Would you sell your v12 vantage manual for a 458 Italia !!?

Would you sell your v12 vantage manual for a 458 Italia !!?

Author
Discussion

cayman-black

12,642 posts

216 months

Monday 25th April 2016
quotequote all
458man said:
Never told him to buy it or to sell his Aston. Just gave him my opinion :-)

Btw this post reminded me to change my username too hehe
Get some pictures up 458man!

458man

2,714 posts

207 months

Monday 25th April 2016
quotequote all
cayman-black said:
458man said:
Never told him to buy it or to sell his Aston. Just gave him my opinion :-)

Btw this post reminded me to change my username too hehe
Get some pictures up 458man!
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&t=1582423

biggrin

458man

2,714 posts

207 months

Monday 25th April 2016
quotequote all
JPF40 said:
Lots of opinion, looks like youll need to dip your toe!

Anyone see Clarksons piece yesterday in the Times?

It does sum up Ferrari ownersip unfortunately.

The only people who really love you when you own a Fezza are your kids, it was one of the reasons for buying a Speciale, and will probably be the only reason to buy another.
No, is there an online link? Would love to have a read smile

FrankieBee

757 posts

122 months

Monday 25th April 2016
quotequote all
458man said:
No, is there an online link? Would love to have a read smile
Here you go: http://www.driving.co.uk/car-reviews/the-clarkson-...

Clarkson at his best, I think he likes it!

458man

2,714 posts

207 months

Monday 25th April 2016
quotequote all
FrankieBee said:
458man said:
No, is there an online link? Would love to have a read smile
Here you go: http://www.driving.co.uk/car-reviews/the-clarkson-...

Clarkson at his best, I think he likes it!
Thanks! Bloody brilliant write up biggrin

cayman-black

12,642 posts

216 months

Monday 25th April 2016
quotequote all
458man said:
Wow its a stunner! Enjoy. Thanks.

Nijius Maximus

586 posts

111 months

Thursday 26th May 2016
quotequote all
So Phil, apologies if you already posted, but what's the update?? Did you test drive the 458 in the end? There was a 458 parked up in my office car park the other day so couldn't resist posing with it. Looks fantastic in the flesh.

So low and wide...


cayman-black

12,642 posts

216 months

Thursday 26th May 2016
quotequote all
Wow that black car looks stunning! biggrin
All jokes apart though some chap on the McLaren forum has just bought a beautiful 540 for £131k new . Looks stunning for the money , i thought they cost more seem better value than a second hand 458 surely.

Edited by cayman-black on Thursday 26th May 08:31

Nijius Maximus

586 posts

111 months

Thursday 26th May 2016
quotequote all
cayman-black said:
Wow that black car looks stunning! biggrin
All jokes apart though some chap on the McLaren forum has just bought a beautiful 540 for £131k new . Looks stunning for the money , i thought they cost more seem better value than a second hand 458 surely.

Edited by cayman-black on Thursday 26th May 08:31
I read that thread as well. Have to admit the 570/540 models do look amazing. They've really perfected the design now.

RHD 458s with decent mileage and from an official dealer seem to start at the £149k level.

650S Coupes from £159k.

570S and Hurracans from £169k.

Eight speed Vanquishes somewhere in the middle... Decisions decisions... wink

cayman-black

12,642 posts

216 months

Thursday 26th May 2016
quotequote all
I know , cars they drive us mad.
They are all nice but i,m going to keep the V12V.

IanV12VR

2,749 posts

155 months

Thursday 26th May 2016
quotequote all
Recently visited McLaren and totally agree their design and attention to detail is just fantastic.

I have two things that would stop me getting one, probably a 570s Spider when it comes out, and that is the noise and the interior. When we were looking at the production facility they were starting the cars up and compared to wht you hear at Gaydon it was underwhelming. I understand that they make a great noise at 10/10ths but you get a fabulous noise, especially in a V12 roadster, at 3/10th and have a better chance of retaining your licence.

I really like the interior of the 570 which has developed very nicely but it will never compare with an Aston - but I do not think they even consider Aston a competitor.

However, I know they are working on the noise, and the 570 is a big improvement on the 12c and 650 and if they get that right then I could live with the interior. You never know........

C997

529 posts

166 months

Thursday 26th May 2016
quotequote all
I test drove a 570S for a few hours about two months ago and really enjoyed it. It looks fantastic and it is very easy to drive quickly.

When I finished I couldn't really work out if I wanted one or not. It struck me about two weeks later that driving it was a non-event compared to driving the V12V and that I had been focussing on the Mclaren name more than anything else. I'd love to have one but I wouldn't change the V12V for it. Now, a 458 or a Huracan might be a different matter, not driven the Huracan, yet.

12pack

1,543 posts

168 months

Thursday 26th May 2016
quotequote all
IanV12VR said:
...starting the cars up and compared to wht you hear at Gaydon it was underwhelming. I understand that they make a great noise at 10/10ths but you get a fabulous noise, especially in a V12 roadster, at 3/10th and have a better chance of retaining your licence.
Indeed. I'm afraid the idle, cruising and light acceleration sounds of the V12 have spoilt any other car for me- not just the Macca's. Even at 10/10ths, the V12 has multiple overtones. If the 458 V8 is a trumpet and the Merc/AMG V8 is a tenor sax - the V12 is a full quartet (sorry - jazz fan here).

cayman-black

12,642 posts

216 months

Thursday 26th May 2016
quotequote all
I was surprised to see when i went to configure the 540 that it said the door panels where standard in black vinyl ,yuk so you have to spend a lot more to get it any where near the full leather of the Aston.

Padley69

187 posts

133 months

Thursday 26th May 2016
quotequote all
Careful Cayman Black, you'll be giving AML ideas on what next to decontent from future models at this rate....

AdamV12V

5,022 posts

177 months

Thursday 26th May 2016
quotequote all
12pack said:
IanV12VR said:
...starting the cars up and compared to wht you hear at Gaydon it was underwhelming. I understand that they make a great noise at 10/10ths but you get a fabulous noise, especially in a V12 roadster, at 3/10th and have a better chance of retaining your licence.
Indeed. I'm afraid the idle, cruising and light acceleration sounds of the V12 have spoilt any other car for me- not just the Macca's. Even at 10/10ths, the V12 has multiple overtones. If the 458 V8 is a trumpet and the Merc/AMG V8 is a tenor sax - the V12 is a full quartet (sorry - jazz fan here).
That's one of the gripes I have with my 918 GT4. At anything under 4,000RPM it just sounds quite, muted and there is more gearbox whine than engine growl. Sure above that it howls all the way to the red line, but 95% of my driving doesn't reach that. The V12 just howls n growls all the way from 1000RPM and puts a smile on your face no matter what.

cayman-black

12,642 posts

216 months

Thursday 26th May 2016
quotequote all
Padley69 said:
Careful Cayman Black, you'll be giving AML ideas on what next to decontent from future models at this rate....
Ha you are right , i hear they are going that way !

CSK1

1,603 posts

124 months

Thursday 26th May 2016
quotequote all
AdamV12V said:
That's one of the gripes I have with my 918 GT4.
You lucky chap, I didn't know they made a GT4 version of the 918! :-)

phil bird

Original Poster:

209 posts

135 months

Wednesday 11th January 2017
quotequote all
CSK1 said:
AdamV12V said:
That's one of the gripes I have with my 918 GT4.
You lucky chap, I didn't know they made a GT4 version of the 918! :-)
Update!! Did I sell the vantage v12 for the italia! Never!! and I plan to keep it forever bow since I posted luckily with work being busy I've added this little beauty to the black fleet and I can't fault the GT4

AdamV12V

5,022 posts

177 months

Wednesday 11th January 2017
quotequote all
phil bird said:
Update!! Did I sell the vantage v12 for the italia! Never!! and I plan to keep it forever bow since I posted luckily with work being busy I've added this little beauty to the black fleet and I can't fault the GT4
Ha, very interesting - it would seem we own 2 of the same cars then, albeit that I have my GT4 up for sale right now. Would love to hear if your thoughts on how the two compare to see if they are in alignment with mine. smile