Mk5 gti owners opinions please
Mk5 gti owners opinions please
Author
Discussion

skypeller

Original Poster:

151 posts

224 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Hi I currently have a mk4 gti which I'm really please with bar some issues (coil pack & this and that which weren't really the cars fault but more the previous owner or terrible local mechanic I used for a one off repair in this cold weather)

I have the 1.8t gti 2003 6speed 180bhp version

I'm currently trying to decide if I want to keep this or upgrade to a mk5 gti so I'm asking the opinion in term of reliability of the current mk5 gti owners out there.

I have owned a few 330ci sports and one 06 plate focus st which to be fair I would easily buy another of as it was great, just prefer the quality feel of vag cars (yes even the mk4 is better built than the focus st)

The focus was reliable and solid to drive, great fun.....just lacked the quality and had a boy racer image frown

Is it true the 06 model onwards are technically better for reliability etc?

Dr G

16,012 posts

273 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
I'm not an owner anymore but less a company car I certainly would be.

Much more fun to drive than the preceding model and mine was very good indeed. The only problem it suffered was a (slightly) leaking water pump but was replaced on schedule anyway.

MK5 dashboards can be a bit rattly squeaky and the aircon compressor is weak (particularly if under-used).

They're getting to an age now where wear will start to come in to play so if you drive one that feels a bit vague or squishy that's not representative of the model. They feel nice and darty/positive when in good health.

ManOpener

12,467 posts

200 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Things to watch out for:

Air con compressors- already covered.
ABS computer failure- common to all Mk5 platform cars.
Diverter valves- old ones leak boost and can make the EML come on.
PCV- old ones fail frequently, resulting in a drop in boost and low-rev hesitation. Lots of people junk them entirely for a catch can because that's supposed to limit carbon build-up.
High Pressure Fuel Pump- check the cam lobe and tappet for wear- early cam lobes wore on some engines, later tappets wear but much slower. Most noticeable under high engine load, you get fuelling cut-out.

Aside from that just the usual suspects (cam-belts at 60k/4 years, springs ect)

I've got the SEAT version and most of the issues are common between them.

qureshia

4,773 posts

237 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
As above ...
Mine (117k miles, DSG)
Rear suspension bushes
Rear wheel bearings
Air con compressor (expensive)
Coil packs (most cars have subsequently had them replaced FOC as part of a recall)


va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Also watch out for funny spec imports on the used market. There are a few 07-plate cars from UAE out there, which actually got built in 2005 and sat around for a couple of years before been registered. These are missing the factory alarm so will cost more to insure. There are also some really weird ones with no A/C fitted.

skypeller

Original Poster:

151 posts

224 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Va1o spot on advice thank you i didnt know about this!

Will keep my eyes peeled.

Keep looking at the st's again (that engine/seats/power) but the golfs are just so much better quality

:-s tough one

qureshia

4,773 posts

237 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
va1o said:
Also watch out for funny spec imports on the used market. There are a few 07-plate cars from UAE out there, which actually got built in 2005 and sat around for a couple of years before been registered. These are missing the factory alarm so will cost more to insure. There are also some really weird ones with no A/C fitted.
I think I have one of these :-) ( car first PDI in UAE)

...on the plus side
It has xenons
Full factory electric sunroof
Cruise
MF steering wheel
Arm rest
Cd changer
Heated and folding mirrors

Built late 2005 registered early 2007 ..so sat around for just over a year (in sunny Dubai)

SMB

1,523 posts

297 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
Other things to check for

Rust on front wings both at the top lip of the arch and also behind the front wheel where silt collects behind the plastic liner.
As mentioned both the Pcv and dump valve tire, so check those if losing boost.
What sounds like rear wheel bearing failure may be tyre wear, and tread stepping, can be very loud.

As a Comment I found the standard rcd300 radio to be the worst I've had in a car ever, very harsh to listen to for any period of time, so you might want to be prepared to change it.

idge

104 posts

196 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
SMB said:
Other things to check for

Rust on front wings both at the top lip of the arch and also behind the front wheel where silt collects behind the plastic liner.
As mentioned both the Pcv and dump valve tire, so check those if losing boost.
What sounds like rear wheel bearing failure may be tyre wear, and tread stepping, can be very loud.

As a Comment I found the standard rcd300 radio to be the worst I've had in a car ever, very harsh to listen to for any period of time, so you might want to be prepared to change it.
+1

We just had both the front wings replaced on our 2006 GTI, it would have cost around £800 a piece according to the VW bodyshop! The warranty covers corrosion for 12 years, I think, and they initially offered to only pay 50%, but after some (LOADS) of complaining, managed to get that up to 100%.

In terms of opinion of the car - it's an almost perfect all rounder and I'll really miss that engine when it gets replaced with something a little more 'white goods' later this year.

pit5top

101 posts

187 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
I had a 55 plate manual 5 door
Bought at 45000 miles and sold at 150000. I drove it pretty hard and did a few trackdays in it.
It was very reliable, the only thing that went wrong was the divertor valve diaphragm tore and it was down on boost. That was it. Original clutch and gearbox, obviously changed pads and discs but that was it.
I've had a mark 1,2 and 4 gti. This was the best allround car I have owned. Entertaining handling, nice noise, perfectly quick enough, great seats, good brakes, easy 30 mpg, reliable. What's not to like? Much preferred it to the mark 4 which I kept for only 6 months or so