short induction no map

short induction no map

Author
Discussion

rossmcdee

Original Poster:

25 posts

201 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
Hi chaps. I recently had my 4.5 in for sercice and a few small jobs where it was noticed that 2 of the standard induction pipes were wrecked. I have already replaced 2 and have found you can no longer purchase them individualy. Any how long story short Ive bitten the bullit and bought one of those act induction kits. (£488) same price as i was quoted for original induction pipes!! I hadnt realy budgetd for this so am gonna fit it without the chip or re map for now. Anyone out there ran one of these kits without proper map?? the car also has no cats. Any feedback would be appreciated.

Ta lads.

boss1uk

260 posts

174 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
I cant help you with that but will be watching the replies as thats exactly what i need to do... my car is running rich any way and will be mapped before summer

gruffalo

7,521 posts

226 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
My 4.5 has the short induction kit and no chip or remap. Runs a little lumpy on light throttle but love it when you give it maxi beans. Also pinks if suddenly increase throttle at low revs, apart from those it is great, seems to run the correct mixture and is very responsive to the slightest input from the right foot.

I will be looking into a remap as well some time, can any one let me know what I could expect to see an improvement in by spending the extra?


bobbins

1,409 posts

207 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
Doh! Joo remapped mine in March and gave me the original pipes to bring home. I had a nose at them and chucked them out, thinking I wouldn't need them again. A couple looked a bit tired and flat but the rest were okay - you could have had them. Kicking myself now cos I hoard so much crap that is unlikely to be needed. Sorry!


Steve_T

6,356 posts

272 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
You can have the fueling checked on a dyno without the need to remap. This way at least you can confirm that while the fueling might not be right it's not going to do any harm to the engine.

Gazzab

21,092 posts

282 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
Get a remap if you have short induction. Or buy some ACT long intake pipes or some good condition ones from ebay?

JensenA

5,671 posts

230 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
There is no point at all in fitting short induction pipes without a remap. Will it damage the engine? Possibly, I dont know. But I definitely wouldn't risk it on my own car. Your messing about with a race engine not a 1.2 Nova! Get it booked in for a re-map asap, it makes a big difference.

rossmcdee

Original Poster:

25 posts

201 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
Gazzab said:
Get a remap if you have short induction. Or buy some ACT long intake pipes or some good condition ones from ebay?
HAVE purchased short induction kit.

Nickccc

1,682 posts

248 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
If you can hear it detting your mad to continue using it untill it's remapped.
That's one way to knacker an engine.

esso

1,849 posts

217 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
I fitted short induction & chip from Joo to my 4.5 without re-map.It picks up without the`hesitation`i used to get,running it on 99 octane it runs great with no pinking.

rossmcdee

Original Poster:

25 posts

201 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
Nickccc said:
If you can hear it detting your mad to continue using it untill it's remapped.
That's one way to knacker an engine.
If it were running I may hear detonation but as mentioned in the original post I have purchased the kit and am yet to install it.
Thank you for the concern though and i am aware of pinking engines and the damage to pistons it can cause.

Nickccc

1,682 posts

248 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
Sorry, it was a reply that had been posted not by you.
Yep remap with short induction.
Maybe if you can contact Joo he can burn you a generic chip untill
you get it mapped.

rossmcdee

Original Poster:

25 posts

201 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
I am not overly familiar with the management used on the ajp8 4.5 but would imagine it would have scope on its standard map to cope with an increase of airflow that a revised induction set up may produce. How otherwise does it work with greatly varying ambient intake temeratures ie freezing (read as) dense air and the oposite being red hot with a relatively low oxygen content. though aware it may not yeild the same results as a custom map.

ridds

8,218 posts

244 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all

rossmcdee

Original Poster:

25 posts

201 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
ridds said:
<div>
</div>
You were saying ??

Boosted Cerb

556 posts

231 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
rossmcdee said:
I am not overly familiar with the management used on the ajp8 4.5 but would imagine it would have scope on its standard map to cope with an increase of airflow that a revised induction set up may produce.
Unfortunately it can't, its an "Alpha N" management system, a race car system as JensenA said. Basically it only looks at rev's and throttle position to calculate how much fuel to injected, there's some compensation in the form of intake temp and obviously lambda feedback but it doesn't measure air flow directly.

Therefore when you fit the short induction, the engine is able to scavenge more air (increased volumetric efficiency) and therfore requires extra fueling, but because of no remap, the engine thinks its still standard and will fuel as for standard.

Also, better volumetric efficiency could mean less timing advance would be required. But if you're running the standard map, you'll be on the original timing advance and hence the pinking frown

Obviously this is over simplified, I expect the standard map runs rich at WOT and better fuel might help the pinking, also its only going to cause problems when you're driving it hard and at high rev's.

Anyone know if Raceprove can offer a short induction kit and remap at low low Joolz prices, I've got a 4.5 here crying out for one smile

Rich.


Gazzab

21,092 posts

282 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
Ring raceproved and ask...?!

rossmcdee

Original Poster:

25 posts

201 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
Boosted Cerb said:
rossmcdee said:
I am not overly familiar with the management used on the ajp8 4.5 but would imagine it would have scope on its standard map to cope with an increase of airflow that a revised induction set up may produce.
Unfortunately it can't, its an "Alpha N" management system, a race car system as JensenA said. Basically it only looks at rev's and throttle position to calculate how much fuel to injected, there's some compensation in the form of intake temp and obviously lambda feedback but it doesn't measure air flow directly.

Therefore when you fit the short induction, the engine is able to scavenge more air (increased volumetric efficiency) and therfore requires extra fueling, but because of no remap, the engine thinks its still standard and will fuel as for standard.

Also, better volumetric efficiency could mean less timing advance would be required. But if you're running the standard map, you'll be on the original timing advance and hence the pinking frown

Obviously this is over simplified, I expect the standard map runs rich at WOT and better fuel might help the pinking, also its only going to cause problems when you're driving it hard and at high rev's.

Anyone know if Raceprove can offer a short induction kit and remap at low low Joolz prices, I've got a 4.5 here crying out for one smile

Rich.

Thanks for that. I had better start saving again!! Where is best for a map session I live in the Norh East. P.s how much does a map ses cost usualy?

Steve_T

6,356 posts

272 months

Wednesday 17th February 2010
quotequote all
Boosted Cerb said:
rossmcdee said:
I am not overly familiar with the management used on the ajp8 4.5 but would imagine it would have scope on its standard map to cope with an increase of airflow that a revised induction set up may produce.
Unfortunately it can't, its an "Alpha N" management system, a race car system as JensenA said. Basically it only looks at rev's and throttle position to calculate how much fuel to injected, there's some compensation in the form of intake temp and obviously lambda feedback but it doesn't measure air flow directly.

Therefore when you fit the short induction, the engine is able to scavenge more air (increased volumetric efficiency) and therfore requires extra fueling, but because of no remap, the engine thinks its still standard and will fuel as for standard.

Also, better volumetric efficiency could mean less timing advance would be required. But if you're running the standard map, you'll be on the original timing advance and hence the pinking frown

Obviously this is over simplified, I expect the standard map runs rich at WOT and better fuel might help the pinking, also its only going to cause problems when you're driving it hard and at high rev's.

Anyone know if Raceprove can offer a short induction kit and remap at low low Joolz prices, I've got a 4.5 here crying out for one smile

Rich.

The issue is that shortening the induction length changes the points in the rpm range where the engine is assisted in breathing. Peak VE may not change, but the variation over rpm will and what you're concerned about is this introducing lean running, detonation etc. This is why you should at least find out if your map is safe to run your engine, even if it is not optimal. As Nick points out the damage from running an engine that's detonating can be far more expensive than a remap.

Cyclone1

2,600 posts

246 months

Wednesday 17th February 2010
quotequote all
Some really good advice on here, so best bet would be to get a fueling check done on a rolling road after installation. If the fueling then requires adjusting you will need to book the car in for a remap.

The other option you have is to see if any of the owners on this forum have any spare original pipes, if they do then you can run these in the short term.

For the guy earlier in the thread who is running short induction with no map and can detect detonation / pinking etc then you are setting yourself up for engine failure. For the sake of a remap you'll save yourself a fortune!! It's a no brainer.

As no Cerb is the same then it is quite possible that some engines could run fine without the need for a remap when short induction is fitted, however the number that are ok is likely to be very small. For most when you fit the short induction without adjusting the fueling you can get a placebo effect that the performance is improved and all is ok, but this is usually not the case, what you tend to find is that below 5k rpm in most points of the range you'll be slightly down on power and torque, however the placebo effect kicks in because the short induction has smoothed out the "normally" humpy curves from 2k-5k rpm so the delivery "feels" much stronger. This is another reason why it is adviseable to either get a fueling chip or have a remap to fully realise the potential provided by the Whirlwind and ACT Short Induction kits.

This graph shows what I am saying albeit overlayed with an early Emerald map, oh the good old development days seem so far away now frown .



Jules.

Edited by Cyclone1 on Wednesday 17th February 10:41