit is infectious. Its enthusiasm never wanes. And nor will yours.
Buy it, discover what the fuss is all about and you'll embark on a Mini adventure of your very own.
I can only agree with the comments on the Clio. I test drove one at launch and while I did enjoy it, I certainly got the impression that its a 100% attack car. On a crisp Sunday morning on your favourite b-road that you know well the 197 would be perfect, but on the mixed route of the usual test drive it felt, well, a bit stale.
Look forward to having a go in the new Cooper S, I was very taken with the last one.
On the other hand I think the Clio looks spot on and Like the Teggy Type R of Yesteryear it is the sort of car that is in its element when on maximum attack - surely the reason for buying a hot hatch?
otherwise why not just buy a diesel golf?
Very taken with the 197 and may just enquire about buying one
I'm after a car that's fun to drive day in day out, not just when I'm "going for it".
My BMW 325ti Sport has had good reviews, but for some reason it just doesn't ring my bell.....I guess if I drove everywhere like a nutter it would probably be great, but these days I just don't get the chance to go for a drive for the hell of it.
Seems like a Mini is what I'm looking for, just need to decide whether to go for a Cooper or an S? Even considering an old shape Cooper.
I'll have to get me some test drives.
It should be around 1000 but it's not actually a small car anymore. It's probably as big as the 1st Laguna. It's one of the reasons why I am totally unmoved by the new Clio but the new Mini
. Yes, I know it's fat and it's too chunky and it's probably form over function but by golly, I want one. It doesn't even have to be an S. I would quite happily take the standard Cooper. And yes, I even like it in that colour.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff