xk8 - 14 years old but only 4k miles

xk8 - 14 years old but only 4k miles

Author
Discussion

Martin_M

Original Poster:

2,071 posts

227 months

Thursday 20th November 2014
quotequote all
Could I have your views on this car please guys. I believe the Nikasil-lined engines were replaced in 2000 so that should be one less thing to worry about.

I know that this is essentially a 14 year old car but do you think it would be a money pit or a good buy

http://www.classicconnection.co.uk/cars-specificat...

stuartmmcfc

8,662 posts

192 months

Thursday 20th November 2014
quotequote all
That's a lot of money for an 8!
There's a lot of newer, low mileage cars out there which have been extremely well looked after.
On the plus side, the interior and exterior should be mint. On the negative side there may be mechanical problems present, or about to happen, caused by infrequent use.
Ultimately, it's your money and if it's the spec and colour you'd choose, then I'd go for it.
But I wouldn't be swayed by the mileage if it wasn't.

IMO, later 4.2 xkrs are better.

P700DEE

1,111 posts

230 months

Friday 21st November 2014
quotequote all
Nikasil is no worry they are either dead or out performing the later steel lined 4.0s smile Bet it's not had it's tensioners done lol.
It's a museum car to be kept in a museum ! If you drive it the value will plummet to about £5K that the real ones currently languish at.
These cars are most reliable if driven garage queens need bushes etc. as often as daily drivers.

£22K gets you a low mileage late 4.2 R Convertible or even a later X150 wink

CarbonXKR

1,275 posts

222 months

Friday 21st November 2014
quotequote all
Martin, I'll sell you a nice 2008 XK-R with 42000 miles for that money - immaculate too!

Shirt587

360 posts

135 months

Friday 21st November 2014
quotequote all
Got to be honest, I would have to really want that specific car for sentimental reasons.

My dad inherited a car once (Alvis something-or-other) that belonged to a distant relative, because he'd always admired it when he was a boy. It did 300 miles a year max, went to Coventry every year on a trailer to get serviced, everything got replaced as often as the garage said it needed, looked after pretty much regardless of cost.

40 years after Dad first saw it, the relative dies and Dad inherits the car. Which was a bloody nightmare. Things broke every time you let it get up to temperature, the steering was all over the road (an Alvis specialist tried They All Do That and then changed his mind very rapidly when he gave it a test), it was an absolute liability because it had never been properly used. Sadly, it went to auction where it fetched surprisingly strong money precisely BECAUSE of the low miles!

Dad promptly used the proceeds to convert his MG TC to run on unleaded which made him much happier and is massively more reliable than the (younger) Alvis ever was. He also swears he's never buying a car based on mileage again.

Martin_M

Original Poster:

2,071 posts

227 months

Friday 21st November 2014
quotequote all
Interesting replies guys - thanks. This particular example has been up for sale for a pretty long time which might tell its own story.

I recently sat in a chap's XKR Zeemax in Glasgow and pretty much fell in love. I'm not desperate for an XK but I do like them. Will continue to look at all of my options but thanks for taking the time to reply.

Martin

designXKR

99 posts

200 months

Wednesday 26th November 2014
quotequote all
Interesting. We have a Y reg coupe in the workshop that has been rebuilt into a new shell and has done only 17k miles. Gives an idea at what we can sell that at

pauloroberto

230 posts

151 months

Tuesday 2nd December 2014
quotequote all
For that money, you could have a nice xkr (100) or a nice xk (150). I've had both. Loved the extra acceleration on the xkr but the dated interior and electrical problems started to grate.

jamieduff1981

8,024 posts

140 months

Wednesday 3rd December 2014
quotequote all
P700DEE said:
Nikasil is no worry they are either dead or out performing the later steel lined 4.0s smile Bet it's not had it's tensioners done lol.
It's a museum car to be kept in a museum ! If you drive it the value will plummet to about £5K that the real ones currently languish at.
These cars are most reliable if driven garage queens need bushes etc. as often as daily drivers.

£22K gets you a low mileage late 4.2 R Convertible or even a later X150 wink
I agree with this regarding the XK8 and its value. That's not to say it wouldn't be a lovely example to own, but you would lose all your money if you started clocking the miles up.

Having said that, I'm not sure the sort of person who would actually buy an immaculate, ultra-low milage example of a first-series car such as this would also be the sort of person looking to enter the bottom of the X150 market. That's not to say a well-used X150 wouldn't be a good buy - but it's unlikely to appeal to a concourse type buyer.

OP needs to figure out whether he wants an immaculate car at premium price to keep as one of the finest examples in the country, or whether he has £23k to spend on something he can drive with relative indifference.