Back to court on Wednesday
Author
Discussion

shocker-z

Original Poster:

554 posts

249 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
Please see previous posting on
http://www.pistonheads.com/xforums/topic.asp?h=0&a...
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

It's that time again!

Just thought I would let you all know that I haven't forgot about this and that I am going in with my mind set on being straight and confident.

I have kept all the documents I produced from the last court hearing as well as creating a new bullet point list of what happened in the right order to keep jogging my memory and to stop me going way off point and skipping valid things.

I still can’t think of any way in which I can lose this battle as the policeman’s statement says exactly where he thinks I was and there are no lines there and have pictures of that to prove it.

Anyway it's Sunday so I’ll leave you with this and feel free to read through the old posts, I’ll keep checking here for any further advice and I’ll report back on Wednesday after the trial.

Regards
Liam

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
Hi Liam,

Thanks for letting us know, looking forward to see you get a resolution at last!

All I would add at this stage is not to be *too* confident. Things in court do not always go your way. Sometimes, too, when you are cross-examining which will be the crux of this case, the witness may not say what you are expecting.

One way to counter this is to produce a 'flow chart' of questions. Note that this is sometimes best *not* in chronological order of what happened. The reason for this is that the witness will naturally have their own bias and want you to be found guilty, so if they get wind of what a line of questioning is taking them to they can 'lean on' their answers in anticipation of what you are trying to prove/disprove.

Everything you ask needs to be in the form of a question. So, you can either ask them a question direct about their memories of the event, or you can read out a section of their statement, and ask if that is true. Of course, ideally you want their own evidence to disprove the offence.

A good technique is to ask them seemingly unconnected or seemingly innocuous questions at the start, which will win you the case later. For example, I would the officer very soon on it to confirm exactly what landmarks you were opposite. He will think you are trying to disprove his memory so will try to be exact. If anything he mentions works in your favour, ask him to confirm *exactly* what he has said, just to drive home your point.

For example, "So it is your testimony that when you first saw my vehicle, it was parked opposite X and it remained there until I pulled away and you later stopped my vehicle?"

They should be completely unaware that their testimony here will disprove the case as you have photographic evidence that if you were where he just said you were then there was no offence! Of course, if you open with the photos it would be very easy for the witness to slightly modify their answer or their memories to show you guilty.

Anyways, I guess you have spent a lot of time planning all this, but if you need any last minute advice on trial procedure then send me a PM.

erdnase

1,963 posts

232 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all

Best of luck shocker.. we're all rooting for ya!

Very interesting, Justin. I've never been in that situation, but find all the tactics and techniques used in court pretty intreguing. Any other advice or anecdotes?

shocker-z

Original Poster:

554 posts

249 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
Thanks,

Cheers for the advice.

What happened last time is i had a bullet point list which wasn't very bulleted so i used it as a general complaint sheet. This time im taking that old sheet and an actual bulleted sheet that i can kind of tick off when i've done as i wanted on each part.

The thing i dont get is surley his written statement is final? Or is he allowed to change his mind and say oh yes i just remembered 8months after writing it that i made a mistake in the location of Mr Wheldon's car?

Because if i said this and changed my mind i would be shot down..

regards
Liam

ypauly

15,137 posts

231 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
nothing to add mate

just best of luck

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
shocker-z said:
Thanks,

Cheers for the advice.

What happened last time is i had a bullet point list which wasn't very bulleted so i used it as a general complaint sheet. This time im taking that old sheet and an actual bulleted sheet that i can kind of tick off when i've done as i wanted on each part.

The thing i dont get is surley his written statement is final? Or is he allowed to change his mind and say oh yes i just remembered 8months after writing it that i made a mistake in the location of Mr Wheldon's car?

Because if i said this and changed my mind i would be shot down..

regards
Liam
The magistrates do not see his original statement. They hear his testimony and then you get to cross-examine him.

His testimony stands by itself in court. That is why you need a coherent 'flow-chart' of questions and to confirm *exactly* where he is talking about so he can't say "Well yeah, thats what I meant... *near* there...." later on.

If the evidence he has given is contrary to what he said in the statement you can refer to this though. For example, in my red light case, I needed to prove the fact that the police officers could only see me after I had entered the junction.

The Freudian slip in one of the statements was something like "I first saw the defendants car as they were turning right...". My first question was to read this out from his statement and ask him to confirm this. I then threw in another random 'scene setting' question, and then confirmed with him that the position of my car when he first saw me was after I had already entered the junction.

He started to object to this, then I reminded him of what he had said and already confirmed that he saw me when I was physically turning right - you cannot physically turn right until you have entered the junction... "...so you would agree that you first saw me *after* I had entered the junction" - "Yes." Game over for the case.

My recommendation would *not* to make the bullet points just a number of individual complaints. You need to sell one story, and make it as simple as possible. Your argument is that the officer make a mistake. If your questions do not have a likely response which confirms this then all the line of questioning does is dilute the point you are trying to make.

This case *could* be as simple as the example of what happened to me - if you are clever about it. Keep your questions focussed around that single point you are trying to make, and make the questions in an order which sells your story, without telegraphing what the story is so that the officer can choose to 'lean on' exactly what they remember.

if you want me to have a look at the statement and give you an idea of the questioning lines, feel free to PM me.

tigger1

8,483 posts

252 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
Liam - PM Justin ^^^^, you know it makes sense.

You shouldn't need to do an awful lot more than ask half a dozen questions - so long as you choose them wisely!

liner33

10,861 posts

233 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
How did things go??

tigger1

8,483 posts

252 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
liner33 said:
How did things go??
There's another thread on this (I'll hunt the link) but the CPS called Liam the day before and said they were taking no further action...a result.

Shame they pissed him about so much int eh first place, and after much dicking about on their part then finally decide they don't have a case.

shocker-z

Original Poster:

554 posts

249 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
heres the link liner33
thanks for asking

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...