Marshall London - smart phone

Author
Discussion

iambeowulf

Original Poster:

712 posts

172 months

Sunday 26th July 2015
quotequote all
The amp/speaker people are bringing out a smart phone. For music lovers.

https://www.marshallheadphones.com/mh_uk_en/london...

Tech not as good as Samsung or Apple but two front facing speakers. Hmm.


Blown2CV

28,811 posts

203 months

Sunday 26th July 2015
quotequote all
Nice concept but I think they've got the wrong mix. Why would you not get any other phone and then one of the million Bluetooth speakers on the market, most of which will be better than any built-in phone speaker. They'd have been better off focusing on uncompressed audio or something. They've got too hung up on bring a speaker company.

justanother5tar

1,314 posts

125 months

Sunday 26th July 2015
quotequote all
They are aiming that at a very specific (read small) audience, surely?

Blown2CV

28,811 posts

203 months

Sunday 26th July 2015
quotequote all
justanother5tar said:
They are aiming that at a very specific (read small) audience, surely?
They're trying to create an android device that actually has some desirability. The only people that use phone speakers are knife-crime teens on public buses, and they're only bothered about annoying other people as an excuse to beat the st out of them, not so much the quality of sound.

Also, I read an article and it does support lossless audio, but with 16Gb of storage you might quickly get a bit bored with your portable music collection being as it would total about 20 tracks.

There is absolutely, definitely a future in high-quality portable music though, but it will remain very niche until devices have so much storage that we can just use lossless for everything. Nearly all people won't give a st or even notice the quality difference though.

stevoknevo

1,678 posts

190 months

Sunday 26th July 2015
quotequote all
Blown2CV said:
Nice concept but I think they've got the wrong mix. Why would you not get any other phone and then one of the million Bluetooth speakers on the market, most of which will be better than any built-in phone speaker. They'd have been better off focusing on uncompressed audio or something. They've got too hung up on bring a speaker company.
It plays flac files and has aptX bluetooth; they're obviously aiming this at the music lover/audiophile - I do like the styling though.

Blown2CV

28,811 posts

203 months

Sunday 26th July 2015
quotequote all
stevoknevo said:
Blown2CV said:
Nice concept but I think they've got the wrong mix. Why would you not get any other phone and then one of the million Bluetooth speakers on the market, most of which will be better than any built-in phone speaker. They'd have been better off focusing on uncompressed audio or something. They've got too hung up on bring a speaker company.
It plays flac files and has aptX bluetooth; they're obviously aiming this at the music lover/audiophile - I do like the styling though.
yea i revised my comment later... however it has nowhere near enough storage to make it a viable proposition for FLAC or even for MP3. I'm not even that much of a music nerd and I have nearly 10k songs in my collection. Even as MP3 I could store about a tenth of those on the marshall phone. If FLAC then I am guessing far fewer!!

JimbobVFR

2,682 posts

144 months

Sunday 26th July 2015
quotequote all
It does have an MSD slot though so potentially unlimited storage with multiple cards.

RobinBanks

17,540 posts

179 months

Sunday 26th July 2015
quotequote all
If I was looking for a phone right now I'd go for that. I really like the looks.

justanother5tar

1,314 posts

125 months

Sunday 26th July 2015
quotequote all
RobinBanks said:
If I was looking for a phone right now I'd go for that. I really like the looks.
Your post has just made me actually click on the link in the OP. I didn't realise it was actually now a thing was available for preorder, thought it was just one of those things where company X are thinking about making product Y. That'll learn me not to make assumptions. hehe

Now I've actually read about it, id like to retract my first post about aiming it at a small audience. The specs look good enough, certainly won't be frustratingly slow by the looks of it. But the phone itself, it looks absolutely great. Id probably buy it for its aesthetics alone. Plus I like LOUD phones, great for watching videos on in the living room without resorting to headphones or MBA.

I stand corrected. I want one.

ZesPak

24,428 posts

196 months

Monday 27th July 2015
quotequote all
Blown2CV said:
They're trying to create an android device that actually has some desirability.
Really? There's dozens? The SGS6 is widely lauded as the best phone at the moment, selling like hotcakes whilst being very expensive.
Blown2CV said:
The only people that use phone speakers are knife-crime teens on public buses, and they're only bothered about annoying other people as an excuse to beat the st out of them, not so much the quality of sound.
Wow, I could measure temperature using a beachball and come to a more accurate conclusion. Try a high and HTC and make that statement again. Or aren't they desireable enough for you?
Blown2CV said:
Also, I read an article and it does support lossless audio, but with 16Gb of storage you might quickly get a bit bored with your portable music collection being as it would total about 20 tracks.
Funny thing, for big storage you don't need overpriced memory from an oem.
This will do: http://www.amazon.com/SanDisk-MicroSDXC-Adapter-SD...

bakerstreet

4,763 posts

165 months

Wednesday 29th July 2015
quotequote all
Having recently watched a very interesting documentary on Marshall, I do wonder if founder Jim Marshall is currently turning in his grave.

Good looking phone though and I'm guessing that they have to lend their name to things other than amplifiers as from what I gather, their amps last a long time, so repeat business could be limiting.

bakerstreet

4,763 posts

165 months

Wednesday 29th July 2015
quotequote all
Having recently watched a very interesting documentary on Marshall, I do wonder if founder Jim Marshall is currently turning in his grave.

Good looking phone though and I'm guessing that they have to lend their name to things other than amplifiers as from what I gather, their amps last a long time, so repeat business could be limiting.

ZesPak

24,428 posts

196 months

Wednesday 29th July 2015
quotequote all
bakerstreet said:
Having recently watched a very interesting documentary on Marshall, I do wonder if founder Jim Marshall is currently turning in his grave.

Good looking phone though and I'm guessing that they have to lend their name to things other than amplifiers as from what I gather, their amps last a long time, so repeat business could be limiting.
Iirc it's a seperate company that makes headphones, under license.
They are the ones coming out with the phone as well.

LiquidGnome

551 posts

121 months

Wednesday 29th July 2015
quotequote all
Very cool idea!

It's a shame that the specs are comparable to that of a 150 quid phone.

RobinBanks

17,540 posts

179 months

Wednesday 29th July 2015
quotequote all
LiquidGnome said:
Very cool idea!

It's a shame that the specs are comparable to that of a 150 quid phone.
Much like an iPhone?

ETA: I'm one of probably very few people who's interested to see if Bang & Olufsen will ever do a decent Android phone.

Edited by RobinBanks on Wednesday 29th July 17:38

LiquidGnome

551 posts

121 months

Wednesday 29th July 2015
quotequote all
RobinBanks said:
LiquidGnome said:
Very cool idea!

It's a shame that the specs are comparable to that of a 150 quid phone.
Much like an iPhone?

ETA: I'm one of probably very few people who's interested to see if Bang & Olufsen will ever do a decent Android phone.

Edited by RobinBanks on Wednesday 29th July 17:38
The specs aren't as relevant with an iPhone due to the software.

RobinBanks

17,540 posts

179 months

Wednesday 29th July 2015
quotequote all
LiquidGnome said:
The specs aren't as relevant with an iPhone due to the software.
I agree, I was missing a wink face.

I do really like this phone but between this and the OnePlus Two this looks a bit basic.

If my Xperia Z2 unexpectedly dies though I will be considering it.

LiquidGnome

551 posts

121 months

Friday 31st July 2015
quotequote all
RobinBanks said:
I agree, I was missing a wink face.

I do really like this phone but between this and the OnePlus Two this looks a bit basic.

If my Xperia Z2 unexpectedly dies though I will be considering it.
It's a shame, I think they missed out on a much bigger audience by skimping on the internals.

Although not every phone needs to be a powerhouse I guess!

Just makes it a bit more future-proof in my opinion.

RobinBanks

17,540 posts

179 months

Friday 31st July 2015
quotequote all
LiquidGnome said:
It's a shame, I think they missed out on a much bigger audience by skimping on the internals.

Although not every phone needs to be a powerhouse I guess!

Just makes it a bit more future-proof in my opinion.
It really does look good, but £400 for an Android with a 720p display (just for instance) really looks poor.

I would be willing to pay a bit more for this phone if the spec was similar to a Sony Z3 or Samsung S5, for instance. But as it stands it would be a step back and even if it was really cheap I would struggle with that. My last two phones were 1080p display and equal to this or better in every other way so I don't really want to go below that.

LiquidGnome

551 posts

121 months

Friday 31st July 2015
quotequote all
RobinBanks said:
It really does look good, but £400 for an Android with a 720p display (just for instance) really looks poor.

I would be willing to pay a bit more for this phone if the spec was similar to a Sony Z3 or Samsung S5, for instance. But as it stands it would be a step back and even if it was really cheap I would struggle with that. My last two phones were 1080p display and equal to this or better in every other way so I don't really want to go below that.
It would be very hard to justify, especially since it's camera looks mediocre.

I don't actually think the resolution would be too much of an issue (for me anyway)- I have a Z3C, which is also 720p, and it's pretty sharp. Although I am starting to miss the bigger screen of my old Xperia Z...can't win can you tongue out