Yes it would be the Challenger for me too if not for its unavailability in RHD. Really liked this one with a vinyl roof I saw in the US a few years ago. I thought the Mustang looked promising in the flesh.
of all the modern retakes, its the closest for me to the original cues. The interior, whilst shocking feel wise, is at least somethin you can look at for more than 2 minutes unlike the camaro (I would consider one of them but the challenger just looks spot on).