smoking at work

Author
Discussion

lord trumpton

Original Poster:

7,382 posts

126 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
Had a good catch up with an old mate today. Aside from the usual stuff he was telling me about their new boss at his workplace.

Apparently the new boss is keen on efficiency etc and one of his bugbears was the time wasted by the smokers in the workforce. The time to get up from behind their desk, walk downstairs and then outside to have a burn at the designated smoking spot.

He wants to limit smoking time to the individuals own time - ie outside working hours or on one of the designated break times. Apparently the office staff used to have a smoke whenever they wanted when the last gaffer was in charge (she was a smoker)

I run my own business and don't have any smokers employed (only have two employees) so I have never really thought about it much.

What is the opinion of the PH lounge lizards on this matter? I

dave_s13

13,814 posts

269 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
If I was the boss it would be a case of smoking only in your own time and not on work premises.

If you don't like it, fook off.

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

244 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
A smoker denied their fix when they "need" it is unlikely to be massively productive. If you want to take their "smoking time" out of the allotted break time, fine; but I really wouldn't try to put any specific clock type timing on it, addictions don't work like that.

a311

5,800 posts

177 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
It will add up, the bigger the organisation the more time lost. At my place you have to go to the designated smoking shelter which is about 75M from the main entrance. It's not policed but at a guess a minimum of 5-7 mins per fag.

I don't smoke at work, don't really smoke at all just the odd one here and there when having a few drinks. But if these add up to 20-30 on top of a lunch break I can see why some would try to stamp it out.

benjj

6,787 posts

163 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
In one scandinavian country, can't remember which, the non-smokers get an additional 5 days paid holiday per year. That's apparently what a half decent smoker spunks per year in fag breaks.

Seems reasonable to me and I'm a dyed in the wool 20 a day man.

lord trumpton

Original Poster:

7,382 posts

126 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
benjj said:
In one scandinavian country, can't remember which, the non-smokers get an additional 5 days paid holiday per year. That's apparently what a half decent smoker spunks per year in fag breaks.

Seems reasonable to me and I'm a dyed in the wool 20 a day man.
Do the non smokers get additional holiday time or do the smokers get less holiday time?

Engineerino

281 posts

165 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
I worked at a hotel recently where the smokers had to register in order to be able to use the shelters used, they also had to work an extra half an hour (I think) to compensate for the time wasted.

On the other hand, working on building sites and in particular a new house being constructed, the smokers just light up inside the bare shell and continue to work. Most contractors seem to have a large number of tea and lunch breaks throughout the day however.

Gaspode

4,167 posts

196 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
On the one hand, smokers take more breaks than the rest of us. On the other hand, they have the good grace to die quickly once they are retired so they don't drain our pension funds.

If they do their fair share of the work then I can't see a problem.

h0b0

7,580 posts

196 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
In my limited observations when I was a smoker I spent less time smoking than the women did in the toilet.

Also, some of my most creative ideas came when I went to smoke. It is an opportunity to take a break and change your thought process. When I was smoking this saved the company many times the value of my wage.

Now I do not smoke and I am a bit useless.

jjones

4,426 posts

193 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
why should smokers get extra breaks because they have an addiction they cannot control? are alchies allowed to slack off 30 minutes early so they can catch happy hour at weatherspoons?


Steffan

10,362 posts

228 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
Ran a factory years ago making light fittings new design created huge interest and the workforce soared to 90+ women assembling in three shifts with supervisors all day every day for many months. We had allowed smoking all well outside the factory (fire risk!) and I got so fed up with the mess and fags everywhere I threatened to stop all smoking on the premises. Smoking was only allowed by agreement with shift supervisors ad limited to two breaks twice a shift already by agreement.

Had a deputation with the shop steward (isn't there always one!) in charge suggesting that twenty girls would leave if we stopped the practice. Since we were negotiating a sale of the factory (which we did in the end and we did extremely well out of it ) at the time I backed down but suggested I would change that agreement unless all the dog ends were properly placed in the fire safe bins we had bought in for that purpose. The girls saw that as reasonable and I never saw a fag end on the floor from that point on which suited me.

Having been a smoker myself on 60 a day I gave up (successfully) after i was diagnosed as Diabetic, Twenty Six years ago. I have never had one since. I fully understand the desire for a fag. Even now I miss them particularly after dinner or being engaged in rumpty rumpty. However had I not given smoking up it would undoubtedly have killed me decades ago. Smoking at work is an oddity really which would never be allowed were cigarettes not already ingratiated into UK life. I think it will die away as the perils loom ever larger and insurance companies etc make the financial penalties (Daft life insurance premiums etc), unaffordable. It is bad news I am glad that I gave it up but with some smokers as I found their intransigence and insistent on smoking whenever they want to is so strong they will leave rather than face not smoking at work.

Real oddity because of common practice whereby an unreasonable and seriously unhealthy lifestyle decision takes precedent over common sense and health. And is more important than earning a living. Funny old world.

jules_s

4,277 posts

233 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
jjones said:
why should smokers get extra breaks because they have an addiction they cannot control? are alchies allowed to slack off 30 minutes early so they can catch happy hour at weatherspoons?
Or people who need to make a fresh coffee every 30 mins or so..

MikeOxlong

3,112 posts

189 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
I enjoy the occasional fag now and then but I don't do it at work, if they want to go for a fag whenever they want then they should work through their breaks, make the time up at the end of the day or take a pay cut.

B17NNS

18,506 posts

247 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
I'm a smoker. I've only ever smoked at breaks/lunch. Wouldn't expect to be able to nip out whenever I liked.

Jonnas

1,004 posts

163 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
It's pretty much accepted practice in industry now that smoking is only in designated break times only in designated smoking shelters or off site.

benjj

6,787 posts

163 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
lord trumpton said:
Do the non smokers get additional holiday time or do the smokers get less holiday time?
The non smokers get more. If the other way round it would end up in the ECHM, innit.

55palfers

5,906 posts

164 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
How many times do parents turn up late / need to leave early due to "little Johnny / Jane "

theshrew

6,008 posts

184 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
I used to smoke work until I quit and could go whenever I wanted but didn't take the p1ss. Sort of started again but don't bother at work now.

1 bloke in our office has one on the hour every hour but tbf he's in 30 min early every day working so I guess that makes up for his time.

PHmember

2,487 posts

171 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
Even if you don't have one cig every hour it soon adds up.

I used to smoke, I loved it - I was one cig EVERY hour at work. Over the course of an eight hour shift that's at least 6 cigs in work time - at 5 minutes per ciggie.

30 minutes every day.
2.5 hours a week (5 day week)
10 hours per month.
120 hours per year.

That's THREE WEEKS off EVERY YEAR over a non-smoker. Sound fair? Nope.

Hudson

1,857 posts

187 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
At an old job smokers used to get 2x 15 min breaks a day as well as their 1 hour lunch. Non smokers didn't get this privilege, so i lied and said i had taken up smoking - half hour off work every day.

It's bullst really but it depends a lot on the company and how the staff abuse it.