Stiff gear change

Author
Discussion

Big Guns

Original Poster:

163 posts

220 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Hi all.Having just picked up my new 5.7 Monaro i fully expected a stiff gear change...very notchy.But this bugger is like a !Especially from cold start.Has anyone else experienced this and how long before it loosens?I have put 800 miles on the clock in a week!

BigNige

2,584 posts

225 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Yep, they all do it.
Reverse especially is a bast.

You'll find it loosens somewhat after about 5000miles and you'll also find that if you drive around town, getting it into first is notchy.
After a run though first is fine.

It isn't a good gearbox.

ringram

14,700 posts

249 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
The box is a solid mutha and will take some abuse. Its used in the Viper afterall. (Well same model, slightly different bearings)
Monkfish changed mine to a redline oil and it definately has made it better. A new shifter will also make the shifts more positive and shorter.
Stock its got about 3 linkages in it, plus a rubber shaft to make it feel all floppy.

P47ThBolt

357 posts

231 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
Ripshifter....nuff said!

mose

814 posts

226 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
Rippy is a great bit of kit, but I still find gear change a nightmare, still very very stiff. Reverse is very hit and miss.

stu harris

469 posts

242 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
They are a bit stiff on cold mornings....

However , it wll loosen up quite a bit with use. If its new and you're trying for reverse slot it into another gear first then try reverse , normal goes in with a metal on metal contact feel.

On gearchanges for the first few hundred miles you're much better off employing a lazy change as this will help it bed in quicker. Also long term try to ride the clutch as little as possible and make it a disengage/ engage action , this will also help reduce the change notchiness.

Fitting the Ripshifter improves the change no end and gives Tremec a heartattack on loadings etc but everyone seems happy so far.

Stu

BigNige

2,584 posts

225 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
As they say, take away the pain but leave the stiffness.

errr...probably

sid447

131 posts

239 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
Castrol Transmax Z,

Is also another option to help with this problem.
Mal Wood from www.malwoodauto.com.au/ who specializes in Tremec, only ever uses this oil.

pomona

303 posts

245 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
Fitted Mal Wood Tremec C/R box & filled with Castrol Transmax.Found no difference than using Red Line.

Big Guns

Original Poster:

163 posts

220 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
Thanx all.I was tempted to take the mother back!Yeah reverse is a real pi**er!Hit 'n' miss is being kind.Still,you pay good money for a workout like that!My last 5 cars(4 jags and 1 merc) have all been auto(lazy git!)so I thought I'd lost the ability!!!Cheers again..Dave

mrs rocket

1,282 posts

285 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
What are you on about you big bunch of girls blouses! I don't have any problem shifting, and I'm just a giiiiirrrl.
Ok, it's a little stiff when you first get it out, but selecting first before reverse helps.

mrs rocket

sjc

13,979 posts

271 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
mrs rocket said:
.
Ok, it's a little stiff when you first get it out,

mrs rocket



rocket

1,282 posts

285 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
mrs rocket said:
Ok, it's a little stiff when you first get it out...

errrrrrr....ok dear, I think we'll leave it there shall we.

And anyway, when can I have my bl**dy car back!?!

ringram

14,700 posts

249 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
I find using a forward gear that goes in easy, then partially releasing the clutch to kind of roll forward a little then shifting quickly into reverse works well. Seems better if you are at a slight roll.

BigNige

2,584 posts

225 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
ringram said:
I find using a forward gear that goes in easy, then partially releasing the clutch to kind of roll forward a little then shifting quickly into reverse works well. Seems better if you are at a slight roll.


I think the point is you shouldn't really have to.

This is 2006 not 1926 and gearboxes shouldn't be such hard work and not require £600 to be spent on a new shift mechanism just to get an acceptably smooth & sure change.

sid447

131 posts

239 months

Saturday 25th March 2006
quotequote all
BigNige said:
I think the point is you shouldn't really have to.
This is 2006 not 1926 and gearboxes shouldn't be such hard work and not require £600 to be spent on a new shift mechanism just to get an acceptably smooth & sure change.


You're right, compared to a ZF it's like something from off the farm; and who in their right mind puts reverse next to 5th instead of at the other end of the gate.

Pomona, Castrol was mentioned as an option, not as a comparison to some American offering.

caspy

1,791 posts

237 months

Saturday 25th March 2006
quotequote all
BigNige said:
ringram said:
I find using a forward gear that goes in easy, then partially releasing the clutch to kind of roll forward a little then shifting quickly into reverse works well. Seems better if you are at a slight roll.


I think the point is you shouldn't really have to.

This is 2006 not 1926 and gearboxes shouldn't be such hard work and not require £600 to be spent on a new shift mechanism just to get an acceptably smooth & sure change.



But i think they were designed and built in 1926!!!

island boy hsv

726 posts

240 months

Saturday 25th March 2006
quotequote all
I don't understand, I have a 2001 HSV VX and have never had any problems selecting gear after installing my ripshifter and running redline gearbox oil. I must admit you have to let the Rip shifter bead in for a couple of hundered miles or so. But after that it should be fine.

BigNige

2,584 posts

225 months

Saturday 25th March 2006
quotequote all
island boy hsv said:
I don't understand, I have a 2001 HSV VX and have never had any problems selecting gear after installing my ripshifter and running redline gearbox oil. I must admit you have to let the Rip shifter bead in for a couple of hundered miles or so. But after that it should be fine.



It's the standard linkage we're talking about on a std box with std oil.

Spend £600 on a Ripshifter & anopther £70 on Redline and yes, you will get a better change...and I would damn well hope so too.

But why should that be the owners that have to cure such "foibles"?

Don't get me wrong, I bought the car after a test drive and accepted that the box & clutch need a real mans touch to get the best out of them...I'd hestitate to say it's part of any "charm" but it certainly makes the car part of what it is, a muscle car.

Big Guns

Original Poster:

163 posts

220 months

Saturday 25th March 2006
quotequote all
Yeah me too.I had a three day extended loan during which I covered 200 miles.The box is tighter than an ducks arse on water though.I LOVE the car,it looks great,drives great and makes me laugh but that reverse is a real bitch.If it was a women....I would still marry it!