Exhaust Sound

Exhaust Sound

Author
Discussion

JimTC

Original Poster:

270 posts

217 months

Friday 25th July 2014
quotequote all
Looking for advice on exhaust sound.

My latest Chim has a sleeved exhaust.

This may come as a shock to some but have to say I am not totally sold on the sound. Yes it's great when at higher revs but at low engine speeds it sounds too much like a tractor/outboard motor.

What I am really after is a much smoother deep rumble.

Is this possible?

Any recommendations other than changing to an Aston (i.e. keeping the Chim)?

Many thanks.


dazee

314 posts

124 months

Saturday 26th July 2014
quotequote all
It's very subjective, but I like the sound of mine.

http://www.dazee.net/tempfiles/ACT_exhaust.mp4

Precats out, standard Y piece with cat, and ACT cherry bomb exhaust.

QBee

20,948 posts

144 months

Saturday 26th July 2014
quotequote all
Jim, your profile says "midlands".
I am in "midlands" too - close to Newark.
My 500 has no precats, no main cat, Clive Y piece, standard exhaust. 105 decibels or thereabouts.
To my ears it sounds purposeful but nice, and I am 60, so not of the Max Power generation.
If you want to come and listen, just email me.

Pinx

188 posts

120 months

Saturday 26th July 2014
quotequote all
dazee said:
It's very subjective, but I like the sound of mine.

http://www.dazee.net/tempfiles/ACT_exhaust.mp4

Precats out, standard Y piece with cat, and ACT cherry bomb exhaust.
I've just ordered one of these from ACT, gotta wait 2 weeks while they make it, cant wait to get it fitted smile

Andav469

958 posts

137 months

Saturday 26th July 2014
quotequote all
I ran with the pre cats out and a Clive F Y piece with the standard exhaust and thought the sound was ok, I then changed the exhaust for the ACT Cherry Bomb and the difference is very noticeable, louder, yes but the tone is very different, more bass without the agricultural sound.
Looks fantastic too, just a shame you can't see it under normal use


BarnFind

492 posts

146 months

Saturday 26th July 2014
quotequote all
QBee said:
Jim, your profile says "midlands".
I am in "midlands" too - close to Newark.
My 500 has no precats, no main cat, Clive Y piece, standard exhaust. 105 decibels or thereabouts.
To my ears it sounds purposeful but nice, and I am 60, so not of the Max Power generation.
If you want to come and listen, just email me.
Ditto.

Best combination in my book you got my vote.just give that man a call in the Isle of Wight !

JimTC

Original Poster:

270 posts

217 months

Saturday 26th July 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies. With no main or pre-cats in do you have to re-fit the main cat for MOT time?

locodude

510 posts

195 months

Saturday 26th July 2014
quotequote all
BarnFind said:
QBee said:
Jim, your profile says "midlands".
I am in "midlands" too - close to Newark.
My 500 has no precats, no main cat, Clive Y piece, standard exhaust. 105 decibels or thereabouts.
To my ears it sounds purposeful but nice, and I am 60, so not of the Max Power generation.
If you want to come and listen, just email me.
Ditto.

Best combination in my book you got my vote.just give that man a call in the Isle of Wight !
Double Ditto
My 400 is the same, no pre-cats, no main cat and a Clive F with std silencer. very sweet but without the tractor noise at tickover.

QBee

20,948 posts

144 months

Saturday 26th July 2014
quotequote all
Not arguing with the guy who switched to a Cherry bomb set up. Noise quality and volume is a personal thing. But I would just draw your attention to one thing - if you have plans to do track days, my car is right on the limit for the louder tracks (105dBA), I have to add track silencers for evenings or places like Bedford (101-102 dBA) and I cannot take part at the quieter tracks.


As to MOTs, mine passed last time, I didn't ask how, but I do have the old main cat Y piece in case I have problems. If, like me, you would get your TVR place to organize or even do your MOT, they can always refit the old Y if needed.

Come over and have a listen to mine and compare with yours - it's the only way you will know. I am in all weekend, 07736 774325. Nice driving weather!

TVRJAS

2,391 posts

129 months

Saturday 26th July 2014
quotequote all
Has anyone had the exhaust modification offered by Central recently? The bit that says "sounds great and not to loud" keeps drawing me to give this ago.

Anyone in the Midlands area i could have a ears would be an appreciated bonus.

http://www.centraltvr.com/product/exhaust-modifica...

ClassiChimi

12,424 posts

149 months

Saturday 26th July 2014
quotequote all
I'm pretty sure the Central mod is opening up the silencer and sleeving or part sleeving the two pipes.
Might be wrong though!
My 4.6 sounds perfect to my ears with
Pre cats removed
Main cat in Y piece
And standard silencer?

It's what I call subtle, some might say it's quiet but I think it's sweet and still really loud around town,
Now I reckon a 4.0 litre engine sounds really good with standard Y but sleeved pipes, they seem to burble really good and not to high on the decibels.

De cat Y is for hard core deaf people, or track folk, Clives Y is very nice but I've little experience of them.

For mainly road use I find with standard ecu the Catted Y piece gives some back pressure, more torque so picks up quicker from low to mid revs, feels faster than a de cat Y?
Err soon as the de cat car hits 4000+ revs it's a different kettle of fish and mine was much faster up the top of the rev range.

Good for track days!

Back to the sound, didn't Tvr employ some music/ acoustics guru to max the quality of sounds available at different revs, probably sales Bull, but I think the original cat cars with pre cats removed is close to perfect taking into account early morning start ups around your neighbours etc. I loved the de cat Y on full throttle pure roar but most everywhere else I felt slightly embarrassed and it ruined my Tvr experience. Just my pennies worth lads and each to their own.


ChilliWhizz

11,992 posts

161 months

Saturday 26th July 2014
quotequote all
Another thumbup for all cats out with Clive Y and standard box smile Especially between 4 and 6k rpm cloud9

Pinx

188 posts

120 months

Sunday 27th July 2014
quotequote all
Andav469 said:
I ran with the pre cats out and a Clive F Y piece with the standard exhaust and thought the sound was ok, I then changed the exhaust for the ACT Cherry Bomb and the difference is very noticeable, louder, yes but the tone is very different, more bass without the agricultural sound.
Looks fantastic too, just a shame you can't see it under normal use

Love the pic, it looks sweet smile How come there are exhaust U clamps on it ? I thought the ACT cherry bomb one came in one piece ?




Edited by Pinx on Sunday 27th July 18:12

Andav469

958 posts

137 months

Sunday 27th July 2014
quotequote all
Pinx said:
Andav469 said:
I ran with the pre cats out and a Clive F Y piece with the standard exhaust and thought the sound was ok, I then changed the exhaust for the ACT Cherry Bomb and the difference is very noticeable, louder, yes but the tone is very different, more bass without the agricultural sound.
Looks fantastic too, just a shame you can't see it under normal use

Love the pic, it looks sweet smile How come there are exhaust U clamps on it ? I thought the ACT cherry bomb one came in one piece ?




Edited by Pinx on Sunday 27th July 18:12
I've since changed the U clamps for round clamps, similar to the down pipe clamp.

ACT Exhausts used to be one piece, however, have changed to 3 pieces a couple of years ago to help with shipping

SILICONEKID345HP

14,997 posts

231 months

Sunday 27th July 2014
quotequote all
ChilliWhizz said:
Another thumbup for all cats out with Clive Y and standard box smile Especially between 4 and 6k rpm cloud9
That`s what i have ,mine is not noisy until i boot it .

I must admit it pre cats out ,main cat in and the ACT sports exhaust sounds better .

You get a very nice rasp .

dazee

314 posts

124 months

Sunday 27th July 2014
quotequote all
Andav469 said:
I've since changed the U clamps for round clamps, similar to the down pipe clamp.

ACT Exhausts used to be one piece, however, have changed to 3 pieces a couple of years ago to help with shipping
They offer excellent service and even split into more pieces for shipping to far off corners of the planet.


Pinx

188 posts

120 months

Monday 28th July 2014
quotequote all
Andav, why did you change to round clamps, clearance or sealing issues ? and where did you get them from ?

SILICONEKID345HP

14,997 posts

231 months

Monday 28th July 2014
quotequote all
[quote=dazee]

They offer excellent service and even split into more pieces for shipping to far off corners of the planet.

[/quote

I would ether pick it up my self or pay the extra for delivery ,there are loads of cheap companies now . I don`t like an exhaust in bits .

QBee

20,948 posts

144 months

Monday 28th July 2014
quotequote all
SILICONEKID345HP]azee said:
They offer excellent service and even split into more pieces for shipping to far off corners of the planet.

[/quote

I would ether pick it up my self or pay the extra for delivery ,there are loads of cheap companies now . I don`t like an exhaust in bits .
Well, I am sure Dazee would love to pop over from Japan to save a tenner.....hehe

Andav469

958 posts

137 months

Monday 28th July 2014
quotequote all
Pinx said:
Andav, why did you change to round clamps, clearance or sealing issues ? and where did you get them from ?
Ground clearance was the main reason, they never actually caught, but they were like hooks hanging down, yes I could have turned them but I also preferred the cleaner look and also in stainless steel.

I got them from a seller on eBay, they are 51-55mm in size