Alternatives To The 991 Turbo S??

Alternatives To The 991 Turbo S??

Author
Discussion

LayZ

1,630 posts

243 months

Friday 5th February 2016
quotequote all
All of this high end machinery is a bit unsuitable for track use, in my opinion.

You don't want to be lugging round hundreds of kilos of heated seats, aircon and the like. The cost of brakes and tyres and wear on a track will be very high on a £150k car, that is not a track special at least.

Get the road car you want an look at part ownership in a track car? Rent something? Buy a Caterham as well?

foxsasha

1,417 posts

136 months

Friday 5th February 2016
quotequote all
It might be worth taking your kid/s for a long run in a demo 911 to see how they handle being in the back. My little boy (5yo) has never been car sick before. However 70 mins into a 100 mins drive out in a 911 he started complaining that his stomach hurt. We thought he was hungry so gave him a banana that he couldn't finish. Arrived at our destination and no sooner had he got out of the car than he was sick. Evidently his stomach ache was motion sickness. I think it's because visibility from the back seats is particularly poor.

He hasn't had that issue in the back of our Maserati GTS despite covering much longer distances in it. It's one of things stopping me getting a Turbo, I need the kids to be happy in the back doing Eurpean trips in it.

Jeff100

8 posts

123 months

Friday 5th February 2016
quotequote all
Hi
Have had a Turbo S for coming up two years. Don't think there's anything to touch the combination of genuine every day usability with absolutely ballistic pace when you feel like it. Regularly achieve 26might, so range is quite sensible - then select sport plus and everything goes utterly mental. Had a 991 GT3 for a while which is a great car, but my other half just didn't like driving it. She Loves the turbo S! So I don't know if that would be a factor but it certainly makes me feel like I am not being so self indulgent!

xFLYNNx

41 posts

141 months

Saturday 6th February 2016
quotequote all
OldBob said:
..Flynn of old gtroc? (Edit: appears so after a quick lancerregister check - nice colour Huracan) If so you've already been through a few alternatives haven't you.

Edited by OldBob on Thursday 4th February 14:28
I have had a few now. Was very close to a Turbo S this week, but just done a deal on a 458. Pick it up next week all being well.

I'll guess the next one will be a Turbo S, but would also like to have had an F12 for a while

Edited by xFLYNNx on Saturday 6th February 13:31

W8PMC

Original Poster:

3,345 posts

239 months

Monday 8th February 2016
quotequote all
Thanks again for everyones opinions & input.

I'll have a closer look at FF's & have started dialogue with McLaren around the 570S (hadn't considered either).

Although a 911 Turbo has been my biggest automotive want since being a young child, this will be a big purchase & as such I don't want to enter this all starry eyed & end up missing a better suited car &/or higher than average financial risk.

I'll be having extended Test Drives in the Turbo & Turbo S next month (dealer's not registering their Gen II's until March 1st).

Quickmoose

4,496 posts

124 months

RoverP6B

4,338 posts

129 months

Tuesday 9th February 2016
quotequote all
Considered anything from Ruf? Like a 911 Turbo but a bit more wild...

Quickmoose

4,496 posts

124 months

Tuesday 9th February 2016
quotequote all
There's a RUF 'Targa Florio' on previous pages which is lovely and comes with 620BHP...

Nice and exclusive...

W8PMC

Original Poster:

3,345 posts

239 months

Wednesday 10th February 2016
quotequote all
Quickmoose said:
That's pretty compelling. Going to take a look at the 570S though as no denying it's a bit of a looker, but i think all told & as per the above video, the Turbo S is on paper the only one to offer the complete package i'm after.

W8PMC

Original Poster:

3,345 posts

239 months

Thursday 11th February 2016
quotequote all
What about the Tesla P90D? Anyone any experience of these?

Although it is far from being a Turbo S, performance wise with the 'Ludicrous Speed Upgrade' it appears on a par with the Turbo S & the running costs would be significantly lower.

I spec'd one up yesterday & with all the boxes ticked it came out at around £112k, however with the subsidy from Tesla etc. the PCP costs were around 60% less than the Porsche & the range is now around 320 miles which is more than far enough for my travel requirements. Without the 'Ludicrous' upgrade which itself is around £8k, the PCP costs are fairly impressive.

Quickmoose

4,496 posts

124 months

Thursday 11th February 2016
quotequote all
Well it's clearly not in the same arena as the Porsche or Ferrari/Maserati etc, but a worthy idea that I think you should explore...a quite unique prospect, that I think looks handsome too...bordering on bland but just doing enough to be stylish...the only other negative as written about is the how the giant iPad has just been thrown at the dashboard...

9e 28

9,410 posts

202 months

Thursday 11th February 2016
quotequote all
W8PMC said:
What about the Tesla P90D? Anyone any experience of these?

Although it is far from being a Turbo S, performance wise with the 'Ludicrous Speed Upgrade' it appears on a par with the Turbo S & the running costs would be significantly lower.

I spec'd one up yesterday & with all the boxes ticked it came out at around £112k, however with the subsidy from Tesla etc. the PCP costs were around 60% less than the Porsche & the range is now around 320 miles which is more than far enough for my travel requirements. Without the 'Ludicrous' upgrade which itself is around £8k, the PCP costs are fairly impressive.
Truly terrible idea lol. Its as heavy as a battleship and watching it go round corners at Brunters was hilarious.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Z0_dLVsq9k

These were Teslas own cars they bought along to VMAX as PR to show how quick they are. They really were not all that quick in a straight line either.

991 turbo S was sooooo much nicer

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NSgqHWunipc

W8PMC

Original Poster:

3,345 posts

239 months

Thursday 11th February 2016
quotequote all
Quickmoose said:
Well it's clearly not in the same arena as the Porsche or Ferrari/Maserati etc, but a worthy idea that I think you should explore...a quite unique prospect, that I think looks handsome too...bordering on bland but just doing enough to be stylish...the only other negative as written about is the how the giant iPad has just been thrown at the dashboard...
That was my thinking & coupled with the virtually Zero running costs it would certainly tick most of my boxes with a couple of ticks in boxes i'd never considered.

I do quite like the styling, but agree it's hardly ground breaking. Looking above though, it may be a bit of a farce on track & always the problem of where would i charge the car up at Spa or the like. Having a closer look at the 570S next weekend as this appears to be a car worthy of consideration, however the lack of rear seats 'could' become an issue & it's certainly a more in your face Sports car than the 911.

Quickmoose

4,496 posts

124 months

Thursday 11th February 2016
quotequote all
hmm in those 3 cars you've crystalized your 'problem'
your spacious, eco performance car at one end...your focused un-spacious performance car at the other and your heart's desire occupying the middle ground....

W8PMC

Original Poster:

3,345 posts

239 months

Thursday 11th February 2016
quotequote all
Quickmoose said:
hmm in those 3 cars you've crystalized your 'problem'
your spacious, eco performance car at one end...your focused un-spacious performance car at the other and your heart's desire occupying the middle ground....
I can't help feeling it's a great problem to have (real world & all that), however the more i look at alternatives the tougher it's becoming.

Although i'm not a huge fan of Chris Harris's reviews (clearly got him the Top gear job however so prices how little i know), i do often value his take on cars & this review of the 570S somewhat surprised me, especially as he makes several comparisons to the Porsche Turbo S.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KyBc1GnJVlM

Quickmoose

4,496 posts

124 months

Thursday 11th February 2016
quotequote all
enjoy the test drives...that'll answer everything...

W8PMC

Original Poster:

3,345 posts

239 months

Tuesday 16th February 2016
quotequote all
Today's the day. Playtime in a Tesla P90D & McLaren 570S. I hope the frost/ice clears before 11am otherwise it could be a very short day.

BMCG

484 posts

137 months

Tuesday 16th February 2016
quotequote all
W8PMC said:
Today's the day. Playtime in a Tesla P90D & McLaren 570S. I hope the frost/ice clears before 11am otherwise it could be a very short day.
Best of luck - will be intrigued as to how the experiences stack up

Edited by BMCG on Tuesday 16th February 09:36

W8PMC

Original Poster:

3,345 posts

239 months

Tuesday 16th February 2016
quotequote all
Didn't get to drive the 570S, that's been postponed until next Friday. Manchester have a white one in the showroom & a black one as their Demo. Both looked stunning.

Took out a new Tesla Model S P90D & that was quite a surprise. The speed of the thing was relentless & it had the Ludicrous upgrade so 0-60 in 2.8sec & a 10.5 1/4 mile. Very quirky travelling that quickly in virtual silence & the regenerative braking wold take a bit of getting used to, but overall i was extremely impressed with the car & the Tech is a whole other level to anything else i've experienced.

hunter 66

3,910 posts

221 months

Tuesday 16th February 2016
quotequote all
Funny just thinking that,as after years of owning and Racing GT Porsches , my next car will be a Tesla X , as fast to the speed limit and has 7 seats , can tow the race car if want to a bit of track work !!
Problem solved