Leaf or Zoe

Author
Discussion

cwis

Original Poster:

1,158 posts

179 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
This is all interesting stuff folks! Keep it coming...

Here's the journey I would have to do on a fairly regular basis, along with the route I currently take (minimal stops, minimal traffic for least stress).

https://goo.gl/maps/vWOu4

It's JUST less than 60 miles round trip. Any current EV owners - would you risk this? Charging at the other end is not an option, really unless I park about a mile away and walk the rest.

IN51GHT

8,777 posts

210 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
cwis said:
This is all interesting stuff folks! Keep it coming...

Here's the journey I would have to do on a fairly regular basis, along with the route I currently take (minimal stops, minimal traffic for least stress).

https://goo.gl/maps/vWOu4

It's JUST less than 60 miles round trip. Any current EV owners - would you risk this? Charging at the other end is not an option, really unless I park about a mile away and walk the rest.
Get a Brompton!!!!

cwis

Original Poster:

1,158 posts

179 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
If I wanted to get cold and wet I'd take one of my 7 motorbikes. If I wanted to pedal I'd take my ancient ProFlex.

Wanna roof. Want cupholders! Sulk!

In all seriousness the frequency of the visits is seasonal. I'm only really there in the winter, and It's dark when I get there and when I leave.

In the summer this route is great on a bike/pushbike. In the winter, not so much. Plus - sweaty hills.

IN51GHT said:
Get a Brompton!!!!

IN51GHT

8,777 posts

210 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
120miles in the winter is unrealistic in my opinion.

cwis

Original Poster:

1,158 posts

179 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
60 miles round trip - as in, there and back again.

IN51GHT said:
120miles in the winter is unrealistic in my opinion.

SydneyBridge

8,599 posts

158 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
Is there anywhere on the way back you could stop for a top-up and a coffee if necessary? I assume even a short top-up would give you enough to get home

cwis

Original Poster:

1,158 posts

179 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
SydneyBridge said:
Is there anywhere on the way back you could stop for a top-up and a coffee if necessary? I assume even a short top-up would give you enough to get home
It's 28 miles there, 28 miles back. There's a shopping centre a mile or so away from the other end, I'd probably be able to charge there. I'd rather not though.

Are you all seriously saying a current tech EV won't make it?

Maybe I should either:

Get an extended test drive - see if it is feasible,

Or:

Wait a few years for the tech to catch up?

IN51GHT

8,777 posts

210 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
cwis said:
It's 28 miles there, 28 miles back. There's a shopping centre a mile or so away from the other end, I'd probably be able to charge there. I'd rather not though.

Are you all seriously saying a current tech EV won't make it?

Maybe I should either:

Get an extended test drive - see if it is feasible,

Or:

Wait a few years for the tech to catch up?
I misunderstood. 28miles each way should be easy.

squirejo

794 posts

243 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
cwis said:
It's 28 miles there, 28 miles back. There's a shopping centre a mile or so away from the other end, I'd probably be able to charge there. I'd rather not though.

Are you all seriously saying a current tech EV won't make it?

Maybe I should either:

Get an extended test drive - see if it is feasible,

Or:

Wait a few years for the tech to catch up?
Doable yes, but your suggestion of extended test drive has to make sense.

Carparticus

1,038 posts

202 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
cwis said:
This is all interesting stuff folks! Keep it coming...

Here's the journey I would have to do on a fairly regular basis, along with the route I currently take (minimal stops, minimal traffic for least stress).

https://goo.gl/maps/vWOu4

It's JUST less than 60 miles round trip. Any current EV owners - would you risk this? Charging at the other end is not an option, really unless I park about a mile away and walk the rest.
My other half has a ZOE and commutes 39 miles each way every day and doesn't bother plugging in at the office. Most of that is a steady 55/60 on a dual carriageway. She usually has 10 miles+ left at the end of the day (not including the 5-10miles hidden reserve most EV's have ..). There are various youtube vids showing owners pushing them past 100miles just to see what happens as a fail safe.

So I'd say don't worry about it.

However, your range will naturally reduce if you want to do 87mph down motorways into a 15mph head wind, and want to do loads of grand prix starts at traffic lights to reach 30 mph in record time ... ;-)


For additional comfort, use Zapmap which allows you to search for top up points based on EV car type :-

https://www.zap-map.com/charger-search/find-charge...


IN51GHT

8,777 posts

210 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
I'm on the verge of pulling the trigger at £159 a month over four years.

cwis

Original Poster:

1,158 posts

179 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
IN51GHT said:
I'm on the verge of pulling the trigger at £159 a month over four years.
Exciting! New toy. Quite jealous...

Which one, Zoe or Leaf? How many miles per year? Any links to the deal, or are you a hard bargaining, muscle bound company director type and you've basically made them beg you to take one off their hands?

GOT to book a test drive...




IN51GHT

8,777 posts

210 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
cwis said:
Exciting! New toy. Quite jealous...

Which one, Zoe or Leaf? How many miles per year? Any links to the deal, or are you a hard bargaining, muscle bound company director type and you've basically made them beg you to take one off their hands?

GOT to book a test drive...
Zoe through simply playing three dealers off against each other. 10,000 mile pcp with 8,500 mile battery lease that can be adjusted up or down.

Carparticus

1,038 posts

202 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
IN51GHT said:
I'm on the verge of pulling the trigger at £159 a month over four years.
Go for it !

Sound like a similar deal to the Zoe we bought. She seems to have been completely in love with it ever since.

The total monthly cost of the PCP finance deal + £15 electricity (and no road tax etc) is considerably less than what it was costing to run her wretched MG F for the same usage. She was burning through £200 in petrol per month, road tax was £250 and typically it needed £1k - £2k per year in MOT failures and the rest, and all that with only 50k on the clock. Glad its gone. Horrible thing ..


The Zoe deal was a bit of a no brainer, and so far its performed faultlessly.


IN51GHT

8,777 posts

210 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
Carparticus said:
Go for it !

Sound like a similar deal to the Zoe we bought. She seems to have been completely in love with it ever since.

The total monthly cost of the PCP finance deal + £15 electricity (and no road tax etc) is considerably less than what it was costing to run her wretched MG F for the same usage. She was burning through £200 in petrol per month, road tax was £250 and typically it needed £1k - £2k per year in MOT failures and the rest, and all that with only 50k on the clock. Glad its gone. Horrible thing ..


The Zoe deal was a bit of a no brainer, and so far its performed faultlessly.
How long have you had it?


Carparticus

1,038 posts

202 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
IN51GHT said:
How long have you had it?
Ordered end of July, took delivery a few weeks later.

The exact model is a "Zoe Dynamique Zen" which seems fairly well loaded, and considerably better than the "Mk1" we tested back end of 2013 which was quite off-putting at the time.

IN51GHT

8,777 posts

210 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
I've just had some bad news. They made a mistake, they meant £189.

Next best price is £164, so trying to push them down a bit.

tony wright

1,004 posts

250 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
IN51GHT said:
I've just had some bad news. They made a mistake, they meant £189.

Next best price is £164, so trying to push them down a bit.
That's the same price I've been quoted for a 4 yr PCP but, with a 7.5k milage allowance. Also includes free servicing, breakdown road side assist, warranty and something else, can't remember...

anonymous-user

54 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
did Renault Sheffield not 'smash the £159 price' as they indicated they would?

Butter Face

30,299 posts

160 months

Monday 1st December 2014
quotequote all
Get your local dealers to try 36m options as they are quite decent.

If anyone wants a specific ZOE quote just let me know your mileage and deposit and I can quote you inc battery hire.