What Truck?

Author
Discussion

Marquis_Rex

Original Poster:

7,377 posts

240 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
I've never done a 'What car' kind of thread and usually view them as quite tedious, but if you cant beat them join them!
Besides, this forth coming purchase of vehicle is one of my least emotional purchases and I need to make a decision quickly- like within less than a week.

I move up north to Ilinois very soon, where to say, it snows alot would probably be an understatement. So 4WD is definately a requirement, along with the capability to tow a Porsche 993 Turbo or Dodge Challenger on a trailer and not break into a sweat. I'll also probably be carrying heavy engines such as Dodge Hemis and BMW S50s around. I may even take this pick up camping sometimes. In time I may do some off-roading in it. I definately need four seats also.
It seems like an amazing time to buy right now, with even dealers putting up sticker prices of way below Blue book values.


I was always naturally drawn to the brawny good looks of the Dodge Ram- especially the "Big Rig" post 2003 design.



So far, I've found a 2005 Chevrolet Silverado Z 71 truck for sale. It has covered 117,000 miles, and has the trusty pushrod 5.3 litre Vortec V8 that makes about 310 Bhp. Apparently the Z71 package is a special off road package with skid pans and specially tuned gas pressure shocks.
The book value for this truck is about $13,000. The dealer had it down to $10,990, however after a test drive and some shrewd negotiating, I got him down to $7,900yikes
The truck looks similar to this:


The truck felt refined and comfortable to drive, although it didnt feel all that fast and the engine felt too subdued. The truck had obviously been taken off road a bit, and unusual for a southern truck had some light surface rust underneath. I personally think the truck looks fairly bland. No real service history I could trace and I dont know how many owners.

The next truck I came across was the 2005 Ford F 150 5.4 litre 300 Bhp V8 "XLT"-which is a base model (less to go wrong). This one is up for $9000 as it has covered 165,000 miles, but has full 'Ben Satchers' Service history and only 1 owner. This truck felt tight and solid and the condition was great inside and out. It also felt fast to drive and it was very easy to 'light up the rears'. There was a slight shudder/shake at 55 mph-which is probably down to wheel imbalance. This truck felt much more responsive than the Chevy, with more direct feeling steering, a great sounding engine, felt faster, and more agile. I went to the dealer who had serviced it, and no expense seems to have been spared in its up keep. The 5.4 litre engine is a 3 valve design, over head cam, and has more torque than the Chevy, not only due to the capacity advantage but also due to the better port air flows combined with shorter duration cams. This truck was typical of a southern truck, and the underneath was just as clean as the top- even the exhausts still seemed aluminised.




Personally I think in the looks department the truck looks bland.

I was out at a bar the other night and by chance the bar man told me his 2003 Dodge Ram thats covered only 60,000 miles may be up for sale for around the $10,000 mark. I told him I would be interested if he was interested in selling. He said he'd get back to me. Viewing the truck externally, has some dings, but has the Rams classically butch good looks. I havent driven it yet, but it has the 5.7 litre hemi engine. This has a shallow Hemi combustion chamber with a twin plug layout (for a fast burn) and cylinder deactivation. This is also a pushrod layout so probably has very low friction. If the gearing has been matched well to the vehicle and cylinder deact- this one promises to have the best fuel economy. From what I;'ve heard it should also sound the best also.

From what Ive heard- Ford makes the toughest Truck chasis and frames. I dont really know if I would be utilising this 'toughness' though. The extra torque of 5.7 hemi would be welcome though. ANy other helpful comments or suggestions welcome!

tossbag

1,590 posts

207 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all




All you need to know.

Edited by tossbag on Saturday 17th January 04:06

chris123321

514 posts

191 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
tossbag said:




All you need to know.

Edited by tossbag on Saturday 17th January 04:06
Yes

Yes

YES



Say no to a yanktank and go for the defender!



all this v8 turbodiesel nonsense.....


Just look at the defender!


oh and when you said what truck i was going to suggest a Scania biggrin



Marquis_Rex

Original Poster:

7,377 posts

240 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
I did think about a Land Rover Defender but they aint cheap around these parts- ebaymotors shows prices ranging from $25K up to $55K!

I know a Jeep Wrangler has too short a wheel base to tow the Chally, but my neighbor (in the UK) seems to think a Defender would have no problems. However, the LR has what- a 4 litre V8, I wouldn't fancy towing with that engine across half a continent.

I also dont imagine the Defender is too refined over long distances when, say , crusing from Illinois to Oregon on Vacation (2000 miles plus)

tossbag

1,590 posts

207 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
Marquis_Rex said:
I did think about a Land Rover Defender but they aint cheap around these parts- ebaymotors shows prices ranging from $25K up to $55K!

I know a Jeep Wrangler has too short a wheel base to tow the Chally, but my neighbor (in the UK) seems to think a Defender would have no problems. However, the LR has what- a 4 litre V8, I wouldn't fancy towing with that engine across half a continent.

I also dont imagine the Defender is too refined over long distances when, say , crusing from Illinois to Oregon on Vacation (2000 miles plus)
you will make the money back in a year on fuel wink
Also, you will be cool biggrin

AdeTuono

7,262 posts

228 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all


That bonnet mascot's a bit gay though.....

markmullen

15,877 posts

235 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
I had a Ram 1500 with the 5.7 hemi for a while, loved it, great truck. Luckily as this was in the UK it had a 230 litre LPG tank in the bed as I averaged 10.1mpg in it.

ol' dirty

9,074 posts

216 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
Ignoring those for a second- the 'trucks' I saw pulling big loads were the Diesel F350's.
Quick Google says the towing capacity is 8.7tonnes, & a payload of up to 2.6tonnes (depending on the back axle)




I had a short drive of the F150 & had an Explorer for 3 weeks & was really impressed with them.

Cabin seemed better built than the Ram- although we put a fair few miles on the Ram & we never complained about feeling uncomfotable.


I'd go diesel all the way. I love me some torque, Ma!Breaker, Breaker, 10-4hehe

Marquis_Rex

Original Poster:

7,377 posts

240 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
ol' dirty said:
Ignoring those for a second- the 'trucks' I saw pulling big loads were the Diesel F350's.
Quick Google says the towing capacity is 8.7tonnes, & a payload of up to 2.6tonnes (depending on the back axle)




I had a short drive of the F150 & had an Explorer for 3 weeks & was really impressed with them.

Cabin seemed better built than the Ram- although we put a fair few miles on the Ram & we never complained about feeling uncomfotable.


I'd go diesel all the way. I love me some torque, Ma!Breaker, Breaker, 10-4hehe
I know the Diesel F350 really well. I wass involved in some of the development work of the Piezo Common rail 1900 bar injection system. I used the development mule (that looks like a run down version of the one in your picture) regularly.
The only diesel I was considering was the Cummins diesel engine fitted to the Ram. Its amazingly robust and not over complicated in the name of emissions- and very easy to get 600-800 Bhp (if you dont mind sold coal coming out of the exhaust tongue out)
Only problem is that diesel is about $2,20 a gallon here versus $1.59 for regular. Then factor in that the actual truck price is about 70-100 percent more year on year. A diesel Ram is a heavy duty affair and achieves about 22 mpg in daily driving. If you tow this doesnt go down much and may go to 18-20 mpg. The 5.7 Hemi petrol will achieve around 18-20 mpg long distance but when you tow- may go down to 11-13 mpg. With all this in mind the diesel is only worth it if I tow all the time-which i dont or if I wanted to have fun chipping- which I wouldnt mind- but not sure if it warrants purchase enough. The other problem is that with the diesel engine in -20 conditions it would probably take about 20 years for the heater to get warm!

Orb the Impaler

1,881 posts

191 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
Those Toyota Hi-Luxs with all the "sticky-out" bits (the one that Top Gear took to the North Pole) look fab; best looking pick-up ev4r!!!


BLUETHUNDER

7,881 posts

261 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
The 60th Defender,is just not special enough.I have a Ram.To me its the only American pick-up to have.I suspect someone from Rebel V8.com will be along shortly to say otherwise..........hehe

The Black Duke

1,642 posts

194 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
Marquis_Rex said:
I've never done a 'What car' kind of thread and usually view them as quite tedious, but if you cant beat them join them!
Besides, this forth coming purchase of vehicle is one of my least emotional purchases and I need to make a decision quickly- like within less than a week.

I move up north to Ilinois very soon, where to say, it snows alot would probably be an understatement. So 4WD is definately a requirement, along with the capability to tow a Porsche 993 Turbo or Dodge Challenger on a trailer and not break into a sweat. I'll also probably be carrying heavy engines such as Dodge Hemis and BMW S50s around. I may even take this pick up camping sometimes. In time I may do some off-roading in it. I definately need four seats also.
It seems like an amazing time to buy right now, with even dealers putting up sticker prices of way below Blue book values.


I was always naturally drawn to the brawny good looks of the Dodge Ram- especially the "Big Rig" post 2003 design.



So far, I've found a 2005 Chevrolet Silverado Z 71 truck for sale. It has covered 117,000 miles, and has the trusty pushrod 5.3 litre Vortec V8 that makes about 310 Bhp. Apparently the Z71 package is a special off road package with skid pans and specially tuned gas pressure shocks.
The book value for this truck is about $13,000. The dealer had it down to $10,990, however after a test drive and some shrewd negotiating, I got him down to $7,900yikes
The truck looks similar to this:


The truck felt refined and comfortable to drive, although it didnt feel all that fast and the engine felt too subdued. The truck had obviously been taken off road a bit, and unusual for a southern truck had some light surface rust underneath. I personally think the truck looks fairly bland. No real service history I could trace and I dont know how many owners.

The next truck I came across was the 2005 Ford F 150 5.4 litre 300 Bhp V8 "XLT"-which is a base model (less to go wrong). This one is up for $9000 as it has covered 165,000 miles, but has full 'Ben Satchers' Service history and only 1 owner. This truck felt tight and solid and the condition was great inside and out. It also felt fast to drive and it was very easy to 'light up the rears'. There was a slight shudder/shake at 55 mph-which is probably down to wheel imbalance. This truck felt much more responsive than the Chevy, with more direct feeling steering, a great sounding engine, felt faster, and more agile. I went to the dealer who had serviced it, and no expense seems to have been spared in its up keep. The 5.4 litre engine is a 3 valve design, over head cam, and has more torque than the Chevy, not only due to the capacity advantage but also due to the better port air flows combined with shorter duration cams. This truck was typical of a southern truck, and the underneath was just as clean as the top- even the exhausts still seemed aluminised.




Personally I think in the looks department the truck looks bland.

I was out at a bar the other night and by chance the bar man told me his 2003 Dodge Ram thats covered only 60,000 miles may be up for sale for around the $10,000 mark. I told him I would be interested if he was interested in selling. He said he'd get back to me. Viewing the truck externally, has some dings, but has the Rams classically butch good looks. I havent driven it yet, but it has the 5.7 litre hemi engine. This has a shallow Hemi combustion chamber with a twin plug layout (for a fast burn) and cylinder deactivation. This is also a pushrod layout so probably has very low friction. If the gearing has been matched well to the vehicle and cylinder deact- this one promises to have the best fuel economy. From what I;'ve heard it should also sound the best also.

From what Ive heard- Ford makes the toughest Truck chasis and frames. I dont really know if I would be utilising this 'toughness' though. The extra torque of 5.7 hemi would be welcome though. ANy other helpful comments or suggestions welcome!
Buy anything Japanese if you cant quite have a Landy?

ol' dirty

9,074 posts

216 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
Marquis_Rex said:
I know the Diesel F350 really well. I wass involved in some of the development work of the Piezo Common rail 1900 bar injection system. I used the development mule (that looks like a run down version of the one in your picture) regularly.
The only diesel I was considering was the Cummins diesel engine fitted to the Ram. Its amazingly robust and not over complicated in the name of emissions- and very easy to get 600-800 Bhp (if you dont mind sold coal coming out of the exhaust tongue out)
Only problem is that diesel is about $2,20 a gallon here versus $1.59 for regular. Then factor in that the actual truck price is about 70-100 percent more year on year. A diesel Ram is a heavy duty affair and achieves about 22 mpg in daily driving. If you tow this doesnt go down much and may go to 18-20 mpg. The 5.7 Hemi petrol will achieve around 18-20 mpg long distance but when you tow- may go down to 11-13 mpg. With all this in mind the diesel is only worth it if I tow all the time-which i dont or if I wanted to have fun chipping- which I wouldnt mind- but not sure if it warrants purchase enough. The other problem is that with the diesel engine in -20 conditions it would probably take about 20 years for the heater to get warm!
Fairy muff, I did not know about the pricing structure of vehicles that side of the pond...

All I was thinking of was it could have been a better towing vehicle.

I picked up a copy of Diesel Power magazine last time I was in the US, & I was amazed at some of the power you can extract from them!



Enough torque to kick start a small moonbiggrin

Edited by ol' dirty on Saturday 17th January 14:03

XitUp

7,690 posts

205 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
The Black Duke said:
Buy anything Japanese if you cant quite have a Landy?
He said he needs to tow stuff.

D900SP

458 posts

184 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
The business where I work has a "96 Dodge Ram 3500 Cummins diesel, single cab, extended bed, dually with about 100,000 miles on it, great for towing. The engine is noisy but apart from that, never seems to go wrong. Even I can park it, which is saying something.
The older Chevrolet/Isuzu diesels had engine problems which Chevy cured and extended the warranty.
Ford have had problems with the diesels and I believe they are "working" on it.

Now is the time to buy in the US as there are way too many trucks sitting in dealer lots. Drove past a Dodge (yes getting rarer by the day) dealer a while ago and the offer was $12000.00 of any new Dodge truck (except the Sprinter).

BLUETHUNDER

7,881 posts

261 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
D900SP said:
The business where I work has a "96 Dodge Ram 3500 Cummins diesel, single cab, extended bed, dually with about 100,000 miles on it, great for towing. The engine is noisy but apart from that, never seems to go wrong. Even I can park it, which is saying something.
The older Chevrolet/Isuzu diesels had engine problems which Chevy cured and extended the warranty.
Ford have had problems with the diesels and I believe they are "working" on it.

Now is the time to buy in the US as there are way too many trucks sitting in dealer lots. Drove past a Dodge (yes getting rarer by the day) dealer a while ago and the offer was $12000.00 of any new Dodge truck (except the Sprinter).
I will second the bullet proof factor.Nothing goes wrong on themthumbup

The Black Duke

1,642 posts

194 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
XitUp said:
The Black Duke said:
Buy anything Japanese if you cant quite have a Landy?
He said he needs to tow stuff.
Toyota Tundra will tow the Queen Mary 2 LOL

BigLepton

5,042 posts

202 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
Marquis_Rex said:
I also dont imagine the Defender is too refined over long distances when, say , crusing from Illinois to Oregon on Vacation (2000 miles plus)
Yeah, I mean how could it's permanent 4WD, coil springs and disc brakes all round compete with cart springs and drums? biggrin

You can also tow 7700lbs easily and legally because the central diff-lock means you can use all ten forward gears and two reverse on the road without winding up the transmission.

But they are a pointless choice on your side of the pond as the youngest official one you can get is now 15 years old and the price of rarity is high.

Best get which ever one of those big ugly chrome gin palaces they are giving the best deal on as they are all pretty similar underneath. smile

Mars

8,729 posts

215 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
Stop fking about with toys. Get a proper truck:



Owned by a PHer too. biggrin

BLUETHUNDER

7,881 posts

261 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
You can keep your Russian stuff.Its liable to break down.Which is more than often the case, that they do.