RE: Government blamed for increase in road deaths

RE: Government blamed for increase in road deaths

Author
Discussion

KMB

254 posts

223 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
Clear case of poor data, one value does not make a trend. Especially when it does not account against a percentage of miles driven/cars on the road/fuel used/people in the country etc etc (pick suitable divisors).


bigdog3

1,823 posts

180 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
boxsey said:
Give them a bit more time and they'll manage to link the small increase in road deaths to climate change.....and then have even more reason to increase fuel duty. idea
Hey this justification is easy.

Cars emit CO2 which upsets the climate and causes all this summertime rain. This rain makes the roads wet, reducing adhesion leading to more accidents and increasing road deaths.

So the bad weather is the government's fault and doubling fuel duty will make roads safer ...whistle




ArnieVXR

2,449 posts

183 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
The sad fact is that speed kills...

If we travelled at a steady zero mph (or even kph), the only deaths that would occur would be due to boredom.

Was wondering if the increase was due to us all being wealthy enough to outsource the driving to people from countries with lower driving standards?

moanthebairns

17,936 posts

198 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
ROAD DEATHS IN 2010-11
Car occupants: 883 (up 6%)
Pedestrians: 453 (up 12%)
Motorcyclists: 362 (down 10%)
Cyclists: 107 (down 4%)

Glad I took the motorbike to work today biggrin


Boydie88

3,283 posts

149 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
"The largest increase is among pedestrians, where the number of deaths rose by 12% to 453" BBC

So, pedestrian deaths have increased by from 404 to 453 - so 49 of the 51 extra deaths.

Reducing the 60 zones to 40 will do next to nothing to this stat.

I'd be interested to know how many of the pedestrian deaths involved modern, quiet cars.

Big loud V8 engines for all and pedestrians will think twice about playing chicken.

hairykrishna

13,166 posts

203 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
This is astonishingly st. The people who wrote this report obviously have little to no grasp of statistics and we pay them to analyse this stuff? News stories don't normally make me this angry!

Mr Whippy

29,029 posts

241 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
Ubernoober said:
Trouble is, this "upsurge" in road deaths will simply add fire to the calls to lower the speed limits on so called 'dangerous' country roads.

Already there is a move to reduce speed limits to 40mph - this will just add to it.

Yes, better education, better standards, less stupidity, more consideration would reduce accidents but what chance is there of any of that?
It'll never happen.

Either adding in the 40 signs everywhere and associated requirements that would bring on other regulated items would be massively costly.
More so would adding back in 60 signs if 'national limit' were made 40mph... there are too many roads where 40mph would be crazy and cause more issues than fix.

Putting more plod on the road and bking bad driving full stop would fix things better than anything else. There are far too many people who just can't drive very well using the roads these days.
That aside, the poor roads in many places doesn't help matters. I wonder how many cyclists get bumped when they go around a pot hole and end up having a driver hitting them for instance.

Hmmmm

Dave

dingocooke

670 posts

220 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
moanthebairns said:
ROAD DEATHS IN 2010-11
Car occupants: 883 (up 6%)
Pedestrians: 453 (up 12%)
Motorcyclists: 362 (down 10%)
Cyclists: 107 (down 4%)
"We are very concerned that 2011 saw the first increase in road fatalities since 2003, with 1901 people killed on the roads," said Louise Ellman, chair of the Transport Committee. "It is shocking that road accidents are the main cause of death amongst young adults aged 16-24 and that so many cyclists continue to be killed or injured."

The chair is clearly not even reading her own stats; cycling deaths down, mortocycle deaths down; pedestrain deaths up...
....hey why not just ban mobile phones (completely) probaly halve the pedstrian deaths, and cut all accidents as well!!! only kidding..but boy is it temping!!!

iain1970

239 posts

162 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
ArnieVXR said:
If we travelled at a steady zero mph (or even kph), the only deaths that would occur would be due to boredom.
Technically, that's staying put. Another report out today warns that doing that can kill you too, it's almost as bad as smoking and we're World leaders in it!

moanthebairns

17,936 posts

198 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
Boydie88 said:
"The largest increase is among pedestrians, where the number of deaths rose by 12% to 453" BBC

So, pedestrian deaths have increased by from 404 to 453 - so 49 of the 51 extra deaths.

Reducing the 60 zones to 40 will do next to nothing to this stat.

I'd be interested to know how many of the pedestrian deaths involved modern, quiet cars.

Big loud V8 engines for all and pedestrians will think twice about playing chicken.
pish its because they done away with flip up head lights that has caused this rise.

least if you hit a pedestrian with flip up lights you could have activated them at the point of impact. flipping the person like a tidily wink over your roof into safety.

Sicob

478 posts

228 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
So if I have a car crash I should stop to ask for the Government's details?

adz13091982

185 posts

168 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
Smells like anti-cuts propaganda to me...

cvega

404 posts

159 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
more driver education!!! tougher exams. Stop giving licenses to virtually everyone and their dog, and oh, small thing - PUT PEOPLE DRIVING WITHOUT INSURANCE TO fkING JAIL

/rant over.

goron59

397 posts

171 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
suffolk009 said:
I read somewhere recently that Britain has the safest roads in Europe as a percentage of miles driven.
That's because in the rest of Europe they drive kilometers rolleyes

originalgeezer

34 posts

210 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
Louise Ellman, welcome to your five minutes of fame of the back of 51 poor souls losing their lives........

leon9191

752 posts

193 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
dingocooke said:
"We are very concerned that 2011 saw the first increase in road fatalities since 2003, with 1901 people killed on the roads," said Louise Ellman, chair of the Transport Committee. "It is shocking that road accidents are the main cause of death amongst young adults aged 16-24 and that so many cyclists continue to be killed or injured."

The chair is clearly not even reading her own stats; cycling deaths down, mortocycle deaths down; pedestrain deaths up...
....hey why not just ban mobile phones (completely) probaly halve the pedstrian deaths, and cut all accidents as well!!! only kidding..but boy is it temping!!!
Well its idiots wearing ear phones then isnt it, not a day goes by that someone wearing ear phones ( normally aged between 18-24) steps out infront of me, are these people totally thick or what or can they just not think for themselves! For gods sake these prats get paid for talking this rubbish when anyone with half a brain can see straight through there stats to the heart of the problem young people are stupid and step out infront of cars while listening to music - FACT!

efini92

1 posts

143 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
It's hardly surprising the number of cyclists killed is high, the amount I see on a daily basis running red lights, dropping off kerbs into traffic, riding the wrong way on the road is ridiculous. These people need educating before its too late. Just thought I'd mention I do also see some adhering to the rules of the road

Podie

46,630 posts

275 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
leemanning said:
Typical 'let's blame the government' scenario. Sick of it.

People need to take some effing responsibility
This.

sidaorb

5,589 posts

206 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
So the biggest increase is in pedestrian deaths, maybe they cant hear the hybrid / electric cars approaching.

BAN THE PRIUS

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

255 months

Wednesday 18th July 2012
quotequote all
Ah, the Commons Transport Select Committee.

A less competent gang of monkeys is hard to imagine.

If you want evidence of this, read the minutes of meetings and evidence gathering for their review of criteria for setting speed limits, under Gwyneth Dunwoody. The review that gave us lower speed limits all over the place, including the dangerous Dunwoody Fifties. All minutes are on the Committee's website.

Health warning - perusing said minutes might harm your blood pressure.