New Mustang how will it compare?

New Mustang how will it compare?

Author
Discussion

ArnieVXR

2,449 posts

183 months

Thursday 7th January 2016
quotequote all
A three page Mustang thread? Time for the HSV/Monaro forum to be renamed...

MedwayMonaro

1,895 posts

138 months

Thursday 7th January 2016
quotequote all
ArnieVXR said:
A three page Mustang thread? Time for the HSV/Monaro forum to be renamed...
Watch out BBQ... laugh

R8VXF

6,788 posts

115 months

Thursday 7th January 2016
quotequote all
ArnieVXR said:
A three page Mustang thread? Time for the HSV/Monaro forum to be renamed...
Only 2nd page for me wink

granada203028

Original Poster:

1,483 posts

197 months

Thursday 7th January 2016
quotequote all
The chart illustrates the peak performance the driver will feel in each gear. So though higher than with the Monaro it will be occurring at a lower speed.

Low to mid range acceleration is what matters in our 70 mph limited world so the shorter geared Mustang gives more scope to play.

With Premium coupes and saloons pushing 550 BHP, I doubt traction is an issue with a mere 400 in good conditions. Certainly my Monaro experience is it would benefit from a shorter 1st and easily cope with it. When I changed the box 1st dropped 49 to 44 mph @ 6000 rpm and I would say 40 mph would not be too short.

The Mustang is good value and can only get better as prices will presumably drop once the initial demand is satisfied. Remember the 04 CV8 dropped 28650 to 26650 when the 05 came out, and this dropped 30K to 24K when Vauxhall got left with a paddock full of them. VXRs dropped 37 to 31K. Early adopters like me payed a premium but I don't regret it.

The Australian dollar has dropped massively against the US and £ over the last year, so VXR8s and Maloos should be 35K now to.

Come on Autocar lets see a proper instrumented road test.





mfp4073

1,946 posts

174 months

Friday 8th January 2016
quotequote all
[quote=granada203028]The chart illustrates the peak performance the driver will feel in each gear. So though higher than with the Monaro it will be occurring at a lower speed.

Low to mid range acceleration is what matters in our 70 mph limited world so the shorter geared Mustang gives more scope to play.

With Premium coupes and saloons pushing 550 BHP, I doubt traction is an issue with a mere 400 in good conditions. Certainly my Monaro experience is it would benefit from a shorter 1st and easily cope with it. When I changed the box 1st dropped 49 to 44 mph @ 6000 rpm and I would say 40 mph would not be too short.

The Mustang is good value and can only get better as prices will presumably drop once the initial demand is satisfied. Remember the 04 CV8 dropped 28650 to 26650 when the 05 came out, and this dropped 30K to 24K when Vauxhall got left with a paddock full of them. VXRs dropped 37 to 31K. Early adopters like me payed a premium but I don't regret it.

The Australian dollar has dropped massively against the US and £ over the last year, so VXR8s and Maloos should be 35K now to.

Come on Autocar lets see a proper instrumented road test

If Vauxhall sold the VXR8 and the Maloo for £35k, I could be tempted!... well if they restyle the front and rear ends for 2017 that is.


granada203028

Original Poster:

1,483 posts

197 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
Not had a test drive yet, cars remain in high demand it seams.

Autocar have published a full instrumented road test in the paper magazine, dated 24th February. Outright acceleration just pips the 6.0VXR though in gear it is quite a bit more punchy due to the shorter gearing. It is more accelerative in 3rd than the original CV8 Monaro was in 2nd.

Autocar relatively more impressed with the Monaro 6.0VXR 10 years ago than they are with the Mustang today, reading both tests. A sign I guess of higher standards of today given cars like the Focus ST and the BMW M cars.

snowwolf

11,503 posts

175 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
Should the new mustang be compared with the Monaro ? Big difference in age

ARAF

20,759 posts

223 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
snowwolf said:
Should the new mustang be compared with the Monaro ? Big difference in age
No, but it will, as no other RHD muscle car has been available to the masses in the intervening years.

I think it's flattering, that the Monaro is still used as the benchmark. smile

DRC72

651 posts

186 months

Friday 26th February 2016
quotequote all
There is a guy local to us at work that came in with his Monaro, according to the salesman.

Anyway he came in to look at the 370z that we have and told the salesman he fancies a mustang but does not like the 10 month waiting list.

I did not see this guy, but the salesman showed him my car and said do you fancy one of these, to which he replied I would love one of them.



raving

1,183 posts

190 months

Friday 26th February 2016
quotequote all
ARAF said:
No, but it will, as no other RHD muscle car has been available to the masses in the intervening years.

I think it's flattering, that the Monaro is still used as the benchmark. smile
I think its only compared due to the V8

Monaro feels much more cumbersome on the road compared to the Mustang even though weight wise I think the difference is only 11kgs

I think it feels better balanced than the Monaro but then again the Monaro is using 1997 ( Vt ) suspension

granada203028

Original Poster:

1,483 posts

197 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
Finally got a test drive last week. Reasonably impressed, the engine character is very different to the Monaro. Where as my 05 CV8 is best between 2000 - 5000 rpm, the Mustang is much more peaky ever pulling harder the higher the revs. On WOT you feels subtle steps ups in power as all the trickery gets to work and really pulls above 4000 rpm. The shorter gearing compensates for less response lower down so I would imagine the Mustang is faster than the Monaro in every situation, as the calculations indicate.

Didn't notice anything different in ride/handling/steering so I guess these must be similar to what I'm used to. Brakes did feel a bit more immediate. Lots of bonnet to look over reminiscent of my 73 and the Granadas.

Lead time is now 12 months and some of the colour options have changed. Also some combinations of interior, exterior and option packs are linked and the combinations I tried on the website all looked forbidden. Salesman said sales would be limited to 4000 or something, maybe just scare mongering.

It's wider than the Monaro with just 6 cm theoretical clearance with my garage door (2.14m) even with the mirrors folded. I will have to mod the Monaro with bits of card board and practice...

When my brother and I turned up for the test drive we were told an online check of our driving history was required requiring our national insurance numbers. So I had to phone a colleague at work to look on my pay slip in a draw and my brother got it off a tax related website. As we are twins we have consecutive numbers.

So I'm pondering the potential purchase.

raving

1,183 posts

190 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
granada203028 said:
Finally got a test drive last week. Reasonably impressed, the engine character is very different to the Monaro. Where as my 05 CV8 is best between 2000 - 5000 rpm, the Mustang is much more peaky ever pulling harder the higher the revs. On WOT you feels subtle steps ups in power as all the trickery gets to work and really pulls above 4000 rpm. The shorter gearing compensates for less response lower down so I would imagine the Mustang is faster than the Monaro in every situation, as the calculations indicate.

Didn't notice anything different in ride/handling/steering so I guess these must be similar to what I'm used to. Brakes did feel a bit more immediate. Lots of bonnet to look over reminiscent of my 73 and the Granadas.

Lead time is now 12 months and some of the colour options have changed. Also some combinations of interior, exterior and option packs are linked and the combinations I tried on the website all looked forbidden. Salesman said sales would be limited to 4000 or something, maybe just scare mongering.

It's wider than the Monaro with just 6 cm theoretical clearance with my garage door (2.14m) even with the mirrors folded. I will have to mod the Monaro with bits of card board and practice...

When my brother and I turned up for the test drive we were told an online check of our driving history was required requiring our national insurance numbers. So I had to phone a colleague at work to look on my pay slip in a draw and my brother got it off a tax related website. As we are twins we have consecutive numbers.

So I'm pondering the potential purchase.
Lot of car for the money , multi valve engines like to be revved & are stronger generally up top
Much better on road than the Monaro by far I thought
Just order one

SturdyHSV

10,095 posts

167 months

Thursday 28th April 2016
quotequote all
Bit of a resurrection, thought this would appeal to some:

Based on this pic, I think it's safe to say the PH Mustang was car number 99:



So it's public knowledge what times they ran:

First run:



Second run:



Third run:



Fourth run:



Those 60' times give some credence to the notion that burnouts on street tyres don't help much. That or it was some deliberate fast and furious showboating spinning the wheels all the way down the track hehe

For reference, it's an American website, so the date format is arse backwards, 04/03 is 'April 3rd' as they say

MyM8V8

9,457 posts

195 months

Thursday 28th April 2016
quotequote all
SturdyHSV said:
Bit of a resurrection, thought this would appeal to some:

Based on this pic, I think it's safe to say the PH Mustang was car number 99:



So it's public knowledge what times they ran:

First run:



Second run:



Third run:



Fourth run:



Those 60' times give some credence to the notion that burnouts on street tyres don't help much. That or it was some deliberate fast and furious showboating spinning the wheels all the way down the track hehe

For reference, it's an American website, so the date format is arse backwards, 04/03 is 'April 3rd' as they say
First On Retard Day!

HappyMidget

6,788 posts

115 months

Thursday 28th April 2016
quotequote all
With times like that I think I need to go f**d hunting biggrin

bigwheel

1,618 posts

214 months

Friday 29th April 2016
quotequote all
HappyMidget said:
With times like that I think I need to go f**d hunting biggrin
My CV8 made better ET and speed than that at Crail. And it still had the tall standard diff!

MyM8V8

9,457 posts

195 months

Wednesday 18th May 2016
quotequote all
How did it compare?

Well I met one on a German Autobahn at the weekend in my VF ute and it couldn't keep up!

Donner und Blitzen!

Edited by MyM8V8 on Wednesday 18th May 18:45

snowwolf

11,503 posts

175 months

Wednesday 18th May 2016
quotequote all
Had the same with a Nissan GTR he was gutted I left him the three times he tried, he was paddling down coming up along side of me, both flooring and said bye bye each time, loved it biggrin was speeds from 60 to about 140 he would have had me every time from a standing start I guess and top end.

raving

1,183 posts

190 months

Thursday 19th May 2016
quotequote all
MyM8V8 said:
How did it compare?

Well I met one on a German Autobahn at the weekend in my VF ute and it couldn't keep up!

Donner und Blitzen!

Edited by MyM8V8 on Wednesday 18th May 18:45
He still had 6k change in his pocket though ;-)

SturdyHSV

10,095 posts

167 months

Thursday 19th May 2016
quotequote all
raving said:
MyM8V8 said:
How did it compare?

Well I met one on a German Autobahn at the weekend in my VF ute and it couldn't keep up!

Donner und Blitzen!

Edited by MyM8V8 on Wednesday 18th May 18:45
He still had 6k change in his pocket though ;-)
Maybe all those coins are what slowed him down so much? hehe