which one?

Author
Discussion

chriz1

Original Poster:

669 posts

216 months

Sunday 3rd June 2007
quotequote all
Posting on behalf of my brother...

He's after a new car so can i have the pro's and con's of ther following cars it has to be 1 of these he wants....

Subaru impreza sti uk
Mitsubishi lancer evo 8 fq300

Cheers

ScoobieWRX

4,863 posts

227 months

Sunday 3rd June 2007
quotequote all
The EVO is more hardcore however the Scooby is easier to live with on a daily basis. Both are pretty quick and the handling is amazing but i prefer the Scooby. After testdriving both i went for the Scooby smile

MarfGTxx

22,907 posts

242 months

Monday 4th June 2007
quotequote all
The EVO has shorter service intervals than the scoob

Andy Mac

73,668 posts

256 months

Monday 4th June 2007
quotequote all
They are very similar, yet so different. The scooby is designed to be uber-fast, and handle stupendously, but have an everyday usefullness, the EVO on the other hand is like a saloon version of a radical. Designed purely to go fast, handle, and it is much harder to live with everyday. What do you need it for?

rescynic

175 posts

203 months

Monday 4th June 2007
quotequote all
Scoobies are common as much nice handling decent price tag.

Evos are pure sex on wheels, fewer of them on the roads. not sure about the price.

My chocie would be the evo any day of the week.

GravelBen

15,724 posts

231 months

Monday 4th June 2007
quotequote all
As far as performance goes they're close enough that you'd have to be driving like a bit of a nutter to really notice any difference on the road, so for most people it comes down to a subjective decision over which they prefer. (Factors used to be blue/red, McRae/Makinen etc but Mitsi don't really do the WRC thing properly anymore)

As others have said, Evo is a bit more hardcore, pointier handling, the STi a bit softer, easier to live with, handles bumpy roads a bit better.

And the Scoob sounds sooo much better than the sewing machine/Evo wink

chriz1

Original Poster:

669 posts

216 months

Monday 4th June 2007
quotequote all
how do you mean harder to live with?

ScoobieWRX

4,863 posts

227 months

Monday 4th June 2007
quotequote all
chriz1 said:
how do you mean harder to live with?
rock hard suspension that will knock your fillings out and break your back, servicing every 4,500 miles which is a pain in the arse and hard on your pocket, drive it on anything less than a smooth road and it will skip and jump about more than a frog on heat, and i have to say....not as nice looking as a Scooby thumbup

EDLT

15,421 posts

207 months

Monday 4th June 2007
quotequote all
I'd buy a Scooby, the used prices won't fall when they start (attempting) selling the new one wink

chriz1

Original Poster:

669 posts

216 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
so seriously what mpg should you expect driving tidy from both cars?
Or how much ££ to cover 100 miles?

ScoobieWRX

4,863 posts

227 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
chriz1 said:
so seriously what mpg should you expect driving tidy from both cars?
Or how much ££ to cover 100 miles?
24/27mpg on a run
18/22mpg around town
7/9mpg on a track day

This really depends on how nicely you drive, however drive like your arse is on fire all the time and you will soon learn not to hehe

As for the EVO i hear they are a little thirstier all round.

Top Trump

1,588 posts

222 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
Go hardcore, go for an Evo. They're brilliant. Not relaxing or particuarly nice to drive sensibly (yes, hard suspension and noisy) but at maximum attack they make complete sense.

chriz1

Original Poster:

669 posts

216 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
so how much dosh we talking to cover 100 mile at that rate?

ScoobieWRX

4,863 posts

227 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
chriz1 said:
so how much dosh we talking to cover 100 mile at that rate?
Do the sums.....

@ 27mpg....100miles is 3.7Gallons
£1 per litre (super 99RON).....4.5litres to the gallon = £4.50 per gallon.

4.50pg x 3.7 = £16.65

If your bro is overly worried about what it will cost to run then neither EVO or Scooby are the right car for him. You'll get around 250 - 280 miles per tank and it's a 50 litre/11 Gallon Tank.

I hear Smart Cars are economical hehe

chriz1

Original Poster:

669 posts

216 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
boys and their toys!

DocJock

8,363 posts

241 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
Andy Mac said:
...... The scooby is designed to be uber-fast, and handle stupendously.....
Eh ? Are you on drugs ?

Don't get me wrong, I love my scoob but as standard they are 'quick' at best, not "uber-fast" and the standard car handles like an understeery bag-o-shite which happens to have loads of grip and traction.

GravelBen

15,724 posts

231 months

Wednesday 6th June 2007
quotequote all
DocJock said:
Andy Mac said:
...... The scooby is designed to be uber-fast, and handle stupendously.....
Eh ? Are you on drugs ?

Don't get me wrong, I love my scoob but as standard they are 'quick' at best, not "uber-fast" and the standard car handles like an understeery bag-o-shite which happens to have loads of grip and traction.
Its all a matter of perspective I guess - compared to any 'normal' car a turbo scoob is "uber-fast" and great handling, its just that there are also better cars out there.

p.s. not all standard scoobs are understeery wink

ScoobieWRX

4,863 posts

227 months

Wednesday 6th June 2007
quotequote all
Mines not as understeeery as it used to be. Many thanks to Mr.Powerflex and Mr.Whiteline hehe

P.S. Ben....I will be within a stones throw of NZ next week. I look forward to sampling that lovely tropical weather and views, both above and below the waterline wink

Edited by ScoobieWRX on Wednesday 6th June 01:02

jonner

142 posts

207 months

Wednesday 6th June 2007
quotequote all
Evo...

GravelBen

15,724 posts

231 months

Wednesday 6th June 2007
quotequote all
ScoobieWRX said:
P.S. Ben....I will be within a stones throw of NZ next week. I look forward to sampling that lovely tropical weather and views, both above and below the waterline wink
thumbup You do realise its winter here at the moment? hehe Or will you be a bit closer to the equator?


If you end up in the bottom half of NZ at any stage I can show some highly entertaining roads though wink