2007 118d sport ?? performance, fuel and baby's ??

2007 118d sport ?? performance, fuel and baby's ??

Author
Discussion

paul n

Original Poster:

247 posts

169 months

Thursday 10th December 2015
quotequote all
hey guys many thanks for the comments

I decided to stick with the Subaru in the end!

I had a look at a few cars but they did all feel a little dull compared to the Subaru! They really are unique cars, nothing like them out there!

I did the maths but with the Subaru only costing me 2k to buy and very very little in repairs so far the savings in fuel and road tax would take me 2 years get back if I traded up to a bmw for about 4-5k and that was one with a lot of miles on it and assuming no big repair bills!

I think as one poster suggested wait a year or two and then have a look at it! maybe the 135i or the golf R will be within my financial reach by then! smile

Many thanks

Paul

Craikeybaby

10,411 posts

225 months

Friday 11th December 2015
quotequote all
Sounds like the right decision to me!

My first choice for a "sensible family car" was an Impreza Wagon, but my wife's only criteria was that it wasn't a Subaru, so ended up with a 1 Series.

paul n

Original Poster:

247 posts

169 months

Friday 11th December 2015
quotequote all
I am very lucky that my wife really likes the Subaru! ..........not that she ever really goes on boost but nice to know it's there!

had to change the exhaust to a quicker one thou as it was little bit embarrassing for her to turn up to meetings with the really loud one! smile

long live these low petrol prices eh! smile

Cheers Paul

rb5er

11,657 posts

172 months

Saturday 12th December 2015
quotequote all
Good choice. Imprezas are very cheap performance motoring ime.

Mr Tidy

22,344 posts

127 months

Thursday 17th December 2015
quotequote all
rb5er said:
Good choice. Imprezas are very cheap performance motoring ime.
Yes, until they break! eek

bennyboysvuk

3,491 posts

248 months

Thursday 17th December 2015
quotequote all
paul n said:
I decided to stick with the Subaru in the end!

I had a look at a few cars but they did all feel a little dull compared to the Subaru! They really are unique cars, nothing like them out there!
Good call and good luck.

AntiLagGC8

1,724 posts

112 months

Thursday 17th December 2015
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
rb5er said:
Good choice. Imprezas are very cheap performance motoring ime.
Yes, until they break! eek
Well Subaru's seem to fair far better than BMW's in the JD Power surveys so maybe it is the smart choice?

rb5er

11,657 posts

172 months

Thursday 17th December 2015
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
rb5er said:
Good choice. Imprezas are very cheap performance motoring ime.
Yes, until they break! eek
Odd comment. Certainly more reliable than a BMW and no more expensive to repair.

V8mate

45,899 posts

189 months

Thursday 17th December 2015
quotequote all
I've got a 2006 (pre-LCI, so no DPF nonsense) 120d with the full M Sport gubbins.

And I love it.

Every year I think I should get something different, but it's just a joy to drive. It's small enough to park anywhere, but large enough for most of what I need, including cross-Europe jaunts. It's planted, balanced, fast and, once rolling, will grab any space in traffic, changing speed marvellously.

I get about 45mpg all round.

I do 15,000 miles a year; change the oil twice a year (ignoring the condition-based servicing thing) and in five years it has only needed front shocks and springs over the usual service items.

I did switch from run-flats to regular tyres after the first year, but have subsequently switched back to RFs. I think the added firmness suits the car. I do have a separate set of winter tyres though (also RFs), as a 1er plus snow is not a fun combination.

,

Edited by V8mate on Sunday 20th December 08:37

Mr Tidy

22,344 posts

127 months

Sunday 20th December 2015
quotequote all
rb5er said:
Odd comment. Certainly more reliable than a BMW and no more expensive to repair.
Just based on my experience of 81,000 miles in a 123d - only things replaced other then oil, filters and brake fluid were a battery and starter motor (probably due to the Stop/Start nonsense)...........

Original brake pads and discs, wiper blades, etc.....

But if you know of a Scooby that has done better I would love to hear about it........(doubt it will be a diesel as they seem to be a bit fragile)!

AntiLagGC8

1,724 posts

112 months

Sunday 20th December 2015
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
rb5er said:
Odd comment. Certainly more reliable than a BMW and no more expensive to repair.
Just based on my experience of 81,000 miles in a 123d - only things replaced other then oil, filters and brake fluid were a battery and starter motor (probably due to the Stop/Start nonsense)...........

Original brake pads and discs, wiper blades, etc.....

But if you know of a Scooby that has done better I would love to hear about it........(doubt it will be a diesel as they seem to be a bit fragile)!
I can beat that! I have a neighbour with an Impreza who has done 126,000 with no real maintenance (its still on its original clutch etc) but to be fair he drives it like most 1 series diesel BMW's get driven, pretty steadily.

I think its worth pointing out that Impreza's tend to live very tough lives rather than your average 123d that spends a lot of time on the motorway living a gentle life.

I'm a big fan of the 123d, superb car for 90% of all activities! I'm considering one for my next work car.

rb5er

11,657 posts

172 months

Sunday 20th December 2015
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
rb5er said:
Odd comment. Certainly more reliable than a BMW and no more expensive to repair.
Just based on my experience of 81,000 miles in a 123d - only things replaced other then oil, filters and brake fluid were a battery and starter motor (probably due to the Stop/Start nonsense)...........

Original brake pads and discs, wiper blades, etc.....

But if you know of a Scooby that has done better I would love to hear about it........(doubt it will be a diesel as they seem to be a bit fragile)!
I have an impreza from 1999. It has only ever needed standard servicing/consumables and a brake caliper rebuild. Its quite an old car and completely reliable.

If you are on your original brake discs etc that points to how its driven more than anything else. The impreza on the other hand does not get nursed about.