Red GT86

Author
Discussion

ECG1000

Original Poster:

381 posts

142 months

Tuesday 9th August 2016
quotequote all
Quickmoose said:
yeah... amongst a few other things...always chasing issues and not enjoying it, seemed to be their experience..
Fingers crossed I've been ok so far apart from the clicking BC which were swapped for better coilovers.

If I did do FI, it would be the tried and tested methods Fensport approve/recommend: Avo for turbo or Cosworth for supercharger.

LordGrover

33,545 posts

212 months

Tuesday 9th August 2016
quotequote all
Have you driven the Harrop? It makes a compelling case... if you want the feel of (almost) a big, lazy V8 - with a bit of urgency thrown in.

ECG1000

Original Poster:

381 posts

142 months

Wednesday 10th August 2016
quotequote all
LordGrover said:
Have you driven the Harrop? It makes a compelling case... if you want the feel of (almost) a big, lazy V8 - with a bit of urgency thrown in.
I haven't sadly.

Keep on meaning to organise some kind of meet and encourage FI GT86's to show up so I can have a good chat with owners to see which option is best to live with, most exciting etc.

LordGrover

33,545 posts

212 months

Wednesday 10th August 2016
quotequote all
I'm sure Mark at Abbey would be glad to take you for a spin and let you take the wheel.

ECG1000

Original Poster:

381 posts

142 months

Thursday 11th August 2016
quotequote all
LordGrover said:
I'm sure Mark at Abbey would be glad to take you for a spin and let you take the wheel.
I'd love to do that but Abbey is sooooo far away from me.

ECG1000

Original Poster:

381 posts

142 months

Thursday 13th October 2016
quotequote all
** Warning, huge waffle ahead **

Haven't updated this thread in a while, so here's an extremely lengthy one about my thoughts and feelings. Could almost be an extract from a teenagers diary.

Just been enjoying the GT86 for what it is. Finding myself using it less for the commute and more on a night for a good tear up when the roads are quieter.


As I mentioned before I went on the Colin Hoad CAT drift training day at Millbrook back in August. I booked the afternoon for one to one tuition. Was a combination of getting to grips (pun not intended) with certain exercises in the Caterham, then jumping into my car and repeating the exercise hoping muscle memory would transfer from one car to the other. I've been lucky to drive a couple of Caterhams at Palmer Sport so had an idea on what to expect.

Was all going well doing little figure of eights round cones etc - then a hop into my car, getting cocky I wanted to try a complete 'circle' type drift. Cones were laid out to mimic a medium sized roundabout, and away I went. I hadn't tried this in the Caterham yet so was trying to run before I could walk. First impressions when getting back into the 86 was how vague and soft it felt! The pointy, feelsome car I once knew and loved had transformed into a boat.... Made me really appreciate how much a Caterham dials you into the road.
The first attempt was dull, juddery understeer, the second attempt resulted in a little skid which I hastily gathered up, the third a whole load of arm twirling and me facing the wrong way. I couldn't find the sweet spot.... After a few more attempts, the best I could do was get halfway round the 'roundabout' and unintentionally straighten up or perform a clumsy pirouette. Apparently, only a small handful of people crack this on their first CAT day. However, I'd imagine that was a kind word to compensate for my ineptness or an effort to cheer me up, or both.
Really quite cross with myself and my car, I trudged back to my trusty old friend the Caterham. First attempt was a little wiggle, then second attempt, I cracked it. Full continuous circles! I found it far more intuitive when I could feel exactly what was going on at terra firma.
Now with a newly acquired spring in my step it was back to the 86. Second try, and again I was round with a massive grin on my face! Like riding a bike.......sort of. It was such a satisfying feeling completing (vaguely) graceful complete circles.
After a brief tiff, I was back in love with the 86.

All in all a very good day out that I'd fully recommend.


Re-visiting the Caterham problem: (already made a thread on here earlier in the year)
I spent the next few weeks pondering the drift day and how good the Caterham felt. This led to reading all the latest reviews and got me thinking about the excitement of owning a 310R. Dreaming of dawn raids on my favourite country roads and making an effort to do more track-days, I picked up the phone to Caterham.
Depending how you see it, a 310 looks fairly reasonable value at 22k. But look again and you’ve to add the R pack to get the LSD, seats, suspension etc. Then there's the 6 speed gearbox, lowered floor and 13" wheels - the list goes on. Oh, and another £1200 for a windscreen!! Why are these necessities not standard fit?!
This all amounts to around 30k! 30k for a 1.6 litre kit car - sounds extortionate if you look at it like that. I hope someone will agree with me here - the price tag makes more sense when you actually experience a Caterham for yourself. There aren't many alternative 4 wheeled options that offer the same excitement for the same money. Almost forgot to mention the extra £3000 required for Caterham to build the car for you. I would attempt to build the car myself (with lots of help from my boss) so at least I could save a bit there and achieve a greater sense of satisfaction.

The thing that throws me is sinking that much into something that will essentially be a very impractical toy. It’s more of an A to A car, rather than A to B, unless B has some form of shelter to park in. However, I’ve always wanted to own a Caterham and hopefully will do someday, if not in the near future.
I’m test driving a 270R down at Donnington on the 29th to get an idea of how a 310 will steer, so we’ll go from there.


So if I don’t chop the 86 in for a Caterham, the idea is to make it a bit more mental – more of an event to pedal.

To turbo or to supercharge... Far cheaper than buying a 310!

Turbo is slightly cheaper and gives a lot more scope for extra power due to being easy to upgrade in the future. Will also be cool experience the whooshes and bang associated with turbo-charging. But then there’s the risk of turning the car into something too ‘boosty’ making it difficult to drive in a linier fashion. And... as I’ll be going with an Avo setup, it’ll have to be an unequal length manifold – I don’t like a boxer burble unless it’s coming from an Impreza. There are other options out there to get round this but Fensport (who I trust implicitly) recommend (and know intimately) Avo, so that’s what I’ll go with.

Supercharger will be in the form of a Cosworth setup. More responsive, linear low end and I’ll be able to keep my equal length manifold for the maniac howl I’ve become accustomed to. Cosworth have put a lot of time into the development process so you know you’re getting a very good quality product that’s going to be kind to your engine.
But.... this option is slightly more expensive and you’re limited to 280 to 300bhp. Any higher than that and you’re into bigger bucks in the shape of forged internals etc.
At the moment I’m leaning slightly towards turbo due to the power advantages later down the line. This view changes from day to day though.


If I were to get rid of the 86 for a Caterham, it wouldn’t be because I don’t like the car anymore, it would simply be because it’s time for a change – having owned the car for two and a bit years, and the fact I’ve always wanted a Seven. Whilst I’m in the right situation to be able to own a Caterham, I might as well take the leap?
At the moment I’m more leaning to sticking with what I’ve got but we’ll see what the 29th brings.


Comments and criticisms (of which I’ll suspect there to be a few) welcome!


If you’ve got this far, well done – hope I haven’t bored you to tears! Just helps me getting my thoughts onto paper.


Here’s a picture of my dog to cheer you up:


LordGrover

33,545 posts

212 months

Thursday 13th October 2016
quotequote all
Surely forged internals would be required for the turbo if venturing north of +350BHP no matter whether turbo or supercharged?

ECG1000

Original Poster:

381 posts

142 months

Thursday 13th October 2016
quotequote all
LordGrover said:
Surely forged internals would be required for the turbo if venturing north of +350BHP no matter whether turbo or supercharged?
This is true, but I think 350 will be more than enough for me.
The Fensport car has 335bhp (standard internals at the time) in this video
( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ut55yR2Yu8M ) of it keeping up with a McLaren. Puts into perspective of how nuts that'll be.

I'd probably start out at 280 to 300 then build up over time to 330 to 350.

LordGrover

33,545 posts

212 months

Thursday 13th October 2016
quotequote all
The first looks similar to DaveJH's - he let me have a go in it a few posts down here: click.
Very quick and very 'drivable' too. biggrin

ECG1000

Original Poster:

381 posts

142 months

Thursday 13th October 2016
quotequote all
LordGrover said:
The first looks similar to DaveJH's - he let me have a go in it a few posts down here: click.
Very quick and very 'drivable' too. biggrin
Read that post of yours many times biggrin It's a good write up.

When you say there is no lag, is it just immediate power, not (for want of a better word) a 'swoop'' of grunt?
My worry with going turbo is that I'll be messing about having a bit of fun skidding out of corners and all of a sudden the turbo will boost, and I'll be facing the wrong way!

LaurasOtherHalf

21,429 posts

196 months

Thursday 13th October 2016
quotequote all
Not sure how I missed this thread, lovely little car.

ECG1000

Original Poster:

381 posts

142 months

Friday 14th October 2016
quotequote all
LaurasOtherHalf said:
Not sure how I missed this thread, lovely little car.
Cheers dude. Thoroughly enjoy reading your threads too.

liner33

10,691 posts

202 months

Friday 14th October 2016
quotequote all
I have to say having been in the same position many many times and gone the "more power" route it rarely works out

Any money you put into the 86 will be gone , you wont get it back when you sell , any money you put into a Caterham you will

If the 86 feels "vague and soft" it always will

The only thing the 86 has going for it is practicality and once you spend a ton getting more power and better handling you will lose most of that

ECG1000

Original Poster:

381 posts

142 months

Friday 14th October 2016
quotequote all
liner33 said:
I have to say having been in the same position many many times and gone the "more power" route it rarely works out

Any money you put into the 86 will be gone , you wont get it back when you sell , any money you put into a Caterham you will

If the 86 feels "vague and soft" it always will

The only thing the 86 has going for it is practicality and once you spend a ton getting more power and better handling you will lose most of that
That's the worry I have; chucking more money at it for more power could end up being a bottomless pit.

It only felt vague and soft when I stepped into it immediately after driving the Caterham. Normally, it feels like a go-kart.

It's wonderful problem to have choosing between a boosted GT86 or Caterham. A harder decision for me to make due to how much I love the Toyota. Out of all the cars I have ever owned, it is hands down my favourite.

LordGrover

33,545 posts

212 months

Friday 14th October 2016
quotequote all
Heh! Try driving an Aygo loaner for a week or so, then get back in the GT86. biggrin

CABC

5,582 posts

101 months

Friday 14th October 2016
quotequote all
An 86 is more of a light daily driver/ practical car that delivers fun and great driving dynamics.
For a w/end or fun only car I'd move on to Lotus, Caterham.
Mod costs are nearly always sunk cash. Even worse, reduce the market appeal.

OwenK

3,472 posts

195 months

Friday 14th October 2016
quotequote all
I agree, I used to be a big modifier, I loved creating something new and that feeling of really making something, but I've gotten fed up of the sunk costs. I was never under any illusion that it would be any different, but when you start adding up the money you've spent... noticing that you've built something pretty temperamental and compromised, for a sum that you could have spent on something you genuinely lust after & would have similar performance, better reliability plus probably even more appeal in other areas, PLUS retained its value for when you want to trade up... it does make you think.

ECG1000

Original Poster:

381 posts

142 months

Friday 14th October 2016
quotequote all
LordGrover said:
Heh! Try driving an Aygo loaner for a week or so, then get back in the GT86. biggrin
Had the luxury of an Aygo when it went if for paint actually. Airbox lid magically loosened itself off a soon as I left the garage. Was quite fun after that biggrin

CABC said:
An 86 is more of a light daily driver/ practical car that delivers fun and great driving dynamics.
For a w/end or fun only car I'd move on to Lotus, Caterham.
Mod costs are nearly always sunk cash. Even worse, reduce the market appeal.
Yeah, I've looked into Lotuses (Loti??) before but ruled them out in favour of a Caterham.

I'm hoping if I were to sell the 86 in the condition it's in now, someone might find it more appealing than a standard car due to it being tastefully modified. Could be a whishfull thinking...

OwenK said:
I agree, I used to be a big modifier, I loved creating something new and that feeling of really making something, but I've gotten fed up of the sunk costs. I was never under any illusion that it would be any different, but when you start adding up the money you've spent... noticing that you've built something pretty temperamental and compromised, for a sum that you could have spent on something you genuinely lust after & would have similar performance, better reliability plus probably even more appeal in other areas, PLUS retained its value for when you want to trade up... it does make you think.
A very good point. Does make me think a fair bit. *goes off to stare vacantly into space, stroking (imaginary) beard.

ECG1000

Original Poster:

381 posts

142 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
Well..... I made my mind up.



Anyone good with spanners?

Yazza54

18,518 posts

181 months

Friday 11th November 2016
quotequote all
ECG1000 said:
** Warning, huge waffle ahead **

Haven't updated this thread in a while, so here's an extremely lengthy one about my thoughts and feelings. Could almost be an extract from a teenagers diary.

Just been enjoying the GT86 for what it is. Finding myself using it less for the commute and more on a night for a good tear up when the roads are quieter.


As I mentioned before I went on the Colin Hoad CAT drift training day at Millbrook back in August. I booked the afternoon for one to one tuition. Was a combination of getting to grips (pun not intended) with certain exercises in the Caterham, then jumping into my car and repeating the exercise hoping muscle memory would transfer from one car to the other. I've been lucky to drive a couple of Caterhams at Palmer Sport so had an idea on what to expect.

Was all going well doing little figure of eights round cones etc - then a hop into my car, getting cocky I wanted to try a complete 'circle' type drift. Cones were laid out to mimic a medium sized roundabout, and away I went. I hadn't tried this in the Caterham yet so was trying to run before I could walk. First impressions when getting back into the 86 was how vague and soft it felt! The pointy, feelsome car I once knew and loved had transformed into a boat.... Made me really appreciate how much a Caterham dials you into the road.
The first attempt was dull, juddery understeer, the second attempt resulted in a little skid which I hastily gathered up, the third a whole load of arm twirling and me facing the wrong way. I couldn't find the sweet spot.... After a few more attempts, the best I could do was get halfway round the 'roundabout' and unintentionally straighten up or perform a clumsy pirouette. Apparently, only a small handful of people crack this on their first CAT day. However, I'd imagine that was a kind word to compensate for my ineptness or an effort to cheer me up, or both.
Really quite cross with myself and my car, I trudged back to my trusty old friend the Caterham. First attempt was a little wiggle, then second attempt, I cracked it. Full continuous circles! I found it far more intuitive when I could feel exactly what was going on at terra firma.
Now with a newly acquired spring in my step it was back to the 86. Second try, and again I was round with a massive grin on my face! Like riding a bike.......sort of. It was such a satisfying feeling completing (vaguely) graceful complete circles.
After a brief tiff, I was back in love with the 86.

All in all a very good day out that I'd fully recommend.


Re-visiting the Caterham problem: (already made a thread on here earlier in the year)
I spent the next few weeks pondering the drift day and how good the Caterham felt. This led to reading all the latest reviews and got me thinking about the excitement of owning a 310R. Dreaming of dawn raids on my favourite country roads and making an effort to do more track-days, I picked up the phone to Caterham.
Depending how you see it, a 310 looks fairly reasonable value at 22k. But look again and you’ve to add the R pack to get the LSD, seats, suspension etc. Then there's the 6 speed gearbox, lowered floor and 13" wheels - the list goes on. Oh, and another £1200 for a windscreen!! Why are these necessities not standard fit?!
This all amounts to around 30k! 30k for a 1.6 litre kit car - sounds extortionate if you look at it like that. I hope someone will agree with me here - the price tag makes more sense when you actually experience a Caterham for yourself. There aren't many alternative 4 wheeled options that offer the same excitement for the same money. Almost forgot to mention the extra £3000 required for Caterham to build the car for you. I would attempt to build the car myself (with lots of help from my boss) so at least I could save a bit there and achieve a greater sense of satisfaction.

The thing that throws me is sinking that much into something that will essentially be a very impractical toy. It’s more of an A to A car, rather than A to B, unless B has some form of shelter to park in. However, I’ve always wanted to own a Caterham and hopefully will do someday, if not in the near future.
I’m test driving a 270R down at Donnington on the 29th to get an idea of how a 310 will steer, so we’ll go from there.


So if I don’t chop the 86 in for a Caterham, the idea is to make it a bit more mental – more of an event to pedal.

To turbo or to supercharge... Far cheaper than buying a 310!

Turbo is slightly cheaper and gives a lot more scope for extra power due to being easy to upgrade in the future. Will also be cool experience the whooshes and bang associated with turbo-charging. But then there’s the risk of turning the car into something too ‘boosty’ making it difficult to drive in a linier fashion. And... as I’ll be going with an Avo setup, it’ll have to be an unequal length manifold – I don’t like a boxer burble unless it’s coming from an Impreza. There are other options out there to get round this but Fensport (who I trust implicitly) recommend (and know intimately) Avo, so that’s what I’ll go with.

Supercharger will be in the form of a Cosworth setup. More responsive, linear low end and I’ll be able to keep my equal length manifold for the maniac howl I’ve become accustomed to. Cosworth have put a lot of time into the development process so you know you’re getting a very good quality product that’s going to be kind to your engine.
But.... this option is slightly more expensive and you’re limited to 280 to 300bhp. Any higher than that and you’re into bigger bucks in the shape of forged internals etc.
At the moment I’m leaning slightly towards turbo due to the power advantages later down the line. This view changes from day to day though.


If I were to get rid of the 86 for a Caterham, it wouldn’t be because I don’t like the car anymore, it would simply be because it’s time for a change – having owned the car for two and a bit years, and the fact I’ve always wanted a Seven. Whilst I’m in the right situation to be able to own a Caterham, I might as well take the leap?
At the moment I’m more leaning to sticking with what I’ve got but we’ll see what the 29th brings.


Comments and criticisms (of which I’ll suspect there to be a few) welcome!


If you’ve got this far, well done – hope I haven’t bored you to tears! Just helps me getting my thoughts onto paper.


Here’s a picture of my dog to cheer you up:

Are you dead set on a Caterham? There are lots of seven esque cars with equal performance out there that can be had for a fraction of the money you're talking...!