The Truth about Vantage clutches!

The Truth about Vantage clutches!

Poll: The Truth about Vantage clutches!

Total Members Polled: 214

ASM1 no issues: 32
ASM1 clutch died: 8
V8 Manual no issues: 104
V8 Manual clutch died: 34
V12 Manual no issues: 33
V12 Manual clutch died: 3
ASM2 no issues: 9
ASM2 clutch died: 4
Author
Discussion

peterr96

2,226 posts

175 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
Ours is still going after 41k. That said we've had it since new and I don't ride the clutch at junctions etc.

yeti

10,523 posts

275 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
Dunno about this poll... Might perpetuate the stereotype that Vantages have weak clutches and they don't really.

What if it was 'tyres died' instead, wouldn't it seem silly? The clutch is a consumable wear item. it is going to wear out, even if your name is Bogie... It will go at some point!

If it fails prematurely, and I would call sub-20k miles premature (Aston call sub-10k premature) then I'd tick the 'clutch died' box.

My DB9 clutch was replaced at 30k miles, didn't fail but the pedal was high and a Monaco trip beckoned, now done 7k very happily on the monstrous BR organic replacement.

The single plate in the Vantage is not as good as it could be (DB9/DBS has a twin plate so Aston have them, just a cost issue) but the average 30k replacement is the same as any powerful manual car I'd say. Same with brake discs, 30k seems the norm...

mikey k

Original Poster:

13,011 posts

216 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
Don't disagree with that
I was more interested to see what ratio of people on each gear box had "issues"

bogie

16,383 posts

272 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
I think the fly off handbrake puts some people off, especially those new to the car, then they end up holding it on the clutch on inclines

same with reversing up hill slipping the clutch instead of letting it out and driving uphill...but of course reverse gear is quite fast so that can lead to bad habits too

combine with city driving and I can understand how a manual car can go through a clutch in 20K miles...

moveover

345 posts

163 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all

I've not had any problems with my ASM1 clutch. But then I regularly carry out the clutch learn and invariably put it in neutral if stationary for more than a few seconds. The secret with reversing seems to be patience; foot off brake and let the SS gradually get the car moving. As soon as you interfere with either throttle or brake, all hell brakes loose.

Incidentally, I asked an AM technician at a local dealership about how often one should perform the clutch learn, and his response was "oh, about once a year should be fine". Is it any wonder that people have bad experiences with ASM1 when the dealers can't even give proper advice.

Token Jock

866 posts

239 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
2006 V8 Manual 31.5k miles, 16k by myself in nearly 3years.

No issues but then I am particular about not riding the clutch or dropping the clutch agressively when moving away from the lights etc.

sadlerj

854 posts

284 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
My 2006 Manual went after 33k miles. I do drive her hard, and she pretty much is never used for boring commutes, all "Champagne Mileage"...so what I would expect really. I do feel most of the wear is when reversing.

shunt

971 posts

225 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
My 2005 clutch threw it's hand in at 28k, Bridge Mill sorted a new one, changed the gearbox oil and undated the gearchange linkage for £1600!!

NigelStn

264 posts

167 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
shunt said:
My 2005 clutch threw it's hand in at 28k, Bridge Mill sorted a new one, changed the gearbox oil and undated the gearchange linkage for £1600!!
Out of interest what were the symptoms when it failed?

crashley

1,568 posts

180 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
MY2006 4.3 Manual, went at 34.5k. Replaced (detailed on here) and just sold it at 35k.

Mako V12V

3,135 posts

214 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
No option for - V12V - no issues but changed under warranty for updated version!

v8woollie

4,363 posts

145 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
bogie said:
same with reversing up hill slipping the clutch instead of letting it out and driving uphill...but of course reverse gear is quite fast so that can lead to bad habits too

c
Tried that. It wasn't fun going up hill in reverse at 50 mph yikes

shunt

971 posts

225 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
NigelStn said:
Out of interest what were the symptoms when it failed?
Usual stuff really it just started slipping in higher gears. I instantly stopped using it and booked it in for a new one. They showed me the old clutch, it wasn't shot but wasn't far from it. The car had previously lived in London hence why it probably went early.

mikey k

Original Poster:

13,011 posts

216 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
Mako V12V said:
No option for - V12V - no issues but changed under warranty for updated version!
Look again wink (the thread is only about Vantages)

Edited by mikey k on Friday 21st December 17:45

Mako V12V

3,135 posts

214 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
mikey k said:
Look again wink (the thread is only about Vantages)

Edited by mikey k on Friday 21st December 17:45
Look again wink (I DO have a Vantage)!!

mikey k

Original Poster:

13,011 posts

216 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Anyone got any more to add?

mikey k

Original Poster:

13,011 posts

216 months

Sunday 24th March 2013
quotequote all
Bump to see if anyone has any more to add?

Jockman

17,917 posts

160 months

Sunday 24th March 2013
quotequote all
mikey k said:
Bump to see if anyone has any more to add?
Mine's a G&T please mate smile

brakedwell

1,229 posts

199 months

Sunday 24th March 2013
quotequote all
I ticked the box on behalf of my son who has an 06 4.3 with 28k miles on it with no clutch problems.

yeti

10,523 posts

275 months

Sunday 24th March 2013
quotequote all
Jockman said:
mikey k said:
Bump to see if anyone has any more to add?
Mine's a G&T please mate smile
Mikey getting a round in? Ale for Mr Toms and I please smile