|
Aizle
11,920 posts
45 months
|
|
|
C2james
4,128 posts
35 months
|
You can't really complain about safety, hundreds of people have been killed on the ring for a reason. If people want to use it on a regular basis then the track probably should be made a bit safer. Granted its cool to have a dangerous historic race track but really as the OP says common sense is one of the main things needed.
|
|
|
Life Saab Itch
34,203 posts
58 months
|
Pistonwot said: Go buy a Dictionary as it appears grammar outwits you! Look up wailing fish-wife whilst your at it! So what is your very own gramatical take on kicking a ball about a park if it is not football? Why be such an immature douchebag? Toolish pedantry is a foul trait in any man and besides, the facts are in front of us all from the off. Facts like it matters not a jot if you believe it or not, dumping a bike at 130mph is gonna be felt. What do you think happens if you bump into the Armco at 130mph,,, It will make a scuffing noise and mark up your leathers? Driving a toll road is not a sport. Football is an unfortunate irrelevance both to this discussion and life in general. Genuinely not sure why you included it. It's not pedantry anyway, it's correcting the view of many that is wrong.A TF session is not a trackday, whichever way you look at it. Apart from that, you should probably find a dictionary to look up the words hypocrite and grammatical.
|
|
|
Aizle
11,920 posts
45 months
|
You missed "your" out of you're post.
Go check that too
|
|
|
Life Saab Itch
34,203 posts
58 months
|
Their they're, don't worry.
|
Advertisement
|
|
|
Kawasicki
1,545 posts
105 months
|
Life Saab Itch said: Driving a toll road is not a sport. It is when the toll road is the one in question. I treat the TF days like a race, i.e. go fast and be careful.
|
|
|
Shipper
35 posts
15 months
|
Dale Lomas said: jnoiles said: Completely calm. I just find his articles painful reading and I'm challenging him to justify his lazy journalism and tabloid conclusions. Tabloid conclusions and lazy journalism? I'm not on fleet street writing about something I know nothing about. I live here, have done for 5 years. It's a nice place to live and to work. But just saying 'let it be, it's dangerous' is what I'd call lazy. "Grow a pair"? I know my way around, I've lapped more laps than I can reliably count. Lots of bike laps, lots more car laps. Public sessions, trackdays, VLN and private sessions chasing lap times. I know what it's like to eat tarmac at 150mph or front-end a stationary car in one that's still moving quite quickly. Try being an instructor here, sitting on the passenger seat with a guy who can't change gear on a manual 'box but wants to do a sub-8 lap on his first day... I'm not going to attempt to grow my pair. When I try and hire the track, the management want me to spend thousands of euros for a full safety team with flag marshalls. Even if it's just me on my todd. But on a big TF day they'll pull in 150k+ and serve several thousand drivers. And with less marshalls than one guy on a private session. I understand your thinking, the 'fix' may just be to close the track, but I doubt it. It's a golden goose that lays a million euro egg every month. If we could get them to replace another 'ring-werk' advert with a message that SPILLS KILL, I'd be happy. Even printing the emergency number and what to do in an accident on the lap ticket? Is that so much? One little change like that could foreseeably save a life. I'm not going to apologise for rocking your status quo... if it's painful to read, why do you read it? Are you a masochist? Well said. "Let it be" is as stupid a comment as I have heard in a long time. People die because other people are idiots and lazy. I spent some time at my favourite track doing "speed off the street" days and realised weekends were deadly. The track's website would state that the day was for "Speed off the street" only. Turn up and race whatever you liked. You had to buy a track license and wear long pants, closed shoes, a long sleeve shirt and a helmet but after that you were on your own. No induction, no rules, no safety, no checking condition of the cars. On one particular Saturday said speed off the street day also had the mx5 club and the caterham club running qualification sessions. So; 1. We get there only to find we had little track time. 2. The rice burners club turns up complete with girlfriends and hit the tract. 3. One girl was black flagged and slammed on the brakes in the middle of the straight just after the start finish line. Cars swerved everywhere and how the whole thing did not turn into a wreck is beyond me. People should have been injured and cars destroyed. 4. One supra drive went off on the same corner 9 times. The marshal yelled “slow in fast out”, and then got angry when said rice burner went off again and again. After he had yelled ‘slow in fast out’ enough times I went up to him and said “mate, he has no idea what you mean, tell him to approach the corner and brake while he still has the front wheels straight and turn only when he is slowed and starts to accelerate lightly through the corner”. People should have been injured that day. Cars should have been wrecked. Here’s what went wrong and how it could have been fixed. 1. Overbooked track day. The circuit had two clubs running events on a public track day that was usually public only. People got angry as they had just three 20 minute sessions all day (call it 5 laps per session as cars went off and red flagged a few sessions). Cranky angry drivers and a race track is a bad mix. Issue – greedy circuit, mismanaged. Result – potential injury and damage. Mitigation measure – do not over book a track! 2. First time track drivers in 400 to 500hp rice burners. Sending thirty 18 to 27 year olds in twin turbo supras and the rest of the Japanese racing car pack onto a 2.8km race track for the first time is going to ask for trouble. Asking them to sign an indemnity and pay $50 for a track license will not insure safety. Issue – lazy and lack of attention to induction and briefing (ship, it would take 15 mins!!!!). Result – potential injury, death and damage. Mitigation measure – Induction for 1st times at 0.5hrs long. Briefing for all at 15 mins long. If people are driving 2 hrs to get to the track and paying $50 for a track license for the year and $250 for a track day, they will wait for a briefing. Safety does not just happen, deaths do. Racing, track days et.al. are dangerous enough without putting the uneducated and under experienced into a dangerous situation with no safety briefing what so ever. Good enough is never good enough and anyone who believes that ‘things will look after themselves’ or ‘let it be’ are clauses often found in any Safe Work Method Statement need to be kept well away from any racetrack!
|
|
|
hora
16,670 posts
81 months
|
pincher said: The arguments for and against the ring will rage forever, both in terms of whether the TF days should continue and whether or not bikers should be allowed out at the same time as cars.
I've been, but only once - it was never something that was top of my list of priorities to actually do but I got the chance last year as part of a trip to Brugge and Spa, so though 'why not'.
I don't mind driving quickly (but would never describe myself as a 'good' driver, compared to some I know) but I did a total of 3 laps - one with a pal who has been numerous times before and twice on my own. I think I could remember the first 10 corners and after that I had no real idea which way I was supposed to be going, whether there was a turn after the blind crest etc etc. Quite frankly, I felt completely intimidated - by both the track (sorry, road) and its reputation and also by the fact that there were some seriously fast people hammering past me, whether it be on a bike or in a GT3.
I saw, on my third and final lap, an incident where a car and a bike had obviously had a coming together - fortunately it looked like nobody was hurt and the only damage was to the metal but it brought home to me the old adage of 'There but for the grace of God go I', so I called it a day and gave away my other laps.
Whether that makes me a coward or not I don't know and to be honest I don't really care - its a box I have ticked but I can't see myself going back anytime soon. To me you quit whilst you were ahead 
|
|
|
pincher
2,712 posts
87 months
|
I like to think so - for me, the risk outweighed the reward. That's not to say that I think everyone else was a loony, more a case of recognising my own limitations and being aware of the potential downside of a SLOT moment - to others as well as myself.
I can see both sides of the argument but would tend to fall on the side of leaving things mostly as they are - I just decided that it wasn't for me.
|
|
|
DSE
65 posts
81 months
|
sorry to hear about your friend ...
as someone who visits the ring often I cant believe some of these comments. who *wants* the threat of oil/fluids on the nurburgring .... how is that adding anything to the experience. The track is difficult enough to drive fast without the concern of crashing due to no fault of your own.
is jnoiles just trolling or has he something against Dale ???
|
|
|
Pistonwot
413 posts
29 months
|
Life Saab Itch said: Driving a toll road is not a sport. In your mind only,,,,,,,
|
|
|
EDLT
14,592 posts
76 months
|
Threads about safety at the 'ring always end the same way.
|
|
|
subirg
250 posts
146 months
|
Firstly, Charly RIP.
Reading this thread makes me think PH has signed up en mass to join Bomber Command. The degree of wild over reaction to this thread is totally over the top. The OP makes some valid points and is not trying to bring about the end of the universe. Why the extreme posts??? The Ring is dangerous - be prepared, know the rules and take your chances only when you feel comfortable. As for fluid leaks - I have a video of a biker going over on the fluid left by some old banger. He slid elegantly along the tarmac for several hundred yards and only avoided being collected by a high speed Lambo Gallardo because the Lambo driver somehow managed to take avoiding action, drove clean off the track and somehow missed the armco. Scary near miss for all involved.
|
|
|
Hatchoo
19 posts
73 months
|
DSE said: sorry to hear about your friend ...
as someone who visits the ring often I cant believe some of these comments. who *wants* the threat of oil/fluids on the nurburgring .... how is that adding anything to the experience. The track is difficult enough to drive fast without the concern of crashing due to no fault of your own. I agree. I can see why suggestions that the track itself should be be made safer are going to get no support here. If you go to the 'ring you are choosing to drive a track that is famous for being dangerous and difficult. That is a massive part of the appeal. I don't understand why anyone would want to protect the rights of the ignorant to endanger the lives of others.
|
|
|
Porkie
2,263 posts
111 months
|
Pistonwot said: I cant believe Im reading such gutter levels of "woe is me" on Pistonheads, please try to act responsibly and control the fish-wife-esque wailings. Why must this fantasy obsessed demographic perennially b  h to us about how, according to their skewed bromidic logic, all things of danger must be made safe to the point of banality? NO THEY SHOULDNT BE MADE SAFE, ADULTS accept the consequences of Motorsport which are NEVER "unexpected" and the results of leaving a track with little run-off at speed has a predictable outcome,,, its not looking good! As petrolheads our actions can amaze and frighten us or maybe upset those around us and on occasion have dire consequences. It is in THIS moment we need to get a grip of ourselves and do the right thing, the right thing is to offer respect and refrain from wailing. It is certainly not the time to get all Dorothy, emotionally over-react and start blaming absolute nonsense like oil on the track. Its actually annoying this nannying sh*te is accepted on Pistonheads, it really needs to be punted off to dull the pages of Road Safety Monthly or NCAP News where it belongs. Why must obvious dangers be "remedied"? Why should "certain" vehicles be excluded. Instead why not limit yourself if your human frailty is the concern? What has happened is tragic no doubt, BUT unexpected or blame apportionable, no, I think not! Safety??? ,,, a healthy lack of it is an integral part of being a petrolhead. Maybe its time for "woe is me" to go fishing or take up gardening? Evil Knievil would have kicked all of your pussy asses. Thats just about the worst post I think I have ever read on any forum.
|
|
|
Pistonwot
413 posts
29 months
|
DSE said: sorry to hear about your friend ...
as someone who visits the ring often I cant believe some of these comments. who *wants* the threat of oil/fluids on the nurburgring .... how is that adding anything to the experience. The track is difficult enough to drive fast without the concern of crashing due to no fault of your own.
is jnoiles just trolling or has he something against Dale ??? I think the point being made is a fair one and without malice. "if an 'expected outcome' will scare you then stay away". That is why I wouldnt poke a Lion in the face with a sharp stick, I KNOW what will happen and I dont like it! The 'ring is a big playpark and we enter it fully aware of the consequences of "what if I fall off the swing", its simple Physics. When a soft organic speeding object meets a solid fixed object = harm. It is undoubtedly upsetting but there is no other expected outcome, even an idiot is aware of this. So why are intelligent people playing dumb and making spurious emotionally biased comments when they do know better? There is ALWAYS the risk of oil, coolant or even an upturned or out of control vehicle waiting for everybody round the next bend on TF. This caution applies EVERYWHERE and Id go so far as to say due to the nature of the sport of hooning it is probably an inevitible event. With this in mind it is therefore quite rediculous to drive ANYWHERE at full chat or even 7/10ths in the expectation you are absolutely safe from harm. TF is for light hearted but speedy fun FOR ADULTS, its not a race or a full on TT.
|
|
|
DSE
65 posts
81 months
|
Pistonwot said: I think the point being made is a fair one and without malice. "if an 'expected outcome' will scare you then stay away". That is why I wouldnt poke a Lion in the face with a sharp stick, I KNOW what will happen and I dont like it! The 'ring is a big playpark and we enter it fully aware of the consequences of "what if I fall off the swing", its simple Physics. When a soft organic speeding object meets a solid fixed object = harm. It is undoubtedly upsetting but there is no other expected outcome, even an idiot is aware of this. So why are intelligent people playing dumb and making spurious emotionally biased comments when they do know better? There is ALWAYS the risk of oil, coolant or even an upturned or out of control vehicle waiting for everybody round the next bend on TF. This caution applies EVERYWHERE and Id go so far as to say due to the nature of the sport of hooning it is probably an inevitible event. With this in mind it is therefore quite rediculous to drive ANYWHERE at full chat or even 7/10ths in the expectation you are absolutely safe from harm. TF is for light hearted but speedy fun FOR ADULTS, its not a race or a full on TT. totally agree but any ideas to reduce fluid spills, in my opinion, are bang on. The ring isnt as well marshalled as a track day so the public need to take this concept and make it work. stop the car/bike if you suspect any fluids are being dropped and report back to ring hq, dont be a t  t and drive 5 miles or whatever back to the carpark on the racing line (I have seen this). thats just being stupid and selfish. 5/10ths on a bike and you hit oil, you are going down and its going to hurt or be fatal and all because of some moron. cant see why anyone would have an issue with this ...
|
|
|
Life Saab Itch
34,203 posts
58 months
|
Pistonwot said: In your mind only,,,,,,, Not really, it's a hobby at best. It's not long ago that they handed out severe b  kings to people seen using stopwatches. Sport implies a competitive element: SPORT noun 1. an athletic activity requiring skill or physical prowess and often of a competitive nature, as racing, baseball, tennis, golf, bowling, wrestling, boxing, hunting, fishing, etc. The only competitive element on a TF day is either with yourself against the clock, or if you're a complete bellend you go for full on racing. That still doesn't make it a sport, it just means that you're more likely to ruin someone else's day. TF and trackdays are not sports. Test days and racing are. It's not rocket science to see the difference.
|
|
|
Life Saab Itch
34,203 posts
58 months
|
Pistonwot said: due to the nature of the sport of hooning 
|
|
|
Vide Cor Meum
1 posts
11 months
|
Regards fluids being dumped on the track:
I happened to be in the right place at the right time, on one of my regular visits to the 'ring in the late 1990's. Whilst videoing, a German registered car came past with frontal crash damage, obviously leaking fluids (smoke coming from vehicle, a trail of fluids behind it on the track and spectators waving at the driver, causing it to skid on the bend). As other spectators tried to warn following traffic, two bikers when down (front wheels lost on fuild) and hit the barriers hard. Luckily they were both ok, other than shaken and annoyed, their bikes however, where totalled. The German Police arrived and a German spectator, who spoke English, asked me if I had the incident on video. I informed him I did and the German Police viewed it, then requested a copy and my details. Later the same week the insurance firms acting for the two bikers requested a copy too. I was later informed the driver of the German registered vehicle responsible was prosecuted by the Police. The Police will act in these cases, but obviously need hard evidence, which in this case was pure luck.
Happy 'ringing guys/girls and R.I.P. Charly.
|
|