Schu has retired again

Schu has retired again

Author
Discussion

rev-erend

21,408 posts

284 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
Give it a year and he will be back in a HRT and a few Le Mans and DTM guest drives.

CiderwithCerbie

1,420 posts

267 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
Alfanatic said:
I'm with this exactly, though whether it's the right time to retire or not is up to him and the team principles, IMO. Schumy will know when he's had enough.

I didn't like him in his first career but he's won my respect with his second. I suppose the difference between me and Cider / WannaGotta is that even though I was never a fan of his the first time around, I never doubted that he was an extraordinarily talented driver, the most complete I've ever seen in F1. Just a pity he is also a cheat. He annoyed me because I thought he didn't have to cheat and he would still have been a prolific record breaker. I think that Cider / Wanna think that without the cheating he'd have maybe been a 1 or 2 championship guy or less. That's the difference.
Wow! I can almost completely agree with that! thumbup

I have been thinking about the 1993-2006 and the real sadness is that we don't actually know how good he really was. I have always acknowledged his talent, that has never been the problem. All the dreadful barging about, the TC/ barge board and FIA shenanigans at Benetton & Ferrari have cheated us all of the truth.

1998-2000 seems to me to have been the best of it, even with Bernie desperately wanting (?manufacturing) a Ferrari/MSC win. I was a Mika fan, not just because of my Finnish connections, but because he was SO honest and such a sportsman as well as being lightening fast and literally coming back from the dead. Those MK/MSC duals were magical. I still think Mika could have been a triple WDC if Mercedes had upped their game after that remarkable race at Spa in 2000, but they let him down, as many on here believe they have let Michael down recently. 1994 was awful, 1995 was very dubious and 2001-2004 were just plain boring apart from the scare Kimi gave them in 2003. I will give him 2000 despite all the nonsense at the end of 1999 season trying to manufacture a WDC for that prat Irvine.

Yes MSC could have been truly great, but instead of embellishing the unique stats, the poor character & behaviour of the man remain to diminish him, visible on video for all time.

I would like to retract something however. The initial quotes on the Beeb from MSC today seemed to particularly enhance my view of his persistence arrogance, but reading the fuller interview shows much more maturity and introspection. He even realises that as a human being you learn more from failure than supreme success. This shows genuine change and as someone who believes in the possibility of real redemption for individuals I was moved by his words for the first time - damn.

In the end his career, to me, is more tragedy than triumph. I really hope for two things for the next two months. One is that he and all his competitors come through the season safely and the second is that his farewell does not upstage the great and competitive season we are witnessing.

SRT77

677 posts

218 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
Vettel's thoughts


http://uk.eurosport.yahoo.com/news/vettel-schumach...

Best thing about his retirement is not having to read the same old BS from the same two people so frequently in the future.

CiderwithCerbie

1,420 posts

267 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
vonuber said:
I am shocked and disapointed that it took until the 9th reply until Cider showed up.
I was having dinner and the wife banned both me and my daughter from our iPhones....

CiderwithCerbie

1,420 posts

267 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
doogz said:
Interesting. What's your opinion of Senna? True motorsport great? Visious cheat? Something else?
This thread is not about Senna.


Let's just say I think he was provoked by Prost and Balestre in a way MSC never was by anyone, so yes I put him above Schumacher

CiderwithCerbie

1,420 posts

267 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
SRT77 said:
Vettel's thoughts

http://uk.eurosport.yahoo.com/news/vettel-schumach...

Best thing about his retirement is not having to read the same old BS from the same two people so frequently in the future.
Add something original & interesting of your OWN without abuse or shut up

Alfanatic

9,339 posts

219 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
CiderwithCerbie said:
I would like to retract something however. The initial quotes on the Beeb from MSC today seemed to particularly enhance my view of his persistence arrogance, but reading the fuller interview shows much more maturity and introspection. He even realises that as a human being you learn more from failure than supreme success. This shows genuine change and as someone who believes in the possibility of real redemption for individuals I was moved by his words for the first time - damn.

That, I think, is what has changed my opinion of him. The soundbites we get from him when he's being interviewed after races. In the old days, on ITV, we never got any of that, he wouldn't talk to the ITV presenters. In the comeback, we got to see the human side of him, both in his lack of dominance on the track and in his attempts to make sense of events afterwards. So I could begin to understand what drives him, what he was thinking and how he was motivated, even if I didn't agree with the conclusions or the actions he took, now all of a sudden he wasn't the baddy in a mask anymore, he is just another guy who has a huge passion for motor racing.

Gene Vincent

4,002 posts

158 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
One of the greatest drivers to ever drive a car leaves F1... the sport is only going to be poorer for it.

Like all champs, he will have a lot of critics, I'm one if I'm honest, and I think it is right that he makes way at the end of the year.

There is though one aspect to this that find immensely to his credit, he tried...

Most leave the sport and become a pundit or similar, he left, got a good offer and gave it a go, we should acknowledge courage, even in our enemies.. to quote Lord Macaulays 'Horatio at the Bridge':-

"Curse on him!" quoth false Sextus, "will not the villain drown?
But for this stay, ere close of day, we would have sacked the town!"
"Heaven help him!" quoth Lars Porsena, "and bring him safe to shore;
For such a gallant feat of arms was never seen before."

It was an act of courage and I'd rather be seen as a Lars Porsena than a Sextus any day of the week.

Wanta996Gotta

5,622 posts

207 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
Gene Vincent said:
One of the greatest drivers to ever drive a car leaves F1... the sport is only going to be poorer for it.

Like all champs, he will have a lot of critics, I'm one if I'm honest, and I think it is right that he makes way at the end of the year.

There is though one aspect to this that find immensely to his credit, he tried...

Most leave the sport and become a pundit or similar, he left, got a good offer and gave it a go, we should acknowledge courage, even in our enemies.. to quote Lord Macaulays 'Horatio at the Bridge':-

"Curse on him!" quoth false Sextus, "will not the villain drown?
But for this stay, ere close of day, we would have sacked the town!"
"Heaven help him!" quoth Lars Porsena, "and bring him safe to shore;
For such a gallant feat of arms was never seen before."

It was an act of courage and I'd rather be seen as a Lars Porsena than a Sextus any day of the week.
Act of courage and at least he tried????? He was rumoured to be getting paid 15 Million a year to win races and develop the car. He has done neither but harm his legacy and cost Mercedes millions in his wages and re-building the cars he has trashed.

You offer "Pundits" like Damon Hill or Brundle 15 Million a year to return into an F1 car and they will come running.




Gene Vincent

4,002 posts

158 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
Wanta996Gotta said:
Act of courage and at least he tried????? He was rumoured to be getting paid 15 Million a year to win races and develop the car. He has done neither but harm his legacy and cost Mercedes millions in his wages and re-building the cars he has trashed.

You offer "Pundits" like Damon Hill or Brundle 15 Million a year to return into an F1 car and they will come running.
"By my words let it be known that venality is my only motive."

You place yourself as Sextus to my Lars Porsena, your words place you clearly.

Wanta996Gotta

5,622 posts

207 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
Gene Vincent said:
Wanta996Gotta said:
Act of courage and at least he tried????? He was rumoured to be getting paid 15 Million a year to win races and develop the car. He has done neither but harm his legacy and cost Mercedes millions in his wages and re-building the cars he has trashed.

You offer "Pundits" like Damon Hill or Brundle 15 Million a year to return into an F1 car and they will come running.
"By my words let it be known that venality is my only motive."

You place yourself as Sextus to my Lars Porsena, your words place you clearly.
Why thank you........

Gene Vincent

4,002 posts

158 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
Wanta996Gotta said:
Gene Vincent said:
Wanta996Gotta said:
Act of courage and at least he tried????? He was rumoured to be getting paid 15 Million a year to win races and develop the car. He has done neither but harm his legacy and cost Mercedes millions in his wages and re-building the cars he has trashed.

You offer "Pundits" like Damon Hill or Brundle 15 Million a year to return into an F1 car and they will come running.
"By my words let it be known that venality is my only motive."

You place yourself as Sextus to my Lars Porsena, your words place you clearly.
Why thank you........
You're entirely welcome Sextus.

anonymous-user

54 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
He definitely had one more year left in him, would have been amazing to see him driving for Ferrari next year frown The only thing I'm pissed off about it the st treatment he got from the joke that is Mercedes.


CarbonM5

927 posts

191 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
7 times WDC

91 GP wins

66 Poles,one of which was at Monaco in an average car at 42 years old

Faster than 25 year old team mate Rosberg.

What a fluke!


SmoothCriminal

5,052 posts

199 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
Glad he did come back even if by his high standards the end result was poor, he changed my opinion of him seemed a lot more down to earth and laid back this time.

Wanta996Gotta

5,622 posts

207 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
CarbonM5 said:
7 times WDC

91 GP wins

66 Poles,one of which was at Monaco in an average car at 42 years old

Faster than 25 year old team mate Rosberg.

What a fluke!
We know all of this so WHY IS HE SO AVERAGE NOW!!!

FIA biase? Unlimited testing? Tyres? Cheating? If it was all down to the car then why has Rosberg whooped his ass since his return.

Al W

591 posts

227 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
CarbonM5 said:
Faster than 25 year old team mate Rosberg.
According to the BBC "he has been trounced by team-mate Nico Rosberg in terms of raw pace. In their 52 races together, Schumacher has out-qualified his younger compatriot only 15 times."

superkartracer

8,959 posts

222 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
http://www.formula1.com/results/driver/2012/7.html

2012 - 14 races , top 4 grid starts = 6 ( 7 including Monaco )

superkartracer

8,959 posts

222 months

y2blade

56,091 posts

215 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
SeeFive said:
Derek Smith said:
By whom and where?
Sky News - breaking news. Evidently straight from Schu.
frown Sad to hear this.