Business Rates

Author
Discussion

mondeoman

Original Poster:

11,430 posts

267 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Had a visit today from a surveyor who claims to be able to get a reduction in our business rates, both for this year, back-dateable three years and going forward as well. All from a cold-call last week where the numpty on the phone had the wrong company name, wrong address, wrong postcode ...

All this for a one off fee of £600 + VAT +20% of the first years savings... The "surveyor" reckons on a yearly saving of c£1500 - £1800. and they "guarantee" a refund if the appeal is not accepted by the District Valuer. To be fair the "surveyor" didn't push it at all, so he wasn't interested in a hard sell

The company website is not live at the moment (surprised??), but I was wondering if anyone had used one of the services in the past or if this is a bit of a scam.... Gut instinct says its probably OK, but .......

TSS

1,130 posts

269 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
I don’t have any direct experience of this but I am told it can backfire. If you force the money grabbing useless b4stards(the council) to review your rates they sometimes do the review and decide you should be paying more.

ginettag27

6,297 posts

270 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
I've met someone who did this for a living, quite some time ago.

I'd ask to see on what grounds they think they can reduce your rates, etc.. Maybe ask for a reduction in their fees or one off fee lowering? At the end of the day though, the more then can reduce your rates the more they earn!

Maxf

8,409 posts

242 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
mondeoman said:
Had a visit today from a surveyor who claims to be able to get a reduction in our business rates, both for this year, back-dateable three years and going forward as well. All from a cold-call last week where the numpty on the phone had the wrong company name, wrong address, wrong postcode ...

All this for a one off fee of £600 + VAT +20% of the first years savings... The "surveyor" reckons on a yearly saving of c£1500 - £1800. and they "guarantee" a refund if the appeal is not accepted by the District Valuer. To be fair the "surveyor" didn't push it at all, so he wasn't interested in a hard sell

The company website is not live at the moment (surprised??), but I was wondering if anyone had used one of the services in the past or if this is a bit of a scam.... Gut instinct says its probably OK, but .......
I did this for a living a while back (but mainly in the City - looking at loopholes in legislation to claw money back).

DON'T pay a one off or upfront fee - anyone worth their salt will no charge this! All he is doing for this fee is entering an appeal online - no work at all (you can do it yourself on voa.gov.uk) and you'll find he'll dissapear if the appeal isnt an easy win. You can then not appeal your assessment again until 2010.

20% of first year's savings sounds high as well (FFS make sure it isnt 20% of ALL savings), but not *that* bad I suppose.

Have a look online at your rating assessment - you can see if anything nearby has been appealed successfully.

If they have been appealed but not changed then the value is set and you'd be hard pushed to get a reduction. If some nearby units have been appealed and not yet heard, then you could contact the company who has served the appeals and try and piggyback their case.

mondeoman

Original Poster:

11,430 posts

267 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Cheers chaps

I'll have a check at the online review - could save a few pennies!!

Maxf

8,409 posts

242 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
mondeoman said:
Cheers chaps

I'll have a check at the online review - could save a few pennies!!
One thing to remember - if you serve an appeal you only get 1 chance, so if you cock it up then you cant reappeal the result. This is where using someone who knows the ins and outs of the system can be better (but more expensive).


Davel

8,982 posts

259 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Ask for the names of a few satisified clients that you can contact.

Golfman

5,494 posts

247 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Bullst. Tell him you will pay after he gets you the reduction...

Maxf

8,409 posts

242 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Also, make sure any performance fees are based on SAVINGS rather than reductions - as a reduction in rateable value might not mean a saving in some cases.

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

204 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
I was of the understanding that *residential* rate appeals could go either way - they can be put up as well as go down/stay the same after the appeal.

Have no idea if this applies to business rates - may be worth checking just in case.

Maxf

8,409 posts

242 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
DonnyMac said:
I was of the understanding that *residential* rate appeals could go either way - they can be put up as well as go down/stay the same after the appeal.

Have no idea if this applies to business rates - may be worth checking just in case.
Yes they can go up if they are deemed to be 'incorrect'.

Chrisgr31

13,488 posts

256 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
I do this for a living! A lot of firms will not charge an upfront fee, and will work solely on savings. As has been mentioned earlier in the thread you only get one chance at appealling on general grounds so if that ground has not been used already they are guaranteed to submit a successful proposal and you will not get your money back! The guarantee only covers you if the VO rejects the appeal because its invalid, it won't payout if they get no guarantee!

If you want to PM me with your address and postcode I'll have a look at the software we use to advise you whether an appeal is likely to succeed. If you tell me who the company is I may also comment on them too!