I Drove Uninsured For Six Months.
Discussion
Shock horror. Renewed the insurance on my old Merc last week. As part of the conversation I was informed by the girl on the phone that she wanted me to send back the insurance certificate for my other car, an MGTF, as the policy had been cancelled in the Summer. I was a tad taken aback.
It turned out that after I had sold my previous MX5 I was asked, by email, to return the insurance certificate for it. I emailed back saying that I had been issued the certificate by email and had never printed it off. As such, I was not able to return said item. The insurance company pinged some nippy emails thereafter the first of which I referred them to my previous Emailed explanation. After that, as I hadn't a car they were insuring and had the balance of my premium returned, I didn't pay ongoing communications much (sorry, any) attention.
A couple of months later I bought my TF. I phoned the same company received a very competitive quote and chose to insure the TF with them. Over the phone I was asked if I could return my insurance certificate for my long gone MX5. I informed the call handler that I had received it by Email and had never printed it off. She replied "that was ok". Within a week the Emails asking for my old MX5 insurance certificate restarted. This time they threatened if I didn't send it they would cancel my MG's insurance. Again I replied that I had never received one by post and never printed it off on my computer. I referred them to previous emails and the telephone conversation when I insured my MG and assumed the matter was closed. I went on holiday and missed the email informing me I was no longer insured and missed the money returned to my bank account. No letters were sent informing me of the situation.
Fortunately I got away with it. Once informed I immediately re-insured my car.
It turned out that after I had sold my previous MX5 I was asked, by email, to return the insurance certificate for it. I emailed back saying that I had been issued the certificate by email and had never printed it off. As such, I was not able to return said item. The insurance company pinged some nippy emails thereafter the first of which I referred them to my previous Emailed explanation. After that, as I hadn't a car they were insuring and had the balance of my premium returned, I didn't pay ongoing communications much (sorry, any) attention.
A couple of months later I bought my TF. I phoned the same company received a very competitive quote and chose to insure the TF with them. Over the phone I was asked if I could return my insurance certificate for my long gone MX5. I informed the call handler that I had received it by Email and had never printed it off. She replied "that was ok". Within a week the Emails asking for my old MX5 insurance certificate restarted. This time they threatened if I didn't send it they would cancel my MG's insurance. Again I replied that I had never received one by post and never printed it off on my computer. I referred them to previous emails and the telephone conversation when I insured my MG and assumed the matter was closed. I went on holiday and missed the email informing me I was no longer insured and missed the money returned to my bank account. No letters were sent informing me of the situation.
Fortunately I got away with it. Once informed I immediately re-insured my car.
LoonR1 said:
You didn't notice extra money in your bank account?
The sort of premium an (and apologies to the OP here) 'experienced' driver may incur on a few grand of MGF, if returned unexpectedly, I would likely miss in the noise.I suspect many other people who would insure a a cheap toy for summer amusement as a second or third car would also.
he probably didn't notice the pitiful amount they returned after absorbing most of it in admin fees
definitely put in a complaint and take it to the ombudsman, you were exposed to serious financial risk, as well as risk of prosecution
and now in theory must declare that you have had insurance cancelled on you when apply for almost any type of insurance for the rest of your life
definitely put in a complaint and take it to the ombudsman, you were exposed to serious financial risk, as well as risk of prosecution
and now in theory must declare that you have had insurance cancelled on you when apply for almost any type of insurance for the rest of your life
That all sounds a bit ridiculous to me, surely you could have just emailed them back their 'virtual' copy and be done...they send it to you that way so no reason they couldn't receive it back in an identical manner...I think the Financial Ombudsman or FCA would consider this a rather anti customer friendly way of working...you having to print something and return it to them!
And of course you could still have retained a pdf (or otherwise copy) of it on your PC so it doesn't stop you being able to re-print and provide for fraudulent purposes in the future (surely the reason of asking for it back!).
In any case, there is an insurance database so why does it matter whether you return an insurance document or not, in the event of a claim whether you have a printed certificate or not, a check would show it had been cancelled?!
come to think of it even a traditional 'printed and posted to you' type certificate could be photocopied so why do they ever need it back?
And of course you could still have retained a pdf (or otherwise copy) of it on your PC so it doesn't stop you being able to re-print and provide for fraudulent purposes in the future (surely the reason of asking for it back!).
In any case, there is an insurance database so why does it matter whether you return an insurance document or not, in the event of a claim whether you have a printed certificate or not, a check would show it had been cancelled?!
come to think of it even a traditional 'printed and posted to you' type certificate could be photocopied so why do they ever need it back?
LoonR1 said:
You just delete emails received whilst you're on holiday when you return?
You didn't notice extra money in your bank account?
Ok.
Where in the OP's post did he say that? You're making it up to suit your personal prejudices. The salient point to be taken from his post is that he may well have been driving uninsured while he was on holiday. A scenario that could happen to anyone. When I go on holiday it is for a break. I certainly don't read e-mails. Do you?You didn't notice extra money in your bank account?
Ok.
Furthermore, how about an insurance company that clearly cba to read what the OP sends them? Despite being told multiple times about the MX5 certificate they basically ignored everything he said. The result could have been 6 points and a fine plus. He now has to declare on any future proposal that he has had a policy cancelled by an insurer. Utterly disgraceful.
LoonR1 said:
Nigel Worc's said:
Loon, if the story is as stated, how would they get away with that ?
How can you return something that was never issued in the first place ?
No idea. The insurer would know they send docs virtually so they wouldn't ask. How can you return something that was never issued in the first place ?
The only criticism that can be levelled at the OP is not checking his bank statements. If he had done so, a credit from XYZ Insurance appearing while he was on holiday should have flagged that something wasn't right.
Sump said:
Why didn't you just print and post it back 
Why should he have to?
Sump said:
It was pretty obvious they wern't getting it :/
An insurer which consistently ignores the contents of repeated e-mail correspondence is likely to be quite capable of claiming they didn't receive the certificate either.Red Devil said:
A nice little rant
Here's where he said about his emailstannedbaldhead said:
I went on holiday and missed the email informing me I was no longer insured and missed the money returned to my bank account
So it's fair to suggest that as he's been back from holiday for a while and didn't take any action that he ignores any emails received whilst he's on holiday even when he returns. Red Devil said:
Sump said:
Why didn't you just print and post it back 
Why should he have to?
Sump said:
It was pretty obvious they wern't getting it :/
An insurer which consistently ignores the contents of repeated e-mail correspondence is likely to be quite capable of claiming they didn't receive the certificate either.You can't fight the system, he ended up uninsured for 6 months. The time he spent sending emails he could have just posted it and be done with it.
Loon has much wisdom from his industry, but his stance of defending insurance company's to the hilt weakens this. He will not admit that the insurance company has made a mistake, or that an insurance company may need to update it's processes.
If the OP story is true (and as he was not stopped then he has no reason to make it up), then a written complaint would be in order.
If the OP story is true (and as he was not stopped then he has no reason to make it up), then a written complaint would be in order.
And if he had deleted the e-mail? Or had problems with his PC and e-mails were wiped? Or never had a printer? or printer wasn't working?
Suppose he could of asked them to send it out to him again so he could print it off and send it back to them?
Suppose he could of asked them to send it out to him again so he could print it off and send it back to them?
Edited by scorcher on Thursday 23 January 10:00
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


