Devils Advocate

Devils Advocate

Author
Discussion

tjones5420

Original Poster:

81 posts

274 months

Thursday 21st February 2002
quotequote all
I don't know why they don't bring a couple of Tuscan's and Tamoras over here, and structure a contract that states if they can't make it meet the regulations you get your money back, and start taking orders. Take them to a couple of Auto shows (not the big ones) and see what the reaction is.

I think they'd be surprised by the numbers they would get....

al27

82 posts

270 months

Thursday 21st February 2002
quotequote all
You are guilty of being logical!

tjones5420

Original Poster:

81 posts

274 months

Friday 22nd February 2002
quotequote all
It's a fair cop. Slap the cuffs on......

I am more than willing to stand by a Tuscan at an auto show all day and answer questions by the way, Mr Samuelson if you are reading this !!!!

One thing dealers do here is put cars in the malls, and I think that would be another way to do. We've got a new mall opening here in about a month, and I can only imagine the stir a Tuscan would cause sat there in the middle.....

jhybinette

23 posts

279 months

Monday 29th April 2002
quotequote all
hmmm,

The way the Tuscan is designed, there is no way it will be DOT approved. Unless you put on some real ugly 5 MPH bumbers onto it. Imagine black wrap around rubber bumpers on the Tuscan back and front.....

jhybinette

23 posts

279 months

Monday 29th April 2002
quotequote all
hmmm,

The way the Tuscan is designed, there is no way it will be DOT approved. Unless you put on some real ugly 5 MPH bumbers onto it. Imagine black wrap around rubber bumpers on the Tuscan back and front.....

tjones5420

Original Poster:

81 posts

274 months

Monday 29th April 2002
quotequote all
But if you look at the VW Beetle, the Elise or the Corvette, you can integrate the bumpers into the design of the cars, and have them the same colour as the rest of the car.

I think the main problem with the Tuscan is the headlights, which will be too low for the US IIRC.

ATG

20,577 posts

272 months

Monday 29th April 2002
quotequote all
All this talk gives me the fear. If the Brazilian operation is a separate company that can go bust without blowing up Blackpool, then I feel more comfortable.

The US is a unique market. There are good reasons why US manufacturers don't export cars, or at most sell a very different range of cars into Europe. Driving conditions are very different, customer expectations are different ... and then of course there are the safety and emissions regulations.

If you sell a few cars to real enthusiasts who play with them occaisionally or take them out on the track, then great. But the thought of someone having to negotiate huge numbers of stop signs, crawling round at 25mph, really crappy road surfaces, air-con that doesn't really do the business and the prospect of 55 and occaisionally 65mph out of town ... this isn't TVR territory. My left foot would drop off at about the same time as cooling system would explode and the spark plugs fur up. Auto box, soft suspension, the mother of all air cons, lots of toys and wizzy things ... corvettes, vipers start to make much better sense. US consumers tend to demand rather good customer service too, and with the best will in the world, there is a limit to what TVR can provide compared to Ferrari, Porsche etc. who would be seen as the competition. If your product costs half as much, then you have less money to play with per customer.

I don't get the impression that TVR are ready for a big leap just yet. Better to go for slower organic growth and concentrate on getting it right in their existing market. If they can spin off a company that doesn't take their eye off the ball in the UK, then they have little to loose. But that seems like an unlikely proposition to me.

PetrolTed

34,426 posts

303 months

Monday 29th April 2002
quotequote all
quote:

All this talk gives me the fear. If the Brazilian operation is a separate company that can go bust without blowing up Blackpool, then I feel more comfortable.

It will be. It will make TVRs under licence.

PiB

1,199 posts

270 months

Monday 29th April 2002
quotequote all
Well one thing that could be done with TVR in the USA is what Caterham 7 and Ultima Cars do. Apparently, sending a car sans engine and in a slightly dissasembled form will bypass DOT standards. But you must then put in a EPA approved engine if in a state that requires emission tests. And in Cali they are very strict on the specs like the exhaust header must be What you can't do is send a non epa engine through customs. But if it were already here (in the US) it could be street legal in some states.

Using a partner to assemble the vehlcles would be best. Penske??

fizz

251 posts

270 months

Monday 20th May 2002
quotequote all
I guess you can add to your list the Dare (Ginetta) G4.

How does Ginetta/Dare Caterham Morgan manage to pull this off ( making cars for the USA) and why hasn't TVR tried?

My guess is that TVR is bigger than Caterham, Morgan, Ginetta, Ultima but not quite big enough to do it with a splash...

airoom

54 posts

262 months

Saturday 8th June 2002
quotequote all
I am glad that Caterham, Ginetta, Morgan and Lotus are able to sell their products here in the USA. TVR really has the look to be a significant player--especially since I'm calculating their price in the Carrera range. I don't want to see myself coming and going--with the TVR I know I will be unique!
I hope TVR continues to make progress regarding LHD--it seems pretty obvious that car companies need to engineer for the global marketplace--or use engines that are for the global marketplace.

fizz

251 posts

270 months

Saturday 4th January 2003
quotequote all
Kind of sad that there has been no progress on the TVR in the USA front.
Maybe PW needs to talk with Penske one more time over a few beers and get the deal done?

tasmin83

681 posts

262 months

Sunday 5th January 2003
quotequote all
What would be nice is to hear some "official" status report from PW and/or "the factory" on the subject.

Terminator

2,421 posts

284 months

Sunday 5th January 2003
quotequote all
I have to go 'up north' later this month so I'll pop into the factory on my way and, wearing my TVRCCNA shirt, I'll find out the latest 'offical' story, assuming that I can get to see Peter.

JonGwynne

270 posts

265 months

Monday 6th January 2003
quotequote all

Alex said: I know, but the quality of the cars is simply not good enough for the US market. Wherever they are made.


What twaddle. TVR's build quality may not be perfect but that didn't stop companies like Ferrari, Lotus, Lamborghini, Aston Martin, Maserati, etc... from succeeding quite nicely in the US.

Also, the BMW M3 hasn't exactly got a squeaky-clean rep as far as reliability goes. But that doesn't stop people buying them.

There's no such thing as either a perfect car or a perfect car maker. People who rag on TVR for its build-quality are just trying to come up with excuses to justify not owning one.