So will it be Rossi or Stoner this year?

So will it be Rossi or Stoner this year?

Author
Discussion

Jetl3on

1,409 posts

197 months

Wednesday 16th July 2008
quotequote all
100% stoner all the way, unlike the past challengers to Rossi`s crown, this guy has the confidence, natural talent, the tools, nerves of steel, can ride in the wet, dry, technical, twisty fast and slow tracks, and just for good measure is popping fastest laps to make his point.

The earlier blip he experienced gave Rossi and Co an opportunity to clear off, they didnt take it

It will go to the wire with Stoner pipping Rossi to the line by 0.0199secs.

Proco

26 posts

216 months

Wednesday 16th July 2008
quotequote all
Rossi all the way!!! Stoner is good without question, but dont forget all the DNFs Rossi had last year tyre and bike failures, think it will be close but Rossi for me

Beemer-5

Original Poster:

7,897 posts

215 months

Wednesday 16th July 2008
quotequote all
Stoner is the best of the latest breed (and i'd love to be half as quick as him), but Rossi is the main man, as Marc B. would have said.

For the moment C.S. is more Blackburn than Man Utd, but let's see how good he is over how many years.

Rawwr

22,722 posts

235 months

Wednesday 16th July 2008
quotequote all
Rocket Pepper said:
Stoner was shagged when he got off the Duc. He didn't seem that chuffed either.
Well, he had been throwing up for most of the morning and nearly puked on Matt Roberts during the post-race interview smile

Jetl3on

1,409 posts

197 months

Wednesday 16th July 2008
quotequote all
Rossi has never had to deal with a challenger like Casey before, Biaggi, Gibernau, Capirossi, Bayliss all fell short, a guy that matched his 11 races in a season, beat him in a 1-2-1 on 2 occaisions last year.

Rossi has tried to pressure Casey, but he just didnt crack. Casey has a mountain to climb, but the M1 is currently no Match for the GP8 and if the bike is working then he will bring it home ahead of Rossi..

Either way, I hope its a fight to the death, with Casey winning of course smile

Biker's Nemesis

38,694 posts

209 months

Wednesday 16th July 2008
quotequote all
I honestly don't care, as long as the fight all race long and cross the line within half a second of each other.

may the best man win.

Rocket Pepper

1,281 posts

217 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
I just don't see the Stoner magic. I see a lot of fuss thrown at 1 Ducati,and Stoner is the lucky lad to be on it. My Mum could win on that thing.

RJO

674 posts

272 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Rocket Pepper said:
I just don't see the Stoner magic. I see a lot of fuss thrown at 1 Ducati,and Stoner is the lucky lad to be on it. My Mum could win on that thing.
Pity she has to stay home and look after your 14 siblings.

Rawwr

22,722 posts

235 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Rocket Pepper said:
I just don't see the Stoner magic. I see a lot of fuss thrown at 1 Ducati,and Stoner is the lucky lad to be on it. My Mum could win on that thing.
That is why there's a big difference between:

1. MotoGP fans
2. Rossi fanboys

Johno

8,427 posts

283 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Rocket Pepper said:
I just don't see the Stoner magic. I see a lot of fuss thrown at 1 Ducati,and Stoner is the lucky lad to be on it. My Mum could win on that thing.
An alternative view may be . . .

Stoner has a huge talent as he is the only person that can make that Ducati dance the way it does. Melandri, Elias and Guintoli have access to the same upgrades and tyres but only the sheer talent of Stoner is what's making the difference . .

Seems to remind me of another rider who changed manufacturers and was the only guy who could make it win, now who was that hehe

Rocket Pepper

1,281 posts

217 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Johno said:
Melandri, Elias and Guintoli have access to the same upgrades and tyres but only the sheer talent of Stoner is what's making the difference . .
Much lauded by the press and race commentators, and Ducati themselves. But what is the truth? I think Stoner is reaping ALL of Ducatis benefits (pretty much like Schumacher did at Ferrari - remember Irvine within two races of a world title for Ferrari?) and the others are not. Wonder what Capirossi will have to say in years to come.

G Man

4,053 posts

261 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Rocket Pepper said:
I think Stoner is reaping ALL of Ducatis benefits (pretty much like Schumacher did at Ferrari
Uummm like Rossi wanting Bridgestone tyres or he would chuck his teddy bears out of the pram


Seems we are bless with 3 riders who have what it takes in Rossi, Stoner and Pedrosa.

If we look at each others team mate rider Stoner we know always smashes his teammate. Pedrosa has now consistently done the same to Nicky Hayden but its never spoken about

Rossi is effectively in a team of 1 because of his tyre choice, this means there cannot be any/little setup sharing and surely this must hinder Burgess

Beemer-5

Original Poster:

7,897 posts

215 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Great though he is, Stoner does have the best bike, as someone a few posts up rightly explained.

Johno

8,427 posts

283 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Rocket Pepper said:
Much lauded by the press and race commentators, and Ducati themselves. But what is the truth? .
You can find quotes from each of the other 3 Ducati riders commenting on the latest mapping changes and how it didn't make a difference to them like it did for Rossi.

I may concurr that satellite team tyres 'may' not be the same as the factory squads, but electronics upgrades which everyone seems fixated about are very easy to pass on to satellite teams and I believe that Ducati do.

Chassis', swing arms etc do tend to take longer probably.

I also agree the evidence does not suggest that the Ducati is the best bike if you look at rider and championship positions overall.

As for Capirossi he openly admitted he couldn't get on with the 800 at all. Both he and Stoner started last year on the same bike remember . .

Rawwr

22,722 posts

235 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Beemer-5 said:
Great though he is, Stoner does have the best bike, as someone a few posts up rightly explained.
lol, ok, so we've already proved it's not the fastest bike on the grid and we know its far from being the most nimble on the grid - so what measure of 'best' are you using? Nicest colour?

Jetl3on

1,409 posts

197 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
One thing is for sure, no mater what feat Stoner performs someone will find an excuse for it.

I seem to recall Rossi having what was classed as the `best bike` on the grid in the RCV and won several titles on it, I dont recall anybody having an issue back then.

The idea of Prototype is to make the best all round bike you can within the constraints of Dorna Rules, Ducati strive to do just that, but some people make it sound like they are cheating somehow.

Rawwr

22,722 posts

235 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Stoner's biggest problem is that he isn't Rossi smile

aeropilot

34,666 posts

228 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Quinny said:
Beemer-5 said:
Great though he is, Stoner does have the best bike, as someone a few posts up rightly explained.
Really??

Why can't Melandri ride it then??

As a package, I'd say the Yams are the best bike. They're consistantly in the top 5 with more than one rider, factory or satelite, Michelin or Bridgestone.

Stoner has the best bike for Stoner, but the best bike on the Grid??? Not in my humble opinionbounce
clapyes


dern

14,055 posts

280 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
There's no way on this planet they'd tolerate Melandri being near last if they could do anything about it by giving him the same bike as Stoner has and I don't believe Melandri is as bad a rider as the positions he is achieving. If Stoner's bike was as easy to ride as everyone is making out Melandri would be coming in second. He isn't.

Rawwr

22,722 posts

235 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
I remember when I first heard Melandri was going to Ducati, I was so sure he'd be the next world champion. I think I got that one quite wrong.