"Following" a police car on an emergency call?
"Following" a police car on an emergency call?
Author
Discussion

londonbabe

Original Poster:

2,160 posts

223 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
Hi all, long time lurker, first time poster.

I'm not sure whether this post should be in biker banter, but I am posting it here because I guess more BiB read this and might venture an opinion. It happened a while ago but it's still bothering me because it doesn't make much sense to me. I've been riding through London (without any accidents) for years and like to think that (although I'm always learning) I know the kind of road attitude and behaviour that keeps me safe, and which doesn't.

A few weeks ago I was riding home on my motorcycle along the A4 near Kensington and as it was the rush hour the traffic was nose to tail. A police BMW 5 series with blues and twos was coming up fast from behind and the traffic was clearing a path in front of him. As he sped on into the centre of London I took up a road position in the nice wide and clear path that was in his wake; after all it's my experience that the further I am from cars the safer I'll be. A few cars pulled into this gap as well, though I had anticipated every single one of them and was able to safely pass them.

Anyway, On a clear stretch the BMW stopped in the middle of the road, waited for me to catch up, and the driver stuck his arm out of the window to stop me. He then proceeded to tell me never to follow a police car with its blues and twos on, and gave me a pretty lengthy lecture about how unsafe it was, and how he had been watching me for some distance and had seen me swerving when other cars moved into the lane. Now to be honest I was pretty annoyed about his attitude but I kept quiet and nodded my head at the appropriate times and let him be on his way - he might well have been right. But it still seems to me that something was wrong with his behaviour, and his assesment of my risk. First off I wasn't following him or chasing him. I was simply using the clearest bit of road. I was some distance behind (well I would be, given that I was riding under the speed limit). What he saw as me swerving was me steering. I even had plenty of time to check my mirrors and even do shoulder checks before changing lanes to pass cars entering the lane I was in. I may even have indicated. If he saw me "swerve" as he put it, he would have also seen this.

A few questions have since raised their heads.

1. The big question: the traffic was heavy. If he hadn't come along and cleared a nice wide path for me to ride down I would have been filtering between two lines of cars. Surely he must have been aware that nearly all bikes do this and there was no chance in hell I would have waited patiently in a queue of traffic (which experience has taught me is a very hazardous place to be when on a bike) when I could be zipping to the front of it? Does car Roadcraft not cover this? The bike one does. Therefore, I'm pretty certain that even with the chaotic traffic and lane switching that occurs in the wake of an emergency vehicle it's still a damn sight safer for me to have done what I did. Am I completely wrong to assume that would be safer or does the driver need to talk to some bike cops? Are there stats on accidents occurring following filtering vs following a police car?

2. If he was speeding through traffic with blues and twos on he was on his way to an emergency right? So why did he stop in the road and give me a lengthy discourse? Either he had to be there fast or there was no need for blues and twos.

3. If he was on an emergency call then why had he been watching me (behind) for some distance when he should have been watching the road ahead as his sirens caused the usual chaos?

Any opinions? I'd kind of like to be the safest rider, and the most alive one, but here I'm not sure whether to keep doing what I've always done or ride differently. In a London commute sirens are pretty frequent...

WeirdNeville

6,053 posts

246 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
I'm not an advanced driver, but almost every advanced driver I know has got a story about having a biker that was following in their wake wiped out by cars pulling back out after pulling over, or getting taken out after following them through a red light (which it sounds like you didn't do).

I have been in a situation where a biker has followed our car through heavy traffic, riding well outside the bounds of acceptability (i.e. keeping up with us at 50 in a 30 limit, running bloodshot lights etc) and when we got cancelled to the call the driver took the opportunity to pull the biker over and give me some practice processing people for careless driving....

So whilst you sound like you know what you were doing, you should also accept that you put yourself at great risk following any emergency vehicle through heavy traffic. As you say, people pull straight back out without checking their mirrors, and this often leads to collisions. I would say the ticking off should be heeded.

Regarding "if he was on an emergency call, why did he have time to pull me over?" Police vehicles often get cancelled on a call if their presence is no longer needed, and it could also have been the the vehicle was on a training run or a check test. Finally, if someone was following me in such a manner that I felt they were a danger to themselves and other road users, I might abort an emergency run in order to pull them over or get them to stop following me.

Hope that helps....

Edited by WeirdNeville on Sunday 13th April 21:18


Edited by WeirdNeville on Sunday 13th April 21:18

Derek Smith

50,027 posts

279 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
It is scary being the second police car in a convoy and it's a bit like the Spanish Inquisition so it is inadvisable to follow a police car running on blues.

But to take you questions in order:

1/ Drivers are often disoriented by a police car going past with lights on. They do silly things. Once the car has gone away they still do silly things and might not be paying attention. Further, there can often be some resentment shown when someone tries to jump the queue. As stated previously, it is a good idea in the immediate aftermath to keep your station.

2/ Blues and twos does not mean it's a grade one emergency. If a police driver needs to get somwhere quicker than just in the flow of traffic and wants to overtake then they can be of great assistance, especially with regards to safety of all road users. Further is seems that he was of the opinion that your riding had a higher degree of potential danger than he was prepared to let pass. It's a balancing act. Get to an alarm or lost child, or protect a vulnerable road user. Further, another response unit might well have radioed up that they were 'on scene' so the degree of urgency was lessened. We just don't know. Further, although you said he was speeding, you seemed to have little difficulty keeping up so I would have thought that the use of the blues/two was considered.

Whilst some drivers misuse the emergency lights and horns, most drivers only put them on reluctantly as they can, as you so rightly pointed out, cause chaos.

3/ Not really a serious question, surely. The driver will be concerned about all traffic. Perhaps one of the reasons he stopped you was that your presence was distracting and he wanted to concentrate on other things rather than the headlight behind.

I would suggest that for your own safety, remember that blues and twos can cause consternation and chaos so take extreme care once an emergency vehicle goes past with them on.

londonbabe

Original Poster:

2,160 posts

223 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
Thanks for those considered replies.
I could see why he would be concerned, but wasn't convinced it was as dangerous as filtering could be. If it's the sort of thing he would have seen a lot of, then it makes a lot of sense that he would have a word.

Just to clarify, I wasn't speeding or even keeping up with him - the traffic would not have allowed me to anyway - just making use of the space. It took a long time to catch up to him and that was because he had stopped.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
As stated by others. Second car on a job is the most dangerous. I'm not supprised the officer stopped. If he felt you were in danger or endangering yourself it may well be something that he /she felt was more important than the call.

I would never suggest to follow a police car on a call and think its a big risk it really is bad enough when you have lights and sirens.

maddog993

1,220 posts

271 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
Have to say it bugs the st out of me if MOP is following or attempting to follow when on red - agree with Derek 100%;
You say you're still open to learning but If you're doing this your learning curve needs to be a bit steeper-at the moment you sound a liability if you make a habit of this
1)It's bloody dangerous - you're an extra RTC likely to happen (for which the EV will quite possibly have to attend to thus delaying attendance at the original emergency)
2)It's illegal & extra bloody dangerous & ridiculously stupid to run a red light following the EV
3) it's incredibly distracting and annoying for the EV driver using their mirrors and perhaps anticipating at any moment the following vehicle will get wiped out
4) Again to re-iterate what Derek has said - one of THE most hazardous times to be running on red is when you're following another EV also running on red - other vehicles just aren't looking out for you and are incredibly unpredictable in their behaviour and ignorance of your presence - and thats with a brightly coloured vehicle with lights and sirens! - You've got no chance of being noticed on an unmarked bike

I don't think I've said anything Derek ( ETA- or Mr Annie VXR!) hasn't already but just to emphasise it's an incredibly daft thing to do - I'm not surprised BiBs stopped to tick you off.


Edited by maddog993 on Sunday 13th April 21:59

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
Maddog, re-read the OP smile
No running of red lights, no speeding, just using the wake of the car on blues to keep position on the road.
That said, I tend to let the traffic batter itself back to normality before getting on with my journey. there are too many idiots who barely cede position to a marked-up car,never mind me. The sole exception to my rule is following the VIP lot,with outriders. I'm guessing they are used to us two-wheeled freeloaders hehe

londonbabe

Original Poster:

2,160 posts

223 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
I am open to more learning. That's why I posted.
And I didn't run any red lights. What do you think I am - a cyclist?

maddog993

1,220 posts

271 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
Apologies - I am not accusing OP of specifically running red lights on this occasion. smile
It is more the inference if performed habitually (and from personal experience of others who have attempted to follow- including through red lights); On virtually any emergency call in an urban area we will have to pass through a traffic light - quite possibly on red - and as such to attempt to follow would be borderline suicidal.
However I am not accusing you of doing so in this particular circumstance londonbabe and I apologise if it seems I implied such wink
ETA also in case there's any misinterpretation - when I refer to running 'on red' it means running on an emergency - not a term for going through red-lights!

Edited by maddog993 on Sunday 13th April 23:30

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
londonbabe said:
What do you think I am - a cyclist?
now thats worth a rofl

Derek Smith

50,027 posts

279 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
Slightly off topic but relevant as far as the unpredictable nature of drivers.

The City of London had two area cars, Alpha 7 and Alpha 8, both white Triumph 2500 pi. Alpha 7 was unmarked (well not quite as it had a few dents, but no markings) while Alpha 8 had the jam sandwich and blue lights.

Emergency call for urgent assistance in the Strand. Alpha 8, blues and two on, joined in just behind Alpha 7 in Fleet Street. At Chancery Lane lights a cabbie, deciding to do his bit for law enforcement, took out Alpha 7.

No one badly hurt.


Medic-one

3,143 posts

234 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
londonbabe said:
2. If he was speeding through traffic with blues and twos on he was on his way to an emergency right? So why did he stop in the road and give me a lengthy discourse? Either he had to be there fast or there was no need for blues and twos.
If i'm on a shout on blues and two's and some muppet is following my every move i will stop in the road and tell him/her te back off as it is very dangerous.

I've seen it gone wrong on several occasions now, as well with following cars as bikes and if i've got an emergency to attend i will not be happy if i have to stop on scene because some following muppet just caused an accident so i now have to stay on scene and deal with that, delaying my response to the actual job i was going to.

Plus whilst driving under emergency conditions i prefer to look in front of me to see how the traffic response and i don't want to have to look in my mirrors every 2 secondes to see if the following car/bike is still there or if he has caused an accident yet.

I don't have to recall why it's dangerous, that's already well explained :

Derek Smith said:
Drivers are often disoriented by a police car going past with lights on. They do silly things. Once the car has gone away they still do silly things and might not be paying attention. Further, there can often be some resentment shown when someone tries to jump the queue. As stated previously, it is a good idea in the immediate aftermath to keep your station.
But i can tell you that 99% of us driving under blues and toos really hate people following them on a shout, for the obvious reasons meantioned above.

Poledriver

29,624 posts

225 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
Slightly off topic but relevant as far as the unpredictable nature of drivers.

The City of London had two area cars, Alpha 7 and Alpha 8, both white Triumph 2500 pi. Alpha 7 was unmarked (well not quite as it had a few dents, but no markings) while Alpha 8 had the jam sandwich and blue lights.

Emergency call for urgent assistance in the Strand. Alpha 8, blues and two on, joined in just behind Alpha 7 in Fleet Street. At Chancery Lane lights a cabbie, deciding to do his bit for law enforcement, took out Alpha 7.

No one badly hurt.
When I was younger I lived in the City and owned a white 2.5PI. I've seen the Police ones there and sometimes used to get a wave! The best bit was that drivers would very often pull over to let me pass around London Wall/ Moorgate/ Aldersgate, made me feel like a V.I.P.

barbalar

29 posts

230 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
As most of the other posters have already pointed out, travelling as 2nd car in convoy is always the most dangerous position. You have less vision and people do not realise that there may be another car there.

I've only stopped and given a bike rider a piece of my mind twice, which in 6 years of various levels of police driving isn't that bad. On both occasions, I found that their riding was of such a shocking standard, that I had to stop and say something, otherwise there would have been a collision and that would have diverted me from my original call.

I get people filtering behind me on a daily basis and I can say from experience that this does have a knock on effect on the way I handle my drive. Knowing that there is a potential hazard behind me, I have to alter my driving plan to suit and this can be a distraction I would rather do without. The more stress you put on a person, the more likely it is that a mistake will be made.

Normally, this'll only slow me down by a minute or two, and I would probably say that with most calls, this will not strongly affect my job at the other end. On others though, it could do. Where I work, in a london suburb, we are often the first emergency service there, and sometimes, this time can make the difference.


Whilst I agree that in most ordinary circumstances, you would be filtering anyway, have you considered the fact that the emergency vehicle is in itself a hazard for your driving plan? Although the emergency vehicle isn't (in most cases) going to hit you, what about the other drivers that are getting out of the way? If you are having to swerve and change your position to avoid other road users then I would suggest that you are not planning far enough ahead and reacting rather than planning. Just my take on it, no offence intended, I would hate for you to become one of TFL's RTA statistics.

BertBert

21,346 posts

242 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
Have I got this right? The traffic is moving over to let plod through and you are going through after plod before the traffic can get going again? Thus the traffic that has pulled over has to avoid you when it tries to pull back out to carry on?

If so as a regular MOP driver, then I would consider that "bad" biker behaviour. You get this with cars after a plod on blues has gone through and it's very poor driving as well as rude.

If I have mis-understood what you were doing, then apologies.

Bert

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
Londonbabe,

You ask about becoming a 'better' rider. I agree with the views above that it doesn't look tidy and can add additional stress to the police driver....another aspect to consider, and one you are unlikely to get mentioned here, is police ego.

Simply, some police ( not all, of course ) will take it personally that you, too, are doing something they have the monopoly on. They can fly through traffic and command it like Moses...you cannot. Silly pride, if you like.

Which is worthwhile considering as a biker.

For example, I would ride much more aggressively in London, than in unknown country towns with 'redneck' police. The London coppers are more used to bikers and our antics, they are more busy.

Do some of the same moves in a Yorkshire hamlet and even if they are 100% legal, you will be stopped and hassled. They have the time, they hate you 'dis-respecting' them.

Bottom line: Let the police go, let the traffic settle....off you go. It only costs a few seconds, and it spares you meeting the copper with a serious chip on his shoulder, which can cost you time AND money.

Medic-one

3,143 posts

234 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
jondude said:
and one you are unlikely to get mentioned here, is police ego.

Simply, some police ( not all, of course ) will take it personally that you, too, are doing something they have the monopoly on. They can fly through traffic and command it like Moses...you cannot. Silly pride, if you like.
Yes offcourse, it all has to do with pride, and nothing with traffic safety.... rolleyes

And all of us lot (fire & ambulance) suffer with "police ego" as well....


Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
jondude said:
Londonbabe,

You ask about becoming a 'better' rider. I agree with the views above that it doesn't look tidy and can add additional stress to the police driver....another aspect to consider, and one you are unlikely to get mentioned here, is police ego.

Simply, some police ( not all, of course ) will take it personally that you, too, are doing something they have the monopoly on. They can fly through traffic and command it like Moses...you cannot. Silly pride, if you like.

Which is worthwhile considering as a biker.

For example, I would ride much more aggressively in London, than in unknown country towns with 'redneck' police. The London coppers are more used to bikers and our antics, they are more busy.

Do some of the same moves in a Yorkshire hamlet and even if they are 100% legal, you will be stopped and hassled. They have the time, they hate you 'dis-respecting' them.

Bottom line: Let the police go, let the traffic settle....off you go. It only costs a few seconds, and it spares you meeting the copper with a serious chip on his shoulder, which can cost you time AND money.
Its views like this that most likely account for why bikers are a disproportionate level of road casualties.

Its nothing to do with ego its entirely to do with it being in a very stupid and dangerous thing to do for anyone and more so for a biker as you will be riding through blind spot after blind spot and putting yourself at risk as well as distracting the emergency driver.

Blaming the attention you get on the police without looking at your own conduct and that of other bikers means your missing the point and not adjusting your driving habits. I have hard far too many fatals this year alone with bikers and its only April.

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
To pretend some ( as I said, some ) police drivers, ambulance fire et al, are not a liability to all of us due to their pride is folly.

As is trying to say it is only about safety EVER - last time I was in England an ambulance driver reduced a young lady to tears by rocking the ambulance at her bumper, the poor girl had nowhere to turn in the tight traffic and was about to scrape the whole nearside against the wall until a van mounted the opposite kerb. The driver was so close to her, he had to back up and try again for the new gap, losing loads of time.

Maybe this is for another thread!

Of course there are bad bikers but come on, let's not pretend every policeman etc is some kind of objective robot without any areas of failure.


Jasandjules

72,688 posts

260 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
My fundamental concern would be that the drivers who have moved for the blues and twos will immediately swerve back to where they were, without checking, because they won't be expecting anything to be following plod in that way.

I've seen some damn stupid behaviour once cops have gone past, including a car who tried to follow plod nearly getting wiped out by an old man who pulled out without checking (though in fairness he was going pretty quickly after plod went past, the M3 trying to get ahead in traffic was as much at fault if not more so), so I think doing it on a bike would be far too risky.

It's not worth the few seconds you'd save IMHO.