330ci or 330d

330ci or 330d

TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED
Author
Discussion

hogit

Original Poster:

3 posts

212 months

Tuesday 30th September 2008
quotequote all
The initial message has been deleted from this topic.

dxb335d

2,905 posts

196 months

Tuesday 30th September 2008
quotequote all
seems a daft question. Do whatever you want to do. not what a load of people on a forum youve not met think you should do.

You have had 330d, try the 330i.

Fox-

13,241 posts

247 months

Tuesday 30th September 2008
quotequote all
Why do you have to change it because the number on the speedo is quite high?

pgilc1

35,848 posts

198 months

Tuesday 30th September 2008
quotequote all
Bit of a silly question. Buy what suits your needs best not what some bunch of people on a forum think they would like best.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

199 months

Wednesday 1st October 2008
quotequote all
There is no info given is this the E92?
If so then its either a 231bhp 330d or a 245bhp 330d, also the 330i is again different BHP & vastly different MPG depending on which one you get.


pgilc1

35,848 posts

198 months

Wednesday 1st October 2008
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
There is no info given is this the E92?
If so then its either a 231bhp 330d or a 245bhp 330d, also the 330i is again different BHP & vastly different MPG depending on which one you get.
e46 i think, as the e92 doesnt have C in the designation anymore.

Nevermind though, as the O/P seems to be huffing.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

199 months

Wednesday 1st October 2008
quotequote all
pgilc1 said:
Welshbeef said:
There is no info given is this the E92?
If so then its either a 231bhp 330d or a 245bhp 330d, also the 330i is again different BHP & vastly different MPG depending on which one you get.
e46 i think, as the e92 doesnt have C in the designation anymore.

Nevermind though, as the O/P seems to be huffing.
So why is he changing form a 2002 E46 to a at most 3 year newer model which would be the same? I guess he must have the 184bhp 330d & 5 speed manual - in which case get the newer 330d Manaul 6 speed more power, more torque more economy more rev range.
330i - Great car sounds really nice but will be doing 10 to 15mpg less than the 330d. Horses for courses.

Fox-

13,241 posts

247 months

Wednesday 1st October 2008
quotequote all
Sounds like one of these people who needs to have a new car every 23 seconds.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

199 months

Wednesday 1st October 2008
quotequote all
Fox- said:
Sounds like one of these people who needs to have a new car every 23 seconds.
If it aint broke/accident damaged/starting to get unreliable then why change? The grass is always greener but frankly keep the old boy (well its hardly old being a mere 6 years old!!).

If he wants the 204bhp 330d over the 184bhp 330d he has apart from the 6th gear I really doubt he'd notice the difference on the public highway.

The switch to the 330i - well again its change for change sake.

If its changing from say a 316i (not even ES just the i bottom of the range) to say the 330d Sport 204bhp E46 then I can understand the change but changing when there is so little real world difference is a waste of £ IMHO.


Welshbeef

49,633 posts

199 months

Wednesday 1st October 2008
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
But the cost to change & the better the devil you know aspect are important.
The 325i doesnt offer effortless pace you need to work the box hard.

In fact Original poster didnt state Auto or Manual - if he wanted an Auto which would be better>?

dxb335d

2,905 posts

196 months

Thursday 2nd October 2008
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Stop labelling every diesel owner as some sort of non enthisuastic dont know how to drive car owner.

YOUR STILL so clearly blinkered...



Edited by dxb335d on Thursday 2nd October 14:26

Fox-

13,241 posts

247 months

Thursday 2nd October 2008
quotequote all
dxb335d said:
Stop labelling every diesel owner as some sort of non enthisuastic dont know how to drive car owner.
Most keen drivers chose petrol, diesel is something they end up with through circumstances. I bet if your Dad had given you a 335i instead you'd be on the other side of the bandwagon.

squeezebm

2,319 posts

206 months

Thursday 2nd October 2008
quotequote all
Fox- said:
dxb335d said:
Stop labelling every diesel owner as some sort of non enthisuastic dont know how to drive car owner.
Most keen drivers chose petrol, diesel is something they end up with through circumstances. I bet if your Dad had given you a 335i instead you'd be on the other side of the bandwagon.
laughhehe

dxb335d

2,905 posts

196 months

Thursday 2nd October 2008
quotequote all
Fox- said:
dxb335d said:
Stop labelling every diesel owner as some sort of non enthisuastic dont know how to drive car owner.
Most keen drivers chose petrol, diesel is something they end up with through circumstances. I bet if your Dad had given you a 335i instead you'd be on the other side of the bandwagon.
Wish he had given it to me. I paid good money.

You are right though. Had i bought a 33i and never tried the 335d i would prob be as blinkered as you. Im glad ive tried it and enjoyed it. Its a cracking car. Not much else comes close for an overall everyday car.

My next car was going to be a E92 M3, but i think i might give the 335i a try first.

Ment-Al

16,988 posts

196 months

Thursday 2nd October 2008
quotequote all
And... and... i'm waiting... phew...

I've driven both, albeit an auto 330Ci and a manual 330Cd, and i preferred the diesel and if i had to take one home it would have been the diesel. Probably due to not liking auto much. Diesel auto to me seems utterly boring, where's the fun?

Manual 330Ci would most likely be my choice.


pstruck

3,518 posts

250 months

Thursday 2nd October 2008
quotequote all
Ment-Al said:
Manual 330Ci would most likely be my choice.
Had mine since last weekend and am loving it. The power delivery isn't as punchy as the diesel with all that torque, but it is smooth and refined ad makes a terrific noise.

If mpg is your concern then don't go the petrol route. Having said that though average combined mpg of around the 30 mark isn't at all bad for a 3 litre.

Ment-Al

16,988 posts

196 months

Thursday 2nd October 2008
quotequote all
pstruck said:
Ment-Al said:
Manual 330Ci would most likely be my choice.
Had mine since last weekend and am loving it. The power delivery isn't as punchy as the diesel with all that torque, but it is smooth and refined ad makes a terrific noise.

If mpg is your concern then don't go the petrol route. Having said that though average combined mpg of around the 30 mark isn't at all bad for a 3 litre.
I got similar mpg from the auto 330 as i did from my manual 318 (2.0) all the time, except when on a long motorway journey.

The effortless acceleration means you dont need as heavy a foot.

The petrol doesnt seem as quick but thats all down to delivery - the petrol pulls nice and hard through the whole rev range. Excellent car the 330.

S1MMA

2,380 posts

220 months

Thursday 2nd October 2008
quotequote all
This thread is futile. 335d (MAPPED) is the obvious winners choice. The End.

Fox-

13,241 posts

247 months

Thursday 2nd October 2008
quotequote all
dxb335d said:
You are right though. Had i bought a 33i and never tried the 335d i would prob be as blinkered as you
How am I blinkered? The two cars I drive the most are a 530d and a 530i so similar their production months are just a month apart. Sounds like a perfect opportunity to make objective comparisons on the petrol v diesel thing.

pgilc1

35,848 posts

198 months

Thursday 2nd October 2008
quotequote all
Fox- said:
dxb335d said:
Stop labelling every diesel owner as some sort of non enthisuastic dont know how to drive car owner.
Most keen drivers chose petrol, diesel is something they end up with through circumstances. I bet if your Dad had given you a 335i instead you'd be on the other side of the bandwagon.
No. I've a 535d because of its all round flexability.

I drive it because i enjoy it.
TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED