Would YOU drive a Cat 'D' registered????

Would YOU drive a Cat 'D' registered????

Author
Discussion

sc00by57

Original Poster:

2,159 posts

243 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Ok so the 3R that is on a certain car sales website.... Would you consider? rather interesting as im looking at spending around 25k ish on a noble but her indoors says get a straight one....

Iaing01

421 posts

212 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
No. Buy a straight one or you'll never sell it

Iain

sc00by57

Original Poster:

2,159 posts

243 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
wink who said i will want to sell it? biggrinbiggrin

Biggriff

2,312 posts

285 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
If it's cheap enough yes I would buy one, but as mentioned resale is always going to be an issue, but if you intend to keep it that's not an issue.

Ideally you want photos and description of the before damage and then details of what was fixed and by whom. These things matter!


AMG Merc

11,954 posts

254 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Biggriff said:
If it's cheap enough yes I would buy one, but as mentioned resale is always going to be an issue, but if you intend to keep it that's not an issue.

Ideally you want photos and description of the before damage and then details of what was fixed and by whom. These things matter!

What he said (although personally I wouldn't touch one).

MadMacMcMad

1,266 posts

255 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Buy it cheap, sell it cheap. Get it checked out first and it could be an absolute bargain.
I have a CatD and it is brill, no regrets. You must just be realistic when selling tho. Based on my experience, about 20% below normal value. Cat D is a very fixable commercial right off. So regardless of the damage done, as long as the chassis is in good nick, the rest is replaceable.

sc00by57

Original Poster:

2,159 posts

243 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
so on that note, an 04 3R is selling roughly around the 32k mark... so 25k would be acceptable.. wink 20% down.. might send a few messages about pic's etc...

joust

14,622 posts

260 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Unless it was 50% of the price of a new one, personally I wouldn't touch it. Far too much hassle come selling it time.

J

ajg31

1,455 posts

208 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
sc00by57 said:
Ok so the 3R that is on a certain car sales website.... Would you consider? rather interesting as im looking at spending around 25k ish on a noble but her indoors says get a straight one....
Ill sell you mine tomorrow for 26. Why buy a bent one for 25?

sc00by57

Original Poster:

2,159 posts

243 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
only 11k miles compared to a lot of the higher mileage ones availiable, I was only looking at either a 2.5 or a GTO-3.

guess as my spec'C' has only done 2k the last year the mileage shouldn't be a problem.

It was only a Question to see who would.. I very much doubt her indoors would ever let me buy a bent one..

mgbond

6,749 posts

233 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
sc00by57 said:
only 11k miles compared to a lot of the higher mileage ones availiable, I was only looking at either a 2.5 or a GTO-3.

guess as my spec'C' has only done 2k the last year the mileage shouldn't be a problem.

It was only a Question to see who would.. I very much doubt her indoors would ever let me buy a bent one..


A car with to little milage can sometimes have more wrong with it. Higher milage cars tend to have most of the issues sorted.

Bondy

ajg31

1,455 posts

208 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
I personally think this is what kills alot of Tivvers, too few miles in a few short summer months. Cant be good for a car to stand all that time?

Y2K

5 posts

276 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
I wouldnt touch the motor unless its been autoligned, there's plenty of these cut n shuts out on the road claim they were light damage, and just bodgered up. give a few months teh fibregalss will start breaking/ cracking.
autolign test costs a measly £250 no seller would hesitate to get it throu if he's confident the repairers 100%.

check dhales, plenty of catd cars on there with so called light damage as well as universal who seem to put every damaged car of any value on a catd because they know people would pay more due to the current lingo of all catd's being light damage

paulcundy

1,896 posts

266 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
The message is clear; mega problems selling it on.

Ergo, only pay a price for it that reflects this.


Personaly I think a thing that is as fast as the most fast things that may have had a bend or two repaired to the pre-bend spec is as good as it once was.

My car's been bent many a time and repaired and I'm still happy enough to race in it again. So why not a road going car? The question is standards. If its been repaired well enough its as good as new.

The issue with cat "D" is as much to do with subjectives as cup "A" or "G".

Its unfortunate and unfair but c'est La vie.

Regards
Paul C

m12gto3r

108 posts

227 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Why buy a bent one for 25K when there looks to be a perfectly good 3R on Piston Heads Classified for 28K.

It has a few more miles on it but like someone mentioned in previous mails, it has probably had any the problems ironed out.

ajg31

1,455 posts

208 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
m12gto3r said:
Why buy a bent one for 25K when there looks to be a perfectly good 3R on Piston Heads Classified for 28K.

It has a few more miles on it but like someone mentioned in previous mails, it has probably had any the problems ironed out.
That one is mine, and looks like its off to a Stealers for much less than the 28k (although i am sure he will push it out for 30K+). Nobody liked the sound of my car after i mentioned a rebuild and non dealer stamps. Again, just like a cat D it makes it undesirable. ce la vie. A Stealer get a bargain, i learn a new lesson in life, the Car goes to a new home at top book.

m12gto3r

108 posts

227 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Well how the next cheapest one. It’s got to be better than buying a bent one.

Out of interest ajg31 if you don’t mind me asking, how much did the stealer screw you for?

ajg31

1,455 posts

208 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Email sent re price

sc00by57

Original Poster:

2,159 posts

243 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
ajg31 said:
m12gto3r said:
Why buy a bent one for 25K when there looks to be a perfectly good 3R on Piston Heads Classified for 28K.

It has a few more miles on it but like someone mentioned in previous mails, it has probably had any the problems ironed out.
That one is mine, and looks like its off to a Stealers for much less than the 28k (although i am sure he will push it out for 30K+). Nobody liked the sound of my car after i mentioned a rebuild and non dealer stamps. Again, just like a cat D it makes it undesirable. ce la vie. A Stealer get a bargain, i learn a new lesson in life, the Car goes to a new home at top book.
wink PX for a Spec'C'??? biggrinbiggrin

ajg31

1,455 posts

208 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
Sorry mate i am off to the land of Fosters and Roo's hence the sale smile