Warning POSSIBLE Tesco 99 Poor fuel problem

Warning POSSIBLE Tesco 99 Poor fuel problem

Author
Discussion

Frik

13,542 posts

244 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
Have you spoken to Tesco about this, or was naming and shaming on the internet your first port of call?

I'd recommend filling from the 95 pump in future...

Shatterstone

138 posts

183 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
Well it wont put me off tescos finest, I always alternate between V power and tescos depending on which is cheapest at the time. The only time ive noticed any differance in fuels was when i filled up with Totals super unleaded. That caused the car to kangeroo at times when cold, so havnt used it since!

dern

14,055 posts

280 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
Andyuk911 said:
Just a heads up but I am 99% sure Tesco have a problem with the 99 Fuel.
What a load of st. Take it to a garage and get the problem diagnosed.

Andyuk911

Original Poster:

1,979 posts

210 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
Frik said:
Have you spoken to Tesco about this, or was naming and shaming on the internet your first port of call?
Phoned and visited, spoke to the Duty Manager. Was told the correct procedure was to write to head office ...

kambites

67,593 posts

222 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
Frankly, if your car goes into a "limp home" type mode without recording a fault, it's broken. No piece of electronics should actively enter a diagnostics mode without recording the reason. If the fuel was bad and there was nothing wrong with the car, it would have recorded that it was having some kind of combustion problem, probably a misfire or overheating or something.

Andyuk911

Original Poster:

1,979 posts

210 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
kambites said:
Frankly, if your car goes into a "limp home" type mode without recording a fault, it's broken. No piece of electronics should actively enter a diagnostics mode without recording the reason. If the fuel was bad and there was nothing wrong with the car, it would have recorded that it was having some kind of combustion problem, probably a misfire or overheating or something.
No over heating or misfire ....

kambites

67,593 posts

222 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
Andyuk911 said:
kambites said:
Frankly, if your car goes into a "limp home" type mode without recording a fault, it's broken. No piece of electronics should actively enter a diagnostics mode without recording the reason. If the fuel was bad and there was nothing wrong with the car, it would have recorded that it was having some kind of combustion problem, probably a misfire or overheating or something.
No over heating or misfire ....
Quite. Then the fault is almost certainly with the car.

TheEnd

15,370 posts

189 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
Andyuk911 said:
kambites said:
Frankly, if your car goes into a "limp home" type mode without recording a fault, it's broken. No piece of electronics should actively enter a diagnostics mode without recording the reason. If the fuel was bad and there was nothing wrong with the car, it would have recorded that it was having some kind of combustion problem, probably a misfire or overheating or something.
No over heating or misfire ....
Don't take it the wrong way, the point is "limp home" is a specific emergency mode activated by the ecu, activated with the engine management light, and it will be recorded. What you will have had is rough running or another problem which pulls the power down, and it wasn't the ecu doing this for safety, in fact, it would seem that the ecu is currently unaware of any problems.

kambites

67,593 posts

222 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
TheEnd said:
Andyuk911 said:
kambites said:
Frankly, if your car goes into a "limp home" type mode without recording a fault, it's broken. No piece of electronics should actively enter a diagnostics mode without recording the reason. If the fuel was bad and there was nothing wrong with the car, it would have recorded that it was having some kind of combustion problem, probably a misfire or overheating or something.
No over heating or misfire ....
Don't take it the wrong way, the point is "limp home" is a specific emergency mode activated by the ecu, activated with the engine management light, and it will be recorded. What you will have had is rough running or another problem which pulls the power down, and it wasn't the ecu doing this for safety, in fact, it would seem that the ecu is currently unaware of any problems.
That sounds much more likely. I have never heard of a car entering its fail-safe mode without recording a fault. That would be a very odd firmware bug. However a modern ECU ought to detect anything with is having a effect on the engine's power output.

Edited by kambites on Saturday 28th November 19:49

Superhoop

4,680 posts

194 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
kambites said:
TheEnd said:
Andyuk911 said:
kambites said:
Frankly, if your car goes into a "limp home" type mode without recording a fault, it's broken. No piece of electronics should actively enter a diagnostics mode without recording the reason. If the fuel was bad and there was nothing wrong with the car, it would have recorded that it was having some kind of combustion problem, probably a misfire or overheating or something.
No over heating or misfire ....
Don't take it the wrong way, the point is "limp home" is a specific emergency mode activated by the ecu, activated with the engine management light, and it will be recorded. What you will have had is rough running or another problem which pulls the power down, and it wasn't the ecu doing this for safety, in fact, it would seem that the ecu is currently unaware of any problems.
That sounds much more likely. I have never heard of a car entering its fail-safe mode without recording a fault. That would be a very odd firmware bug. However a modern ECU ought to detect anything with is having a effect on the engine's power output.

Edited by kambites on Saturday 28th November 19:49
There is one specific 'Breed' of car that i'm aware of, that does enter limited power mode without recording any fault codes in the PCM.

Some of that later Ford stuff limits maximum engine speed at certain engine temperartures, which is something like

up to 105 degrees - Full engine speed

Over 105 but under 110 degrees - approx 3500 rpm

Over 110 but under 115 degrees - Max 2500 rpm

Over 115 degrees - no increase in engine speed, with PCM deliberately stalling the engine when the roadspeed drops below 3kph

No warning lamps, no fault codes stored..... To make things worse, it tends to used as a fail safe of the cars with dual stage thermostats, which are generally not fitted with a temp gauge, only warning lamps for cold (up to 65 degrees, and hot for engine temps over 120 degrees) so the fail safe operates before the hot warning lamp comes on

kambites

67,593 posts

222 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
My Lotus limits maximum revs below a certain coolant temperature too, but it has no effect on the engine below the artificial rev limit that it imposes. It's damned obvious when it's happening though. Surely Ford fit a temperature gauge so you can see what's happening?

Edited by kambites on Saturday 28th November 20:57

Rollcage

11,327 posts

193 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
kambites said:
My Lotus limits maximum revs below a certain coolant temperature too, but it has no effect on the engine below the artificial rev limit that it imposes.
A bit like the variable red line an an M3 - the rev counter leds change as the car warms up.

Superhoop

4,680 posts

194 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
kambites said:
My Lotus limits maximum revs below a certain coolant temperature too, but it has no effect on the engine below the artificial rev limit that it imposes. It's damned obvious when it's happening though. Surely Ford fit a temperature gauge so you can see what's happening?

Edited by kambites on Saturday 28th November 20:57
No temp gauge, as they are generally fitted with a dual stage thermostat, and as a result there tend to be temp fluctuations bug enough to make a gauge swing up and down slightly.

On early Ford's fitted with them, owners used to complain, so Ford ditched the gauge in favour pf warning lamps for cold, and over 120 degrees.

The power restrictions all occur below 12o degrees though, so no visual sign to the driver

kambites

67,593 posts

222 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
hehe I love the idea that customers complain about their temperature gauge moving erratically so Ford just take it away. smile

EDLT

15,421 posts

207 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
There was a Laguna at work once with a similar problem, it turned out to be the throttle position sensor and for some reason the ECU wouldn't record the fault. It took bloody ages to find, the owner had brought it from a Renault dealer who had told him it needed a new engine, wiring loom, injectors, fuel pump and ECU. rolleyes

SiF

17 posts

175 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
I had a similar issue with Tesco's 97 on a Smart Roadster. Normally used Vpower but was caught out and filled up at Tesco's. After 20-30 miles (time needed for engine to register new fueling) retarded ignition and limited boost. Garage found nothing, as no fault codes raised. Ran it through, re-fuelled (VPower) and it picked-up after 20-30 miles. When I looked into the issue across the forums, as was rare, one name kept coming up - Tesco! Obviously not a octane issue as had used 95/97 fine before from several suppliers.

BlueMR2

8,656 posts

203 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
My last cars engine went pop on Tesco 99. The only other car to do the same thing we knew of at the time was also running Tesco 99.

The ingredients used to make it 99 are not appreciated by especially some older engines so if you run an older car with it make sure it wont damage it first.

I went back to Shell after that and have never used Tesco fuel in my cars since. My Dad uses the normal 95 ron from Tesco all the time though especially with 5p a litre off. I wouldn't use Tescos 99 again though only V Power.

AndrewW-G

11,968 posts

218 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
Quick idea for anybody thinking there is a great difference in Tesco / Sainsbury / Asda / Shell etc, please go here

http://maps.google.co.uk/maps?hl=en&q=53.28086...

And watch carefully as the Tesco / Sainsbury / Asda / Shell etc tankers fill up with petrol from the same tanks..........

Edited by AndrewW-G on Saturday 28th November 22:53

PJR

2,616 posts

213 months

Saturday 28th November 2009
quotequote all
Maybe Tesco's regular fuel is pulled from the same tank as other companies? But the 99 stuff is supposedly made by "Greenergy"
http://www.greenergy.com/tesco_99_octane/index.htm...

Adam_W

1,075 posts

201 months

Sunday 29th November 2009
quotequote all
pfft IMO its more likely to be the french nature of the car rather than then fuel, surely you'd get a specific code from the ECU for excessive knock caused by bad fuel.

And if you were that sure it was the fuel you would have it drained rather than burn it off as you'd risk damage by using it.