Current market

Author
Discussion

Sukh13

726 posts

185 months

Friday 22nd September 2023
quotequote all
Have you asked to see the damage repaired? I was also looking at that one.

Problem is it could drop like a stone if the market corrects...

PaulJC84

924 posts

217 months

Friday 22nd September 2023
quotequote all
Jefferson Steelflex said:
What would the PH hive mind do if say someone was in the market for a 997 Turbo manual, had the money available and a space in the garage?

Not many around right now, those that are all have nothing special about them to warrant jumping into it, but asking prices remain absolutely firm. I don't (or rather don't want to) have the patience to stick the money in the bank and come back after Xmas, even though logic suggests prices are going to fall.

Are some of the older Pork more immune to market forces? I sold my last one for £57k back in 2021, paying more than that now feels a bit incongruous with where the current market is looking to be headed.
I think i would just keep looking and if one comes up in a spec/condition that appealed to you then buy it. If nothing takes your fancy there is no harm in waiting.

I only buy cars that I am happy keeping for a while and not to buy to use for a short period and hope to sell on at a similar price.

People have been calling down the market for years that possibly want prices to come down (Brexit/Covid etc..). But you could end up waiting forever.

Ed.Neumann

421 posts

8 months

Friday 22nd September 2023
quotequote all
PaulJC84 said:
People have been calling down the market for years that possibly want prices to come down (Brexit/Covid etc..). But you could end up waiting forever.
I think most are simply not happy to pay considerably more for a car today than that same car was 4 years ago when it also had 30k less miles less on it.



But there must come a point where you just want to have that car, so what if it falls further, cars depreciate?
Jesus, people are loosing £20,000 on a base Tesla over 2 years and here we are not wanting to lose that on a £70k Porsche over three years.

I just think be realistic. The silly period is over. I say go for it, but don't expect a £70k 991 to be worth £60k in 3 years time.






CK11

273 posts

184 months

Friday 22nd September 2023
quotequote all
Sukh13 said:
Have you asked to see the damage repaired? I was also looking at that one.

Problem is it could drop like a stone if the market corrects...
I havent no. Not sure im brave enough for a cat s 911 tbh. Unless it was an absolute steal.

CK11

273 posts

184 months

Friday 22nd September 2023
quotequote all
I just ran that £62,500 2018 Cat s Gts through wbac out of interest.
It was coming back at £35k !
Motorway wouldnt bid, i take it they dont value anything cat

Autotrader have similar 2017/18 NON CAT gts starting at £80k up to about £90k
Motorway seem to value those around £72k.
So basically its about 10k under non cat motorway prices. No idea if thats about right or not.
Prices all over the place.


Sukh13

726 posts

185 months

Friday 22nd September 2023
quotequote all
It feels like we the supply of 992 has increased, as the Cat car ages out, it will drop faster than other cars as it will become an outlier in a larger pool of cars.

GT4RS

4,429 posts

197 months

Friday 22nd September 2023
quotequote all
CK11 said:
I just ran that £62,500 2018 Cat s Gts through wbac out of interest.
It was coming back at £35k !
Motorway wouldnt bid, i take it they dont value anything cat

Autotrader have similar 2017/18 NON CAT gts starting at £80k up to about £90k
Motorway seem to value those around £72k.
So basically its about 10k under non cat motorway prices. No idea if thats about right or not.
Prices all over the place.
Very few people will buy a damaged repaired car, they have very little value in the real world and very difficult to move on.

Find a straight on

Ed.Neumann

421 posts

8 months

Friday 22nd September 2023
quotequote all
GT4RS said:
Very few people will buy a damaged repaired car, they have very little value in the real world and very difficult to move on.

Find a straight on
Agreed, trade on a Cat S is 50-65% of non cat car.

ATM

18,298 posts

219 months

Friday 22nd September 2023
quotequote all
PaulJC84 said:
People have been calling down the market for years that possibly want prices to come down (Brexit/Covid etc..). But you could end up waiting forever.
Yes but now is different.....

Interest rates rising and that is a first for like 20 years

So if you don't understand why this is significant I'm not sure what to say


CK11

273 posts

184 months

Friday 22nd September 2023
quotequote all
The seller of the gts apparently turned down a £55k bid from a trader earlier today. His prerogative i guess.

Sukh13

726 posts

185 months

Friday 22nd September 2023
quotequote all
Did you get any details of the damage?

julian987R

6,840 posts

59 months

Friday 22nd September 2023
quotequote all
Ed.Neumann said:
I just think be realistic. The silly period is over. I say go for it, but don't expect a £70k 991 to be worth £60k in 3 years time.
991 prices, in time, will drop lower than 997's.


CK11

273 posts

184 months

Friday 22nd September 2023
quotequote all
parts replaced - PS 1/4 panel , door, wing , headlamp , Ft bumper
the DS 1/4 panel was repaired.
Because the 1/4 panel was a weld on part made it a cat S the rest of the parts were bolt on.
From my understanding there would be no future porsche warranty allowed on it either, could be wrong on that though

As others have mentioned, v prob best avoided unless you plan to keep for about 10 years

Sukh13

726 posts

185 months

Saturday 23rd September 2023
quotequote all
Cheers.

Think the price is too rich for that amount of damage and getting precluded from Porsche warranty

CK11

273 posts

184 months

Saturday 23rd September 2023
quotequote all
He might regret turning down that offer, if real, but does show a trader thinks he can turn a profit on it.
Just a shame its so hard to sell on a cat s car privately and the trade dont offer, or when they do offer, its such a difference in price. In that example wbac are 50% of trade price.
All of a sudden a 2018 991.2 gts is £35k, that would quickly get you rethinking.

POORCARDEALER

8,525 posts

241 months

Saturday 23rd September 2023
quotequote all

WBAC do not set prices for specialist cars - they are buying to put in an auction that the trade buy from, and make a fat profit….. I’ve just given £8k over what WBAC quoted on a 997, and will still turn decent profit .

CK11

273 posts

184 months

Sunday 24th September 2023
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Out if interest in this particular example.
So you hypothetically buy the cat s 2018 gts for £60k or You buy a non damaged 2018 gts, same miles etc for 80k at the current market rate.
If Both cars drop at a similar rate that would make the cat s car a more astute financial buy surely, because of the 20k difference in starting price for the same car.
Say In 5 years they have both dropped 50%
The straight car is now 40k
The cat s is £30k





ATM

18,298 posts

219 months

Monday 25th September 2023
quotequote all
CK11 said:
parts replaced - PS 1/4 panel , door, wing , headlamp , Ft bumper
the DS 1/4 panel was repaired.
Because the 1/4 panel was a weld on part made it a cat S the rest of the parts were bolt on.
It is my understanding that Cat S means structural. I dont know if welding on a panel is structural. My 981 was Cat S because some suspension parts were damaged. These are structural.

Also I believe insurance quotes or assessments never look to pull or repair panels - they have to replace. This can make repair costs escalate quickly. The rear quarter was damaged - in the pic - and the Porsche approved repair quote had 1000 + vat just for the replacement panel and then add for fitting and paint etc.

My repair estimate was a minimum of 17,500 + VAT.


MC99

411 posts

186 months

Tuesday 26th September 2023
quotequote all
CK11 said:
The seller of the gts apparently turned down a £55k bid from a trader earlier today. His prerogative i guess.
I would have done that deal - brave to turn down real money on a CAT S car

C320

47 posts

85 months

Tuesday 26th September 2023
quotequote all
MC99 said:
CK11 said:
The seller of the gts apparently turned down a £55k bid from a trader earlier today. His prerogative i guess.
I would have done that deal - brave to turn down real money on a CAT S car
Indeed, £55k for a straight no hassle sale sounds about right for that.