Cayman S engine failure and how Porsche will deal with you.

Cayman S engine failure and how Porsche will deal with you.

Author
Discussion

IknowJoseph

542 posts

141 months

Wednesday 26th November 2014
quotequote all
hartech said:
The addition of a third radiator seems a logical additional benefit but is only so at very high ambient conditions and hard driving whereas on cooler days and more steady driving it can make the inside of the engine run even hotter (previously discussed, explained and proven under test)

Recently we managed to develop a method of replicating the bank 1 temperatures inside bank 2 while managing the addition of a third radiator effectively in all conditions, but a heavy existing workload and the design, manufacture and installation of new tooling has delayed availability.

These are designed to enable engines not yet scored to last much longer and will be fully explained and hopefully available in the early New Year.
Looking forward to news on this.

Ken Figenus

5,714 posts

118 months

Friday 28th November 2014
quotequote all
RudeDog said:
That's the thing, nothing major happened, these cars just cost a fortune to run. Simple stuff like an electric window regulator ends up costing ~£500 when it should cost about £80.

You should be able to see the full breakdown of costs if you click on the "Blog" tab under the car in My Garage.
I had a look and a tear for you! About a grand a month? Shocking - did you track it a lot? I know the internet only mentions the problem percentage cars but really though these Porsches were more reliable and better built? My V8S TVR gave me no grief in 5 years daily commute (other than 3 snapped throttle cables) and they get pilloried for reliability! Other than £600 annual services I spent £100 for 2 Ford Granada disks for it once :-). Luck of the draw mate. eek

RudeDog

1,652 posts

175 months

Friday 28th November 2014
quotequote all
Ken Figenus said:
RudeDog said:
That's the thing, nothing major happened, these cars just cost a fortune to run. Simple stuff like an electric window regulator ends up costing ~£500 when it should cost about £80.

You should be able to see the full breakdown of costs if you click on the "Blog" tab under the car in My Garage.
I had a look and a tear for you! About a grand a month? Shocking - did you track it a lot? I know the internet only mentions the problem percentage cars but really though these Porsches were more reliable and better built? My V8S TVR gave me no grief in 5 years daily commute (other than 3 snapped throttle cables) and they get pilloried for reliability! Other than £600 annual services I spent £100 for 2 Ford Granada disks for it once :-). Luck of the draw mate. eek
Ha, thanks smile

I never tracked it but I did do around 50,000 miles in it during the three years I owned it (most of it motorway). I might have been a bit unlucky with the one I had but I cared for it as well as I possibly could (even performing mid service oil and filter changes just for good measure). I expensed a lot of my mileage so the grand a month was not all out of my pocket. The real killer was the cost of minor repairs, everyday stuff that you expect to have to fix during three years of ownership and 50k of miles covered. Porsche just charge a lot for their parts and labour (even if you use a specialist instead of an OPC, you still get ripped off for the official parts, some of which you cannot avoid using).

Yet still, I loved the car and yearn for another one... but not without an OPC warranty rolleyes

blueg33

35,980 posts

225 months

Friday 28th November 2014
quotequote all
RudeDog said:
Ken Figenus said:
RudeDog said:
That's the thing, nothing major happened, these cars just cost a fortune to run. Simple stuff like an electric window regulator ends up costing ~£500 when it should cost about £80.

You should be able to see the full breakdown of costs if you click on the "Blog" tab under the car in My Garage.
I had a look and a tear for you! About a grand a month? Shocking - did you track it a lot? I know the internet only mentions the problem percentage cars but really though these Porsches were more reliable and better built? My V8S TVR gave me no grief in 5 years daily commute (other than 3 snapped throttle cables) and they get pilloried for reliability! Other than £600 annual services I spent £100 for 2 Ford Granada disks for it once :-). Luck of the draw mate. eek
Ha, thanks smile

I never tracked it but I did do around 50,000 miles in it during the three years I owned it (most of it motorway). I might have been a bit unlucky with the one I had but I cared for it as well as I possibly could (even performing mid service oil and filter changes just for good measure). I expensed a lot of my mileage so the grand a month was not all out of my pocket. The real killer was the cost of minor repairs, everyday stuff that you expect to have to fix during three years of ownership and 50k of miles covered. Porsche just charge a lot for their parts and labour (even if you use a specialist instead of an OPC, you still get ripped off for the official parts, some of which you cannot avoid using).

Yet still, I loved the car and yearn for another one... but not without an OPC warranty rolleyes
Wow! I am doing 20k miles pa in my Evora and it hasn't so far cost anything like that per month. I thought the Porsche would have similar running costs. 2 x services = £600-700. No repair costs (a couple of things have been done by Lotus even though the car is out of warranty).

It was a toss up for me between the two cars......

Edited by blueg33 on Friday 28th November 16:15

monthefish

20,443 posts

232 months

Monday 12th January 2015
quotequote all
hartech said:
I'll try and find out for you but if the different IMS bearing and shaft design changes are anything to by there could be quite a long period during which either could have been fitted!

Baz
Thanks Baz.

jmcc42uk

110 posts

181 months

Monday 7th September 2015
quotequote all
So would anyone care to guess at the percentage of failure rates in relation to the number of cars produced?


northernmedia

1,988 posts

139 months

Monday 7th September 2015
quotequote all
Too high to chance IMHO

mollytherocker

14,366 posts

210 months

Monday 7th September 2015
quotequote all
jmcc42uk said:
So would anyone care to guess at the percentage of failure rates in relation to the number of cars produced?
What? So far? I bet its 10%-20% and climbing.

northernmedia

1,988 posts

139 months

Tuesday 8th September 2015
quotequote all
Even in my relatively small network of car mates I know of 5 cars that scored (2 caymans, 3 997 S)

northernmedia

1,988 posts

139 months

Tuesday 8th September 2015
quotequote all
They'll be along shortly no doubt wink