Helmet Advice.

Author
Discussion

DanSI

139 posts

143 months

Monday 22nd August 2016
quotequote all
You might also want to pay attention to the " SHARP " safety rating. This is a UK recognized helmet rating. http://sharp.direct.gov.uk/
To this point, you could spend £500 on an ARAI helmet, that has a lower (Sharp) safety rating than a helmet that costs HALF that price.

Do people splash out £500 for an ARAI just for the image/recognition/brand wink , or for other reasons...

tom_e

346 posts

100 months

Monday 22nd August 2016
quotequote all
DanSI said:
You might also want to pay attention to the " SHARP " safety rating. This is a UK recognized helmet rating. http://sharp.direct.gov.uk/
To this point, you could spend £500 on an ARAI helmet, that has a lower (Sharp) safety rating than a helmet that costs HALF that price.

Do people splash out £500 for an ARAI just for the image/recognition/brand wink , or for other reasons...
Build quality, fit, features, weight, noise. All things that suffer at the lower end of the market compared to more expensive helmets.

Like most kit as long as you don't go full on bargain basement the cheaper stuff will for the most part protect as well as something 3 times the price, you're paying for all the nice little extras that generally make it a more pleasant place to spend the time which makes a massive difference if your bike is your only form of transport like me.

julian64

14,317 posts

255 months

Monday 22nd August 2016
quotequote all
1) Go to helmet superstore and take girlfriend
2) Get girlfriend to put a blindfold on you, so you can't look at the label on the side of the helmet, the safety rating, or any of the other crap which sways your judgement because you're a man.
3) pick the three that fir the best.

Then

4) ask you girlfriend which is the prettiest, and when she tells you discard that one
5) ask the store manager which one he'd recommend out of the last two, and when he tells you discard that one

This then leaves with a good fitting helmet which doesn't look like you were trying to hard to look good, and its not the end of season stock the manager is trying to get rid of.

Last note and an important one, there is a high change the girlfriend will kick off after this, but the way I've found works best is that you say to her 'If I go back and change to the one you suggested, you have to wear the dresses I suggest'. If she accepts this then you go back without a moments hesitation, and are a lucky man.

OverSteery

3,613 posts

232 months

Monday 22nd August 2016
quotequote all
DanSI said:
You might also want to pay attention to the " SHARP " safety rating. This is a UK recognized helmet rating. http://sharp.direct.gov.uk/
To this point, you could spend £500 on an ARAI helmet, that has a lower (Sharp) safety rating than a helmet that costs HALF that price.

Do people splash out £500 for an ARAI just for the image/recognition/brand wink , or for other reasons...
ISTR, ARAI disagree with the nature of the tests, so its more do you trusting their judgement or some relatively new testing body. Arai do not do a slide down internal dark visor for safety reasons.

I say this without any axe to grind as I find Shoei more comfortable.


Edited by OverSteery on Monday 22 August 17:06

black-k1

11,936 posts

230 months

Monday 22nd August 2016
quotequote all
tom_e said:
DanSI said:
You might also want to pay attention to the " SHARP " safety rating. This is a UK recognized helmet rating. http://sharp.direct.gov.uk/
To this point, you could spend £500 on an ARAI helmet, that has a lower (Sharp) safety rating than a helmet that costs HALF that price.

Do people splash out £500 for an ARAI just for the image/recognition/brand wink , or for other reasons...
Build quality, fit, features, weight, noise. All things that suffer at the lower end of the market compared to more expensive helmets.

Like most kit as long as you don't go full on bargain basement the cheaper stuff will for the most part protect as well as something 3 times the price, you're paying for all the nice little extras that generally make it a more pleasant place to spend the time which makes a massive difference if your bike is your only form of transport like me.
The other thing cheaper helmets tend to do more than expensive helmets is that the padding "squashes" with prolonged wear, making what was a tight fitting helmet into a loose fitting helmet in the first 3 to 6 months of usage. It’s not guaranteed to happen and price isn’t a guarantee it won’t happen but (anecdotally) there does tend to be some correlation with price.

I paid around £400 for my 3 star Schuberth C3 when the Caberg Trip has 5 stars but was 25% of the price. I did this because the C3 is the second quietest helmet (second only to the C3 Pro) that you can get. And, of course, I only have a 3 star head! biggrin


bgunn

1,417 posts

132 months

Monday 22nd August 2016
quotequote all
julian64 said:
1) Go to helmet superstore and take girlfriend
2) Get girlfriend to put a blindfold on you, so you can't look at the label on the side of the helmet, the safety rating, or any of the other crap which sways your judgement because you're a man.
3) pick the three that fir the best.

Then

4) ask you girlfriend which is the prettiest, and when she tells you discard that one
5) ask the store manager which one he'd recommend out of the last two, and when he tells you discard that one

This then leaves with a good fitting helmet which doesn't look like you were trying to hard to look good, and its not the end of season stock the manager is trying to get rid of.

Last note and an important one, there is a high change the girlfriend will kick off after this, but the way I've found works best is that you say to her 'If I go back and change to the one you suggested, you have to wear the dresses I suggest'. If she accepts this then you go back without a moments hesitation, and are a lucky man.
biggrin Awesome.

Biker 1

7,741 posts

120 months

Monday 22nd August 2016
quotequote all
julian64 said:
1) 'If I go back and change to the one you suggested, you have to wear the dresses I suggest'.
I how I wish my missus was like this..... My glasses steamed up just thinking about it getmecoat

Keithyboy

1,940 posts

271 months

Monday 22nd August 2016
quotequote all
Another vote for Helmet City in Tatsfield. I spent almost a whole afternoon there a couple of years back trying on loads of lids and kit until I found exactly what I was comfortable in - including wandering around wearing the lids too hehe They have a vast stock of helmets and gear plus very hepful staff too. biggrin

Djkirk3000

Original Poster:

48 posts

110 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2016
quotequote all
julian64 said:
1) Go to helmet superstore and take girlfriend
2) Get girlfriend to put a blindfold on you, so you can't look at the label on the side of the helmet, the safety rating, or any of the other crap which sways your judgement because you're a man.
3) pick the three that fir the best.

Then

4) ask you girlfriend which is the prettiest, and when she tells you discard that one
5) ask the store manager which one he'd recommend out of the last two, and when he tells you discard that one

This then leaves with a good fitting helmet which doesn't look like you were trying to hard to look good, and its not the end of season stock the manager is trying to get rid of.

Last note and an important one, there is a high change the girlfriend will kick off after this, but the way I've found works best is that you say to her 'If I go back and change to the one you suggested, you have to wear the dresses I suggest'. If she accepts this then you go back without a moments hesitation, and are a lucky man.
Think this may be the best plan of action, although i doubt she will kick off meaning i wont be the lucky man in the situation.

Helmet City in Tatsfield is a bit far from me, im in the North west so anywhere round here is fair game, biggest place ive found so far is J&S Accessories.


308mate

13,757 posts

223 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2016
quotequote all
Keithyboy said:
Another vote for Helmet City in Tatsfield. I spent almost a whole afternoon there a couple of years back trying on loads of lids and kit until I found exactly what I was comfortable in - including wandering around wearing the lids too hehe They have a vast stock of helmets and gear plus very hepful staff too. biggrin
Yep, good guys down there and they will let you take the helmet home, sit on the couch wearing it for an hour and if its uncomfortable you can bring it back. Cant say fairer than that.

tjlazer

875 posts

175 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2016
quotequote all
I wouldn't disregard a Shark Skwal, if the fit works they are a decent helmet and on sale at the moment around £130. 4* rated, great internal visor and disco lights to entertain the kids at the lights. My next helmet is a Shoei NXR or Shark Spartan as I fancy something a bit lighter and more racey.

welsh blackbird

690 posts

245 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2016
quotequote all
Djkirk3000 said:
Think this may be the best plan of action, although i doubt she will kick off meaning i wont be the lucky man in the situation.

Helmet City in Tatsfield is a bit far from me, im in the North west so anywhere round here is fair game, biggest place ive found so far is J&S Accessories.
J&S are quite good. I got £50 off a C3 pro with a bit of haggling!

tom_e

346 posts

100 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2016
quotequote all
tjlazer said:
I wouldn't disregard a Shark Skwal, if the fit works they are a decent helmet and on sale at the moment around £130. 4* rated, great internal visor and disco lights to entertain the kids at the lights. My next helmet is a Shoei NXR or Shark Spartan as I fancy something a bit lighter and more racey.
Be aware if you need to replace the visor on the Skwal or Spartan you're looking at the best part of £100!

Djkirk3000

Original Poster:

48 posts

110 months

Tuesday 30th August 2016
quotequote all
Thanks to everyone that helped with this. Went to J&S accessories at the weekend to try on lots of helmets after initially feeling hounded in the shop and followed i left for a brew and returned with a clearer head and a better experience. The shoei qwest, Arai Axces 2 and the HJC RPHA ST all fit quite well.

I went for the HJC RPHA ST in the end pic below. Price was what i was after paying, fit was good and it includes the internal sun visor meaning i dont need to splash out on an additional visor, also has pinlock included.


Wildfire

9,790 posts

253 months

Tuesday 30th August 2016
quotequote all
Keithyboy said:
Another vote for Helmet City in Tatsfield. I spent almost a whole afternoon there a couple of years back trying on loads of lids and kit until I found exactly what I was comfortable in - including wandering around wearing the lids too hehe They have a vast stock of helmets and gear plus very hepful staff too. biggrin
Another vote here. I got mine from them and when I needed one for the GF, they spent a very long time with her getting the best fit at a number of price points.

PTF

4,355 posts

225 months

Tuesday 30th August 2016
quotequote all
FIT, FIT, FIT every time. And like others have said spend ages with them on your head in the shop, and if you can try to crouch like you're on a bike. Better still, go sit on a bike if they'll let you.

I bought a Shoei GT Air from sportsbikeshop. Spent ages in there trying loads on. The Shoei just felt "right" in the shop. Everything else i tried on there was something wrong with it. Back to the Shoei and it was perfect.

Wanted to spend £150-£200 and ended up spending north of £450!

First time i rode with it on i knew i'd made a mistake. Felt like it was pushing down on my eyebrows when crouched on the bike. Riding along with a shocked/surprised expression on my face just to keep the padding from coming down over my eyebrows.

I had bought an XL, but i think the top of my head is a bit smaller than my chubby cheeks.

I also don't like the visor mechanism, which insists on being open either 1cm, or being closed - nothing inbetween. I like a few mm of open visor, but not 1cm.

So i'm flogging it and taking a huge hit on it.

If anyone wants a cheap GT Air PM me.

Gunk

3,302 posts

160 months

Tuesday 30th August 2016
quotequote all
PTF said:
FIT, FIT, FIT every time. And like others have said spend ages with them on your head in the shop, and if you can try to crouch like you're on a bike. Better still, go sit on a bike if they'll let you.

I bought a Shoei GT Air from sportsbikeshop. Spent ages in there trying loads on. The Shoei just felt "right" in the shop. Everything else i tried on there was something wrong with it. Back to the Shoei and it was perfect.

Wanted to spend £150-£200 and ended up spending north of £450!

First time i rode with it on i knew i'd made a mistake. Felt like it was pushing down on my eyebrows when crouched on the bike. Riding along with a shocked/surprised expression on my face just to keep the padding from coming down over my eyebrows.

I had bought an XL, but i think the top of my head is a bit smaller than my chubby cheeks.

I also don't like the visor mechanism, which insists on being open either 1cm, or being closed - nothing inbetween. I like a few mm of open visor, but not 1cm.

So i'm flogging it and taking a huge hit on it.

If anyone wants a cheap GT Air PM me.
I completely agree, an ill fitting helmet is a huge distraction. When you get it right you forget you're wearing it.

Gusto

606 posts

234 months

Tuesday 30th August 2016
quotequote all
If you are looking for endorsement I have a qwest and it's great. But agree buy on fit over form/name.

Sorry hadn't updated and seen you had bought something! Enjoy!

Gusto

606 posts

234 months

Tuesday 30th August 2016
quotequote all
PTF said:
So i'm flogging it and taking a huge hit on it.

If anyone wants a cheap GT Air PM me.
Pics/design!?

PTF

4,355 posts

225 months

Tuesday 30th August 2016
quotequote all
Gusto said:
PTF said:
So i'm flogging it and taking a huge hit on it.

If anyone wants a cheap GT Air PM me.
Pics/design!?
It's a Patina. Great design. Slightly matt finish. Worn it about 4 times. Comes with pinlock.

Kicking myself. After a string of schuberths i thought i'd go for something else. Oops!