What car from my shortlist (£3K, 4/5 door, quick)

What car from my shortlist (£3K, 4/5 door, quick)

Author
Discussion

Synchromesh

Original Poster:

2,428 posts

167 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
Hi all,

New car time comes round in January, so starting to get ideas together as to what it will be.

I have a budget of £3k, need 4 or 5 doors (so hatch, saloon or estate) and want something with a bit of poke. It can't be crippling to run and must be reliable.

My shortlist is this:

1. Volvo S60 T5
2. Saab 9-3 Aero
3. BMW 330i / 328i / 325i
4. VW Golf Mk4 GTi 1.8T (w/ remap)
5. Seat Leon Cupra (w/ remap)
6. Skoda Octavia VRs (w/ remap)

Just wondering what people would choose and why.

If you can think of any suitable car that I haven't thought of then say, but chances are I will have, and will have dismissed it for a reason.

Six Fiend

6,067 posts

216 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
As you say you have probably already considered and have reasons against, which is fair enough but just in case...

Jag X-type 3.0 V6, manual, AWD (all 2.5 and 3.0 are).

SE for comfy, Sport model for slightly stiffer setup.

Engines are bullet proof, transfer box can be troublesome (it will be at some point, mine has been replaced).

0-60 in 6.6, 147 max.

70mph in 2nd, 90mph in 3rd.

Town 21-22mpg

Cruising @ 75 should see 34-36mpg
Cruising @ 65 I get around 40mpg

Many service parts cost peanuts as they're Ford shared.

smile

Edited by Six Fiend on Wednesday 23 November 06:08

Synchromesh

Original Poster:

2,428 posts

167 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
Six Fiend said:
As you say you have probably already considered and have reasons against, which is fair enough but just in case...

Jag X-type 3.0 V6
Considered these but:
  • Don't want the complexity (and associated repair costs) of 4wd, or indeed the 4wd handling
  • Less economical (and more to tax) than my other choices
  • Don't like the looks of them

phil_cardiff

7,104 posts

209 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
Six Fiend said:
As you say you have probably already considered and have reasons against, which is fair enough but just in case...

Jag X-type 3.0 V6, manual, AWD (all 2.5 and 3.0 are).

SE for comfy, Sport model for slightly stiffer setup.

Engines are bullet proof, transfer box can be troublesome (it will be at some point, mine has been replaced).

0-60 in 6.6, 147 max.

70mph in 2nd, 90mph in 3rd.

Town 21-22mpg

Cruising @ 75 should see 34-36mpg
Cruising @ 65 I get around 40mpg

Many service parts cost peanuts as they're Ford shared.

smile

Edited by Six Fiend on Wednesday 23 November 06:08
How much does the transfer box cost when it goes?

scrwright

2,631 posts

191 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
BMW has less to go wrong being N/A, but carry a premium.

I'd go saab personally, but I would get a 9-5 aero rather than a 9-3 (in fact looking for one right now)

ali4390

2,322 posts

166 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
I'd go Saab as well to be honest, although the Skoda could be nice...

Volvo360

8,202 posts

152 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
Mazda 3 or 6 MPS?

Chris Peacock

815 posts

209 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
^^^^...for 3 grand?......Not for an mps.



Leptons

5,116 posts

177 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
A £3 car, Billy Bargain!

Synchromesh

Original Poster:

2,428 posts

167 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
Leptons said:
A £3 car, Billy Bargain!
laugh It would be great if a mod would be kind enough to make it "£3k" in the title.

Synchromesh

Original Poster:

2,428 posts

167 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
doogz said:
WRX.
Don't want 4wd. Also, I can't get insured on them.

Volvo360

8,202 posts

152 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
Chris Peacock said:
^^^^...for 3 grand?......Not for an mps.
I know the asking's 4k, but with a bit of a haggle and a rummage behind the sofa?

http://tinyurl.com/8aaobcl

GreatGranny

9,141 posts

227 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
ST220?

http://www4.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201...

Probably juicier than the others and higher tax but alot of car for the money.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

191 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
BMW.

issey23

173 posts

190 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
Volvo360 said:
I know the asking's 4k, but with a bit of a haggle and a rummage behind the sofa?

http://tinyurl.com/8aaobcl
Bottom of auto trader ad says... 'needs an engine, conrod out the side'

Best have a rummage in all your neighbors sofas too for the repair bill...!

GreatGranny

9,141 posts

227 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
BMW.
"300/bhp in one word answer shocker"

Volvo360

8,202 posts

152 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
issey23 said:
Volvo360 said:
I know the asking's 4k, but with a bit of a haggle and a rummage behind the sofa?

http://tinyurl.com/8aaobcl
Bottom of auto trader ad says... 'needs an engine, conrod out the side'

Best have a rummage in all your neighbors sofas too for the repair bill...!
Ha ha! Oops.

bicycleshorts

1,939 posts

162 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
issey23 said:
Bottom of auto trader ad says... 'needs an engine, conrod out the side'

Best have a rummage in all your neighbors sofas too for the repair bill...!
hehe

Coming in significantly under budget: Focus ST170?

mywifeshusband

595 posts

199 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
Buy a Saab.

I see you're in Bristol so you've a couple of local indies to rely on. Jamsaab in Keynsham always has a great reputation. Also Simply Saab in Brislington.

elephantstone

2,176 posts

158 months

Wednesday 23rd November 2011
quotequote all
What kind of mpg do you get from the 9-3 aero? 2002onwards...