The "Holy Grail" ?

The "Holy Grail" ?

Author
Discussion

mep12345

2,061 posts

201 months

Friday 10th October 2014
quotequote all
s p a c e m a n said:
yikes

Little Shop of Horrors?
Yep but that was as I bought it. Weld repairs later to the correct standard of course!!

mep12345

2,061 posts

201 months

Friday 10th October 2014
quotequote all
Barkychoc said:
Surely there's some worry about nothing here?

You are going to lock the front wheels up long before the caliper bolts ever let go?

Just my non scientific penny for thought!
Chris,

When in training they show us what can happen. To do that they put a small bore pipe in a beaker of salt water and put a Bunsen burner under it. Before the water even gets to boiling the pipe shatters where it is in the water and comes out looking like a flower. For the brakes or suspension, the stress comes from the torque, the salt from road dirt and water and the heat is all that is needed, for brakes where that comes from is obvious.

Crux is CSC cracking can cause stainless to shatter, I'm not saying it will here but personally I don't trust it

Looked for a film but couldn't find one, but look at the pipe on this link as that can happen instantaneously

http://corrosion.ksc.nasa.gov/pittcor.htm

Hope this answers your question

v8s4me

7,240 posts

219 months

Friday 10th October 2014
quotequote all
phillpot said:
...Joe, would that be two sets (8 bolts) front and rear?
Oh go on then thumbup

Alan461

853 posts

131 months

Friday 10th October 2014
quotequote all
Put me on the list for a set, I'll collect when next we meet. smile

Buzzlt

239 posts

165 months

Friday 10th October 2014
quotequote all
Andrew thanks for the lift from the pub last time. If you need a lift to the wedding i am happy to take you in the back of my van. If you needed some incentive theres some - congratulations
Greg
P.s. sorry Mike dont need any bolts yet but will keep my fingers crossed that I will need some soon :-)

phillpot

Original Poster:

17,114 posts

183 months

Monday 13th October 2014
quotequote all
mep12345 said:
When in training they show us what can happen. To do that they put a small bore pipe in a beaker of salt water and put a Bunsen burner under it. Before the water even gets to boiling the pipe shatters where it is in the water and comes out looking like a flower. For the brakes or suspension, the stress comes from the torque, the salt from road dirt and water and the heat is all that is needed, for brakes where that comes from is obvious.
Mark, brakes are obviously a serious matter and I don't mean to make light of your concerns or knowledge, but I'm really not getting the pipe in boiling water thing?

So, cooking my peas for dinner last night I had boiling salted water in a stainless saucepan and dropped in a short length of 1/2" stainless tube. stirred it with a stainless slotted spoon and fished it out with stainless tongs.
Apart from my peas tasting "funny", perhaps piece of pipe wasn't as clean as I thought, nothing happened.

Stainless exhaust systems get hot and cold, get sprayed with water, possibly salty in winter, but don't self destruct?

Stainless is often the material of choice for replacement caliper pistons, bleed nipples and braided brake pipe end fittings.

Swirl pots, header tanks, cooling system pipework, the list goes on....

mep12345

2,061 posts

201 months

Monday 13th October 2014
quotequote all
phillpot said:
Mark, brakes are obviously a serious matter and I don't mean to make light of your concerns or knowledge, but I'm really not getting the pipe in boiling water thing?

So, cooking my peas for dinner last night I had boiling salted water in a stainless saucepan and dropped in a short length of 1/2" stainless tube. stirred it with a stainless slotted spoon and fished it out with stainless tongs.
Apart from my peas tasting "funny", perhaps piece of pipe wasn't as clean as I thought, nothing happened.

Stainless exhaust systems get hot and cold, get sprayed with water, possibly salty in winter, but don't self destruct?

Stainless is often the material of choice for replacement caliper pistons, bleed nipples and braided brake pipe end fittings.

Swirl pots, header tanks, cooling system pipework, the list goes on....
A lot depends on the stainless grade used and the stress they are under. Believe me the pipe thing does occur, I was shocked when shown it during training and it sticks in your mind. The crux is chloride stress corrosion cracking is small microscopic cracks that you cannot really see by eye but can see as a brown sheen (it is also known as brown staining - ooh er). If you look at a stainless exhaust you will see that discolouration everywhere, I certainly can on mine, but an exhaust is under very little stress, and if it fails will not have diasterous effects. I happily use stainless on areas such as swirl pots as the thickness of the material to the stress is massively over engineered, but for bolts on safety items, I.e brakes and suspension I personally will not use it. The chances of failure may be small, but why take that additional risk when a good quality played bolt does not suffer the same degradation and looks just as good.

Another example of brown staining is the marks that occur on your cutlery when you put them in a dish washer in contact with a steel pan or similar and can then not get rid of.



Edited by mep12345 on Monday 13th October 17:17

phillpot

Original Poster:

17,114 posts

183 months

Monday 13th October 2014
quotequote all


Thanks for further explanation smile



High tensile bolts often seem to come in just a "black" finish (rusts very quickly) but even if you can get BZP it lasts no time at all in my experience almost as if it is just there to protect while in stock!



Stwdv

273 posts

124 months

Tuesday 14th October 2014
quotequote all
Just looked at the Bumax thingy, interesting they don't tell you that to use S/S in some of those environments you need to use Sacrificial anodes !!

fozzy280472

305 posts

148 months

Tuesday 14th October 2014
quotequote all
Hi Mike , I would like a set please , no big rush , just let me know when you want payment , address etc ,
cheers Paul

phillpot

Original Poster:

17,114 posts

183 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2014
quotequote all
Da Dah, we have bolts (and washers) smile




Fitted mine today, couple of little points...

1. Heads are, unusually, 16mm not 17 as you'd expect on a 10mm bolt. 16 is a bit of an odd size, if you're struggling a 5/8" AF is a perfectly good fit

2. Most of you will be fitting these on the front brakes (apart from those with rear discs), they end up very close to the disc, 28mm long would have been ideal but that wasn't an option. If you're using spring washers as well as the flats they'll be fine otherwise you may want to cut a "smidge" off each one or use double flat washers.
Whichever option you choose you must, of course, also use a reputable "threadlock" compound.

3. Tightening torque, manufacturer says these are good for 66Nm, the figure I have from TVR (Chimaera but same set up)is 58-60Nm. Thats 44ft lbs to any old school guys out there wink


If you're still interest it's £8 for 4 or £15 for 8 inc. postage please pm me your address.

Should I actually sell every last bolt I will end up a pound or two in profit, that will go to Longers next charity bike ride.

Scubaman04

64 posts

132 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2014
quotequote all
Just emailed you with my order

Thanks

fozzy280472

305 posts

148 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2014
quotequote all
Hi Mike YHM ,
Cheers/regards Paul.

Jaye R

790 posts

225 months

Thursday 23rd October 2014
quotequote all
Hi Mike

YHM smile

Cheers
Jaye

TVR-Stu

813 posts

199 months

Saturday 25th October 2014
quotequote all
Hi Mike, YHM. Thanks, Stu.

phillpot

Original Poster:

17,114 posts

183 months

Saturday 25th October 2014
quotequote all



All gone, thanks gents.


Andrew S2, let me have your address please.

Alan, want yours posted or I'll pop them in the glove box so I've definitely got them next time we meet?

Steve, you didn't confirm so guess yours are M12?

Alan461

853 posts

131 months

Saturday 25th October 2014
quotequote all
phillpot said:
All gone, thanks gents.


Alan, want yours posted or I'll pop them in the glove box so I've definitely got them next time we meet?
NEC classic maybe?

phillpot

Original Poster:

17,114 posts

183 months

Sunday 26th October 2014
quotequote all
Alan461 said:
NEC classic maybe?
Giving it a miss this year.


PH Sunday Service at Gaydon Heritage Centre next Sunday?

v8s4me

7,240 posts

219 months

Tuesday 28th October 2014
quotequote all
Mine arrived today. Thanks Phillpot thumbup

Jaye R

790 posts

225 months

Wednesday 29th October 2014
quotequote all
Hi Mike

Mine arrived today - many thanks wink Now put away for safe keeping until required smile

Cheers
Jaye