Running in Ceramic brakes

Running in Ceramic brakes

Author
Discussion

Glenn McMenamin

Original Poster:

2,305 posts

239 months

Friday 6th August 2004
quotequote all
Picking up my new Turbo cab next week from OPC Silverstone.

Unfortunately i specced it with the PCCB's before all the bad press etc, and left it too late to change my mind and de-spec them.

The good news is, that i have since bought a GT3 for the trackdays, so the cab brakes should never really be pushed to their limits. However even with this said, i have heard that the running in process itself is very important with PCCB's, as this can determine the feel and longivity of the brakes.

Anyone got experience of this ??

G.

zanzibar

234 posts

240 months

Saturday 7th August 2004
quotequote all
Porsche GB policy is to change the discs, if they fail free of charge. I would not worry all the problems are from over heating on the track, you will not get them nearly as hot on the road. Bedding in the pads is the same as steel discs.

Z.

mogul

14,987 posts

251 months

Saturday 7th August 2004
quotequote all
Glenn McMenamin said:
Picking up my new Turbo cab next week from OPC Silverstone.

Unfortunately i specced it with the PCCB's before all the bad press etc, and left it too late to change my mind and de-spec them.

The good news is, that i have since bought a GT3 for the trackdays, so the cab brakes should never really be pushed to their limits. However even with this said, i have heard that the running in process itself is very important with PCCB's, as this can determine the feel and longivity of the brakes.

Anyone got experience of this ??

G.


Sod the question...

You lucky bast*rd!

GuyR

2,206 posts

283 months

Sunday 8th August 2004
quotequote all

Tell that to my mate with whom they have refused to replace his PCCB discs at 12,000 miles.................

Guy


zanzibar said:
Porsche GB policy is to change the discs, if they fail free of charge. I would not worry all the problems are from over heating on the track, you will not get them nearly as hot on the road. Bedding in the pads is the same as steel discs.

Z.

bennno

11,659 posts

270 months

Sunday 8th August 2004
quotequote all

Was talking to somebody at porsche on friday, it seems that it is £27,000 for 4 replacement disks and pads.

This sounds daft but can assure you its correct, despite it being only £5.5k to spec them initially!!

Bennno

GuyR

2,206 posts

283 months

Sunday 8th August 2004
quotequote all

It was £27,000 for all four.

They have reduced the price significantly and the cheapest option is now a set of 'exhange' discs which are new disc on reconditioned bells, which ar £2,200+vat per disc i.e much less but still £5k per pair

MOD500

2,686 posts

251 months

Monday 9th August 2004
quotequote all
Guy, what reason have they given for refusing to exchange the discs for free? If you don't mind me asking that is!

Thanks

Martyn.

GuyR

2,206 posts

283 months

Monday 9th August 2004
quotequote all

Because they were badly damaged and it had occurred in low mileage they deemed them to be 'abused'.

They tried this with me when mine needed replacing at 9,000miles, but after I pointed out I had only owned the car one week and that it couldn't be me, they replaced tham as a 'goodwill gesture'.

Guy

steve-p

1,448 posts

283 months

Monday 9th August 2004
quotequote all
GuyR said:

It was £27,000 for all four.

They have reduced the price significantly and the cheapest option is now a set of 'exhange' discs which are new disc on reconditioned bells, which ar £2,200+vat per disc i.e much less but still £5k per pair


They sound more like a liability than a benefit. How good can they be FFS?

MOD500

2,686 posts

251 months

Monday 9th August 2004
quotequote all
Seems really strange this caper with the ceramic discs, surely its costing Porsche a fortune in warranty claims and good will gestures.

Is your mate swapping over to conventional steel discs now?

Best Regards


Martyn.

GuyR

2,206 posts

283 months

Monday 9th August 2004
quotequote all

Yep - he swapped to steels and reported no difference in braking at all.

It's not costing Porsche much as few people have PCCB now and fewer still have broken them. This might change with 997s.................

They are also insistent that PCCB discs are not covered by warranty and should 'be checked or replaced' after every trackday...............

GT3RS

402 posts

239 months

Monday 9th August 2004
quotequote all
PCCB problems happen to anyone who really uses them either on track or road. I know of at least 5 cases personally and have read posts on forums from a lot more people. Porsche's official line is they have only has 2 failures and one of those was because someone cooled them with an extinguisher. It is harder to get them overheated on the road but it is possible, the additional weight of the cab will cause more heat build up. The PCCB fitted to 997 is not the same as 996 they have inproved cooling.

GuyR

2,206 posts

283 months

Monday 9th August 2004
quotequote all

According to the Porsche website the PCCB fitted to the 997 is the same as the 996 GT2 and Turbo S, it specifically says so..................

slim_boy_fat

735 posts

240 months

Friday 13th August 2004
quotequote all
GuyR said:

Tell that to my mate with whom they have refused to replace his PCCB discs at 12,000 miles.................

Guy



My heart bleeds.............

rich1231

17,331 posts

261 months

Friday 13th August 2004
quotequote all
slim_boy_fat said:

GuyR said:

Tell that to my mate with whom they have refused to replace his PCCB discs at 12,000 miles.................

Guy




My heart bleeds.............


Erm slim boy fat, that wouldnt be you taking pleasure in anothers misfortune would it?

I would really hope not..

dazren

22,612 posts

262 months

Friday 13th August 2004
quotequote all
slim_boy_fat said:

GuyR said:

Tell that to my mate with whom they have refused to replace his PCCB discs at 12,000 miles.................

Guy




My heart bleeds.............

Mine too. I'm absolutely disgusted that Porsche could market these brakes stating a service life of 180k miles and do nothing about those that break within 12k miles. It is scandalous before we even move onto the ridiculous cost of the replacements.

DAZ

Marki

15,763 posts

271 months

Friday 13th August 2004
quotequote all
dazren said:

Mine too. I'm absolutely disgusted that Porsche could market these brakes stating a service life of 180k miles and do nothing about those that break within 12k miles.
DAZ



Is this how they marketed them in the start !

dazren

22,612 posts

262 months

Friday 13th August 2004
quotequote all
Marki said:
Is this how they marketed them in the start !


Which is why I tried to spec them on my car. Luckily I was not able to, due to slow disc production delaying deliveries of GT2s the PCCB option was taken off the "menu" for turbo buyers. A very lucky escape, considering I crack up the front discs evey 6/7k miles with sensible road and occasional high speed driving (note I think of my driving as sensible).

After all the sh1te hit the fan and news spread through internet discussion forums etc and american customers started legal actions in the USA etc Porsche changed all the wording of their PCCB literature.

There are many threads about this over on Rennlist.

DAZ

>> Edited by dazren on Friday 13th August 13:00

Marki

15,763 posts

271 months

Friday 13th August 2004
quotequote all
The trouble is a lot more cars are going to be coming along with them new M5 i belive has them as standard

At the moment it seems you can switch back to the steel disks and save a packet , what happens when you do not have this luxury available 27,000 pounds for a set of fecking brakes .....

slim_boy_fat

735 posts

240 months

Friday 13th August 2004
quotequote all
Seems to be a Porsche problem, as the ones on the 360CS,Enzo and 575 dont seem to get the same press for failures.

And you can bet BMW ones on the M% will work properly.

Its quite funny reading about people complaing about the pice of parts on there £100k cars...

Reality cheack i think..

If you dont like it buy a Focus.....